Salvatore&#x27;s Old Fashioned Pizzeria

7.3 mi

Brand new pizza joint in Phelps. I just had a slice of pepperoni for lunch and it was delicious…read more They sport a thin New York style crust. Service ran smoothly for a new place that was pretty busy for lunch. They have indoor and outdoor seating as well as a separate arcade room with several different games.

In town and had to stop by. I am so glad we did. I was in the mood from some good wings and boy…read moredid this place deliver. These wings are life changing.

Pepperoni slice

See all

KFC

Ordered online 9pm, went to pickup, was told they had no more chicken(at kfc...) I was told I had…read moreto get a refund through the app, they would not give me one. 15min with Ai telling me to wait, then 10min confiming my details. and no food to show for it. KFC is dead to me.

After 60 years or so of KFC ya kinda know what to expect right? WRONG! Friday night, 5pm, this…read moreplace should be at its best right? Wrong. I was greeted with "we only got crispy". I wanted original but what the heck. I can live what crispy. "Okay, 2 3 piece dinners one all dark meat, one with one piece of white and 2 dark. Green beans on one, Cole slaw with the other." "No green breans, we got corn." "Okay, I guess that will have to do." I bought as take out. I get it home. My partner takes one bite and could not stand to take another. Mine was just as bad It tasted like they made it at 5 am and let it sit on a shelf all day. The food was crap. Nearly $30 for 2 meals that were not fit to eat. Sorry Cor. S. This was awful. Never again.

Wings Over Ithaca

Horrible location and parking for drivers/commuters. Chicken was decent. Fries not so much. I got 4…read morepiece tender Honey BBQ and Garlic Parm fries. **** Updated rating due to restaurant's response below. Geographical location can't be changed but acknowledgment and accountability go far. Tab n you!

The wings are always so good, I love the limited flavors they always have and the ranch is so good!…read moreThe service is always quick when I go for pick ups as well!!

Garlic parm wings and Waffle Fries

9 Wings (cajun)

See all

Waffle Fries

TK Tavern Waterloo

3.6

(7 reviews)

8.3 mi

Small but mighty sports bar with a light menu and weekly specials…read more This was our first time trying TK Tavern. It is one 2 shops over from Chacinos Italian. There was a small sign saying too go to the bar to order food off menu, but we were fine sitting at the Bar. It was a Monday evening. Staff/Owners were friendly and attentive. Customers where friendly. We see that Alot here in your small village of Waterloo NY. We were told they smoke there own meet for pulled pork sandwich's. Make there own Homemade mac and cheese. I did not try them yet but they make there own empandas!! Everything sounded so good. I choose a philly steak sandwich. It came loaded with meat, cheese. Onions and peppers! Hot and Savoy. Bread roll was very fresh. Meat was juicy and tender. I loved it. I choose Mac and cheese for and up charge over french fries that came with the sandwich. It was not a disappointment. Hubby choose pulled pork sandwich with onion rings and coleslaw. He raved to them on how good it was! They have a drink that is marketed with an elevating ingredients. Pre packaged cans. He said they are not over powering but 2 will get your just right. He had a special license to sell them. If you know what I mean. We heard him explaining it too other custumers about the drink and they can not mix them with alcohol! You can it home but not in the bar! Needless to day we were impressed for your first visit to TK Tavern. Just goes to show your, you have too step out of your normal to find new and exciting places to dine. Simple yet enjoyable night. Thank you for making us feel comfortable at your place and new we are hooked!#

This place is closed and the location is for sale. We came for some bar food and ended up at the…read moreItalian restaurant next door.

Philly steak and cheese. Mac and cheese

See all

Amelia’s pizza

4.6

(16 reviews)

22.3 mi

A charming mom & pop kind of place, with delicious pizza to feed a crowd! The kids are picky about…read moretheir pizza and asked for extra slices, gobbling them up. Our baby niece was overjoyed to gnaw on the crust, and cried whenever she ran out. The dough was pillowy soft, the crust was crispy, and it wasn't too greasy. If you're looking for a great local pizza place in Auburn, Amelia's is your place!

Needed a quick slice so stopped here. Inside of this place isn't very appealing. The pizza though…read moreis really good. The plain cheese was great. No flop and cooked to perfection. Nice sauce and cheese ratio. The Sicilian was average but not bad. It looks burnt in the picture but I like it that way. They had tons of flavors of pizza ready for their lunch rush. If you are in the area, try this place.

This is all of the sauce that he dumped on top of the wings. I took the wings out so you can see all of the sauce.

See all

The sauce and the two wings I ate

The Pizza Coop

7.3 mi

The best pizza in the area. They are always friendly and helpful. I order from them whenever I…read morecan.

Day manager h as d as b great attitude went out of there way hyp please and on. S very b hot day…read moremade you comfortable and at. Home.

A dozen of buffalo wings for $12 !

See all

Woodhouse Stadium Grill

For almost 25 years this local watering hole has been slinging grub, pulling drafts, and pouring…read moreshots for the thirsty and hungry. Meeting with a friend for lunch on a busy Friday, I only had one goal: fish fry. Golden fried haddock with a side of creamy mac-n-cheese. And boy did they deliver! So happy I made my way here--they nailed it. Staff was wonderful. Atmosphere as expected. Catching up with my old friend: priceless. Support local. Go here.

This place is a gem, great service, daily specials, and just good food. Of course, good-sized…read moreportions. The back room has lots of wood, giving it a rustic appearance and lots of tv's, tuned into sports. We ordered the chicken wings, and they came with ranch and fresh cut fries. And a meaty cheesesteak sub. All was delicious. Parking can get a bit of a challenge with a limited parking lot, so street parking is an option.

Fried haddock Friday fish fry. Mmmmm!

Medium Buffalo wings

See all

Deweys 3rd Ward Tavern

3.7

(13 reviews)

11.3 mi

We came here when we first got to town & we were expected to watch the FIFA finale. Lots of tv's,…read moreseveral open tables in the side room. The fish is huge- it was pretty good. Mushrooms, fries, and onion rings -all good. The boneless wings were wonderful, nice and crispy- I don't remember which sauce we had but I think it was mild, was so good!! Just a note - they do not have draft beer (per the server, who didn't know what an IPA was...)! It's a neighborhood bar and I bet you'd have a hard time being a stranger there, people seem friendly and nice!

Dewey & Lynda are always very polite and their food is amazing, very friendly atmosphere.read more

Onion rings and breaded mushrooms

Fish with fries

See all

Little bitty wine

A Round Pizza

We stopped by here 3 years ago on a trip to see family and my husband loved the pizza so much that…read morewe had to stop again on our next trip through. It did not disappoint. Delicious pizza! We had sausage and pepperoni and pepperoni pizza.

One of the most tasteless pizzas I ever had. Wouldn't order again. Sauce was bland.read more

House meatball pie. Everything about this pie was good except the really bad meatballs

Thin crust. Cheesy

See all

House cheese pie

Bb's Pizzeria

4.4

(17 reviews)

13.9 mi

My chicken wings in garlic sauce were cooked to perfection, the salad could use more lettuce but it…read morewas flavorful. Service was cool but the appearance inside wasn't so pleasant, they really need to renovate to improve the smell and gain new customers.

Always the best pizza in the area! Staff is extremely friendly, prices are completely fair!read more

Large pizza with pepperoni, onions, and black olives

BB's counter

See all

Biggest and best calzones and strombolis around

Kindred Fare

If you buy wine at the adjacent beverage store, there is no corkage fee! We brought a local…read moresparkling wine and loved it! The food here is really good! I highly recommend starting with the cheese plate. We only chose to do the single but the star is all the things that accompany it! For $12 a great value! For our meals, Schweety had the burger with a side salad and i had the Crispy Chicken entree. He really liked his! The salad portion of my meal was excellent, I would have preferred the chicken to be a little less crispy as it took away from the flavor of the chicken. Justin was a great server and gave some recommendation for our explorations in the area

5 stars for the service, 3 stars for the food…read more We visited for dinner on a Sunday evening and, thanks to our reservation, were seated right away despite the restaurant being quite busy. The service was excellent. Our waitress was friendly, polite, and attentive throughout the meal, making the experience enjoyable. The food was good, though it wasn't particularly memorable or outstanding. We both love poutine. The fries was good but the gravy was a bit too salty and it definitely need more cheese curds. Overall, it's a great spot for dinner with friends or family, especially if you're in the area and looking for a pleasant dining experience.

House made sandwiches and burgers

Celebrate with bubbles

Seasonal salads.

See all

Water St Cafe

Great value! What a lovely brunch we enjoyed at the Water St Cafe. We didn't go more than 5 minutes…read morewithout a warm-up on our coffee. Excellent service. The portions were generous and food was flavorful. As a starter we enjoyed home fries loaded with homemade sausage gravy. That was a meal in itself! The coffee mugs were a hand-thrown pottery that was unique and beautiful. We stopped in on a Saturday and there was a local brewery offering their drinks, along with a volleyball team raising money for a trip. Lots of young people in the "team room". It was an engaging spot to enjoy food and we would definitely return! Good meetup place for friends.

HORRIBLE SERVICE! HORRIBLE STAFF!…read more You should have been prepared for the people that came for the Ironman. We put our name on the list, waited to be called, came when they called, they sat us down and then we waited and waited and WAITED. And no one came. People were seated after us, their order was taken , their food was served...and we just waited and waited and WAITED. WE WERE NEVER SERVED. Even if their food was good (which I'll never know) their service, and lack of customer service and people skills is absolutely disgusting and unacceptable.

Exterior with ice sculpture

Hamburger with fries

See all

Smokin Petes

Food is all so wonderful, corn bread tender and just the right flavor, pulled pork is tender and…read moredelicious along with the Turkey, sausage, ribs, chicken, brisket, my all time Favorite. The kids tried broccoli salad had a nice flavor but I had mostly the hard parts and not much the flurets. Mac and cheese was good, salt potatoes are assume. My husband liked the slaw, thou he likes it with pineapple. He was not overly thrilled with mac salad. Drinks I tried were the blueberry smash. Very tasty. Not that thrilled with the peach drink that was 25 dollars. But I drank it. Tastes more like a Ice tea drink. Service is good. They take your order at the bar with a designated area to wait in line. Give you a buzzer to pick it up at the window. They have a condiment area to get soda, utensils, sauce sides and so on. They have seating inside and out side. You can play with games they have set up. Inside it decorated with old and new signage. They have a book of bourbon selection. Bar stools chairs and tables,booths and high top tables. People clean up after themselves. Kid friendly. People are friendly. Most of the times we went they were busy or at least a steady flow of customers. If you get a chance to stop here to eat you will not ve disappointed!!

Smokin' Pete's is the perfect lunch stop on the wine tour along Seneca Lake. But we weren't the…read moreonly ones who thought so -- the place was busy. They have plenty of seating both inside and outside, with a cozy bar feeling. Still, we didn't have a long wait to place our order. Not a huge selection for non-meat eaters, admittedly -- but just ask for a grilled cheese, they'll make it, and the side salads are delicious. Be better a Bills fan - Go Bills.

Even more bourbon and other liquor

See all

More bourbon

The Rusty Pig

OMG!!! Deliciousness! We were lucky to get seats at the bar on a busy Saturday night, but MAN! I am…read moreso glad we did. Could be all the wine in me talking (though I don't think so from the way everyone was chowing down), but this was some Grade A BBQ! Pulled pork was laced with sauce - sweet, sticky, not the least bit dry... the spare ribs were so tender, Smokey and flavorful and honestly not a whole lot of fat... and the brisket, well it melted in your mouth. Honestly - just way too good! Drinks. Food. Service. Company - 10 for 10!

I loved the setup and ambiance, and the first-come-first-served policy (no reservations) is a great…read moreconcept. Coming in on a Tuesday night, the place was busy and the wait was about 30 minutes -- but there was free seating at the bar. Fair enough, not many restaurants were even open in Geneva on a Tuesday. The food was solid -- nothing extraordinary, but nothing to complain about either, and the presentation on those big plates is genuinely fun. The lady bartender had her hands full preparing drinks while also serving everyone seated at the bar, including food orders. It was sometimes hard to catch her attention, but overall she did a great job juggling it all. What really bothered me: the owner (CB) is one of the few Master Sommeliers in the world and a big promoter of the FLX wine region (which I love), so can anyone explain why a glass of FLX wine costs about 40% more than a glass of California or even Australian wine? That's not exactly "Think NY, Drink NY" -- despite those charming stickers around the restaurant (which I do love).

Cozy side street beside the pig

Restrooms

Pierogi

See all

Grounded

(33 reviews)

1.7 mi

Stopped by for a quick latte but soon realized they have a beautiful shaded courtyard which was a…read moreperfect reprieve on a hot summer day. The couple of folks I talked to who were working were super kind. Great all around!

We had been trying a new coffee shop each day we were in the finger lakes. This one had a nice, m…read moreopen interior with enough seating for everyone. Probably a 7 on a scale of 1-10 for coziness. The sandwich bread was perfectly crisp and melt-in-your-mouth buttery. The bacon and cheese were delicious. My only issue was the egg. This is just a personal preference, but I much prefer traditional fried eggs to the spongy, egg patty that was used on my sandwich. This was especially disappointing because fresh eggs are everywhere in this region. If not for the egg issue, this sandwich would have been perfect. Not too heavy, incredibly savory, and hit the spot without going overboard. My coffee was just OK. Nothing crazy, a little too much of synthetic sweetness in the syrup. And they asked if I wanted it in a mug or to-go cup: I said mug, as you can see this is not what they provided me. A little disappointed by that as well. Overall, I'd maybe go back but I'd ask if they could fry my egg and for half sweet lattes. And I'd confirm that my coffee came in a mug.

View from the counter where you pay

Iced peanut butter latte and an everything bagel with cream cheese and salmon.

See all

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria also viewed

Jason's New York Pizzeria

4.6

(18 reviews)

Every time my husband and I pass through Union Springs it's a must to stop by Jason's NY Pizzeria!…read moreThe pizza tastes great, the service is always friendly, and the price is so great especially for 2026. Can't wait to return!

Great service and the pizza, wings and subs are excellent! My favorite is the chicken wing pizza.read more

Naples Wood Fired Pizza Smokehouse BBQ

3.9

(89 reviews)

My family loved the pizza! No photos of the chicken strips but they were delicious. Homemade ranch!…read moreSo yummy. Definitely coming back.

Came in for a quick lunch and this place delivers! Located in what appeared to be an historic home,…read morethe menu has something for everyone. We ordered the smoked mac n cheese with brisket, a brisket taco, and the brisket sandwich with chips. The brisket was tender and delicious, the smoked mac was perfectly cooked -- the cavatappi pasta was al dente and the sauce was creamy without being too thick. The brisket sandwich was super tasty and filling. They sure did not skimp on the brisket! Loved the chopped apples in the coleslaw. A different take on it that made it refreshing. The brisket taco was OK -- good, but not amazing. I think it would have been better had it been in a corn tortilla rather than flour, and have the shredded cheese that was on it, melt. A condiments area would also be nice -- put out some of your housemade BBQ sauce, hot sauce, etc for those that like things hot and/or saucy. Service was friendly and efficient. Atmosphere: casual. Place order at the counter and they bring your food to you. Ample free street parking.

Nima's Pizza

3.6

(37 reviews)

If you are looking for good food in palmyra LOOK NO FURTHER! This place is amazing and it truly had…read morethe small town vibes we were looking for. Service was amazing and the lady looking after us was super nice and funny and made sure we had everything we needed. The day we went the A/C was actually broken and it was a little hot inside but it was no problem since it was a cooler day. If you have a large family like us I 100% recommend the sheet pizza since it is only $20 (additional cost depending on toppings) and we easily fed all 6 of us and we even had some leftovers. We had it split with veggie garlic and chicken bacon ranch but our favorite was definitely the veggie garlic. 10/10 recommend To top it all off the cookie was solid

Delicious pizza slices served fresh. Very large slice for $3 feels like a steal…read more The dining room is large and specious. Very quiet location. I had the whole dining area to myself on a weekday afternoon. The staff was friendly and the service fast. Ordered and my slice was ready just a few minutes later

Silverbird Woodfired and Gastropub

3.3

(173 reviews)

•$$

Came by on a Tuesday night. Service was great…read more We got the pretzel bites - comes with an IPA infused cheese. I ordered the custom burger - cooked well to my liking and was a standard, solid burger. We ordered the kids chicken tenders. Fries are solid here. Chicken tenders are also good. They also have some arcade games, but they didn't have them on when we got there. They turned it on eventually.

First time ordering here, pizza, meh...obe and done They…read morecharge $2 extra for every topping and my black olives were like 1 thinly cut olive per slice???? Really a whole can costs $2 retail, not generous toppings at all, not enough olives, mushrooms or pepperoni...as things get more expensive you will lose customers if you dont serve quality food...many restaurants will go out of business. Might be you Crust too thin not great Bye-bye you dont get 2 tries for that price $22 plus tax jeez

Bb's Pizzeria

4.4

(17 reviews)

Always the best pizza in the area! Staff is extremely friendly, prices are completely fair!read more

Otis & Reds Pizza

In town and had to stop by. I am so glad we did. I was in the mood from some good wings and boy…read moredid this place deliver. These wings are life changing.

Little Italy

3.4

(70 reviews)

Stopped in to Little Italy for dinner on a Tuesday night, and we didn't leave disappointed! It…read morewasn't terribly busy for a weeknight, and we were greeted quickly when we arrived. They have a pretty large selection of beers, wines, and cocktails, so no need to worry if you need a drink. As the name suggests, Italian Food is the name of the game here. The atmosphere is casual, and I could really see this place bustling on a Friday night. My pizza was very tasty! The crust was crispy and it was just the right amounts of sauce, cheese, and toppings. My wife opted for a pizza roll... essentially a calzone rolled instead of folded. Hers had an enormous amount of pepperoni inside, so much so that it wasn't quite cooked all the way through. A little more time at a slightly lower heat would probably have been better. Aside from that, no other complaints. We considered it a W as far as dinner was concerned.

Recognized immediately upon entry and welcomed. Place has character and ambiance. She had the sub…read moreand I had the slice of pizza. Enjoyable!

Luigis

3.8

(26 reviews)

I will start by saying.... WOW!! Walking in, I am certain there has been those who were not…read moreimpressed by the dated, warn, and simple decor, BUT the food is the star here. We started with the popular Budah sticks; fresh & delicious. Since we were only snacking, we shared a small super garlic pizza with the recommended mushrooms. Fantastic! The service was fast & friendly too! Such a great spot!

Overall good food. Could be more pizza options (such as supreme), but the pizzas are generously…read moretopped and cooked perfectly. I went here twice this week, the first time getting a sub. If you get a sub here, just know youre getting a bang for your buck. I got the 7" (only 8 dollars) and it was absolutely loaded with meat and toppings. Cozy nostalgic ambience, good service, and overall good eats.

The Pizza Coop

The best pizza in the area. They are always friendly and helpful. I order from them whenever I…read morecan.

Day manager h as d as b great attitude went out of there way hyp please and on. S very b hot day…read moremade you comfortable and at. Home.

Giovanni Gourmet Pizzaria

4.4