My chicken wings in garlic sauce were cooked to perfection, the salad could use more lettuce but it…read morewas flavorful. Service was cool but the appearance inside wasn't so pleasant, they really need to renovate to improve the smell and gain new customers.

Always the best pizza in the area! Staff is extremely friendly, prices are completely fair!read more

If you are looking for good food in palmyra LOOK NO FURTHER! This place is amazing and it truly had…read morethe small town vibes we were looking for. Service was amazing and the lady looking after us was super nice and funny and made sure we had everything we needed. The day we went the A/C was actually broken and it was a little hot inside but it was no problem since it was a cooler day. If you have a large family like us I 100% recommend the sheet pizza since it is only $20 (additional cost depending on toppings) and we easily fed all 6 of us and we even had some leftovers. We had it split with veggie garlic and chicken bacon ranch but our favorite was definitely the veggie garlic. 10/10 recommend To top it all off the cookie was solid

Delicious pizza slices served fresh. Very large slice for $3 feels like a steal…read more The dining room is large and specious. Very quiet location. I had the whole dining area to myself on a weekday afternoon. The staff was friendly and the service fast. Ordered and my slice was ready just a few minutes later

The Service was GREAT awesome people.. And I got to say it…read morewas the BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN... No shit.. And im a Wop full blooded... So I have had a great deal of pizza in my 67 years on earth...Even the pizza from Vito's pizzarea can not compare to the pie I had from them... GREAT JOB YOU ALL.. But please don't go there because then I will have to wait in line to get my pie.... Just kidding..... This place is great and ypu should definitely go there and see for yourself.

I ordered a 19-inch pizza with grilled chicken, pepperoni and red peppers. Overall, it was pretty…read morestandard, though a bit greasier than I prefer. I blotted off a lot of the excess oil with paper towels, but there was still quite a bit left. I ordered the pizza to go, and the staff were pleasant and friendly. Ideally, I'd give it 3.5 stars, but Yelp doesn't allow that.

Was driving through town recently and wanted a quick late afternoon snack…read more This place was exactly what I hoped it would be. The guy working the counter was friendly and welcoming. He still had a few slices left from lunch, so I grabbed one of those. It was excellent New York style thin crust. Perfect for an afternoon snack. Bathroom was clean, parking was easy, food was good, and the pizza chef was a cool dude. There's a few booths for seating indoors and, at least in the summer, two tables outside. I'll gladly stop here next time I'm in town and need a bite.

Great pizza , their "weird" sauce is really good. Always positive and friendly, definitely…read morerecommend trying a slice

We were recently dog sitting nearby Pizza Chef's Perinton location, and were recommended to go here…read morefor pizza and subs. Specifically, we were told to either get their turkey sub, made with fresh-roasted-in-house turkey and their delicious bread, OR the taco pizza. We couldn't decide so we got both, figuring we could always eat left overs. The time of our order was peak lunch time rush, and it took about 30 min to get our food. We saw them making the pizza and subs fresh, and we also observed a lot of other diners, some regulars, enjoying their food and the conversation with the staff. Everyone was friendly and happy. We took our order back to where we were staying and dug into the pizza. It was a little salty for my personal taste buds, but not my husband's - he really loved the flavors. I was impressed with the crust - which is always a mark of a good pizza in my book. I would get this again, but would ask for something like a side of ranch or blue cheese to help cut the saltiness. Later that same day we ate the subs. The turkey sub was easily - seriously - the BEST turkey sub I had had in a very long time. Maybe ever. The fresh-roasted turkey, the fresh fillings - lettuce, tomato, cheese, onion, and the Italian dressing - all were the perfect flavor profiles and amounts. The whole sammy was well balanced, so no one ingredient dominated. We had ordered a large, again, with left overs in mind, and cut it into pieces. I added mayo, and just thought it was moist, really tasty, and total comfort food. I would drive across the city to get that sub again. Pictured here is the pizza; by the time we at the subs I forgot to take more pics! Couple other notes: Pizza Chef is in a plaza where there is plenty of parking. They sell soda in a case as well as ice cream, and have quite a large menu that includes wraps, sandwiches and subs (hot and cold), lots of different signature pizzas plus a breakfast pizza and options to build-your-own, plus a variety of fried sides like fries, onion rings, mozzarella sticks, jalapeno poppers, etc. They also have wings and salads. Definitely check them out if you haven't already. And get that turkey sub. You won't regret it!

I love thin crust pizza and this place doesn't disappoint. We tried the bbq chicken and the white…read morespinach pizza and both were amazing and not too greasy! If I lived in Fairport, I would be a regular customer.

Pizza and wings were amazing! We walked in to place an order to go. While we were waiting, someone…read morebehind the counter gave us some pizza bread to go feed Shelly, a huge snapping turtle. The biggest I've ever seen. Love the atmosphere of this place. The people were super nice plus great food - a must go.

I went here for the first time and was so impressed by how kind and welcoming the staff were. You…read morecan tell they truly take pride in their work. I originally thought they sold slices, but that's just a lunchtime option. Honestly, I wasn't disappointed at all to order a whole pizza instead! We got a half cheese / half sausage, mushroom, and olive. It came out hot and ready in under 10 minutes and was served right at our table. The toppings were generous, and we ate almost the entire thing. My son loved picking out a bag of Ruffles to go with his slices, and it was great that they had cold drinks on-site too. Looking around, it was clear that there are a lot of regulars including families. The people who work here clearly care about their customers, which makes for such a great atmosphere. When I tried to tip at the counter, the cashier politely declined and simply asked me to come back again. Since the table was serviced, I left a tip there. I was truly grateful for and impressed by their hospitality. Pro tip: they're cash only, so make sure to have some on hand. I'll definitely be back again!

Tried their whit pizza for the first time and it is absolutely delicious. Top sub and pizza shop in…read morethe area.

I was so excited to find an authentic Italian deli not far from my destination in Farmington NY. I…read morewas especially intrigued upon seeing they use Boars Head products. So I placed an order for 5 sandwiches to sample. I guess my Philly roots compromises my ability to not judge this kind of stuff against the originals, Philly hoagies. Alas, I still haven't found bread or rolls outside of Philly that deserve to be used on a decent hoagie. (Hoagies and cheesesteaks ARE about the roll, the taste and texture, above everything else.) This place is no different. It's hard to judge what is inside a sandwich made with really awful rolls. Sorry, but wherever these slightly crusty versions of white bread come from...not good. That said, they offer a fair quantity of Italian goods, I guess for this area, I should be happy just find some Cento products. Way better than Dario's in Farmington, but not even as good as very mediocre Jersey Mike's, solely on the basis of comparing the rolls used. If you're starving have at it. Otherwise, just a notch above Subway.

Great food awesome wings and wonderful customer service would highly recommend if you are in the…read moremood for great food

Great service and yummy pizza! The veggie pizza was chock full of vegetables. The chicken Parm…read moresandwich was tasty as well. Would definitely recommend.