Stopped in to Little Italy for dinner on a Tuesday night, and we didn't leave disappointed! It wasn't terribly busy for a weeknight, and we were greeted quickly when we arrived. They have a pretty large selection of beers, wines, and cocktails, so no need to worry if you need a drink. As the name suggests, Italian Food is the name of the game here. The atmosphere is casual, and I could really see this place bustling on a Friday night. My pizza was very tasty! The crust was crispy and it was just the right amounts of sauce, cheese, and toppings. My wife opted for a pizza roll... essentially a calzone rolled instead of folded. Hers had an enormous amount of pepperoni inside, so much so that it wasn't quite cooked all the way through. A little more time at a slightly lower heat would probably have been better. Aside from that, no other complaints. We considered it a W as far as dinner was concerned. read more

Recognized immediately upon entry and welcomed. Place has character and ambiance. She had the sub and I had the slice of pizza. Enjoyable! read more

Little Italy - Cheese and Pepperoni sold by the slice or entire pie. - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

See all

The waitress was very nice, however the food wait was the worse. More than an HOUR for a sandwhich. They offered to refund in 1-2 weeks since we were under a time crunch. It was a large group but still. read more

Unfortunately, I chose to order subs from Little Italy. Got the subs home, take a bite, another, it's clear the turkey is bad. Most places would just refund. Instead, they offer to remake or give a credit. I don't want a credit and certainly don't want more expired turkey. Asked for the owners number. I'll update if there is a better outcome. read more

The pizza of the month, wicked chicken riggi, was amazing! We just each grabbed a slice at the counter, but the woman waiting on is was super nice. If we didn't live five hours away, this would be my go to shop for pizza! read more

Little Italy - Pizza of the month-wicked chicken riggi pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Pizza was delicious!! Service was great! They had live music the night we were there. Nice atmosphere decent prices.

Food was slow and took over 35 mins to make when I ordered ahead by 20 mins. Food should have been ready by 30 after according to the app. Wont come here again. please don't waste your time unless you have the time in the world to waste. Avacolli's is way better and right down the street. the have faster, friendlier service. read more

This is a cute little place with really excellent service! The staff person who took our order could not have been more welcoming, and was excellent with kids. They have a quick serve area where you can place the order at the counter and take it to go or eat right there in a small seating area, or you can get table service in the dining room. We opted for quick serve and got some of the huge slices - cheese, pepperoni and mushrooms, along with the homemade chocolate chip cookies, and a slushie, which the staff offered to do a swirl with the two flavors, which ended up being a big hit. Tasty lunch! read more

Walked in and there were only a few people around 8:00pm. We were from out of town. We ordered three different slices of pizza. They were very flavorful and we loved the crust. read more

This small pizza place was good! Pizza was solid and everyone was super nice. We came in town out of California and enjoyed it.

Got the family special and took it out on the lake. Have to admit some of the best wings I've had! Will be stopping in again! I camp here on the weekends and it's hard to find quality takeout. Definitely worth the drive. read more

There are so many good things to say about this place!! I am from KY and up in NY 2 times a year. The most amazing NY style pizza, best service! Eat there every time!! read more

This garlic knot is stiff as a board, and it tastes as if it wasn't made in-house. Avacollis is the way to go for garlic knots. Also, the pizza is always burning hot when you get it, which makes it unappealing. The cheese on the pizza feels like there is almost none, and the sauce taste is overwhelming. Finally, inside the building is very hot and the air feels thick. The service is good. The people always seem friendly. read more

Little Italy - Cheese pizza and garlic knot - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

I have never been to regular sized Italy, so I'm not sure how Little Italy compares to the real thing, but I do know they've been doing live music on Saturday nights. I went there a couple of Saturdays ago, we got the pizza and pitcher of beer special. I forget the actual price, but for a large cheese with a pitcher of draft beer its a pretty good deal. They threw on the SU basketball game for us and we listened to some stellar live music, not a bad night. The only disappointment was that SU lost, but I cannot blame the restaurant on that one. The za is decent so I will be checking out other options on the menu in the future. read more

At first I was ready to be disappointed. But far from it. Food is very good in ample portions and the waitress was as cheerful and accommodating as could possibly be. I highly recommend this place. In the added benefit is that it has a perfect view of the bridge in the famous movie It's a Wonderful Life. read more

Little Italy - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

See all

A great pizza place! The staff was super friendly, personable and fun all while serving solid eats. The pizza dough is made fresh daily and the sauce is homemade. It was perfect for those late night cravings. read more

Little Italy - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Food and service. The pizza is amazing. The crust is just right. The waitress was great. Came up to visit family and found this because we were looking for good pizza. I would definitely recommend it. read more

I have to give this place 5 stars even though I've only been here three times. The first time I was walking up to the outer door and was greeted with the nicest smile through two doors! I walked in and said it was my first time. She warmly welcomed me. I asked about all of the pizzas they had on display. She told me about the pizza of the month, along with all of the others she had on display. The phone rang. I thought- ok, she will take the call while I was making up my mind. She answered and said - can you please hold. She waited for me to chose, prepped it to cook, then told me she would answer the call while my pizza was heating. I said yes, of course! I payed and she boxed up my pizza. I left and ate it , staying in a hotel close by, I enjoyed the chicken Parm pizza I ordered very much and felt like an important customer ! Two days later, I went in and received the same treatment from another girl working there. Totally friendly and one on one. She was there for me. Only checking on her duties while my pizza was heating. read more

Little Italy - Bacon tomato with quality white cheese and a slightly garlicky white sauce. Amazing - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

We ordered a roll. It was hot outside but cold inside. We sent it back to the kitchen. It came back lukewarm only. The mozzarella was not even melted. :( read more

Little Italy - Sausage and spinach roll. - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Came to Seneca Falls for my grandson's graduation. His favorite place is Little Italy's restaurant. I looked over the menu and decided to get the Philly cheese steak. They cut the steak themselves making it fresh. I requested marinara sauce to be mixed in with the steak onions peppers and mushrooms while it was being cooked. They obliged. I ordered some macaroni salad as well. I took only about 10 minutes and the sandwich came out. There was a copious amount of meat and filling. The Marinara sauce was very good. It was delicious, 5-star. In fact it was probably one of the best philly cheese steak in this area. Kudos to the cook Sean. I'll be back here again. Mainly because my daughter lives here. read more

Little Italy - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

See all

My customer and I arrived late and had the place to ourselves. Sitting at a booth by the window over looking downtown Geneva and learning this is where they had filmed "It's a Wonderful Life". Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. Prices are reasonable. I started off with a house salad and we split a medium vegetable pizza. A medium has 8 slices and was too much. All toppings including onion, mushroom and spinach were very fresh. The crust wasn't NYC thin, but not Chicago style either. Very tasty. read more

I've never written a bad review in my life. I try to give every place I go to the benefit of the doubt if the experience is less than stellar. Unfortunately, Little Italy has made me see the Yelp light. What a disaster. This was the *worst* dining experience of my life - and I've eaten on a NY Subway while a rat ran across my shoes. The service - looking at you, "manager" James - was confrontational, rude, and unprofessional. My pasta was served in a bowl of oil. I was told this is what James calls "sauce" - so we soaked a napkin in it to see. Yep, still oil. A BOWL FULL OF OIL AFTER A TWO HOUR WAIT FOR THE FOOD? My Mother-in-law's dish was just as bad - but at least she could get drunk off of hers. A bowl of wine pasta. (On Mother's Day, no less! Wish we'd have gone anywhere else.) The young waitresses we dealt with were kind and helpful. I felt so bad for them working in this hostile environment we were witness to and hope they quit ASAP. As for my family, we've quit eating here. Never again. read more

Little Italy - Yes, that's a bowl of OIL. - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

First time trying this place yesterday and I was pleased. Called in an order for two gluten free Pizzas and picked them up. So awesome that they were like normal full size pizzas. They also came with their own safe pizza cutters and on a foil baking dish so you know they take measures to avoid CC. Next time I'd love to try the Gf pasta! read more

We ordered a large pie- to go and it pretty tasty considering the pizza we've had outside of NYC Seemed like a well like place. It was pretty crowded. Pizzas looked good as did pastas read more

My husband and I shared a sausage calzone. Cut it in Half and it fed us both thoroughly. Super stuffed with cheeses and a cup of red sauce to pour over it. Our server was very attentive checking on us several times. We were seated quickly and drinks arrived fast. This was our first dine in here and we will definitely be back. read more

I would not advise anyone to order Chicken Marsala from Little Italy. I was in the Area visiting & I decided to grab dinner from here . It's unacceptable the way they serve me the Chicken Marsala a plate floating with pasta & water so it was a watered down soup chicken Marsala. I ate Chicken Marsala in the past and this is the worst. I would never eat at this place again. I did not try their Pizza. I uploaded a few pictures here of what I was served. read more

See all

First time and will be back. We had chicken wings ( crispy and delicious). Pan pizza with pepperoni, onions,peppers and mushrooms. They don't skimp on the toppings. Crust was perfect. read more

Super pizza, antipasto is awesome. Try their home made Italian dressing. Our waitress Melyssa was awesome welcomed us and was super helpful. read more

Little Italy - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

service was terrible told me 20 min be done took almost near an hour. food was cold and not only was the pizza completly wrong. front servers have terrible etiquette especially serenity. tried to call back to see if they could fix it and serenity hung up on me. read more

Went for lunch today..delicious!!! Tiffany was amazing!! Made us feel welcome and gave us great service. Will definately be back when in the area read more

Middling experience here. On one hand, the food product I was served in the end was stellar. On the other hand, it took 25 minutes for me to receive this single item. *** I ordered the Buffalo Roll, essentially a buffalo blue cheese calzone. It's presented in a "boat-style" manner- a hearty portion of chicken finger breading and white meat, mozzarella and lots (LOTS) of buttery buffalo sauce. Does it look appetizing? It sure does. The presentation is marvelous. *** It took nearly 30 minutes for my order to come of of the kitchen, however. I've worked in pizzarias before, and a wait time like that means only one thing, generally speaking: cooks who aren't exactly rushing their way through getting ordered food items out to the customer, but who rather take some leisurely liberties with the pace they work at. *** Sure, a calzone is going to have to take longer than ten minutes to bake fully in the oven, especially one with meat in the middle. But 30 minutes seems a bit ridiculous. In their defense (I AM giving them three stars, of course, which is a mostly positive review) they did warn me the order might take a while, though I in no way expected to have to sit through an entire television episode on their TV while I waited for my dinner. *** Would I come back? Perhaps for slices or a casual sit-down dinner with friends. The location within Seneca Falls is prime. *** ProTip: Order ahead. I'll do the same next time. read more

Little Italy - Buffalo roll- essentially a buffalo chicken calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Worst Italian Restaurant EVER!!!! Ordered some subs here over the weekend. A Hot Ham and Swiss and Cheeseburger. Hot Ham and Swiss: - was told when ordering that sub didn't come with any condiments, so I asked for the usual suspects (let, tom, on, mayo and dressing). When I got sandwich home, only had ham, swiss and tomato on it...nothing else.....to top it off, it wasn't even toasted or 'warm'. Cheeseburger Sub: - this was completely inedible. Bun was loaded with lettuce and tomato with the well done burger patty just plopped on top of the roughage. There was no way to pick it up to consume.... Actually ended up throwing both away.... Not sure if they have new staff here or what, but how difficult is it to make an edible sub???? With other options so near by, they really need to step up their game..... read more

Pizza used to be better with a healthy portion for topping on their pizza. Must be cutting costs by raising prices and using less product. read more

I am a college student who has an autoimmune disease that affects the way my body processes gluten. I cannot have it in my body, so I have to go out of my way to get gluten free options from restaurants. I bought their gluten free pizza, and I have never been more disgusted with food in my life. read more

Food was great and the server was nice! There was a little bit of a wait but it seemed that the server had little help so she did great for what she had to work with. I'm visiting from out of town but would go back if I find myself in this part of town again. read more

Their customer service was great as they were very friendly and helpful over the phone and in person with COVID-19 procedures. However, the food was miserable. The gluten free pizzas we ordered had congealed cheese and the crust was a little too moist. The regular pizzas had a good crust but the cheese did not go down well. read more

One of the worst meals we've ever had at a restaurant. I ordered penne with vodka sauce with extra sauce as previous visits the pasta was a bit dry. Husband ordered chicken riggies. Plates come out, my vodka sauce was 90% cream and flavorless. Husbands riggies were dry so he ordered extra sauce. Both of us left more than half of our food behind because it didn't taste good. Bill shows up and we were charged $7.90 for the extra vodka sauce and $5.49 for the extra riggie sauce! We expected an upcharge but come on! Husband was charged $1.99 for his side salad (wasn't included in the $19.99+$5.49 meal he purchased.) total bill was over $68 and we didn't eat most of our food. Our waitress was very nice but told us the manager wouldn't do anything about our meals. When we complained about how bad everything tasted she commented, "yeah, I know who's cooking tonight" which wasn't very reassuring. Everything was dirty and there were flies and gnats flying around. Arrived at 5:30 on a Sunday and there was no one else in at the time, should have been a sign. Will not be returning. read more

Little Italy - Flies - Pizza Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

The food is not very good and it costs a lot. The gluten free pizza's cheese congealed on the ride home and the crust is like a soggy cracker. The normal pizza had a good crust but the cheese was very oily and that ruined it. The food overall is ok but not worth the amount that it cost. read more

If I could give this place zero stars I would. We went there on a slow Thursday afternoon after the lunch rush and waited over 45 minutes to get our food which included a simple steak and cheese grinder and some wings. We had to get the food to-go because we had fussy babies. Not to mention, it was FREEZING in there. Asked the staff to turn down the air. Horrible horrible service and experience. read more

Stop here for lunch and was very satisfied. I had a Buffalo Wing Roll and my wife has a buffalo chicken wrap, both were really good. The fries were are favorite part of the meal, very crunchy and fresh! We had great service and prices were fair. read more