Very nice Italian deli here. Stopped in a couple times. Very clean and friendly atmosphere. Ordered a couple Italian combo heroes and they were packed nicely with mozzarella and roasted peppers. Another time ordered a couple chicken parm heroes and they were REALLY good! Nice job guys! Well done. They have a nice selection here and the service is good. Really good food with very fair prices. I stop in when I can. The outdoor seating is a nice touch...and you can relax and eat your lunch. read more

Local deli with fresh food and daily specials. Have ordered many wrap platters with everything always tasting great. Nice atmosphere. Always and welcome and smiles. read more

Local spot that makes really good Italian sandwiches. They get pretty busy during lunch, so if you are tight on time, i recommend calling in your order. The staff is always friendly and happy to recommend something. I usually order The Sicilian (vegetarian) or the Al Pacino (chicken). These are not "light" sandwiches. I always think i can eat one, but end up saving half for a 2nd meal. Ask them to put the sandwiches in the panini press, much better that way. read more

The real deal authentic Italian combo the way it should be. Small, cute spot with more than any deli double its size. Options are amazing and the portions are generous. Polite staff, clean appearance, an all-around nice refreshing authentic deli. Dry sausage hanging and all. All around good experience. read more

San Fratello's - Italian Combo - Grocery Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Fresh and tasty . Would come back again. Street parking was pretty easy in the early Saturday afternoon. Happy with the experience. read more

See all

The Al Pacinio...chicken cutlet, prosciutto, arugula, fresh mootz, sun dried tomato, and a slightly sweet balsamic glaze. The location in Tuckahoe is abt 1.5 miles off the Sprain Pkwy...parking in front (never an issue). An absolute gem and it always a visit when I'm down in Westchester. read more

One of the nicest family owned businesses, I've known. Food is always fresh and delicious. read more

Food is so good and so cheap, inflation never hit this place it's like 8 dollars for a sandwich and it feeds me for 2 days, they're huge. People are so sweet and the deli is cute. read more

Had to write another review for this business! Had a party this weekend and chose them for the catering! Did a mix of chicken cutlet, Italian, and American 3 foot sandwiches, not to mention they came with sides of coleslaw, potato salad, and macaroni salad. EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS! Our guests were blown away by how fresh, tasty, and huge the sandwiches were! The sides were a huge hit too! Everyone was making comments, compliments, and asking where the food was from! Plus, they all had seconds and thirds! Happy guests means happy host!! San Fratello's always comes through!! Highly recommend, and the ordering process with Josephine was no hassle at all! Sal made the presentation look beautiful and clean!! They took care of everything! Thank you all!! read more

San Fratello's - 3 foot sandwich - Grocery Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Had prosciutto and mozzarella on a roll with balsamic glaze sandwich. Very substantial and piled high. This was a classic Italian sandwich and I wish I lived in the neighborhood to eat there more often. read more

Small deli, with massive sandwiches. Order a meat lovers sandwich and you will get exactly that. Layered with meats, enough cuts to make a charcuterie board. Great place gf had a bec which was also great. read more

San Fratello's - The Meatlovers Special - Grocery Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

See all

San Fratello's puts out an incredible variety of sandwiches. I'm working my way down their sandwich menu. So far it hasn't disappoint. If you're in the Tuckahoe area of Westchester County, stop by & see for yourself. read more

Incredible little Italian deli in Tuckahoe. Clean, vibrant, and authentic. The food is perfect and the service is fast. Great spot!

Delicious , fresh , great options . Love this place - my go to for a sandwich . Very pleasant people working there too.

Had the Italian grinder. Absolutely amazing! Must have had 12 oz of meat on it. I'm not lying. It fed me for 2 full meals. Delicious. The bread, the array of meats and cheese, etc. I'm a sub/grinder connoisseur and this sandwich was among the top 5 I've ever had. read more

Good deli sandwich's and wraps. Never had a bad experience here, always fresh and priced good!

We used San Fratello's for a large catering order for a 65th birthday party for about 35 guests. Sal and Josephine are beyond amazing and met all of our party needs and exceeded all of our expectations !! They customized our menu from the fresh antipasto , wedge, mozzarella salad, stuffed mushrooms , rice balls, chicken Marsala, veal, Stromboli , hot peppers , penne alla vodka and they even offered chicken fingers and French fries for the kids etc..! Everything was AMAZING !!!! Our guests raved about the food all night! We will most definitely use San Fratello's for all of our future catering needs and can not recommend them enough!! read more

San Fratello's - Grocery Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

See all

Checked out this place today - had The Inferno sandwich. It was absolute fire!!! (Spicy/Amazing) the staff is great here; seating outside; super clean deli; parking outback. There are lots of nice Italian grocery items too. read more

Off the charts good. Had the Al Pacino and I'd say the semolina bread was the best I've ever had. Just terrific stuff.

Delicious little deli and their sandwiches are HUGE! They even have a couple of little tables outside to enjoy your food. Great spot !

Changing to 4 because I got catering from here and I just didn't think it was that great. I was a little disappointed. The eggplant rollitini didn't do anything for me. There was only ricotta not mozzarella and it was nothing special in my opinion. read more

They made me my signature hero today that was killer. Chicken cutlets with sweet peppers, mozzarella, bacon, pesto & mayo. The deli I grew up near actually named this hero after me, the McNasty . Highly recommend you try this place and my signature hero. read more

Love this place but wish they didn't keep Fox News on while customers are in the store. Makes me think twice about going back.

Since I moved to Tuckahoe back in November 2020, they are my go to spot for lunch. I'm big on ordering from Delis, and I was blessed to have a deli walking distance from my home. Their customer service and food are amazing! Had a few of their speciality sandwiches, as well as regular sandwiches ( they have Ciabatta bread!!!), wraps, hot food, and it's all amazing. If you live/work in the area or if your visiting, definitely stop by. read more

If you're looking for the best sandwiches in the country, look no further. San Fratello's has a range of delicious sandwiches for great prices: I regularly get the Sicilian sandwich while my fiancé gets a breakfast wrap. The sandwiches are the best we've had and the staff are incredibly friendly. If you're ever looking for a great breakfast or lunch, this is the place to go. read more

Great homemade food and friendly service! You can't go wrong with any of the sandwiches on the menu, and the prepared foods are delicious

Most underrated deli in Westchester. Great food, fair prices. Friendly workers in who get in it right the first time.

This deli is awesome.. got "The Main Street" sandwich and you can tell everything tastes fresh and the chicken is seasoned well. We go to delis everyday all over WestChester and this deli is deff top 3. Also considering the location and quality of food the prices are cheap and very reasonable. read more

I found out about San Fratello's on the Next Door app. There were nothing but great reviews, so I decided to try it, and it did not disappoint. The eggplant parm was absolutely delicious! Seriously better than any restaurant I've had it at. And so glad I had some leftover because it was even more delicious the next day! The sautéed string beans were also very good and perfectly seasoned. I can't wait to go back and try more of their dishes. The staff were so nice and the place was super clean. And they are very reasonably priced! read more

So nice here! Stopped in her to get my Italian pizza items. Very cozy and super helpful. Looking forward to trying the homemade food!

Great homemade food, great customer service and a wide selection of imported Italian food products.

I am so happy to have found this deli. I ordered a tray of sandwiches to be delivered with a bag of cookies. They loved them! They said the ingredients were fresh and they tasted incredible. The recipient sent me a picture and it even looked wonderful when delivered. I found them by an internet search of Tuckahoe delis. When I called, the woman who helped me couldn't have been nicer and just so helpful. Thanks for the excellent service and delicious food. read more

Went there on a Friday evening but the store was closing. Went back on Saturday afternoon and the owner recognized me right away from the night before. The owners make you feel like family, They are very kind and the food is delicious. Great price too. I would highly recommend this deli to everyone. I will definitely be referring all my friends and family to this place. The entire family is warm and welcoming. read more