I called today to place an order for my wife's birthday (which is a dinner for 3 adults and cake…read morefollowing). However, in an odd turn of events, the lady told me they would not write the words "Happy Birthday" on the cake. She said they only do dessert cakes... I said a dessert cake is perfect but could I have just with words "Happy Birthday" across the top (suppose I was thinking I must have confused the situation somehow).... She said she was sorry but they don't do that.... I said OK well thank you anyway. I so want to support and see Winterville businesses do well.... But just a little flexibility to meet my needs would have been so appreciated and would have made this bakery my go-to place for all needs in the future. Now I go elsewhere... I hope the Sweet Couple will see this review with the sincerity intended.

I've been to this wonderful establishment several times, even ordered my wedding cake from them,…read moreand they have never disappointed me. Yesterday, my family and I went there and I got the Cookies and Cream Cake slice....OMG SO DELICIOUS!!! You have to try it for yourself.

-Cakes are delicious! -It smells so good when you walk…read moreinside. -Service is great! **Don't forget to download the app to get reward points!

The cake is delicious and expensive, also it's way too much icing so. I always ask for less icing…read morewhen l'm buying a cake.

My wedding cake was beautiful but it was very dry and hard. After paying about $400 for the wedding…read morecake I didn't not expect it to be that way. He cake was good that the bridal show but was not for my wedding. We ended up throwing majority of it away. A waste of mone.

Cake slice was absolutely delicious, but pricey. Eclair tasted like the refrigerator and we threw…read moreit out. Wasn't worth it. But the real issue is the lack of politeness we received. When asking a question if they had anything similar to Black Forest cake, we were told "we don't have anything like that" with a pretty rude tone. Of course, recommendations are appreciated similar, but it is cherry/chocolate. And they had plenty of chocolate cakes. Just recommend something else, no need for the nasty attitude. But the cake slice was delicious and rich. Don't think I'll be back just because of that comment. Also, would appreciate labels on the selection. Would've been easier to know what they had, because after asking that question I didn't feel welcome to ask what they had in stock. Three stars only due to the cake being that good--looked like cookie dough but not sure because of a lack of label.

I love the cakes here, I've had the pineapple cake, Golden Oreo cake, the Keylime cake and they're…read moreall delicious and moist. A bit pricey but good enough slice to make up for it. Two people can share it.

My best friend and I came here on a soft opening day to try out some cupcakes after following Made…read morewith Love on Facebook. The space is great: perfectly airy with a clean look and spacious feel. As soon as we walked in, we were warmly greeted by the owner. She ran down the flavors that were available and while they ALL sounded amazing, we opted for two red velvet cupcakes, one earl grey and lavender cupcake, and one cinnamon swirl cupcake. We also received complimentary peanut butter and chocolate mini cupcake while we waited. I ordinarily don't like the combination of peanut butter and chocolate but this mini cupcake was super moist and the peanut butter buttercream perfectly complimented the decadence of the chocolate cake. It was definitely a home run. Our cupcakes were boxed and we paid while chatting with the owner. When we exited, we took pictures of the cupcakes before devouring the first one in the car in four bites each. The cake of the cinnamon swirl was perfectly moist with excellent cinnamon flavor. The buttercream was not only pretty but had a wonderful flavor and perfectly velvety texture. My best friend enjoyed the red velvet, too. Wonderful cupcakes! We will be patronizing Made with Love in the future. I can't wait to explore all this spot has to offer!

Ally was quick in her response when I had questions prior to placing the order. Ally was so patient…read moreand caring too. I sent Made With Love a picture of what I wanted and the cake match my picture. They are so talented! The cake not only it was beautiful but it was moist and full of flavor. Can't wait to work with Made With Love!! The store was also super clean and spacious. I didn't try their cupcakes but there was a great variety available when we went to pick the cake on Saturday before noon.

Love love Gwendys! The maple bacon sticky buns are…read more Customer service is bad. Everybody is super nice. Love the café, it's beautiful inside and you feel right at home!

I've never had anything from this place. That wasn't excellent…read more Very friendly staff and I understand they are Expanding

There cakes are delicious!Their cakes are delicious and all of them are very kind also!read more

This place makes awesome cupcakes. They tend to be fancy ones (red velvet, german chocolate cake,…read morecarrot cake, etc) so I think they use the cupcakes as examples of the cakes they can make. I haven't tried a full cake from them however so I speak for the cupcake experience only. I usually get the german chocolate or the carrot cake cupcakes. I really need to try more, but these are so good that I keep getting them over and over. It is a small, locally owned shop so you may need to wait a minute or two for them to finish what they are doing and come out from the back. Simple shop but I'm paying for something that tastes good, not their decor. Give this place a try, chances are you'll love it.

The best cold stone I've ever had! The frosting mixed into the coffee Oreo ice cream makes the ice…read morecream so light and creamy. We typically go on the later side and the staff is always happy to make our orders. They will customize anything to your needs. They were nice to allow me to add extra frosting to make the perfect ice cream combination.

Ice cream was very good, and rich. Service was fast. Staff was patient. Place was clean and had…read moreoutdoor seating as well.

Enjoyed talking with the GM and great to have a community minded bagel place. We enjoy a quick meal…read moresometimes and here is a place to get that.

Just moved to the area and found this on the map. Came and tried it with my husband on Saturday,…read moreabsolutely AMAZING! The food is delicious, the staff were so friendly and had great recommendations! We went back this morning as well because the coffee was great quality and we were already craving more. Will definitely be coming back! Atmosphere is friendly and inviting!