I recently took my girlfriend to a surprise dinner at Sardelli to celebrate her recent success in getting a job she had been eagerly anticipating. Before booking my reservation with Sardelli, I read many reviews that seemed a bit inconsistent. This worried me slightly as I had not been before and wasn't sure of what to expect.
I did not know much about Sardelli other than what I had read online and via their website. I was aware that the owner Fulvio is the owner of the former Fulvio 1900 and of my favorite local Hollywood wine bar called Vino. I read a plethora of reviews about Sardelli and scoped out their menu online and decided to make the reservation for Friday at 8pm.
I arrived at Sardelli much later than anticipated and had called Sardelli in advance to notify them that I'd be late the host assured me not to worry. As I arrived I was happy to see that my reservation still held and we were promptly seated on the second floor in the wine cellar room. There was a larger party and one smaller party dining but it wasn't busy at all. Let's get on with the review.....:)
*****'s - Ambiance/Decor - This place is GORGEOUS. The exterior reminds me of a Tuscan villa, and is very nicely situated throwing distance from Hollywood beach. The interior of the restaurant is stunning, the cellar room, the tables, the chandeliers, and the downstairs bar area. Even the elevator is very nice. I love the downstairs open-kitchen concept, and it's just very well put together. Not many people REALLY dress up in South Florida, but this place makes me want to sport a fine a Italian suit whilst dining. I saw some reviews about the bathrooms not being kept up...I used the bathroom twice that evening and they were immaculately kept each time.
*****'s Service/Staff - Our server was Julian, he was AWESOME. He took his time with us as we are slightly indecisive and like to thoroughly look over the menu items, he was able to offer me two wine suggestions since the original wine I had come for was not there. I ended up with my backup choice and was not disappointed in the slightest. He was very patient with me and my gf taking several times to decide what we wanted to eat. Food came out in perfect timing, not too soon, and not too late. When we got to the second floor, there was no music playing, and my gf whispered "It's really quiet in here" the staff within minutes played some very nice tunes. Our other encounter was with the bartender downstairs, I want to say her name was Jackie? (I forgot as we did get a bit tipsy lol) she was also excellent, she allowed me to try several of the wines at not cost and was VERY attentive as a bartender and the restaurant itself was closed and only entertaining a small group of people. The service was outstanding all around, and I could not have been happier.
****'s Food - I've dined at some pretty fancy establishments over the years. Scarpetta, Palme D'Or, Ai Fiori, etc.Sardelli can definitely hold up to some of these establishments. The food that night was excellent, and as the restaurant matures, I am sure the food will only get better and better. My only complaint was that my Lobster pasta could've had a little bit more creativity added to it to set it apart from the others I've had. My girlfriends Lobster Francese was amazing, the lobster was very fresh and a very generous portion. Appetizer of grilled octopus and white beans was to die for, the buratta was incredibly fresh and tasted great. The amuse bouche of butternut squash soup was amazzzzing.
****'s Value - I admit, some of the dishes are a bit pricey, but I understand that given the total experience, ambiance, and location you are paying a bit extra for the total package. I felt treated as if I was a valued patron and not as if this place only caters to people with hordes of money as I feel at some establishments. On my way out I ran into Fulvio and he is incredibly humble and nice. He even warned me of the step that I was about to tumble over lol.
4.5 *'s Overall - I selected 5 *'s here but I would like it to be 4.5 8*'s. It's very difficult for a restaurant to get the 5 star rating. Fulvio at Sardelli is doing an amazing job and if he stays true to his art and takes criticism constructively, he can develop a 5 star establishment.
NOTE: For those complaining about the parking and knocking the reviews due to paying "6.00 to Valet..." there is a Parking Garage across the block on Harrison street that won't cost you more than 2 dollars. However, if you're griping about paying 6 dollars for valet and then going to spend 35+ on a plate of food per person, you probably shouldn't be dining out at restaurants with that price tag anyway. Don't reflect your hatred on having to valet park you car into the total review of the restaurant because it grossly skews the rating. Park in the parking garage and walk, or valet your car and don't gripe about it. read more