10.13 for 2 slices of pepperoni pizza that were thinner than a piece of paper. I had to go buy more food afterwards because this Chuck E. Cheese pizza did nothing for me. Then I looked at my bank activity and they charged me $12.16 instead of the $10.13 I was told at the register. First and last time I will ever step foot in this place. The pizza looked like it was sitting there since this morning, do not go here. read more

This place is delicious. Wish they had Zeppolis. Their prices are reasonable and if you want a quick slice here is to go!! Much better than mama Lisa's read more

I went here for the first time. I order a plain slice and a chicken roll. The marinara sauce on my plain slice had a funny taste and the dough was too hard. The chicken roll was all dough the chicken had an off taste. I was highly disappointed on the food. I wouldn't recommend it. Service was okay no good customer service, just someone asking what you want and here's the price now are you eating here or out. Definitely not going back here. read more

Walked in for lunch on a Sunday afternoon, with my wife and two daughters (3yrs & 1). As soon as we walked in we were greeted with the most inappropriate music blasting. I'm sorry, but Missy Elliotts "Work it" isn't exactly desired background music for a family lunch. The profanity wasn't even censored. It's just inappropriate to play any music like that at a family establishment. Leave it for the bars and clubs. Don't suggest going if you have children! read more

$10.45 for 1 pepperonni slice, 1 regular slice, and a small coke. ripoff. spend your money elsewhere if looking for pizza in the area. read more

Savarona is great Long Island pizza, let me start off with that! When I came in I saw that it was pretty busy in the store. The cashier, a young very polite girl took the orders. The pickings were many so I had time to decided as they took down the line. I'm bad at picking so I tried the Spinach Stromboli and the Chicken, bacon Ranch, slice. Man I didn't know what I was in for. The Stromboli danced in my mouth! The chicken slice talked sweet nothings into my ear. The Stromboli was full of cheese and spinach, it was crunchy outside with Parmesan and light oil on its shell. It added to the already strong flavor of the spinach. The chicken, bacon, ranch slice went another path. The well cooked chicken was fried and mixed with chopped bacon. There was no marinara sauces, it was completely ranch based. The tomato on the bottom actually helped the tangy ranch flavor stand out. I have no choice now but to try more menu items later. Now that I done grabbing your stomachs attention, it's time to speak to your eyes. When I walked in I saw the table were not wiped down at all. I mean there were crumbs everywhere. The table I sat at I moved because there was a cup with a straw still in it. They had water damaged ceiling tiles move out of place that exposed the dirty roof. The floor tiles have seen better days too! At least 80% of them were cracked. The deliver guy dropped his pizza holder at a empty table then went to the bathroom. For some people that might be offensive. Lastly when there's downtime the staff sat at a table and talked, loud. I don't think customers want to here there conversation at all. All that is still not enough to keep me away! I plan to come again soon and try there heroes. Just know what you want when you get here. Don't buy everything like me. read more

See all

best pizza i've had and pasta! Their penne ala vodka is amazin. My boyfriends family caters from here all the time and I love it.

My girlfriend was asked to leave because she did not have a mask on. She is fully vaccinated and nys and cdc has lifted the rule. I called and asked to speak to the owner. He or she was not there. I politely explained to the employee that her me and my friends and family will not patronize this establishment until they lift this insane rule. This is now on the owner. They can no longer say it's not my fault. It's the law. Myself and a dozen others will go elsewhere. What a shame. So dumb to lose business. I guess they can afford it though. Plenty of pizza places I can go to that don't require this nonsense. read more

Walked in just for a slice, The girl puts the slice in the oven and tells me it's $3.75. To my embarrassment I only had $3.00 left in my pocket because I lost my debit card so haven't been able to take money out. She asks the other guy if that's ok? The small man with the Napoleon attitude says "Well that's what it cost". I told him to keep his slice and walked out. 1st off lose your little attitude. 2- I didn't know you guys were hurting that bad. 3- $3.75 for a slice!?, glad I didn't have the .75 cents. I went to the parking lot and called Mama Lisa's down the road for a fresh pie, that I paid for with a credit card. Go to Mama Lisa's, it's WAY better food, friendlier staff, better prices, better atmosphere and from what I saw great lunch specials. Thanks for encouraging me to buy elsewhere. read more

I am VERY disappointed with this place readers beware, this is going to blow your mind. My family and i have been ordering various forms of stuffed pies from this place for years . Usually they are pretty good , sometimes a bit of a flop. But we always kept going because nothing too serious was ever wrong. Well this time we ordered a stuffed meat pie with olives and when the pie got home there was VERY little meat and no olives. So we called and spoke with the owner who said his chef admitted to forgetting the olives and that he would replace the pie and just come in in 20 min to get it. so with the remaining 4.5 slices excluding the half chewed remainders, we went to pick up the pie. out comes the fresh stuffed pie and the guy takes the pie and cuts it in half and said hes only replacing the uneaten portion. WHAT AN A**WIPE! honestly how are you going to tell a loyal patron that you will replace the pizza you royally screwed up and then when they come in for the promised replacement give them half. to top it off the half they took back from us, he set on the back table and we had to ask... "are you going to throw that out? " he said "throw what out? " we walked away. DO NOT DO IT ! read more

Savarona Pizzeria - The half of a pizza pie that the owner gave us to replace the whole pizza they screwed up. - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, New York

I love NY pizza and this is our new favorite place when we are in Suffolk county. We use to go to Carlo's Pizza but they have gone downhill over the years so Savarona is now our favorite go-to-place. Whenever I eat at a new pizza place, I always order the plain cheese so I can really taste the sauce and cheese. Savarona's does a good job with making sure their pizza's have a good amount of both sauce and cheese. The combo of those 2 ingredients are what make a pizza perfection.. so simple, but yet so dificult to master. I also like that their dough is chewy and just a tad sweet. One thing I did notice is that their pizza is slightly saltier than other NY pizza, so don't add salt unless you really like your pizza's salty. read more

I'd give it to 2.5 stars if possible. Passable chicken roll mostly bread though just under 8$ with a cup of sauce idk what sauce but didn't taste like Marinera. Don't feel necessarily ripped off but I'm positive I'll never come here again. read more

First time here walked in all the pies looked like they were sitting around for awhile. Was recommended by a friend 2 slices $6.31. Went home and eat the 2 slices they were dry and had hardly any cheese. Never going back there. read more

This pizzeria just won my loyalty. I've had pizza from them a couple of times with friends but I just called and placed an order myself for the first time and the customer service was INCREDIBLE. I work in food service so I have very high standards for "good service." The girl on the phone was so nice and didn't sound bothered by the call (which so many places and people do?!). She was very patient; I asked what they have as far as desserts go and she listed what they have, again, without sounding impatient. I used my card to pay over the phone and anytime she didn't hear me clearly she politely asked me to repeat or confirm what I said, clearly wanting to ensure the order and my card o info were correct. And finally, I asked to make sure I can tip on the card and she fully explained how to put a tip on the card. Again, the patience, kindness, and friendliness was astounding. I can't say enough about how good of an experience it was. I'm so pleased to have spoken to such a good representative for the pizzeria! I didn't get the girl's name so I hope they recognize who this is because she deserves all the praise!! read more

This is why I miss living in NY, this pizza is great. And the pie was $13 instead of pizza half the size and taste for $20 in San Francisco. read more

Savarona Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, New York

I have ordered 3 times. I think the pizza is excellent. But, only the 1st time was a pleasant experience! The 2nd time pizza guy showed up gave us pizza got tipped a $5 and quickly left. We quickly discovered that the pizza top was pressed against the pizza. We called they were helpful and said they will send another one. They did 30 min later it showed up. We should have recieved a discount or some knots for the trouble. .but No! The 3rd time the same driver kid shows up with $20's and $50's for change. What did he expect a $15 tip? We then opened the pizza and see that the cheese had slid all to one side and half the pizza didn't have any cheese. Oh and they didn't send the marinara sauce we requested for knots. This will be our last order despite the pizza being decent..even thou they couldnt figure out what well done meant! read more

My favorite pizza by far. Everything is better here. The crust is thin and perfect and the cheese is real. You can definitely taste the difference. I can't get enough of the garlic knizzots yo. read more

See all

Sorry, but just no. I know it seems good to have in the Kohl's outlet while doing shopping, but there are plenty of better eateries around. I remember going once or twice as a kid and be very underwhelmed, but figured I'd try again. (Just a heads up, the following story happened a few years ago, but I couldn't find the name of this place so yeah, outdated story that's gonna cause eye rolls, but anyway.) I was doing some birthday shopping for a friend at Michael's and was starving by the time I was done, so I decided to retry this place. The service seemed pleasant enough and let me and my friend who was with me sit in the back. While that may sound nice, they were reluctant to let us do so, but it was a cold, blustery day in March, and the door was wide open, with insects flying in. This room in the back was dinky, cold and honesty a little gross. Our pizza? UGH. May I bring up again we were very hungry, but it was near inedible. It was painfully overcooked, you couldn't even taste the cheese and marinara. My garlic knot was also scorched. I mean, I hate how a majority of LI's Italian food is undercooked and doughy, but that doesn't mean I want it cooked to practicality nothing! To top this lovely meal off, (and here's where the eye rolls start,) 2 employees plopped themselves down and the one had a cone on his head for who-the-hell-knows what reason, and the charmer that was near him said, "nice China hat! You should be a ninja fer Halloween!" Um, wait to mix up your cultures on top of your racist comments! To which he responded, "no, I'm being a m**get fer Halloween because I have a high voice and I'm short." SERIOUSLY? That's like putting yourself in a wheelchair and saying you're going as a cr*pple. It's discrimination and it's repulsive. A giant middle finger to their racist and ableist selves. Learn hygiene, cooking skills, and sensitivity then we'll talk. Yes, I acknowledge again this was awhile ago, but it needs to be addressed. And also again, NO. read more

BEST SLICE IN TOWN! My family and I are huge pizza eaters and since savarona's has come to town we have not gotten pizza from anywhere else! read more

I went in there today and saw absolutely no one who worked there wearing a face mask. On top of that the person making the pizza had it less than a foot from his face I don't need corona thanks. Never going back there again if I could give it zero stars I would read more

Tried the first time tonite. Ordered a pizza for delivery, was told one hour. Now 2 hours and 15 minutes, Called, was told the driver was lost. Never again! read more

I have always like this place in the past, but when i ordered food from here last night it was a totally different experience. I called and i must have had an older menu, because they don't make the combo platter i like (veal and stuffed shells parmigiana dinner) anymore. When i asked if they could just make it , they said no and that i would have to order the veal and stuffed shells separate. I was a little taken back Then at the end of my order i asked for the total, i ordered 2 veal parmigiana heroes, 1 sausage parm hero, and stuffed shells dinner. I asked for the total and the girl over the phone said "I cant give you the total cause another girl is using the register". I told her nicely that I needed to know how much money to bring with me and she finally gave me the total. Thirdly when i brought the order home I found that there was almost no sausage in the sausage parm hero. the veal was ok and they only gave 3 stuffed shells in the dinner. But the sausage parm was ridiculous. In conclusion I have decided to never go back there and I'll have to find another place for Italian night. read more

This pizza place is the best. In the Mastic Beach/Mastic/Shirley area there are a lot of mediocre pizza places but this one is legit. Every time we're in that shopping center I always get myself a slice from the best. Out of all the years I've lived out here I could never find a pizza place that was right for me they (other pizza places) always had something I didn't like. This one is perfect the staff is friendly, the tables are usually clean and the pizza is great. If you're ever in the area stop by and get yourself a slice. read more

I went to this place for the first time my dad use to love there pizza and always spoke very highly about the staff very nice polite accommodating.so I figured I would give them a try I'm glad I did the best ever Sicilian pizza I ever ate .. the crust was so light and flaky delicious . Will def be back read more

Its OK, I have eaten here several times out of convenience while at Stop N Shop or Kohls, but I don't really consider it a destination Pizza place. They do have variety iof different Pizzas including a pretty decent deep dish, but I prefer going to either Mama Lisa(West on mtk) or a tad east to Domenic's Mr.Pizza (Pathmark). It is an above average pizza I just think there are a few better in the neighborhood. read more

First I wouldnt even give this a rating but since you have too I went with the lowest possible one. Since shopping in this shopping center it seemed a conveinent place to stop and have lunch with my family. We order several different speciality slices and sat down to eat our meal. The first problem was nothing was hot and everything was greasy. Two bites into out meal A ROACH went running across my table right on top of the napkin holder! When I approched the people behind the counter they just shrugged their shoulders and said "i cant belive that the exterminators were just here last night" and he walked away. We quickly got our money back and left. So disgusted I would never eat there again and never reccommended this place to anyone. If those disgusting bugs are out during the day I can only imagine the problem they have with them!! read more

Been coming here for around 10 years. They have had ownership changes in that time but whoever owns it now does a nice job. Pizza to stay is awesome. Comes out perfect. read more

Giving 5 stars since this has been the best pizza near me (I'm in Moriches) in the six years I've lived here. I've been to all the joints and this one is by far the best and most consistent (We go to Anton's too). The last few pies we've ordered for take out have been a bit on the thin side (their pizza is not the thickest usually, but this has been thinner than usual). Not sure if there's a new pizza maker in there!! I recommend the place. You can't go wrong for pizza here. read more

Worst customer service. Owner/manager is nasty and does not know how to speak to customers. They completely messed up an order and double charged my card. I was told there was no way for them to reverse the charge and that the next time I ordered there would be a note in their system to make it right. When I called the next time to order again and explained what happened I was told that the girl who did this was fired and there is nothing they can do. Not how you should treat customers. I will never be going back there. read more

My husband went there yesterday to get some pasta carbonara, they charged us $30 for 2 pasta carbonara and when we got home we realized the pasta was plain. I called to tell them I didn't want plain pasta I wanted it creamy, we came back to exchange the pasta and they pretty much gave us the same pasta with sauce poured out of the can! It was disgusting! We will not be coming back! So overpriced for such bad food and horrible customer service. read more

I Love Savarona's! I have always held fast to the belief that the further away from the geographic center of Brooklyn you get, the crappier the pizza is, and I have no idea how the clean majority of other pizza places in the area stay in business, but this place makes great pizza. Best Ever? Nah, but it is damn good. They have good side dishes, and lots of different types of pizza, and the staff is friendly and helpful. And now they deliver! If I'm eating pizza in Central Suffolk, I'm going to Savarona's. read more

My fave pizza place around here, crust tastes amazing and cheese is real not that cheap fake cheese I've encountered at other places. Sauce is good too. I'm a regular here read more

Great pizza, great mozzarella sticks. I've been gong there for years. They have always been good to me and my family.

Two words: Food Poisoning, got a regular pie and 4 hours later i couldn't get off the toilet and 20 minutes after that i was puking. Do Not Eat Here! read more

My family and I have stopped in a few times for pizza while shopping. The food is ok/ good but certainly not amazing however while stopping in today with my mother for a slice I noticed the man behind the counter pick up the tip basket and look in it and say something like " ugh really" ( it was empty). I was a little shocked that he did this right in front of a customer. While eating my mother and I saw him do this to the 2 customers after us as though he was trying to create attention for someone to give a tip!!!! He heated the pizza and that's about it so I am not sure why he wanted a tip. We will not be eating here again with employees acting like this. read more

Food is delicious! I highly recommend this place! There baked ziti is to die for!! They are always very friendly there. Only thing that is annoying is they have a min for the card. I usually don't carry cash on me and just run in for a slice ect and I can't use my card. Even as a debit. But other then that. Great food! read more

CAUTION! They advertise "Gluten Free" pizzas but they bake them in the same oven as the regular pizzas which defeats the purpose. They will also put on toppings from the regular pizza area = Cross contamination. Pizzerias that don't fully understand what Gluten Free is, should not be allowed to sell items labeled as such read more

This pizza place is really good for how far east it is. The crust is delicious, the sauce is good, and the cheese isn't that cheap crap other places give you. read more

It's been a while since I've been here but tonight was an awful experience. My husband and I decided to split an eggplant parm hero and it was terrible! First, there was about a 1/4 of the amount of eggplant I was expecting (even more sad since their prices went up), no sauce on the eggplant at all, it was overcooked and had a TON of cheese on it. Thankfully my salad was good but my dinner had already been ruined. Sad to see the place isn't what it used to be. read more

Good Pizza is hard to find out East, so a place like Savaronas is great for someone as picky with there pizza as I am, great crust, nothing gets left out and go's stale, I give there sauce a 7 out of a 10, but hey, I've been very disappointed with Mama Lisas, and other Italian restaurants in town... read more