As a transplant from Queens, this pizza reeks of said boro. Long Island pizza is too thick, too cheesy, undercooked, and overwhelmingly bloatedly bland. As for your Traditional Neopolitan, The Don has a perfectly balanced sauce, and just the right ratio of cheese. To be safe, I always order Well-Done, but I really do like the char flavour of a hot oven! We have had some other food here- Chicken Française, which is spectacular. Nice crunch on the chicken, loads of lemon and fresh herbs. Garlic Knots- small, packed with the purest Garlic, Oil, and Parmesan. Grandma Pie. Haven't had not a single bad bite food in all of the years. Coming back to visit NY, there is always the anticipation of taking a pie out. read more

SO GOOD!! The best garlic knots in Long Island... and pizza reminds me of Queens ones! People say too little cheese but I think its perfect ratio. I dont like when cheese slides off my pizza. Glad to find this pizza spot with ubereats! read more

Don Jono's Pizzeria - Garlic knots are so yummy - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Pizza is consistently excellent. Staff always goes above and beyond. Can't recommend here enough!

Solid food, consistently good. The staff are great. Get a pint of the rainbow cookie ice cream trust me

My family and I have been eating here for years! Their food is excellent and always consistent! Their help is always friendly! One my favorite chicken ceaser salad! read more

Stopped in for a quick slice. The gentleman behind the counter was so kind. We chatted about the Yankees and our connection with the Bronx. I ordered a pepperoni slice. It was perfect. The sauce on the slice was flavorful and the crust perfectly crisp. There's some tables to eat in if you like. Definitely a good neighborhood staple. read more

Best garlic knots around , by far ! Everyone is super friendly. They kept pumping during COVID when a lot of places were closed. Good traditional Pizza . read more

Not what I was expecting when I asked for 1/2 meatball and 1/2 pepperoni. But I guess technically you weren't wrong either read more

Don Jono's Pizzeria - Not really what I was expecting when I asked for 1/2 meatball and 1/2 pepperoni. But I guess technically it is 1/2 1/2. ‍ - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I ordered a pizza for lunch on two different occasions both with chicken and I'm extremely disappointed. The chicken taste very weird and old. At first I thought it was an off day for them but after a second time and their chicken tasting strange it is definitely not okay. I do not recommend anything with chicken at their restaurant. read more

The food and service are always of very high quality. I ordered the chicken Parm hero and it was perfect. Very tasty sauce and cheese covering a very generous amount of chicken. My wife who is gluten free had the gf penne with broccoli,garlic and oil. She loved it. With such a generous portion, I had some too. It was so fresh and savory that I hardly realized it was gluten free which is quite a complement. Very fair prices,great service and really good food. Go Don Jono. We love this place. read more

We moved out here from Queens 2 years ago and it has been a struggle to find good pizza until!!! We found this spot! It's always the small joints that been around for a while that make the best pizza! read more

Food is great! Service and staff are extremely friendly. A must if you're a local. Try the pizza's and the salads are great and love their pasta dishes. read more

Completely random reason I was in the area and although I've passed it over the years I never stop in that shopping center. Had a slice (Excellent, crust, cheese, suace..) and a special item Thick sliceed ham and provolone in a garlic knot bun. By far the one of the best things I've eaten in a while. Have to take longer lunch to go back. Great job!! read more

They make a delicious rice ball and a delicious pizza pie . The service is great and they make you feel welcomed . read more

Don Jono's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Greatest pizza around, nice staff . Step above the rest, I new original owner and I'm happy quality didn't change when ownership did. Many times that's the case. read more

I'm going to be honest. Black People/POC that happen to be in this neighborhood, do not eat at this restaurant. At least one to two of the guys behind the counter are racist. I'm a relatively new customer, but my girlfriend had been going there all her life. The last FEW times, the guy behind the counter told her and myself, both separately and together, that we could get the heck out of his restaurant. I thought maybe he'd said it jokingly when she told me what happened when she was alone, but once I was in there with her the next time, I could hear the undertone and seriousness is clear. We're both of brown/caramel complexion. I've yet to see him say this to anyone white or white passing. It wasn't always like this. Let's say there's even a 1% chance that I'm wrong and he's not a racist,..one of the other comments here says a guy behind the counter called her friend a c*nt as they left just because they were confused about the order they were picking up. Honestly with what i experienced, that's totally believable for me. On that alone, the customer service here is clearly trash, and that's not a place I want my money going towards. We shouldn't have had to feel that way in 2021, or ever. Safe to say we're never going back to this place again. read more

Very friendly staff. Entrees are huge! Enough to share! Shopping center it's in looks dismal. Very tasty. Worth the extra drive to support a local business read more

Not only is this my friends restaurant, but the food is fantastic! Get over here and try it yourself!

Food was so salty we couldn't even eat it. Called up to let them know and they told us there's nothing they can do about it they cook food with salt to flavor and you can't have flavor without salt. I couldn't believe it. This was my final attempt there previously they forgot a dish and I was too tired to go back so they credited me for next time. The next time I ate there I reminded them of my credit and he said you have a credit for an eggplant parmesan not chicken parmesan and you only ordered chicken tonight. That was the salt night so we never returned and I never will redeem that credit read more

It's quarantine. You don't want to be out and about trying to judge places by what they look like. We took a gander on this one. We ordered through door dash and honestly it was the best decision We've ever made. Their sauces are out of this world, it had us closed eyed and savoring the flavors. The portion sizes? Amazing. Definitely recommend their Penne a la Vodka! read more

I'm at St Catherine hospital and ordered from them tonight and they did not disappoint . pizza is delicious and they are incredibly nice people. Thank you for the great pizza guys !!!!!! read more

The food speaks for itself (which is 5 stars on its own) but I'm writing this review about the people behind the counter. Every time I go in here they're having a conversation with a customer. They go above and beyond to make everyone feel welcome. I get nothing but compliments when I'm here. Who doesn't love to hear they have a great shirt, right? The family feeling is one I'll frequent any establishment for. PS if you're GF, their cauliflower crust pizza is one of the best we've found. read more

The pizza is good, the dough is not too thick and it doesn't drip with oil. Garlic breads are the best read more

Don Jono's Pizzeria - a pepperoni and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Purchased stuffed meat pizza over Fathers Day weekend 2022. Quality has fallen off a cliff since last purchase about 6 months ago. Pie diameter was 17" and the cheese portion of stuffing was only a 12" diameter circle inside the pie. Meat stuffing was less than that diameter and thinner as well. Doing some quick math revealed that 50% of pie was only dough with no filling. Marinara sauce has changed as well. Much lower quality than in the past with a much lighter color. I may try once more in future to see if situation fixed before dropping this establishment. read more

Don Jono's Pizzeria - Paltry stuffing in stuffed meat slice. A real joke of a portion! - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Great Food and they treat you like family,Have been going there since my children were toddlers and they are grown ups now.

Hands down the best pizza and food in town ! Billy, Phil, Jeff, Louie and the entire staff at Don Jono's not only make the most amazing Italian dishes , they are the NICEST people as well ! Hands down - Don Jono's is my family's fav ! Best food , best people !! read more

I do not care for their pizza but the hot food is tasty. We recently catered food for a family barbecue and the food was a hit. The sausage and peppers were good but a bit salty, while the chicken Frances's was absolutely delicious! read more

Don Jono's Pizzeria - a table full of food - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Always a solid slice! Regular slices have the right consistency for folding over. They don't make too many specialty slices but if you ask for simple toppings, they'll throw a ton on to a regular with some extra mozz before heating it in the oven. Slices come out crispy, melt-y and delicious. Sicilian slices are great as well. There's plenty of parking and a good sized seating area. Brings back memories of my lunch period during senior year at Smithtown High School... read more

There is really no better pizzeria around for miles, so I would always recommend this place while in the area. My friends and I frequented this place quite often senior year of high school and I always looked forward going to school knowing I will end up here for lunch. I was a little disappointed going back and realizing they no longer make pepperoni rolls. But their pizza is still good. Decor is a little outdated and there only a few booths inside, but I would still recommend getting take-out read more

Pretty bad overall. First of all, what the heck is in the Cesar dressing? It's so terrible that it made the salad inedible. Grilled chicken was dry and rubbery. Chicken franchise was absolutely awful...bland and it's like they forgot the lemon which is key to this dish. The Alfredo taste nothing like Alfredo style dishes. I question if they actually understand what these Italian dishes should at least somewhat taste like. AVOID THIS PLACE! read more

It's like these guys are from my old neighborhood in Brooklyn. Excellent pizzeria on the Smithtown/ Commack boarder where one bite of their regular slices take me back to Knickerbocker Ave. Perfectly crispy crust and great sauce to cheese ratio. Closest I can get to Bushwick on Long Island. Great counter service and reasonable prices. Highly recommended for superior pizza. read more

Don Jono's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

I've always loved Don Jono's!! It's my favorite pizza place, ever since they first opened!

We absolutely love Don Juno's. The pizza is always great, the hero's are delicious, and the grilled chicken Greek salad is awesome! It's the only place we get pizza from for many, many years. read more

Ordered a shrimp parm hero and garlic bread w/ cheese for delivery, it was delicious! Excited to order from here again (this was my first time). read more

Old School Pizzeria. Don't expect anything fancy, but the food is good. Here's a test to know whether you would like this place: They don't have ice for their fountain drinks. The water lines are refrigerated so the drinks are cold, but not ice cold. To some people, this is no problem (or even a good thing because you get more liquid). To other people, it's the end of the world. read more

Great food. Great owner and employees. IF they make a mistake,they make it right and do the right thing. Hard to find today.

This use to be my Number one place for a Great Pie but when they cut corners on the Cheese the pizza has never been or tasted the same.I like the Staff very polite but the Pies And the Sicilian are not number one anymore..Did they Change Owners. ?? read more

Can I just give up a hallelujah for the fact that after trying so many pizza places in this area, that this is one of the few that has a 12 slice Sicilian? I'm over this 10 slice BS that seems to be taking over. Anyway, the pizza was very yummy. I also ordered their cheese stuffed garlic knots. Also good, but coated in an extra layer of olive oil that is not to my taste. Rice ball parm was on point though. After living in the area for 5 months and trying many recommendations, I can finally declare this place as my go to pizza spot. read more

My first time ordering from Don Jono's. Pizza is good, cheesy garlic knots are awesome and the delivery person was super nice. Might be my new go-to spot. read more

One of the few pizza places that the better item is their hero's. The pizza is good and the specialty pizza is better, but the hero's are fantastic. They are big and filled with whatever you want. Meatball, eggplant, sausage and more. At only $10 it's a meal and a half. Just be careful of Friday nights. At dinner time the line is out the door. read more

Don Jono's Pizzeria - The line at Don Jonos on a Friday Night. It's worth the wait. Order ahead. - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York