Just found out about Ciro's pizza. First off, super friendly staff. They greeted me when I walked in. A few guys behind the counter and they were chatting with me while I waited for my pie. Traditional style pizza place. A great NY style slice. I like how the doughy the crust is. This is one of my new favorite pizza places. The pizza wasn't too oily and the cheese was the perfect amount. read more

Great pizza, great staff, the grilled chicken was so good on the house salad. Definitely a to go kind of place.

Amazing pizza slice. Very good size slice lots of meat, cheese and sauce plain Jane atmosphere. Have eaten so much pizza lately it's hard to tell them all apart solid 4.5 only behind Branchanellis read more

The regular pizza here is delicious! Great place to grab quick slices. Owners seem to always be there working and the quality never slips.

The pizza was amazing. FResh and hot. Slices were generous. Staff was attentive and friendly. read more

I had several shops for varied pizza pies and sometimes together with HEROS. All my family members enjoyed the tastes of CIRO's Pizza! It's our regular lunch picks! Love you CIRO's! read more

The guy at the register was very rude for some reason, barely filled up my sprite drink and made a weird remark when I asked for a fork, the food I got was also terrible and I ended up going to chick fil a next store.. never go here. Unless u wanna feel awkward. The old man's name is Tony. He is not a professional read more

Five-star hole-in-the-wall slice shop. Always pass by on 347 but going the wrong direction, we were in the area, and the slices were balanced and crispy. The counter service was friendly and prices were fair. We'll be back next time we're southwest of Spuntinos. read more

Ciro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Best pizza I ever had!! First time going and I loved it. The staff was very friendly. Perfect slice of pizza and great caesar salad. Loved it! read more

Some of the best pizza in the area. The Sicilian is especially good. Light and crispy.

Visited for lunch this week. The slices are gigantic, and taste delicious. Even with how busy it was during the lunch rush, the employees kept getting food to people as soon as possible. read more

Hands down the best pizza! I have been coming here since they opened the doors many years ago! Same owners and amazing pizza! The only pizza I ever have, even when traveling up from Florida I usually bring a couple pies back! read more

Pizza was great, people were nice and friendly Nice place to meet a friend for a slice! read more

I admit, Ciros is still great pizza. Moving away from this town I rarely get to have it. So a few days ago, I treated myself but I was so surprised of how expensive it got. Sure inflation is hitting everyone and food prices are increasing but $50 for one pie (half topping) 12 garlic knots and a pinwheel? At that price point, I could get almost 3 pies from my local joint. I think their high rating got to their head and I'm afraid I'm in no rush of returning. read more

Ordered from Ciro's on a whim this past weekend and left an impression great enough to make me want to leave a review. I heard about Ciro's Pizza just through word of mouth. Safe to say, the hype is real. We ordered a Sicilian pizza and loved every bit of it. The pizza pie was very thick and flavorful. The sauce was made just right. It was crispy and very fresh. Highly recommend Ciro's the next time you are craving pizza. Delivery was very fast. Prices are affordable. read more

Excellent pizza and quality service. The owner was incredibly nice with a great sense of humor (he could tell we were from California). The pizza was exactly how New York style pizza should be--thin, greasy, cheesy, hot and delicious. Thank you, Ciro's, for a great experience. We look forward to our next visit! read more

Ciro's Pizza - Pepperoni Slice (Sausage Slice in the Background) - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I stopped in for a few slices to go on my way home from work and I'm so glad I did. Don't let the decor deter you from the really great pizza. Pizza is priced like everywhere else, and it was worth every penny. I also chatted with the employees and owner a little and the service was really great. Overall I'm really pleased with my experience and I would come here again for sure. read more

Really great pizza being in Smithtown! From the crust, to the cheese, it was all great. Not very oily either. Can't wait to go back. Garlic knots are like mini sizes. It was tasty too. Service was good and prices are well worth it. Service: 5/5 Food: 4/5 Price: 4/5 Overall: 4/5 read more

Ciro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Delicious pizza. My family and I always get the pepperoni pie. Friendly environment. Good service. read more

Pretty excellent pizza in the area! Looks like the restaurant got a makeover now that the entire strip was redone. But inside is very clean and decorated with tons of pizza paraphernalia (pizza-phernalia?) I ended up ordering a white slice to go. Pretty quick and friendly service and the pizza itself was amazing. Sturdy, almost buttery base and crust. With a plentiful amount of gooey and creamy cheese on top. A dusting of garlic powder on top and I was in heaven. Honestly, it's further than my local pizza joint but I may have to make Ciro's my go to in the area! read more

We were in Long Island for the weekend and tried the two best reviewed NY-style slices in the area that we could find on Yelp - Ciro's and Paradise Pizza in Commack. Both were good, but Ciro's was the clear winner. The sauce was sweeter and not as bold, the cheese was gooier, and the crust was a tad thinner. It just tasted much better overall. I really, really enjoyed it. I am not a New Yorker and have not tried Di Fara or Famous Ray's or Scarr's but of the NY slices I've had, this one is the best. I can't imagine another place making better NY-style pizza, but some supposedly exist because I've never seen Ciro's on any "Best of NY" lists. I've been dreaming about this pizza since trying it and if I ever find myself in LI again, this will be my first stop off the plane. read more

Ciro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Large pie is 18 inches instead of 22 inches it's also $22! And very thin how is it little Vincent's pizza can sell a 22 inch pie for $ 11.50 but no one else can ? Not the best value . Quality of food doesn't justify the price. read more

I can definitely see why there are so many good ratings for this place. Went during lunch on a weekday and expected a bigger crowd but the pizza did not disappoint at all. I would def stop in here again if I have an appointment in the area. Great job! read more

Ciro's Pizza - Cheese Pizza and Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Every single food item me and my family have eaten from Ciro's is absolutely delicious!!! The owner and the staff go out of their way to make you feel like family. I have eaten a lot of different pizza from around the world and Ciro's wins! YUMMMMMY! I'm ordering now. lol. Scrumdiddlyupmptious! ENJOY read more

Really good white slice. A little pricy but the slices are oversized. Great pepperoni pinwheels too.

I've been back a few times for take out and eat in, since my first review. Still the best on Long Island. I drive 12 miles just for this pizza because everything local is just bad! Ciro's uses real cheese with a nice pull, and a nice old school thin crispy crust. And the family 5hat runs it is very friendly, they know us now. Mangia bene! read more

Was passing by & decided to give Ciro's a try for the first time. Had the reg slice which was big $3.75 & it was really good. The ppl behind the counter were all very nice. Must be a well known place because the pick up orders were non-stop. read more

A buddy and I stopped in to get some grub to bring next door to Tap n Barrel after a long hike through Blydenburg. The pickins were slim so I grabbed a grandma and a plain slice for $5.50 The three slices of plain at about $2.75 a slice were quite large, the three together was an entire half a pie which means it was 1/3 larger than your normal pizza shop slice here on the island and I'd say 1/3 tastier too :) There was a bit of grease but it was crisp and tasty. Not my favorite and the crust wasn't amazing either but all in all a decent slice for sure. -Y'all are too bold to claim they are the best on the island- Again, when oil drops out, that's not at all a sign of "the right cheese." There is both high a low moisture mozz, there is greasy pizza and oily sauce, there is also amazing pizza that doesn't drench your plate in grease and visa versa. It's a great slice, and I'd order a ton more, but the best is just a stretch of all your doughy brains. Also, stop using the word Neapolitan in all your reviews and get educated. This is NOT anywhere near Neapolitan style pizza. It's yummy, it's not Neapolitan. read more

Ciro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

This owner is DISGUSTING!! RUDE and told a customer that asked for extra sauce to GET out and never come back. because his worker was UNABLE to add extra sauce to a slice of pizza because she was on the phone. He clearly does not allow phones in his medicore pizzeria. & has a DISGUSTING attitude for absolutley NO reason. STAY AWAY if you own a phone. STAY AWAY if you want extra sauce STAY AWAY if you want a decent slice of pizza STAY AWAY if you like good service STAY AWAY if you dont wish to be treated poorly. read more

Grape pie! Fantastic flavor! I will definitely go back if I'm in that area. Why does Yelp make you write so many words. My first two phrases sum it up read more

Ciro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

It was my first time at this pizza place. The pizza was very good. I had a chicken slice which had big chunks of chicken on it and a regular slice. It was too much pizza for me to eat both of them so I took one to go. read more

There really isn't much to say... Ciro's is seriously the best pizza on Long Island, and in my all-time top 5 for anywhere (which are all in NY, so don't try to convince me out-of-towners!) Perfect cheese, amazing sauce, dough that is cooked just right, not dry and just the right amount of greasy... simple perfection. Plain slice is delectable, add pepperoni for some pizazz, have extra cheese and roll your eyes in ecstasy at just how awesome it tastes. We drive out of our way to get pizza from Ciro's. My only complaint is that I wasn't smart enough to buy a house that is closer! read more

Ciro's Pizza - Yummmmm - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Very underwhelming. I live in an adjacent town, with a lot of pizza options, so I hadn't been here. Someone highly recommended it to me. Got a 'large' cheese pie, chicken roll, and a couple of extra slices - $48 !! About $10 more than similar places in the area. The first thing that hit me was how small the pie was (even the box was much smaller), and not any thicker than typical, so they are clearly cutting corners there. The chicken roll was the best item. Very tasty and fresh. We got one buffalo chicken slice that was almost absent of any buffalo sauce. Maybe a mistake? The food was just ok, and for the price and the size of the pie, I will not be back. read more

I will insist that Ciros has the best pizza I've ever had in Suffolk county. I spent 30 years in Manhattan and I assure you, it tastes like any good pizzeria in the city. The crispy crust and rich sauce. The pizza here is the real deal. Nothing beats our favorite combo. Call in a pie at ciros and bring it into tap and barrel. Life doesn't get much better. Our choice is the pizza with mushroom. The ambience here is like a New York pizzeria. Grab a quick bite or take it to go. Not a real sit down place. And yes. I assure you tap and barrel has no issue with you bringing a pie into the bar. But I warn you. You'll get a lot of hungry stares and you usually find yourself feeling guilty for not bringing enough pizza for everybody. read more

Ciro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

A no frills super casual establishment: don't be fooled by its humble exterior and interior because Ciro's is probably the best pizza joint in the area. When we're in the area, we'll always swing by for a slice or two (we'll even do a detour just so we could eat here). Standouts are the Sicilian: the crust is light and crispy on the outside and soft on the inside-Delicious. The classic slice of cheese is also very good, best eaten piping hot. Regulars often pay after they've eaten but you can just pay once your pizza's ready. read more

See all

Stopped by this place as I picked up a delivery. Saw a glimpse of the garlic knots in their foil-wrap and gave them a try. I was not disappointed! Medium sized, they truly look like knots, coated in that garlic mash that is the hallmark of a good, if not great knot. When baked up proper they have a great garlic flavor, with a crunchy, slightly biscuit-like medium-light chew. It's too bad I don't live locally, as I would stop in often for these knots alone. If I should pass by or am in the area in the future, I will get a dozen, at least . . . ! read more

Ciro's Pizza - Garlic knots (before baking): I bought them cold, to enjoy later. See my other, post-bake photo. These knots are among the best I've had! - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

There are two steps to eating a GOOD pizza: 1. you pick up the slize and 2. you fold it and Ciro's Pizza needs 5-6 steps including using a fork and knife. Smh, such a waste of time and money! The crust was so thin i could see the box underneath which is why it was all falling apart. Should it have been thicker I'd order again but idk, I'd hate to be disappointed for a second time. Also, you can be a little nicer on the phone... read more

Ciro's Pizza - Completely falls apart - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Best pizza on Long Island. If you're looking for a pasta dinner. There is a large selection. The lasagne is incredible. Just like homemade. read more

Old school in all the right ways. It's been operational since 1979, so obviously they're doing something right in a very competitive market. First, the staff. They were all middle-aged or older Italian American gentlemen who make the pizza right in front of you. They do so carefully & with both ease & grace. The guy at the cash register is like something out of a movie about a NY pizza place. Dressed in all white, white hair combed back & a heavy, heavy Italian/NY accent that asks, "whadda ya havin?" He even pronounced sausage as "saw-siege"...which was awesome. We got a pepperoni "pie," a meatball pie, & some garlic knots. All were great. The crust on the pizzas was perfect. Crispy outside & a slightly chewy inside. They use top notch ingredients and cheese & you can tell. The pepperoni was a little greasy, but guess what... pepperoni is greasy! If you can't handle that, order a different topping. This is not the best pizza ever, but it is way above average by NY standards which makes it the best pizza ever in about 95% of the country. That includes my home of Miami. I wish we had pizza like this place down there, but on the flip side, I'd probably weigh 300lbs if we did, so maybe for the best. Either way, check it out if you find yourself in the area & hungry for pizza. read more

Ciro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Pizza was very good I'm from queens originally and the Sicilian Pizza reminds me of queens Plain Slice was good too I recommend t it to all