Solid spot for both pizza and sandwiches! Delivery was fast. California chicken cheesesteak was tasty, and onion rings were great. read more

Schianos Pizza - California Chicken Cheesesteak and Onion Rings - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

Drive about an hour away to try this 50 year Family Owned Pizzeria. First up white slice one of my gf favorite. Next the crispy chicken the Caesar wrap . Probably one of the best if not the best I've tasted in a while. The chicken tender and juicy, the wrap huge . The dressing freshly made and the steak fries crispy. read more

Schianos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

See all

We used to love this place but haven't ordered in a while, not for any reason, just have been trying other places. The ordering process over the phone was fine, the delivery was quick and friendly. All good there. The food however, was not very good. The cheesesteak was so dry we couldn't eat it! There was next to no cheese... my husband had to recook it with more cheese. Garlic knots were topped with what seemed like raw garlic. Not a fan. Was super strong & had that raw garlic spiciness to it. Pizza was okay. Kids enjoyed the pizza but complained they ate a chunk of garlic. Overall disappointed. I hope next time is better! read more

Schianos Pizza - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

See all

Take out pizza was ready on time and hot. Delicious garlic knots loaded with perfect amount of garlic & antipasto salad was fresh and crisp.

Food was very Good. If you offer a couple for a stress free meal Have a great weekend everyone!

Lovely food and even lovelier service. obviously filled with people who love to cook. Ate in and got some chicken Alfredo which was delicious and after my meal they gave me four free slices. could not recommend enough read more

Came back from the beach and needed a few things at the grocery store for my room when I saw this Pizzeria. I can't pass the opportunity to have northern pizza. It's my favorite. I met the owner who was so very nice. Amazing customer service. I ordered a few slices of cheese....then I was introduced to the Chick-fil-A pizza. If you like Chick-fil-A you must try this pizza! Amazing! I only wish I took pictures before I ate it! I miss the pizza ... Wish one of these was in North Carolina. read more

The food is good. The place is clean and looks to be covid safe. Prices are is fair. Servers are friendly. read more

Schianos Pizza - the inside of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

Great Service Best pizza I have tasted in a very long time! They actually use good cheese! Not like the rest around the area! My husband ordered seafood dinner he loved it. We will definitely make Schianos's a weekly staple in our home! read more

Quality and quantity of food has gone down - ordered a grandpa pizza half sausage ... well I got about a 1/3rd or less covered with sausage if that's what you wanna call it as the sausage was ground to the size of a grain of rice. $26 or so for a pizza with almost zero sausage ... the delivery guys are awesome but one customer that will not be ordering from there anymore - and I tip well ... sorry but your boss needs to inspect the food as this was the 3rd time in a row that the order was sub par read more

I never write a review but this pizza is really the greatest. believe me or not I have not had this great tasting pizza sense I left New York years ago when they actually had great pizza. try it you won't be disappointed. read more

One of the best old school pizzerias around! Nothing fancy it is pizza the way it is supposed to to be! Definitely recommend

Love the garlic Parmesan wings ! Pizza is also great. Been around forever and always deelish!

The food is always delicious ! The staff provides outstanding customer service! You will enjoy anything you order for sure!

Just ordered a cheesesteak with extra cheese & got this dried ass cheesesteak with NO CHEESE. More than once has this place giving us shitty food. Always give the benefit of the doubt, but end up getting shitty dried food. I DON'T recommend this place at all. You're better off going to charlies on fischer blvd where they listen to what you say and give you extra cheese & a good dish of food. read more

Schianos Pizza - a piece of meat and ketchup on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

Ordered a tray of chicken Parm for Memorial Day...full tray...was disappointed because it was like frozen chicken cutlets...they gave you a lot...but I could have made it...not fresh chicken parm...I do like most of their food...but this was a bit disappointing. read more

Schiano's has always been great food, fast delivery. They have an amazing towering carrot cake that is $9.00 but used to be the size of about 1/4 of a cake to justify the price. They have consistently reduced the size of the slice thinking no one would notice, now it's a pretty small piece for $9 should probably be about $4. read more

Schianos Pizza - $9 slice of carrot cake - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

Best pizzeria i EVER been to! Family owned- they been here for 48 years, making delicious pizza & fresh italian cuisine. This family is well respected in the community. They have been serving family Generations and will continue. Keeps our family and friends keep coming back. Simple the best! read more

When a restaurant allows this to go out the door you need to question everything you ordered. I ordered the Meat tortellini, they sent cheese. It was bland probably from the shop rite next door. I have only ordered pizza from them in the past and it's not bad for the area but tonight was horrible. read more

Schianos Pizza - When a restaurant allows this to go out the door you need to question it. - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

We used to order from here all the time - the pizza, cheese steak, and a few other items use to be go to orders. However over the years the quality has gone extremely down hill. It got to be that we only order pizza until we did not. Over 10 years it has gone from excellently to don't even waste your money! We have started ordering from another local spot that is WAY better in Ocean Gate. read more

Awesome pizza and Italian dishes. If you are lucky, they will have vanilla bean cheesecake. Worth every cent but usually sold out

This was our "go-to" for 8 years. Practically every week without fail. Sadly, we are DONE. They screwed up our delivery order so bad (after waiting an hour-and-a-half for a "40 minutes" lie) 2 weeks ago. So I called to let them know what was wrong and was completely belittled by the man that answered the first time I called. After all was said and done and me just fighting for my $60 worth of food that I paid with a cc, he agreed to send all that was missing from the order. You know, so we can ENJOY our meal that was paid for. Long story short, 45 minutes later, still not here. So I called again. I didn't get the woman's name that answered the phone, but what a complete and utter ANIMAL. She was telling ME that I need to be patient. Are you kidding me??????? Than she has the audacity to say "you are a problem account. I'm looking at your previous orders and you complained once about the garlic knots. And another time about the pizza". I'm like "ARE YOU KIDDING ME????? YOU KEEP NOTES?????? And yes, if my order is wrong, I have EVERY right to call and complain. I paid for a meal and a service!!!" I asked her if she also saw on our "report card" all the hundreds and hundreds of times how much money we have spent there dining in and the dozens of times we used them for take-out for birthday parties, etc.... Nope. She didn't care. She basically told me to go screw myself and to be patient that the person is on their way with the rest of our dinners. I told them i want a refund just come get your 2 hour old nasty food out of my house and bring my money or a receipt proving it's back on my card. I kid you not, this is where it gets good: Not even 10 minutes later, the doorbell rings. It's the delivery person from Schiannos. And guess what????? It's not the delivery person that was supposedly driving around with our order. She had no idea that we were waiting for the rest of our food!!!! She said she was told to come over and get the WRONG order back!!!! She had no money for us. No food for us. She said she didn't even know she was supposed to give us money or food!!!!!! So, they couldn't get a person to deliver our food that we paid for. But you were able to somehow get a person to pick up the sh*t????????? Wow! Great Customer Service. Of course we didn't give her the food. And the sad part. She right away recognized us since we are ALWAYS there. So, long story short. Schiannos never called us. Never came back with correct order. Never came back with $ and to get the old stuff. I checked my bank, money was there. I'm so sad by this. This was, by far, our FAVORITE place to eat at every week. We chose to order in on this particular day because we had just gotten over COVID and we weren't up to going out. So just wanted to watch a movie and eat from our FAVORITE restaurant. Well, what used to be our FAVORITE restaurant. read more

Best garlic & tomato deep dish pizza! We also love to get their grandpa pie and an antipasto salad as well. They have fair prices and are always on point with the quality of their food. We always order from them when we're visiting from out of town with the family! Definitely recommend! read more

I live in California but my beother lives in Bayville. When I'm here visiting him, I always hit this restaurant for pizza or a sub. Seriously, the best meatball parm sandwich I've ever had. And their pasta slice is amazing with a side of their delicious marinara sauce! read more

Lovvvve this Italian restaurant! Used to come here with the kids after work almost everyday. Such nice staff and good people!

I when I'm home from school I wouldn't even bother getting pizza from anywhere else. This is easily the best pizza in Bayville and there are a fair share of them around. They have a pretty good selection of entrees and subs too, but I usually just stick with the pizza. The food is generally pretty cheap, so its light on the wallet. The only downside is no delivery, so you have to go pick up your food, but its worth the trip. read more

I spent my summers in Ocean Gate growing up. Stopping at Schianos was a requirement all of the time. I was diagnosed celiac last year and stopped coming here because I couldn't bear the idea of not eating my favorite pizza. What a welcome surprise to learn they serve (really delicious) gluten free pizza. The pizza i have loved for 20 years was available to me. Brought my gluten-loving friend with me and we chowed down. Thank you, thank you Schianos, for giving me great memories, for staying open for me and my friend to chow down, and for giving me 20 years of great pizza and memories. read more

I love this place! It's real Italian pizza and you'll know it as soon as you walk in! The smell of garlic is as close to heaven as you're going to get. The garlic knots actually have garlic on them, not like most places where you get oily bread chunks. The grandpa pie will change your life forever!!! Eat here and do it often! read more

This used to be our go to for pizza and garlic knots. The quality of the food has steadily gone downhill and tonight was the last time I'll order from them. The garlic knots tasted old, the pizza crust was chewy, the tomato sauce was tasteless and everything was cold. I also have a problem with the person cooking the pizza -she picks up a "corner" of the pie snd blows under it before putting it in the oven. I'm guessing it's to help it slide off the peel but it is so weird to me especially in light of the pandemic. read more

Ok, let's keep it in perspective , I'm not going to write in detail about a pizzeria but I enjoy the pizza here, it's nothing over the top but just good food. Great selection of pies for slices from old reliable to gourmet. The only advice id give them is to have a better selection of drinks in the cooler. Sandwiches are good here as well , for your local pizza spot in a competitive market they are worth it. read more

Always great pizza and knots. Dinners are good but. Pizza and cheese steaks. The best

Came here today for the first time , food was good ..But the girl behind the counter who was serving us had earphones in her ears I watched her handle food, touch her phone and deal with money No gloves and didn't even wash her hand Not coming back here again read more

So just got a summer home in the area. This place has a website where you can order food and even offered a 5% discount to use the website, I just didn't feel like ordering entering in the card info ect. So I called it in using the site and though that was the pricing, ordered a pasta dish and a cheese steak so according to the website it should of been about $18.00. Arrived and it was $28.00 the guy at the counter said "hey I just work here" so paid the bill and left, WILL NEVER GO BACK! WAY TO GO TO GET NEW CUSTOMERS TO THE AREA read more

Completely screwed up our order & told us not our problem. So I just threw out $50 for garbage.

Inconsistency is probably the key word for Schiano's. My wife and I order out every week - two weeks, and either you get some exceptional food or an utter disappointment. Most recently we ordered a pizza and by the time I got home (a five minute drive at best) it was ice cold. On the opposite end of the spectrum the time before that we ordered 2 hot sandwiches and they were great. Oddly it feels like quality of the food is dependent on how busy they are that night. Ironically it seems that the busier they are, the better the food is. If you plan on giving Schiano's a shot, make sure it's on a Friday or Saturday night when they are truly busy. read more

When I was eating a piece of their pizza, I nearly choked on a shard of plastic about 1/2 inch long that was in the pizza. When I called to let them know, the workers were laughing and said that they couldn't do anything about it and used a rude attitude towards me. read more

Schianos Pizza - an airplane on the ground - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

Pizza and Stromboli are great, the meat dishes are uneatable. The meat Lazagna tastes like over cooked all day turkey burger. The meatballs are uneatable and anything containing meat tastes awful. Will never order another meat or cheese item at the restaurant(other than pizza or Stromboli) because their Italian sauce also tastes awful. They also own Bon Appitito and the meat dishes and food and sauce is much better tasting. The owner of Schiano's hires cooks that follow horrible tasting recipies. read more

Terrible service, delivery never showed up attempt to call and they had closed. It's a shame because pizza can be pretty good. But we are very happy with Frankie's now! read more

I tried to order 2 subs for delivery today. When we called someone with a German accent took our order, he said some weird things while we were on the phone but they repeated the order and address back to us okay. After an hour we called back and they told us the ticket was gone so our order was on the road for delivery. (I live about 5 minutes from the restaurant.) After another 15 minutes we called again and they said that our order was up next and would be delivered soon after. We've ordered from this restaurant many many times in the past and never experienced anything like today. Not sure I can ever give them my business again. read more

Schiano's is the best pizza in the Toms River and Bayville area. Excellent food, great prices and they are pleasure to talk to when you go in. AND!! They now deliver! I'd give it 100 stars if I could! read more