This place is the best in town! Our old place (which wasn't all that good anyway) was recently sold and went directly down hill. We tried everyplace in town trying to find a decent pizza and we have finally finished looking. MaMas is pizza like it should be. read more

Service is very spotty. Ordered food and it took 2 hours for them to deliver it to me. My food was also wrong. Pizza was over cooked, fried wings were soggy. They forgot the blue cheese. I asked for garlic bread with no cheese...I got cheese. Menu is limited to standard pizza joint fare. They do alot of fund raisers with the community but I have been burned one too many times with long delivery times and sub par food. I will going elsewhere for my pizza from now on. read more

Twice I've ordered, and twice it's been a home run. The chicken Francese sub was fresh and very pleasant. The second order was a grilled chicken mozz and red pepper wrap. Also so good, especially the balsamic on the side...darker than my soul and twice as good lol. And the fries...since when do pizzerias make the best fries?! All this plus reasonable prices. Sold. Will order from again. read more

Great buffalo chicken pie, the cheese and buffalo sauce just oozes and melts in your mouth. The consistency is always there, you will NOT be disappointed. read more

The pizza is as good as you'll find anywhere in New Jersey. The menu items are nothing special. Delivery is Hot and Fast if you call them directly. read more

Best pizza in NJ! And I'm from NY!! Such a variety, everything is delicious! And Tony is always so friendly and kind! He does so much for his community!! read more

I've lived in Bayville for 3 years and have ordered from every spot in town. Tony's is my new favorite spot! The pizza is great prefect amount of sauce, cheese, & toppings. The rice balls are delicious. Ordered chicken parm one night and it was great! I finally found that go to spot I've been searching for. read more

Very disappointed, they use a Slice app to order online but apparently they didn't check to see if anyone ordered through it. Got there and they couldn't find the order had to wait another half hour in addition to the original half hour. No one was wearing gloves or masks and they forgot the garlic knots on top of everything else.. they are dead to me read more

Always order from them. Best Italian I've tried around here yet for such good prices. Very friendly and on-point service.

Best pizza on the shore, I grew up in this town and I've had pizza around the shore and his by far is the best around. I also had a half of cheese steak and that was also very good, crispy bread, cheese mixed in with the steak . I recommend this place to everyone! read more

MaMa's Pizzeria - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

Great pizza ! I'm always there. $1 slices so I grab more than I should! Friendly local place. No complaints.

Nice little place! Got a house salad to go and it was really good!! Nice staff. And garlic knots were great!

So disappointing. They were really good at one point but now, everything is inconsistent. One great pie last week after months of disappointment. Unless they get back to what they once were, there are many other options around to get a great pie elsewhere. read more

This place has the best chicken cheesesteaks EVER!! I am obsessed. Very friendly staff, and quick delivery. If I could order from them everyday, I would. read more

their food isn't bad. their time estimates and understanding of the food you order is. ordered food at 7:09 to be exact. simple order. margarita pizza and order of calamari. estimated time to get delivered = 40 minutes. reasonable. called at 8:24 because the food still wasn't here. they said it'll be going out in 4 minutes. got the food at 8:40. so the time was way off . the calamari was decent but cold. the margarita pizza wasn't even close to what it should be. no basical, no sauce, mostly mozzarella and a TON of garlic. not even close to what the pie should be. ordered from you guys a few times but this pizza was so terrible it's the first time I ever wrote a review. I get you have a business but you can't give someone mashed potatoes when they ordered French fries. know your pies read more