It was a little strange how you ordered before you get to the table but it was well worth it. It was absolutely the best prime rib I've ever had. We got the Schwartz cut and it was huge. The service was excellent. The price was reasonable. It had an old school super club vibe. I understand why it is packed when the doors open at 3. read more

Schwarz's Supper Club - My wife getting a prime rib that is bigger than her head . - New American Near Me - New Holstein, Wisconsin

See all

Start by throwing out the low stars. I've been to dozens of supper clubs and after visiting Schwarz's, I'd put it in the top 10. Classic Scony supper club. Get there early or you'll end up waiting. Don't drink? Too bad; if you don't get there early, you'll wait. Salad bar (which I love), not here. Muddled old fashioned, not here. Cozy atmosphere and solid customer service, definitely in the right place. We arrived with a veteran couple. They got us there early, understood the ordering routine and found us a place to sit. We ordered appetizers and drinks. Definitely get the onion rings as they are incredible! Drinks were solidly poured and reasonably priced. We ordered and were surprised by how quickly we were seated. The vegetable tray and bread basket were good. Our meals came out shortly after we were seated. The salads were nice sized and the blue cheese dressing with crumbles was great. Our entrees (ribeye, tenderloin with chicken, prime rib and fish) were all sized nicely and prepared as ordered. My dining partner said the chicken was some of their all-time favorite. My ribeye was seasoned well and cooked perfectly. Our dining partners loved their choices. Overall, I'd really like to give 4.5 stars, but my pals at Yelp still don't trust half stars. We all enjoyed our experience and will definitely put this on our list of supper clubs to return to! read more

See all

The twice baked potato was the best I've had and the prime rib was excellent. Service was great as well. The onion rings were also fantastic. A must-eat if you're in the area. read more

4 for experience, 3 for food. If you're going for an authentic supper club experience with locals, this is the place to go to. However, if you're a foodie looking for delicious new foods to try, this isn't the spot for you. Clientele generally consists of older folks and multi-generational families, which worked for us since my group consisted of me, my dad, hubby, and 6-year old daughter. Instructions: As others here mentioned, you immediately find your own seat in the huge bar area directly to your right and all to the left of the entrance--the "bar" includes bar stools as well as the multitude of tables and booths that are visible from the bar. Waitresses walk around (generally they wear black) and pass out menus to newcomers--no need to flag them down, they'll see you. To order drinks, you walk up to the bar and then carry your drinks back to your table; drinks are affordably priced. There are some arcade games to occupy the kids, including one that we love, which is a rubber duck "winner every time" claw game for $1--easy activity and something to help your young'n happily pass the time. Waitresses then come by to take your appetizer orders (which can be either enjoyed at the bar, or when you are seated in the dining room), and your entree orders, and ask you for your group name (you can give a name or a fun saying--when we were there, a group called themselves "The Over 85 Club"). All entrees include your choice of soup or salad (and choice of dressing), and potato (baked, broasted, fries--I recommend fries, as broasted is a bit flavorless though has a nice texture). When your entrees are almost ready and they are ready for you to sit in the dining room, they will call your group name over the speaker system. Take your drinks and apps and head over to the opposite side of the bar and greet the hostess. Your dining table will be fully equipped with your soup or salad selections and some raw crudite (typical for supper clubs, and perfect for my carrot sticks and plain black-olives-loving daughter). [Any additional] appetizers and entrees arrive promptly thereafter. Broasted chicken ($18 for half a chicken) was rather bland and could have been more juicy. So I requested bbq sauce (which to my pleasant surprise, arrived warm!), which was desperately needed for my chicken. On the plus side, the chicken was not oily, the breading was light, and my daughter happily ate the simple white chicken meat, so it was easy for her to get some protein! Hubby ordered the 16oz tenderloin ($52), which was cooked properly, however interestingly was served as two 8oz pieces and was really bland--had to add salt. Dad ordered fish & chips ($26) which he said was a bit too salty (though I didn't think so). Overall, love the authentic supper club experience and dining with locals. Friendly, welcoming service. But, would generally only come back here if accompanied by my daughter's grandparents. read more

See all

If you love the chaos of a small town supper club on a Saturday night, this is the one. We stopped in with some friends and it was a solid 3 hour event. The place was packed to the brim that you could barely move but we stuffed out way to the bar and got some old fashioneds. Always amazing. Played some pull tabs while we waited for our order and had some apps. Food here is great always, though if they did a ribs and chicken combo that would be delightful. But alas I suppose I'll choose. Great relish tray and salad. Service is usually good, though our last visit our server checked on us maybe twice and no water refills until we flagged someone down. It was very busy though, so that's not too surprising. read more

See all

Food was great. I got the Queen's cut prime rib with broiler potatoes and I truly struggled to finish but it was so good! Service was excellent as they continued to check on us. read more

Schwarz's Supper Club - Queen's Cut Prime Rib with broiler potatoes - New American Near Me - New Holstein, Wisconsin

See all

Food was great. Service was great. Very busy but waitlist went fast. We will definitely go again. Recommend chicken mila

4 of us went to Schwarz's Supper Club. Very nice looking restaurant and the food was incredible. It was a long drive from menomonee falls but totally worth it. I had a fabulous steak. Everyone loved it and we are excited to go back. read more

See all

The food is amazing. I had tenderloin combo with scallops with backed potato and my partner got prime rib and boasted potatoes with scallops. Nicely decorated for the holidays. Staff was as nice as they could be with as busy as it is there. Do not go if you have no patience. read more

See all

Recipes are back to the old ones. Yummy! I wish they would have dinning in the restaurant again. I don't know why Chinese restaurants believe they don't need to offer service on site anymore. read more

What a great place! The system is great: they take your order in advance, so by the time you get seated, salads and/or appetizers are on the table. This is highly appreciated as this place is extremely busy on a Saturday night. We got there at 5pm and the bar was full...and also the waiting area. The layout of the restaurant is interesting; divided in rooms that you don't see until you get to your table. The menu is great, and the service is even better. One of the best supper clubs in the state! Highly recommended! read more

See all

You start by walking in. If you can get in the door, you'll have to squeeze past other patrons to get a bar table or seat at the bar. There are no reservations taken. You have to flag someone down to get a menu. Then you have to order first to reserve your spot in the cattle line for the meal. They call you name overhead, and once again squeeze through the crowd where the head waiter (I use loosely) tells you, not walks you to your table, tells you, which number is your cattle trough. They're known for great steaks? I'm not sure why. The medium rare steaks my wife and I ordered had raw spots in them. These steaks are sous vide, basically boiled in a bag, then given a quick sear, to save time, but not flavor. This is definitely not a date night destination. Save your money. Better yet, travel a few miles north to a great supper club that takes reservations and has a real soup and salad bar! You won't be disappointed by this place! read more

The prices keep going up and the quality of the food keeps going down. Ordered a steak. Waitress was still at table as I cut into it. The outside was almost burnt and the inside was blood red and cold. She even commented that it didn't look right and said she was going to order another one for me. Second steak came out looking good on outside, but cutting into it was still blood red and cold. Because I waited so long for my food being done twice and was still not good, waitress brought me prime rib. I couldn't even eat it as it was so fatty. She asked me if I wanted to take it home, and I refused and said it was nothing but fatty and awful. The only good thing was that they did not charge me for the meal. read more

Drove an hour on a recommendation for a great steak; really wish we hadn't. As plenty of others have stated weird seating and ordering routine, if you don't look them up first you have no idea what you are doing. You walk in and are smack in the middle of the waiting area with no direction; but ordering was quick and staff was pleasant. Other reviews state they ordered drinks at the bar while waiting, we were told by a bartender we could only order alcohol anything else had to be ordered once we were called to our table. So we sat around with nothing to drink waiting to be called. Prime rib, 16oz tenderloin (arrived as 2-8oz pieces??), Sirloin for 2, and 2 chicken dishes were ordered. None of the steaks had any flavor whatsoever (even though their website boasts "delightful journey through flavors"), nor did they have a sear: so no good coloring at all. The broasted chicken was ok, but the broiled chicken was not seasoned either. Oh and the fries weren't even salted. I'm not sure where the flavor was, but it wasn't at this place. read more

We came just shy of 3 hours to try out the infamous Schwarz's! We arrived just at 4 on a Saturday, and the parking lot was stuffed full already. Their bar opened at 3. We walked in with a dozen other people and it was already difficult to scoot around everyone. When you arrive, the bar is a giant V shape. You can go to the right, which is toward the dining room area OR you can go to the left. Along the left side are a few booths and tables for waiting. If you follow the left side along the bar, you'll come upon an entire side room further to the left. Full of tables and booths to sit at. Could definitely have a cocktail waitress or five! We got a drink right away, since we didn't know much about the ordering process before going. I asked the bartended how we order, and she said to look for a lady with menus. It took a while to get one to even LOOK at us to get a menu from. Luckily, we didn't look over the menu beforehand and really already knew what we'd be ordering. When I finally caught a hostess to ask how she knew whose order she would take next, she said, you have to put your menu in the air so she knows you are ready. I replied with we didn't have any, but we were ready anyways whenever she was. She took our order right then and there. They ask your name and party number. Then when your table is ready, they will announce it over the loud speakers. We were told it would be an hour before we go to our table, but it's wasn't even a half hour! I think stopping her and knowing what we wanted really helped speed up our time. But we didn't know the process, and it's not mentioned anywhere! When your name is called, you follow the V Bar off to the right from the entrance and toward the dining room. There is a desk before you enter the dining area and you check in there to see which table you are at. Your salads are all there waiting for you, paired with a classic supper club relish tray and rolls. We had scallops, prime rib, baked potato and fries. Everything was very yummy and our waitstaff were so attentive. I love seeing them work together! Even the teens cleaning off the tables were noticing our water glasses were empty and stepped in to help. Only place it lost a star is the lack of organization with ordering. I know it works for them, but could very well simplify it for both them and the customers by mainstreaming it a bit. A few hostesses looked distressed, but I would be too if everyone was stopping me constantly for menus and to see when they can order or what the process is. Definitely a good one to experience once, but I would hate to navigate the craziness with any additional people in our party. read more

See all

This is a classic Wisconsin supper club. You gotta Tiger there early because they don't take dinner reservations. I really enjoyed the time I spent here with family and friends and the food was good. I also enjoyed how quaint everything was and the fact that it was clean. Job well done. read more

Friends of ours have suggested Schwarz's as an old fashion Wisconsin supper club that we needed to try. It's the typical order at the bar, have a few old fashioneds and get called to your table when it's time to eat. Our group suggested I had to have the cowboy ribeye. Oh my goodness, what a steak it is. So thick and well prepared. We had a great time with good company, good food and good prices. read more

Schwarz's Supper Club - Cowboy Ribeye - New American Near Me - New Holstein, Wisconsin

They've really got it down here. They staff is a well oiled, hustling machine. You wait in the bar until you're ready to order and stand the menu up to let them know. They take your order and call you when you're table is ready. You sit down to your salad, rolls and relish tray waiting for you--followed by your delicious meal. Everything we had was delicious. We opted for: Prime Rib, Walleye, Lobster, Rib Eye with sides of baked potato, french fries, and onion rings. Everything was cooked and seasoned perfectly. As always, the perfect way to end any supper club meal is with a Brandy Alexander or Grasshopper. We always share one and opted for the Brandy Alexander. Sooo good (but you can't go wrong with either of them). read more

See all

This is a great place to visit, and to show others when they visit. The steaks are amazing, the people were amazing and the atmosphere was amazing. We are all looking forward to visiting again and trying other items on the menu!! read more

Interesting visit. You order at the bar which we've seen at other places. However, no one really explains the process unless you explicitly ask. They also didn't have the vegetable and potato options on the menu so we had to ask after that. The bartenders seemed over it real quick. They must have regulars primarily who know exactly what to do. It was tough to come prepared since they don't have a food menu on their website. Once your salad is at the table, they call your name over a loud speaker so you know to seat yourself in the dining room. They had bread and a relish tray at the table, too. After we finished, our meals came out pretty soon. The first few bites were good, but they serve the entrees on metal plates to keep the meal warm which continues to cook the steak. By the end, the sirloin was well done and tough to eat. Our server stopped by to check in on things but also didn't seem that invested. Now that we know what to do and what to expect, it might be a better experience next time but we're not in a hurry to go back. Not the supper club vibe that we have grown accustomed to, maybe. read more

See all

Incredible! So I've been here once and really enjoyed the dinner. With high expectations I wasn't sure what to expect. Incredible! Let me say the old fashioneds were not muddled but excellent! Relish tray was very good and the salad with blue cheese was at least average but the Prime rib was outstanding! Then the coffee and the white chocolate blue berry cheese cake was to die for! The coffee was also excellent. Coming to the restaurant with high expectations and to have them raised- incredible! read more

See all

Excellent Wisconsin Supper Club specimen! Comfortable environment and just a warm welcome and inviting atmosphere to entertain guests from out of town. Easily one of my favorites... a top 5! Come in, get on the list, have a drink, place you order. You'll be seated at the time your food is ready. What an amazing experience. Service is amazing. They responded to any requests with graceful speed and execution. read more

Schwarz's Supper Club - Sign all done up in the Christmas spirit. - New American Near Me - New Holstein, Wisconsin

See all

if this is fine dining then i am truman capote. they treat you like cattle herded in for a parasite bath. the food is average at best. they make sure you spend enough time in the bar in order to get you drunk enough to overlook how bad the food is. good business model i guess. won't get any money from me though. read more

Don't expect to sit down and relax. First, you have to order dinner at the bar. Then you have to stand at the bar and get your own drink and carry it into the dining area when your table is ready. WEIRD. It's more like a production line than a pleasant dining experience. There are several waitresses, the food comes too fast and IT WAS COLD. The twice baked potatoes and prime rib were COLD!!! The salad was good except that the carrots and they were indistinguishable from the cheese so I kept tasting carrots and couldn't enjoy it. The bread was cold, too. And if the food wasn't bad enough, we were one of only three diners and they sat us in front of the kitchen door. It was totally unpleasant. The waitress dropped the leftover (still cold) potato upside down on the table cloth and scooped most of it into the doggie bag. And it was over in less than an hour!!!!! They processed us out of there as fast as possible. We drove 30 miles for this. read more

Always an amazing meal! Service is excellent! (No reservations) Adult beverages are spot in as well!

We had an outstanding experience in every respect. Food, service, price, and cocktails were all terrific

The layout perfect. The drinks great! The service 100% incredible! The most delicious steaks served by the most on point waiter staff. A big shout out to Sierra for being friendly attentive and accommodating. read more

Food and service was amazing!!! The bartenders were super friendly!!! The atmosphere was very nice too!!

The supper club experience is so legit here. Walk in, get a drink, peruse the menu while having another drink, order your meal, have another drink or two and when your table is ready, sit down. By the time you have another drink and salad, your meal arrives. I have had the tenderloin as well as the prime rib cooked medium rare. Both are some of the best pieces of meat I have ever eaten. The potatoes were perfectly cooked and make sure you get the onion rings and mushroom medley. This place is not fancy, but the staff, food,, drinks and overall experience is amazing. read more

First time visit on a Wednesday evening. Arrived around 4:30 and enjoyed two drinks at the bar. Did not understand the meal ordering arrangement, but the young bartender was patient and kindly explained what to do. We ordered an appetizer and order of onion rings in addition to two medium rare ribeye dinners. When we were called to our table, we sat down to two average lettuce salads, plastic prefilled cups of salad dressing, a basket of Parker house style rolls, not warmed, and an unnecessary relish tray of pickles, olives, and mini corn cobs. As I began to butter a roll to begin to eat my salad, a young man brought over a tray which contained all of our food order at once. Everything was dropped off at the same time. There was not a square inch of open space on our table. Calamari appetizer, onion rings, ribeye steaks and baked potato on metal platters, a tiny cup of prepackaged sour cream for the potato. Salad, bread basket, foil wrapped butter, relish tray, water glasses, cocktails....it was all there. As I moved my steak to the side of the table to eat my salad and hopefully enjoy the calamari appetizer, my eyes searched for our waitress. She was there, but suspiciously flitting around from table to table and never once acknowledging us. I was hoping to ask Abby K to put our steaks under a warmer for ten minutes so we could enjoy the salad and appetizer, but no such luck. Steaks and potato cooled off by the time I was ready to eat it, so main course went home in a box. After reading other Schwarz Supper Club reviews the next day, it appears this is their customary serving style. Apparently many fans find the "controlled chaos" here to be just wonderful. But it definitely is not for my DH and me. Food was average to good....nowhere near the raves as best supper club in Wisconsin by a long shot. Service at bar was excellent. AK, our server in the dining room, barely deserved the 10% tip we felt obligated to leave. read more

See all

Excellent food and service. Very different dining environment. You enter at the bar area, sit and order a drink and peruse the menu. Waitress will come and take your dinner order and you continue to sit at the bar until your table is called when your food is ready. Then you move to your actual dining table and enjoy your meal. read more

We arrived with a party of six. We were lucky to find a large semicircular booth in the bar area. This is where you relax, order a drink at the bar, and someone hands you a menu to peruse. While we greeted people we knew and visited, we enjoyed our drinks and decided what we wanted to order. A second round of drinks, and we were ready. When you stand your menus up, that is the signal for a server to come and take your orders, Once ordered, you can enjoy your drink for a brief period before they call your party's name and you are led to your table where your salad is waiting. The food was delicious and plentiful. Service, when needed, was prompt. Their desserts and ice cream drinks were terrific! We hope to visit again. read more

It's been on my supper club enthusiast hit list a long time. It was crazy busy as a place like this should be. Started with drinks and appetizers at the bar. Ordered to host and waited for our turn. Every entree was to die for. My ribeye was perfect. The service was good despite how absolutely busy they were. Everyone in our party shared our entrees just we all could see how good everything was. Closed the dinner with a right sized grasshopper. Was worth the hour drive. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Just unbelievable flavor! Best flavor on a piece of meat I've had in years! Don't think twice about road tripping for this classic supper club. Bartenders were excellent as well! read more

Schwarz's Supper Club - King prime rib - New American Near Me - New Holstein, Wisconsin

Steaks and Kessler Old fashioned cocktails are the name of the game here. We've been dining here for roughly forty years, and we've never been let down. For a rural supper club to be the number one seller of Kessler whisky in the world is amazing. The prime rib for two is like a foot thick (looks like a roast). Haystack onion rings are a must. My wife and I love the sirloin for two it's really more like steak for four. Dinners include a bread basket with bread sticks that you have to try to believe as well as a vegy dish with carrots, radishes, green onions, midget pickles and those weird tiny ears of corn. This place is old school and I love it! read more

See all

Schwarz's is worth the drive from Milwaukee if you like traditional Wisconsin supper clubs, giant pieces of prime rib, stiff drinks and friendly service. If you don't like those things, move back to IL, ok? So if you're going know that you need to get there EARLY. Like before 5pm on a weekend, or you'll be waiting a long time. There's also a system that's somewhat unique - you belly up to the long, curving bar and have a drink while you review the menu. Be warned that they make a mean old fashioned with lots of liquor - so be careful If you're driving. When you're ready to order, grab one of the ladies walking around - they'll announce your name over the loudspeaker when your table is ready. The dining room we were in was rather modern and bright - a bit of a surprise after coming in from the vintage bar. Salads and bread will be waiting for you and your food will arrive shortly thereafter. We opted for prime rib for 2 and received a slab of beef as thick as my hand - about 3lbs worth, served medium rare as requested. It comes with plenty of au jus but I found I preferred their creamy horseradish. Dinners come with a choice of starch (baked, fries, hash browns) but the focus is on delicious meat. Even though we were stuffed, we couldn't resist after dinner ice cream drinks (grasshopper for him, something very tasty called a "desperate housewife" for me). The staff and other patrons are friendly and welcoming. This is a first-class representation of a Wisconsin supper club. Highly recommend. read more

See all

We were doing a Kettle Moraine color drive with our friends. We stopped at Schwartz's on October 19th for dinner. We arrived at 3:45 thinking we would beat the crowds, well not exactly. The parking lot was more than half full but we managed to get a table to view the menu and place our order. It seems a tradition there is to give a funny name for your group, I used Dracula. The place stated filling up right after that, we had cocktails and waiting to be called. It only took about 45 minutes to be taken to our table which already had our salad and bread. The food came about 15 minutes after we sat at our booth. Sufficient time to finish our salad without being rushed. We ordered Prime Rib, Walleye and the Sirloin tips ( pictured). All of the food was excellent and perfectly cooked as ordered. The meat was very tender and flavorful and the fish was excellent. I thought the pricing was reasonable as well. All of the staff seemed pleasant and attentive. When we left there were people outside waiting. All in all a pleasant experience and definitely glad we stopped there. read more

Schwarz's Supper Club - Large order of Sirlion tips - New American Near Me - New Holstein, Wisconsin

Just excellent. The best supper club in Wisconsin without a doubt. You will love it

When in the Elkhart Lake are this is a must visit restraint. Great old time supper club. Enter the large friendly and packed bar and enjoy a drink as you wait to be seated. The bartenders are competent and very attractive women. Not something I'd complain about. The menu is not overly complicated but when in Schwartz's order the prime rib. Even if you were enamored with the bartenders order the queen cut or plan on leftovers or splitting it. The portions are generous and the flavor delicious. The place is packed for a reason don't miss it. read more

This is very unique Wisconsin Supper Club The Prime Rib was truly Prime! One of the best I ever had The service here is second to none Anyone of the wait staff will be serving you during your meal If something is ready to go to the table whichever waiter or waitress is at the service counter will bring your item to your table No standing around while food gets cool because it's not their table It's all their tables This system works really well read more