It had been several years since we last patronized Scotty's, so we decided to revisit during our latest stay in Ludington. Upon first look it does not appear any exterior improvements have been made - the place looks a bit run down and can do with some paint and landscaping. Upon entering I immediately noticed that the interior had been redone with paint to brighten up the place. We were quickly greeted and seated by the hostess. In re iew of the menu it does not appear much has changed since our last visit in 2018. Being in the mood for a steak I ordered the Blackened Ribeye. It came out very quick, but though properly cooked, I was disappointed in: 1. It was not blackened 2. It was pretty thin about half the thickness of ribeyes I have had in the past I didn't return the steak because I did not want to wait for a reorder. The waitress was great - didn't ask her name or I would give her a shoutout, but if it helps, she said she had only been there 1.5 years and has a tatoo sleeve on her left arm. She was sweet, friendly, attentive, and took great care of us. Not sure I will be returning for a third time. read more

This wasn't our first time here but it's been several years. Not sure what happened but it definitely isn't what it used to be. The cloth napkins are gone along with the jumbo shrimp for the cocktail appetizer (now you get 6 tiny pieces of shrimp that look like they came in one of the frozen rings from Walmart). It was disappointing having celebrated many special occasions at Scotty's and everyone always enjoyed it. I don't think I'll be going back any time soon. Service was great and the food was edible so gave two stars but not worth the $ anymore. read more

Scotty's has been in Ludington forever. And based on what we experienced likely will continue for years to come. Why? Because of their fabulous decor. Nope. Because of the friendly service. Well it didn't hurt. Because of the delicious perch prime rib and cocktails? Ding ding ding. The special little white tablecloth was a huge hit with our crowd. The next memorable thing was the vacuum. Maybe there were two because the minute a messy table left super Hoover was powered up and roared across the floor. Little Mr teacher snarfed his fries the birthday girl says cheers to the cherry old fashion little mustachio might ask for light paprika on his tasty stuffed catfish next time. So much wrong with that sentence. Well we'll be back. read more

See all

Menu and interior pictures appeared great online on different websites. We got there early to beat the rush. Dining area was very clean, comfortable, and there were plenty of tables and room in between them. The restaurant filled up fast so we thought that was a good sign. I don't know if our server was new, overwhelmed, or both, but our service was VERY slow and we heard others around us complaining as well. Our food eventually came out and I would give it a C- rating. Most of it was cold. The food was not seasoned and most of it lacked flavor. The prime rib sandwich was good. The stuffed mushrooms barely had any "stuffing". I would not recommend and we won't be going back. read more

Let's start with the good. Our server was great. That's it. Now the bad. For an "upscale" place, sitting down to a bare table and paper napkins is surprising. But whatever. We went for my birthday dinner while I was in town and it was one of the worst meals I've had in a long time. My old fashioned showed up and it was undrinkable. I sent it back and asked how it was made. Muddled with orange and maraschino cherry, I can forgive. Topped with soda water? No. I got a Woodford Reserve instead. Thankfully they didn't mess that up. Our appetizers: potato skins and coconut shrimp. Coconut shrimp was almost okay, just really, really oily. The potato skins were sad and had a steamed quality. Then, our meals... my mother, my father, and I all ordered prime rib. It was completely inedible. I could barely cut it, let alone chew it. It was also incredibly bland (not my top pick of meat in the first place, but they didn't have a ribeye). The ONLY thing about the meal that was decent was the garlic mashed potatoes. When none of us ate our meals, the waitress asked if it was bad. When we said it was, she said that she'd had 3 other tables complain about the prime rib and send it back. I don't know how you mess up a prime rib that badly, but it was AWFUL. The only silver lining is that the waitress removed the prime ribs from the bill, so we only ended up paying $120 for a really awful meal instead of $200. read more

I was a bit nervous trying this place because of the reviews and the pictures taken. But man this was one of the highlights of our trip up to Michigan. The all you can eat shrimp is a must try. They use the same breading as you would normally get with a fish fry. It's hard to find shrimp that good back in Chicago. The portions are generous as well and they bring out each plate in a timely manner. (Which can't be said for most places offering AYCE!) The service was amazing as well. I'm sure we'll be back! A well deserved 5 stars. A local staple for a reason. read more

The Parmesan Whitefish was delicious! We asked to share the entree and just bring an extra plate. The staff was beyond kind and gave us our own prepared plates instead! The fish was fresh and the potatoes were great. read more

Scotty's - Seafood Near Me - Ludington, Michigan

The food was by far the worst I've ever had at a restaurant. $37 for 1/4" thick overcooked sirloin that I ordered medium. Every bite was filled with fat and gristle. It was covered with fishy smelling crab meat that was dumped on it from a can. The service was fine and the ambience was okay, but the food being served the way it was, was insulting and ruined what was supposed to be a romantic dinner. read more

What a disappointment!! It was wrong from start to finish. 2 of our 4 people had drinks that were so bad they had to be sent back. The shrimp appetizer was battered and fried with the tails tucked in. The blue cheese dressing on the salads was made with Miracle Whip. And finally 3 of our 4 people ordered prime rib which was so tough as to be inedible. Literally, it couldn't be chewed. So we gave up. The waitress, who by the way is the reason they got 2 stars, saw our plates and said she'd had 3 other tables complain about the prime rib. And she comped those entrees off our bill. This was supposed to be a birthday dinner for our son but needless to say he was less than impressed and we won't be going back. read more

A classic restaurant. Decorated and an easy and relaxing manor. Nothing special really, but nothing wrong with it either. I ordered The Apple Bacon Stuffed Chicken ($18). This is a Chicken Breast stuffed with bacon, Dried Cherries, and Fresh Apples. Sauteed in a Apple Brandy Sauce. It was simply Spectacular! Every part just worked together to make something greater than it's parts. I chose a Baked potato as my side and is was excellent. Entrees come with Sweet Rolls. They were super soft and so yummy. The Service was slammed so a little slow. I understood though because a bunch of restaurants chose to close today (Tuesday). Otherwise very friendly and efficient. Overall an easy 5 star review. Next time I'm in the Area, I will be back! read more

See all

Ordered coconut shrimp and it was so overcooked you could hardly bite through it. Bland potatoes and barely cooked baby carrots. Steak had very good flavor read more

First as a veteran, I would like to say thank you to Scotties for my meal. Now let's get down to the service and food. Took fifteen minutes to get a waitress. Took our drink and meal orders at the same time. That was good because we got our drinks and it was another fifteen minutes before we got our salads. We finished our salads and the bowls were collected and we still waited for the main course. The waitress never asked me how I wanted my steak but it came out rare. I ate it but was not happy as there was blood all over my plate and the steak was tough and cold inside. My wife had cod and she said that was good but her baked potatoe was not warm enough to melt butter. Waitress never came back to ask how our food was until we were done. Then she said that was poor customer service and she was correct. Usually have good food and service there but not tonight. read more

Literally the worst and most shocking food experience I've had in a restaurant. I ordered a medium rare prime rib. The waitress said that it would be closer to medium. I was disappointed but it was the "house specialty" so I figured I would still give it a go. I came out dry, grey, with sear marks? I was dumbfounded. I normally don't send anything back, but this was inedible. The waitress tried to argue with me but ended up comping it. I tried something else - equally terrible. After speaking with the manager, we still ended up spending $100 for one appetizer, two salads, and my companion's entree, which was pretty much inedible as well. Do yourself a favor and avoid this place. read more

Food has improved with the new owner. The service is always good. I had the shrimp special and it was very good. It is a place that can talk and hear your guests. read more

Locals go here to reminisce when this was the best in town. No longer. Prime rib was bristled and end cut was unbeatable. Fried food safest but salads good for healthy eaters. Service was attentive. read more

The Friday night fish fry is the best deal in town! When available, you cannot beat the classic fresh whitefish. Friendly, efficient waitstaff, too. We're locals and visit throughout the winter, as well. read more

I am a cottage owner on Hamlin lake and I'm here from spring to Fall. This is still my favorite GO TO place for great meals. In the spring take advantage of all their asparagus appetizers. OMG ! I still love the lake perch. Seems to be my favorite. My husband orders something different every time and never is disappointed. Outside looks run down so don't let that scare you!!!!! read more

Went in for a great chef salad and an order of grilled asparagus which was awesome! Our waitress was very attentive and courteous. Great service . read more

Amazing food! Great service! Wonderful atmosphere! Excellent drinks! Loved the pear martini read more

Scotty's - Pear martini - Seafood Near Me - Ludington, Michigan

Terrible food, prime rib was ordered rare it came out over done. Gross nasty food. Girlfriend's pasta was nasty, disgusting food all around. The cream pasta sauce was green from the un blanched asparagus. But the shrimp and salmon in the pasta was good and the basil was a nice touch. The pasta was cooked correctly.bread was good butter was cold and miserable. Service was okay. Napkins were nice and the water was the best part of the meal. Scotty needs to call Gordon Ramsey asap. read more

We had an excellent dinner over 44th of July weekend!! Great service even though they were very busy- I recommend check them out

Not much on the outside, but the inside is lovely and light. Loved the ambiance. The fried zucchini was amazing. Thick cut, thin crispy coating. The vegetable really shined. My mom ordered the prime rib, which was tender and juicy, full of flavor. The fries were thick, hand cut, and delicious. I had the Parmesan whitefish, and it was really good!! The baked potato came with chive sour cream, which was a nice touch. The dinner roll taste very close to Bob Evan's, but not as fluffy. I looooved it. I wish they gave more than one per person though! Our waitress was awesome and prompt. The price fit my expectations and experience. They did social distancing measures well. I will be back! read more

Meh. Not great, not bad, just average. I had the Parmesan whitefish. It had way too much caper sauce. We were seated in the back of the restaurant and there was a small party (Xmas season) in front area of restaurant. It's one of the few places open in winter in Ludington. Portion size was generous, waitress was nice. I would go back, but it wouldn't be my first choice. IMHO the menu needs an overhaul. read more

Scotty's was perfect for our group dining event, over Labor Day weekend! Great food and wonderful service! Scotty's was very accommodating in every way! Kara helped us with a large party reservation and provided wonderful group dining menu options. Stephanie, our server, took great care of us! Highly recommend Scotty's! read more

Food below average had Last evening (9/21/19 ) my wife I had one best meals we have eaten in years my wife had the shrimp dish ( shrimp toasted just right and the shrimp was fresh ) I had the prime rib best ever .thanks for a great experience kathleen and mike u 10/02/2022 We had brunch today I had egg Benedict terrible English muffins was soft and maybe old impossible to cut with the fork had to saw .eggs were under cooked and runny the ham was ok sauce was just ok . My partner country's egg Benedict was even worse the sausage gravy lacked sausage the biscuit was old and tough she said hers was worse than mine which I thought might be impossible Kathleen and Mike U read more

Ordered filet and crab cake Saturday evening June 5. Filet was ok but crab cake was made with imitation crab sticks with the red dye. The rest of it was soggy bread crumbs. Worst crab cake I have been served. Inedible! Was never asked how the meal was and because I was in a large group I didn't complain and regret not doing that. For $38 I expect "real" crab meat and a good preparation. Shouldn't be on the menu if it will be done in this horrible way! read more

Roxanne was phenomenal! Food was not. We had been here last year and the food was very good. Unfortunately we did not have the same experience this year. read more

Sure don't understand why only a '3' rating. The service (Patty was great!) and the food was hot, plentiful, tasty and very fairly priced. Going back for the perch! read more

Food was good but service was awful. Waited 45 minutes for food and had to ask 3x for water at two separate times. Place wasn't even that busy. Might be better off doing a carry out order. read more

* As a 27 year seasonal resident of Ludington we have dined many times at Scotty's over the years and have had the misfortune of witnessing the decline in the food quality as the prices rose. On 7/13/18 we went as a group of six and had the poorest excuse of a meal ever. The three prime rib were dry, only warm and completely tasteless (tasted like they were microwaved and NO juice when it was cut just a dry plate ).the three kabobs (2 chicken 1 beef) were over cooked and also very dry and tasteless. * The service provided by the server was excellent and she thankfully kept our beverages (cola/water) full lest we choke to death. * In the past we have said that we wouldn't return but have always said lets "try again" this time we won't "try again". * I never thought I would see the day when Burger King would be the restaurant of choice in Ludington. read more

Yum! Came here on "date night" which was also their wine promo night! Win win! Awesome food! Great prices. Can't wait to go back. Prime rib was outstanding! read more

Scotty's - Seafood Near Me - Ludington, Michigan

On a Tuesday night, we were seated at 6:10. Salads (upcharge) came right away, but were wilted and one had a worm in it. Our meal didn't come until 7pm and there were only 4 other tables with customers. We ordered the lobster special, and Parmesan encrusted whitefish with capers. They were served attractively, but the fish had the skin on under the crust and only 5 capers. We would not come back, though our server was friendly. Baked potato was excellent. read more

Scotty's - lobster - Seafood Near Me - Ludington, Michigan

See all

This place is so tired. Good martini but food favors one of those steakhouses along the highway. The kind with empty parking lot. The menu reminiscent of a small town diner with a short order cook at the helm. Scotty needs to find new fresher fare. Maybe go on line and choose some 4 star recipes from a foodie website and have your cooks step out of their box? Something's gotta give. Iceberg lettuce, white rolls and baked beans, really? read more

Dined here twice during the past week. The Friday fish fry was one of the best I've ever had. Large choices of fish. I had whitefish, the batter was very thin and crispy, dish was excellent, as was my wife's shrimp coated with the same batter. Server Roxanne was pleasant, menu knowledgeable, attentive, and very accommodating. My only criticism might be that the restaurant pylon sign is somewhat difficult to read if you're not familiar with the area. Food is good, absolutely worth a visit. read more

Prime was ok but over cooked. Crab stuffed shrimp was ok. Perch was bland and soggy. Great waitress!! Thanks Rachael. Wouldn't go back

Our group had mixed experiences here. First of all, they had a great and affordable wine list. Everyone who ordered seafood (shrimp, crab legs, perch, whitefish) loved it. However, everyone who had steak was very disappointed. Every steak was more than well done (despite everyone asking for medium or medium rare). The lobster tail with the surf and turf was terribly over cooked and chewy. The server we had was great. I don't think we'll be coming back. read more

Third time going, we went based on the recommendation of our hotel. Very run down looking outside, which was off-putting, lblown glass light fixtures inside could use a good cleaning to show how beautiful they really are, the prime rib the first two visits was incredible. This is the house special! Third time the prime rib was overdone, but the sides were excellent. It was really disappointing, but the waitress made it right. read more

Decided to try here for dinner on a spontaneous trip up to Ludington. Love the area but look elsewhere for food. The service was extremely slow and the food was pretty bland overall. I ordered the prime rib sandwich which mostly consisted of 3 or 4 slivers of prime rib, a ton of onions in between an inch and a half high piece of Texas toast. The kitchen messed up my fiancé's order and the waitress forgot her salad. In the end if I had known, I would have suggested we go elsewhere for dinner. read more

Best meal I enjoyed in months . . . maybe years. Delicious. The staff was energetic, friendly, and knowledgeable. The restaurant is large, roomy, and clean. The food was so good! I wish I lived closer because this would be a definite monthly go to. read more

We stopped for brunch/lunch and found a great selection of menu items for both. The Sunday Special breakfast plate and the turkey/bacon/guacamole wrap were delicious. The service was prompt and accurate. The prices were certainly reasonable too. read more