Papa D's Original is an amazing place for subs if you are in the Tuckerton, New Jersey area…read more The staff is friendly and the place has that old school ambiance. Wonderful place and I would definitely recommend here.

The food is ridiculously good!!! Two orders of eggplant…read moreParmesan is out of this world! Enough food for 6 people. I've never had anything mediocre from Dominic, Madeleine and Mary Beth. Like visiting my Italian grandparents house, and I'm Dutch!!!

This pizza is legit. I ordered take out as there are no tables and therefore no service. The…read morelocation is a small spot on the east side of Long Beach Avenue. The crust is chewy and crusty - the way it should be with great flavor. The sauce is flavorful and thankfully not sweet. The cheese is great. The B&T is basic and good. The Margarita is excellent and I recommend getting the Margarita over the B&T. We will not be getting pizza from anywhere else.

Do yourself a favor and give Liberta a shot if you haven't already. Friendly staff and honestly…read moresome of the best pizza on the planet, and that's coming from a New Yorker who eats pizza almost every day. I come to LBI every summer and crave Liberta all year long. Side note -- It's pretty ridiculous that someone would leave a 1 star review without even eating there just because they don't know how to look up a business's hours. Get a grip, Howie B.

Order to take out pie to be delivered, it was simply amazing! It got here on time in a good shape…read moreand very hot

Ordered one large plain pie, took over an hour to get here although they said it would be here in…read more45 minutes. Delivery driver was either deaf or inebriated because he stumbled onto my front steps with the pie in his hand and didn't say a word to me even though i tried to initiate a conversation. Opened box and half the cheese was ripped off of the pizza. When I called about this, they told me it would take another 45 minutes to remake a pie, and I would have to hand in my old one. I simply told her that I am not comfortable handing in an old pie especially to that driver, plus how do I know it's really going to be 45 minutes when I've already been lied to? Lady on the other end kinda snickered as if I was the one trying to rip THEM off, and told me to have a nice day. Well PS people, it's 7pm and i'm starving, so I wouldn't exactly call that "nice" or during the "day."

Amazing pizza - worth the price! Best on the island. One of the best in NJ. Great customer…read moreservice. Has a tomato pie with no cheese which is perfect for vegans or those with dairy allergies.

Tried this place for the first time and really enjoyed it!…read moreOne of the best pizzas on LBI.

Mama Maria's pizza was pretty fast fulfilling our online order, so service was quick. That pleased…read moreus the most. The price point is fair. The interior is kind of small, and has a few booths to sit in. When I came inside I noticed they also have pizza by the slice, which is good if you need a little something to keep you going. The taste of our pizzas was okay: not bad, but not glorious. Crust was on more of the flat side, not ready. The sauce was a tad sweet for my preference.

Best pizza around. Staff is always friendly. Love the "local" feel. Very prompt response to…read morecustomers. Clean. Casual. You can buy uncooked pizza balls to make your own at home.

They changed the decor so it's very nice and updated. We were seated right away (weekday). Our…read moreserver, Elijah was phenomenal, so personable and friendly, just a great attitude. The food, clams, scallops, crabmeat were delicious. Definitely has changed and a must go to now.

OMG. I ordered a bowl of mussels. It came out. 8 mussels! I discarded 2 because they tasted bad (…read more which you can expect from mussels). So I paid $14 for six mussels. What a rip off. I would not order that again from this place! Oh & yes no bread to dunk into the sauce.

We ordered a large pie, 1/2 meatball & 1/2 sausage and it was AMAZING!!…read more We are return customers to Mystic Island Pizza and the staff is always friendly, the service is great and the food is delicious and never disappoints!

I ordered broccoli with garlic and the was not extra broccoli I need a replacement deilv to meread more