best jelly doughnuts ever, everything else was good too, never tried the cakes but they look good

This bakery used to be good. Not any more. The last three visits our doughnuts have not been fresh. They are at least one day old!! How can you religiously sell day old doughnuts and not let your customers know?? The doughnuts are absolutely terrible. If this was a one time thing, that might be ok. But every time?? You won't be seeing us any more. If you want fresh, go to Ferrara's Bakery in Ship Bottom. I have NEVER, EVER gotten day old doughnuts and pastries there!! read more

We were visiting Beach Haven/ LBI and needed a carrot cake. After reading reviews we landed on Crust and Crumb. I called to order a cake which they said they didn't do orders on a carrot cake and we'd have to come in one morning to get one. When I arrived on a Monday morning, the line was out the door! I was a bit in shock considering it's a random summer Monday. I waited for over 25 minutes. Cake was nice, tons of icing! I'd come back for some of their other pastries! read more

Cute little bakery. A little bit of a small city so it was kind of clustered. The free samples are absolutely excellent. Service was reasonable. It is a tourist area so it's a bit of a hustle. read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Wow this place. Crust & Crumb has an amazing GF selection. They had the most delicious rainbow cookies I've ever had and I've had a lot in my day. The carrot cake was so moist, the brownie was ok, the brookie was kinda dry, the chocolate glazed donuts were delicious, and the s'mores cookie bar was pretty damn good. They also have a great selection of normal gluten rich foods like a bunch of different crumb cakes and cookies. The cakes looked so elaborate and yummy. Highly recommend when you're in LBI read more

See all

I swear these bakers need to be on the food network! Here is this year's challenge met perfectly! Thank you crust and crumb for maintain our annual tradition. See you next year! read more

See all

Whatever you pick out of the display case you're going to like so get a bunch of stuff and make sure you pick up 2 rainbow cookie style crumb cakes. One to eat outside in that alley with the small tables so you can devour it while reading all the witty slogans on the dish towels hanging in the window of the shop next door and one to eat in the car at a red light. The jelly is perfect and the cake is soft with that authentic Staten Island Italian bakery rainbow cookie taste that we all crave. Next time I'm trying the napoleons and a cupcake. read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Rainbow cookie crumb cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Grew up having the vanilla cream doughnuts. Out of this world!! The croissant Doughnut is INSANE and will not disappoint. Great location right in bay village. read more

I decided to visit crust and crumble because I had heard about their cronuts. Since I never tried one, I decided todays the day. You're overwhelmed with all their selections as soon as you walk in. Cookies, cakes, donuts, cronuts, bread, they have it all. What caught my eye right away was the pepperoni and Asiago bread. It was delicious. Fresh and very well packed with meat and cheese. They also have an Asiago baguette I want to try next time! Onto the cronuts, I felt like they were just glazed croissants. I mean, trust me they're not bad but not what I was expecting. The cream filled was great, definitely jam packed. My favorite was the glazed, simple and great. The star of the show is here is their huge cookies. I got an m&m and a peanut butter to try. They're absolutely delicious. Perfectly crunchy on the outside and super ooey gooey inside. Yes, that's the technical term for the inside old the cookie. The only drawback is that they're $5 dollars each. It's a hefty cookie at a hefty price. Overall, a great bakery. The team behind the counter is quick and efficient. I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

We tried a number of things over the course of a few visits and they were hit or miss. But 4 stars since it was more hits than misses. The m&m chocolate chip cookies are BOMB! Don't sleep on those. The donuts were also all delish. As was the crumb cake. The cinnamon bun was a miss - sooo dense and way too sweet. The real surprise was the gluten free peanut butter cookie - I would've sworn it wasn't gluten free! And it was nice that they had so many delicious looking gluten free options! read more

There's never a time when on the island that we don't stops for the world famous elephant ears. There's nothing better. We also tried there donuts omg breathtaking. Super filled jelly and very light. read more

See all

Service was not friendly. Charges for cake pops that weren't put in the bag. Birthday cake writing was misspelled.

The best gluten free donuts I've ever had!!! Glazed and pumpkin donuts taste like regular ones- so moist and delicious!

I stopped in today looking for a loaf of bread. The person that helped me was very kind. I asked him what kind of bread they had and he very patiently explained each of the breads to me. I decided on a basic baguette. I struck up a conversation with a woman behind the counter who was very nice. Not sure if she was the owner or the baker, but seems she was in control. When I had the baguette in my hand, I could tell that it wasn't fresh. I have a baking background and there was no crunch or crumb to the baguette. When I questioned whether or not the baguette was fresh, she assured me that it was. I got home, it was clearly not fresh. I understand that these businesses are seasonal and they have a limited time to make money but come on... if you're going to charge me $7.00 for a baguette, at least let it be fresh and when I question it.. don't lie to me. No crust, no crumb... it was clearly a day or two old. I'll add that it was a low humidity day so weather was not a factor. I'm giving two stars because the guy that waited on me was very kind. The bread deserves 0 stars read more

This was the best and most beautiful cake I could ever imagine!! Thank you Crust and Crumb Bakery for making the most special custom 21st Birthday cake for my son. Not only was it so beautiful and elegant with the gorgeous , edible seashells and starfish in blue and white cream colored ornaments, but it was also so delicious! Everyone couldn't believe it. This is the only place I'm going for all my special occasion cakes! Thank you for such an important celebration cake! read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - 21st Birthday cake!! - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

TASTES AS GOOD AS IT LOOKS. warning: As soon as you walk into the bakery you will lose all self control read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Apple pie - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

I've come back to LBI again two years later, and this place is still the bomb! If you're feeling pastries, cake, cannoli, elephant ears, anything of that sort, you're in the right place. 10/10 would still recommend read more

Super happy with a birthday cake that I recently ordered! The lady who took my order by phone was friendly and professional. She did a great job explaining the options and designing a beautiful cake. The cake itself was DELICIOUS! Everyone loved the chocolate cake with raspberry filling. The decoration was detailed and beautiful. We have found a new favorite beach bakery! Thank you for making the birthday extra special!! 10+++ highly recommend! read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Went with the family , we ordered two powered donuts with custard filling , two cinnamon rolls , and this giant Oreo cookie filled with cream which tasted like a devil dog. Everything was amazing! Staff was very friendly and patient while we decided what we wanted. read more

Amazing! Fairly affordable for what you get - so many different options but my favorite is their cookies, and lobster tails! Rich and delicious!! I go every time I'm on the island read more

Love, love this place. Been going there for about 20+ years. Deserts are amazing, muffins are delicious. Elephant ears are kid's favorite. Key lime pie is my favorite. Staff is amazing, always helpful and friendly. Great location, open late. read more

They have the most amazing baked goods!! The crumb cakes the cookies and don't forget the elephant ears!! Mmmm I'm having a sugar rush just thinking about it. My wife and I have been going to LBI for over 30 years. This is one of our first stops when we get there. read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Best bakery in south jersey!! - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Crust and crumb bakery was such a good find in Long Beach Island! The donuts are made fresh daily, they are soft, the icing is delicious, the filling is delicious, they look nice and presentable. The crumb cake is moist. The asiago bread was great, I would recommend heating it up first if that is an option. We loved the elephant ear, it was huge, like an actual elephant ear but it was fresh and it tasted so good - it was very sweet with a little crunch. The cakes here were beautiful and although we did not try one I would definitely want one in the future should an occasion arise. Their display case in the morning when it was full looked lovely and there's pretty much nothing I wouldn't want to try here! Based on my experience, I would highly recommend and I will definitely be coming back on any future long beach island visits :-) read more

This place is DELICIOUS! I had a black and white "cookie" and it's the only place I've ever been to that makes the correctly!!! SO good! The elephant ears are the big draw to this place, but I didn't really care for them. But the cronuts are to die for!!! I will definitely be going back! read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Super cream SUPER filled cronut! - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Our family got together for movie night. We cannot say enough about the wonderful menu, great service, decorations and special touches which made the night an enormous success. For the kids we chose Aladdin. They were well feed and entertained while the adults enjoyed a very complete and wonderful meal that complemented the theme of the movie. Our "Jasmine"server was perfect. We cannot say enough to recommend this experience; it was enjoyed tremendously by all that attended read more

Read about this place on yelp and recognized it as soon as we happened to walk by it! We stopped in real quick and grabbed an elephant ear for later. What amazing treats and pastries! And wow, beautiful cakes! There's some limited, but lovely outdoor seating. The service was quite slow for a busy summer Friday night, only 1 guy serving customers and a big line. But we really enjoyed our (enormous) elephant ear! read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Great food all around! From cakes to pastries, they are amazing and the service is quick and well organized. Always a must go and try the elephant ears! read more

My sons 21st birthday fell on the Saturday of Memorial Day weekend ( I had forgot to order cake and I still wanted something special- only a few days before) Not only did they create an amazing cake in time , but it was also absolutely delicious !! It was completely gone by the end of the night ! Thank you so much ! read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - a chocolate birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

My BIL and I escaped from the family on an LBI vacation and decided to treat ourselves to some Elephant Ears and other pastries...say what? You never heard of an elephant ear...well your missing out! They are a sweet treat cinnamon flaky with the rich goodness of pecans. They are superb when fresh and this bakery does them right! They offer many other bakery staples but if you venture here, this is a must purchase. Grab a fresh brewed cup of coffee and enjoy one in the shared outdoor seating (with other shops). It's quite the treat! Staff is quick and friendly and follow all guidelines. ENJOY! read more

We have been purchasing the Chocalte ganache cake for the past 23 plus years for my daughter now 30. We never leave the island without stocking up on the best crumb cake and brownies ever!!! read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - My daughters 24th maybe even 25th Chocalte ganache cake traditionally from C&C bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Did the recipe for the chocolate chip cookies change? They just don't taste the same. Please help get it back on track.

This place is a landmark.It's Known for it's giant elephant ears. lately I think it deserves a 3 but we love walking around and grabbing a linzer tart and coconut brownie. You Know when pastries kinda taste idk how to describe it almost like they are using something cheap. It's not bad but not great, maybe if I liked elephant ears.Its surrounded by a little village strip mall called bay village that has very charming stores, restaurants,take out chowder,cool beans coffee and the well known bay village pizza. read more

One of the best bakeries around. Donuts and elephant ears are the best! We've been going here for years and hope to continue doing so. read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Powdered donut with custard filling - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Amazing bakery. Things to try: -The elephant ears are amazing and for an added bonus you can watch them make them! -The cinnamon buns are the best I have ever had. -Their entire assortment of cookies are great which is strangely rare for a bakery like this. -I can not speak for their cakes but I have heard very good things. Every time we come to LBI Crust and Crumb is a must; I would highly recommend stopping by! 4.5 read more

Best white cream filled donuts in the world!!! do not miss the chance to try them!!! Love this place and we go there every year when we vacation!! pure heaven! read more

Their custard donuts are a "must try"! This is one of those old fashioned bakeries that makes everything fresh & you really can taste the difference. read more

THE BEST donuts by far, I've had in a very long time. Their jelly donut is amazing. If you've been to LBI you probably know this place. Great Bakery! read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

For Julia Child's 100th birthday, our vacation party decided to bake a French dinner in her honor. For dessert, we decided we just wanted to buy some Eclairs and Napoleons, but none of the bakeries on LBI had French pastries except for the Crust and the Crumb. This was quite a hike since we were staying on the opposite side of the Island, but the yelp reviews convinced us the trek would be well worth it. The inside wasn't fancy, but it smelt of sugary delights. The selection was just the right amount of overwhelming. All the reviews told us to try the Elephant Ears. A sign informed us that they are a French pastry as well, so we ordered one along with our Éclairs and Napoleons. The staff wasn't the friendliest.. But the place wasn't busy and we appreciated getting in and out quick considering our small journey there. Elephant Ears: Delicious and light. Buttery and sticky pastry with just a hint of cinnamon. There is no way one person could finish this tasty but massive dessert in their own. Éclairs: Extremely rich, but delectable. I'm no éclair expert, but these were great in my books. The custard made the dessert a little heavy, but I still enjoyed this rich classic. Napoleon: I'd never had one of these, but I'd definitely try it again. This one was like a vanilla tiramisu, but a little lighter on the crust layers and a little heavier with the cream layers. Very rich and impossible for one person to eat alone as well! I'd definitely try this bakery out if you are searching for a cannoli or cupcake instead of the traditional summer time island sweets. read more

Crust And Crumb Bakery - Smells delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Stayed with a friend for the weekend and she picked up a bunch of things for us to sample for breakfast. One was better than the next. Elephant ears were amazing. Jelly doughnuts .. amazing. Blueberry muffin - one of the best I have ever had and the crumb cake... seriously amazing from a B&w crumb cake lover. Wish someplace that good was local. Although perhaps not.... read more

We went in for the Elephant ears. I had no idea what elephant ears were, until I saw them. Giant flaky buttery crumbly cookies the size of dinner plates....that's what elephant ears are. And where else in the world would you find such an item? Not anywhere on LBI other than this adorable bakery. You must stop in and grab an ear.... Just one, you can split it! read more