Pizza only review have had pizza from here several times but haven't tried sandwiches or hot dishes…read morejust to be upfront! Excellent pizza, yesterday we ordered a half protons half sausage large pie (around 20 bucks and change) The crust was great just as you would except from a Jersey pizza shop not too firm but soft enough to fold if that's your thing. The pepperoni cooked well to be crisp which is just my preference and also not overly spiced. The sausage tasted great but I always prefer sliced or chunks of sausage but no big deal. The cheese...nearly perfect blend I always like a mozzlrella and provolone mix which is a good taste but also gives the melted cheeses a bit of firmness and that stretch h always see in commercials.. highly recommended.. service was polite and efficient and I noticed a decent dining area better than most pizza joints!

The food is good but they charge a 4% SVC charge when you use a debit card which is illegal in New…read moreJersey . The receipt they give you just has the price on it so you don't see the charge but if you ask for an itemized receipt you can see it . You can not charge anyone when they use a debit card . You can only charge when someone pays with a credit card .

After I messed up our reservation 3 times on the same day they graciously accommodated my wife and…read moreI for dinner that evening. It being a beautiful summer evening helped the whole experience but the service and food exceeded it. We shared the asparagus wrapped in cheese and prosciutto with balsamic glaze. It was delicious and plenty for the two of us. Our server (Betsy) was a delight. Helpful and with just the right amount of attention. A very nice person who treated us like old friends. I had a special. Orange Roughy with bay scallops and a spicy tomato sauce over capellini. The fish was perfect with a slightly sweet flavor and flaky texture. Bay scallops are not my favorites as they tend to cook to a tougher texture with less scallop taste than diver scallops. Probably would have preferred 2 or 3 divers instead. But overall a delicious dinner and would have it again. My wife has some issues with garlic which is tough in an Italian restaurant. She had linguini primavera with just olive oil and cheese and really enjoyed it. We sat outside. The inside was noisier than we prefer. All in all a great byo Italian restaurant and I highly recommend it. You might see us there as we plan to return. Go!

It's a quaint place, well decorated, and staff was so accommodating. We had gotten there later then…read moreplanned and they were so kind and never once acted like we are making them stay open longer then expected. Even had 2 takeaways they prepared. I had the mussels and they were tender and cooked perfect. Their pasta is handmade and both my friends had different pasta dishes. One had rigatoni with meatballs in meat sauce. He loved it. My other friend got dish with Gorgonzola cream sauce and scallops. That was excellent as well. Would highly recommend to anyone. And if ever in this area again, I would want to go back

Food. The people. All were terrific. Enjoyed being there with a small and large party.read more

Great time with our family. Food was amazing, well prepared and really fresh. We enjoyed some…read moreappetizers which were so delicious, some did not want to share. Lol. Staff were super nice, making our night perfect! Thank you Russos!

MIL just purchased a house nearby so we wanted to check out the highest rating pizza place nearby…read moreand this was it. What gem we found! That chicken parm garlic knot sandwich with vodka sauce was phenomenal and I do hope they have that often because that would be my new go-to. My husband had the lasagna slice and said it was so good he was UNWILLING to share, so there's that! Now I have something else to try when I'm by there. Cute little spot that I'm sure is a BYOB. Service was great; highly recommend.

We recently ordered takeout from Naples and got their fried calamari and a large pizza with extra…read morecheese and pepperoni. The fried calamari was crunchy and tender but was a bit over fried. It came with lemon wedges and a delicious marinara sauce which was definitely homemade. You could see bits of plum tomatoes, fresh basil and garlic. I could have just eaten that with Italian bread and I would have been happy. The pizza was floppy, probably because it was takeout and overloaded with mozzarella cheese. I'm not complaining! The crust had a nice crunch, and the sauce was delicious! Staff was pleasant

Another solid experience at Isola. Food was very tasty and the service was excellent…read more Unfortunately, once again we could only get a table on the porch. And there's little atmosphere out there. They should add some votives or something to cozy it up a bit - especially during the winter months.

Our waitress Savannah was great. We have been here a Few times before. The food this time was not…read moreup to par. Chicken parm had no sauce and almost no cheese. Scallops risotto had barely any taste. We had reservations for inside as confirmed by the restaurant but they put us outside anyway. The table of 6 inside stayed empty for an hour. Doesn't make sense. Won't be going back here. Based on the fact that reservations were not hard to get, the people have spoken.

Everything was great! Mozzarella app, Ceasars salad, dinner were all top notch. Looks like gal's…read morefavorite new place.

Tableside pasta great Had the meatball appetizer might be…read moreThe best meatball I ever had. , the breadbasket they give you was great too. Didn't really care for the chicken parm. Love their cheesecake was so stuffed.Could only have a bite or two.But got it anyway.

We ordered a large pie, 1/2 meatball & 1/2 sausage and it was AMAZING!!…read more We are return customers to Mystic Island Pizza and the staff is always friendly, the service is great and the food is delicious and never disappoints!

I ordered broccoli with garlic and the was not extra broccoli I need a replacement deilv to meread more

Best meal EVER! The seafood salad is the BEST thing you'll ever eat. Such an amazing meal from…read moresalad to desert. Banana Cream Pie is amazing. I can't say enough great things about the dinner ........ but I can!! MARY was the BEST server ever. She made us feel so welcomed and took the time to explain everything along with making us smile and laugh. When we come back which we will, we are requesting Mary. Great job!!!!!!

This was absolutely incredible, from the atmosphere to the food everything was just perfect…read more We started with the salad which was very good, good dressing and the croutons are the same bread as you get on the table when you sit down which is really good. The Chicken parm on steroids is what they called it and let me tell you it was amazing. I absolutely loved the potato's on top and the sauce was outstanding. You get 2 nice sized pieces of chicken definitely fills you up. The bolognese sauce was incredible. Lots of meat and lots of pasta. Very garlicky which I love. Got it with angel hair pasta which was a great choice as well. The cappuccino and biscotti was amazing as well. Everything just tasted so fresh. Service was awesome, they were on point. Food came out fast and again tested great. It's a BYOB so dont forget to bring a bottle of wine. It's hard to get a reservation so if you're lucky to get one you will enjoy it.

Odd combination for a restaraunt/to go place but it works out! Serves excellent Italian food…read morewhether it be a meatball parm sandwich, pizza...or the delicious chicken quesadillas !

Delicias Sobre Ruedas pizzeria is our go to !! Amazing food ! Best in the area ! Highly recommend!read more

Okay so yes I'm from Jersey so I'm so lucky to be in one of the few states that have good mom and…read morepop pizza joints..with that said tho dominos and Pizza Hut dominate the more commercial side which serves most of this country. I hope I can respectfully differentiate the two of them both b/c they are both the same one is not better or worse but we all have preferences I'm here to simply review my experience understanding that. I've always occasionally ordered dominos regardless of the mom and pop joints, dominos makes some decent wings but this order is about the ny style pizza... I pulled off a slice which was missing one major if not the most important characteristic of any style pie, the outer crust was quite good very close to a by pie but the crust underneath is embarrassingly unstable. Pick it up to fold or est flat is impossible no it literally flops over with ok structure. Again the crust was food and crispy with a new taste but I don't know why the rest was so bad and basically u had to eat with a fork and knife. The sauce if different was quite good ! I also ordered the boneless a in ha which were excellent. In the end dominos failed miserably at a my style bit there deep dish etc all other types are very good and I will still continue to order them here and there just don't go after the ny style

my friends and I called this Domino's Pizza place and my friend was talking and she said the wrong…read morenumber because we were calling off of my phone not hers and once I said my phone number they immediately refused to service because they thought we were prank calling them we were paying customers. We just just didn't have a car so we were asking them to possibly just to see if we could pay at the door, but it was just cause I didn't have any previous call service and it is allowed that you are allowed to pay at the door. I think that this guy was extremely rude because then we called off of my friend's phone, who has ordered it off of that number before and we said one word and he hung up. Don't order.