The service was amazing, very kind and friendly. The pizza was incredible and had a great crust. Overall the place was very cute and a relaxing dinner spot after a Long Beach day! read more

We tried Sebby's after seeing the good reviews and ordered the $27 Grandma's pizza. Unfortunately, it was disappointing. The crust tasted like a premade frozen base, the mozzarella tasted low-quality, and the pizza was far too salty. The cheese and sauce were unevenly distributed--covering some sections while leaving others bare--and the toppings slid off the crust. For $27, I expected better. The staff were friendly, and the restaurant looks inviting from the outside. If we're back in the Oak Island area, we'd give Sebby's another try and order a regular thin-crust pepperoni pizza. This particular pizza missed the mark for us. read more

After reading the great reviews on Yelp and Google, we decided to order personal sized pizzas and garlic knots from Sebby's. I ordered the works and my husband had the white pizza. We ordered carryout and took it back to our hotel room for dinner. Both pizzas were very salty, and the garlic knots were hard and chewy. For $48 I expected more. The pizza crust was good though. read more

See all

Tasted great and would definately go again. Little pricey but it was really good pizza.

Let me say first the food was excellent. Had of course pizza plus a meatball parm. And a Stromboli. Arrived at 5:15, waited an hour and 15 mins for our food. Departed at 7:15. One waitress, Elaina who was working her butt off. The person up front was answering phones, taking orders, seating people and getting to go orders out. Whoever runs this place is abusing the help. And has no idea on how to run a restaurant. They care about Castuccis but not Seppys. Just an idea, stop seating people until the kitchen can catch up. It's ok to have open tables. Especially when service (not the waitress fault) is horrible both front and back of house. If you go, make sure there's more than one waitress on duty. Otherwise go someplace else. read more

This quiet little place next to Castucci's in Southport has nice offerings in quaint quarters but what they do, they do well. We typically get a plain pizza, well done. The sandwiches are very good and they do have some calzone/Stromboli/traditional spaghetti dishes. Not a ton of full meal Italian dinners but that is what next door is for. While you're waiting for your to-go order or with your dinner if you eat in you can grab a beer and/or a glass of wine. We'll be back! read more

The pizza is good, but be prepared to wait. It's never ready when the order is confirmed to be. I keep trying, because it's good, but it never changes. Doesn't matter the time of year. Next time I'll order an hour before I actually want to eat. read more

Fantastic pizza, get the Chicken Parm pizza and the fried mac and cheese. I'll be back!

Absolutely discusting pizza. Ordered a cheese pie with instructions for thin and well done. Gummy dough line through out, One of the worst I have ever seen! BTW we live here , been here over 30 years. Unacceptable! read more

The restaurant has awesome employees! Mine was a takeout order but she made every change that I needed to make my cheesesteak sub exactly as I liked it. I can't wait to eat there again! read more

We visited here on a Sunday after church and couldn't believe we were the only ones here. Once we tasted our food we were definitely confused... why aren't more people here? We ordered 2 pizzas and 1 pasta and everything tasted so good. The actual restraint itself is adorable- with plenty of seating. The portions were large -especially for the price. We spent $60 for 2 of us but have enough leftovers for at least 2-3 more meals each. We asked for the pepperoni pizza to be cooked well done (we like it a little toasty)- it came out perfect. The pizza had a lot of pepperoni on it and it was good pepperoni- a little spicy. The pesto on the chicken pesto pizza was full of flavor. The garlic knots were fresh and garlicky. This place is a hidden gem and if I lived here I would be visiting often. read more

See all

Sebby's is a very nice small pizza place. Nicely appointed with tile, very clean. The pizza selection gives a lot of options. We tried the Sausage and Broccoli Rabe with Ricotta. Very delicious however the crust was just a bit too dry at the edges. We had the 12"/6 slice size between 2 of us but it could easily have fed 3. Definitely good pizza. read more

Sebbys Pizzeria - Broccoli Rabe and Sausage - Wine Bars Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

If you want the best gourmet Italian pie, roasted pizza go to Sebbys! Atmosphere is pretty laid-back. The bar in the back is great for a glass of wine while waiting to go to go to Castucci's! Although the line is long at Castucci's i's and you didn't make reservations, Sebby's is a great place to go amazing food, easy-going atmosphere Perfect alternative to get tasty incredible pizza!!! read more

I love pizza. Unfortunately a little over a year ago, I started having reactions to certain foods. Long story short - it turns out that my sensitivity is to tomatoes, peppers, okra, potatoes - aka "nightshades". I'm not allergic, but eating them causes nasty eczema breakouts. Ugh! Bye-bye to my favorite foods . Until now. Just ordered a White Pizza from Sebby's. Wow! So good! Chewy crust, mozzarella and creamy ricotta with Italian herbs. Absolutely delicious! I almost didn't miss the tomato's and peppers. . We ordered pickup, but it's a real cute little shop - although parking can be an issue at times. read more

We ordered Sebby's our first night on Oak Island. It was quick and easy and honestly, we enjoyed every bit of our food. The crust was baked perfectly, the food was ready in a timely manner, and the staff was super friendly. We'll definitely be returning on our next beach trip! read more

We ordered the square Sicilian style (grandma) added onions. Best pizza in town. Delicious, great tasting sauce, and pizza. It is huge! Fed 5 people and still had leftovers. Service is great and friendly. We took it to go. However, the place looks really cute inside. Would definitely recommend it. read more

Sebbys Pizzeria - Half eaten Sicilian Grandmother pizza with onions. - Wine Bars Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

Every restaurant has bad days, but it's about how the people that work there handle it that matters. Today (Dec 31st), I ordered a Cheesteak Sub via DoorDash. When I received the order, the sandwich had almost no meat in it. It was basically just bread with a small amount of steak and cheese. Now, I have ordered from Sebby's many times, so I thought I would give them a call, not to complain but to let them know. I wanted nothing in return. The woman that answered simply did not seem to care. I told her what happened and she did not say she was sorry, just that 'she would let them know'...whatever that means. She went on to say that everything is portion controlled so it's unlikely there was an issue. I then told her that I have ordered before and this has never happened. Bottom Line: I want to support local businesses, but it's not just about having good food. It's also about the service you get, especially when things don't go right. Hopefully they can do better next time. read more

Sebbys Pizzeria - No meat...Its usually full. - Wine Bars Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

See all

As pizza goes in this area, Sebby's is the best- by far. Don't fall for the other places that say theirs were "voted" best in Southport. BS. Sebby's has primo sausage (pinched style with full fennel flavor); a crust that finishes with a good crunch to it; and sauce that's not too sweet but has a full flavorful impact. Will go back every time. Atmosphere is decent. Wish they had a better beer selection being our only area for improvement. read more

Great food! Great atmosphere! Great service! We love this restaurant and when we don't feel like leaving home, we use Door Dash to get our favorites. By the way, our favorites are pretty much everything on the menu!! If you haven't tried Sebby's - do so ASAP! You won't be disappointed!! read more

Lady that answers the phone is extremely rude every single time you call. Food is good, staff acts like they hate working there.

3 drafts beers, 10 wings, large meat pizza and a huge piece of cheesecake. All excellent tasting and all for 70 bucks. We will definitely go back again!! read more

Great pizza. One of the best in the area! Warning....the wine selection is not good and is pricey. 14 dollars for an average Cabernet is absurd. Just go for the pizza. read more

Sebby's is a small pizzeria owned by the same people who own Castucci's Italian Restaurant next door. It's fairly new and has a classy, modern vibe. My boyfriend and I got a 12" Chicken Artichoke Pizza to share, it was delicious and we ate every last bite! We went around 3 pm on the weekend so we missed the lunch and dinner rush. Our waitress was friendly and checked on us often. We really enjoyed our experience and the food. read more

See all

Ordered delivery. The sausage, mushroom, and black olive pizza was delicious. The crust was not too thick. The tomato sauce was quite tasty without being overly spicy. The pizza had plenty of mozzarella cheese and a generous amount and distribution of the toppings. read more

This is the third time we've had a bad experience with takeout. We usually order the plain cheese pie, but there's usually hardly any sauce when we ask for extra sauce we get extra cheese no sauce this time we ordered the chicken Parm pie, no mozzarella three pieces of tiny pieces of chicken, no sauce all bread very disappointing won't be returning read more

Sebbys Pizzeria - This is supposed to be a chicken parm pizza ! No mozzarella skimpy sauce only 3 tiny pieces of chicken . - Wine Bars Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

Food is good, service is terrible. We called to place an order for pick-up around 6pm and after 5 minutes of calling and getting a busy signal, I finally got through and was asked if I would be ok being put on hold. After 15 minutes on hold, I could hear I was no longer on hold and could hear the noise of the restaurant but I was clearly forgotten and they couldn't hear me saying hello repeatedly. I hear a ring of another call coming in and was hung up on. After calling back and not getting through, seemingly having the call picked up but then putting down the receiver to not deal with customers calling in, I gave up. We decided to drive over to try to place the order in person and my brother finally got through and placed the order. We were told it'd be 30-35 minutes, we arrived at the specified time and waited 20 more minutes for our food to be ordered. We waited without acknowledgment while the single person in front of house cleared tables even though only people waiting for takeout were there. We would've appreciated an honest estimate of when the pizza would be ready and some level of customer service. read more

The service was great and the pizza is always a hit with the group They also have carrot when you are in a rush read more

We are vacationing on Oak Island and gave this place a whirl tonight. It was FANTASTIC. My husband and three boys all agreed we haven't had pizza this delicious since we were in Italy! We look forward to coming back to eat here and will send everyone we know your way! read more

See all

This establishment is affiliated with Catuccis, which is great Italian food, so by relationship , I'd say probably very good. Hey the owners are fro Joisey via Italy, so what's not to like! read more

Pizza is great. I've tried lots of food there and it's all good. Very clean and the staff are great. Love their sauce. Cheesesteaks are so good. read more

Hubby and I decided to try for breakfast. Sat at bar. The mimosas are good, but expensive. Short wait. I tried the cheesesteak omelet. Everything was great except the meat wasn't seasoned. Lots of veggies. The hashbrowns are really small cut potatoes. I asked for cheese and onions. The were good plain and with the onions and cheese. My husband had the French toast platter with sausage and hashbrowns. The egg was cooked perfectly. Two sausage patties. He said it was a solid four. Let's talk about what happened. The server put in a western omelet for me - no cheese or onions. A pancake platter for the hubby. When they brought it out we said we'd just eat it. The server then said it was the folks beside us food - did we eat it? She then took it away. Then she said, that was your food. I said it was totally wrong. She then realized she put it in wrong. So we ended up with plain hash browns and the cheesy ones and somehow my husband got an order of grits. He loved them. They made it right. For a $40 breakfast it was chaotic. I'll give them a little more time to work out the kinks. read more

Sebbys Pizzeria - Hash browns with cheesesteak omelet - Wine Bars Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

See all

It took over half an hour to get through on the phone to place our order. We kept getting busy signals and hang ups. We placed our order came back 30 minutes lates when then said the pizzas would be ready. Only one person on staff and she cleared tables and took orders before waiting on us. Horrible service, horrible service. read more

A tasty addition to the OKI/SP pizza scene I'm a NY Pizza Guy. I put Sebby's right up there with my favorite area pizza joints. Mrs B actually prefers it. Definitely a bit better than anything on the island. Available through Door Dash read more

Sebbys Pizzeria - Wine Bars Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

My wife and I were in town on vacation and popped over to Sebby's for breakfast. We landed here after the first couple places we stopped at had extended waits. It was a blessing in disguise! We called ahead and were told they had about a 5 minute wait so we added our name to the list and were seated almost as soon as we arrived at the restaurant. Started with coffee which wasn't as strong as I personally prefer but enjoyable nonetheless. My wife got a vegetable omelette which she loved and had enough for leftovers. I ordered the shrimp and grits special that included bacon and chorizo. Grits were cheesy and patties and had a nice crispness to them. Didn't look like much of a serving but I was pleasantly surprised. Only flaw on the food was that it did seem to take a while to come out. The highlight was the staff we interacted with. It's tight quarters in the restaurant and for them I would imagine a bit chaotic but everyone smiled and laughed with us throughout. I don't remember our waiter's name but if I could have that level of customer service everywhere I went, I'd be a happy consumer! Kudos to the team and thank you for a great dining experience! read more

Sebbys Pizzeria - Shrimp and Grits special - Wine Bars Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

Terrible service , lol old bag couldn't tell me what pizzas they had said there were "too many" XD GOOD LUCK MAKING MONEY with that attitude. Zero stars read more

Meatballs are good but the chicken parmigiana pizza was dry. Menu stated it came topped with sauce but our pizzdid not. read more

Sebbys Pizzeria - Chicken parmigiana pizza - Wine Bars Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

Unspectacular, greasy , and overall meh. Pizza is more than just cheese , sauce and dough, sadly the nuance is lost on many read more

Great food! I definitely recommend this place and we will be returning! Get the fried mozzarella cheese, it's amazing!

Our family stepped in here on a rainy day and enjoyed a couple of really nice pizzas: Sausage and broccoli rabe and Pepperoni and sausage. The topped part of the pies were good but the crust was a little dry as others have mentioned. The inside of the restaurant was cute and clean. The wine bar looked like it could be a nice spot to wait for a table here or the sister restaurant next door. read more

Ordered a sausage/ mushroom pizza with extra sauce. Not a drop of sauce on the pizza. Bottom of crust was burnt while inside was still a little doughy. What pizza does not have sauce? Sorry Sebbys not acceptable. Third time this has happened. Why would I want to spend $30 on one pizza that was not much better than frozen. read more