I have been to this bakery several times and I have always enjoyed all my purchases. However,…read moreyesterday my husband and I were in there it was fairly busy. We waited for our turn. The girl helping the people in front us was very friendly and wished the couple a happy 4th of July. She took our order, packed our items and sent us on our way. No thank you, no happy 4th of July. My husband and I are POC and we felt very slighted. I'm not sure I want to visit a place that is so racially biased. This experience put a sour note on our visit and I'll be more inclined to shop elsewhere.

Friday August 21st, 2026. We Celebrated a Birthday with a…read morespecial someone. We ordered an Oreo Cake. It had a cream filling with chocolate cake. It was moist and delicious!!!.

The Treatery in Jamesport is a must stop while on the North Fork. The cookies are out of this…read moreworld. My fave is the chocolate covered oatmeal raisin. A customer sitting next to me had their GRILLED CHEESE it looked so delicious. They greet you with a smile. They maybe a small store, but they pack a big punch for flavor. Ciao for Now.

Words can not describe the flavors coming out of this quaint bakery. If you are passing through…read moreJamesport or staying here, you must stop In and try something scrumptious. People are so nice.

We have been ordering my Moms birthday cake from Tilda's since she was 86. Last week Mom turned 99!…read moreTilda's did not disappoint. I ordered a yellow three layer cake with cherry filling (Moms favorite) and chocolate buttercream frosting. The flavor was outstanding. The cake itself was moist without being gummy, the frosting was to die for, and the cherry filling wasn't too sweet. It was a perfect cake. Best one yet! My only critic, and it's a very slight one, is the edible butterflies they placed on the cake looked cheap. I removed them prior to serving. I'll be back for her 100th birthday celebration next year!

Large Blueberry Crumb Pie is to die for! Peach Pie not so…read moregood. People that work there are ok. Ambiance is great!

i would 100% recommend checking out this bakery. i placed a custom cupcake order and they totally…read morehit the mark. the decorations were superb. i gave some flexibility on what i wanted along with a few inspiration pictures, and they did an incredible job. i ordered 10 jumbo cupcakes, funfetti flavor with vanilla icing, and honestly the taste was exceptional. everyone was raving about how fresh, moist, and delicious the cupcakes were. it was really easy to order. i called about a week in advance, and they were very accommodating. service was exceptional. when i went inside, they individually boxed the cupcakes for me. overall, i couldn't recommend this bakery more. cost-wise, it was also the best deal out of the local bakeries i had looked into.

Still a solid bakery well known to the neighborhood area. Been in the same spot on Middle Country…read moreRoad for many years. Good spot to pick up a cake or cookie platter for the family gathering during the holiday season.

It was time for me to get my sugar on, and this place really took care of me.Running in last minute…read moreas they were closing, (I didn't realize) so funny how you can be so unaware of time when that sugar monster is upon you The woman who helped me was very sweet and generous Let me try one of her sugar Dolce Leche cookies. I have never had one before, and it was absolutely scrumdiddlyumptious. It was a pillowy light sugar cookie with the dolce Leche caramel in between and dusted with fine white powdered sugar. Just fabulous There are so many options here for Easter if you're not sure what to do you should head on over. The attention to detail on the cookies and the pastries is perfection. I look forward to my next adventure here.

Had a danish pastry. A carrot cake…read more And a lemon cupcake. My favorite was the lemon cupcake. So soft sweet and velvety.

Still over 10 years later I can't look at my wedding photos or hear a wedding story and not…read moreimmediately think how awful the Rolling Pin Bakery. The owner was rude and dismissive when I asked for refund of the profit she made. I really really suggest you go somewhere else. The fact they treat your wedding day like just another day, no care, no love, nothing but disappointment, disrespect, and distain if they screw up and you'd like it to be corrected. Rolling Pin is awful in all aspects. DO NOT ORDER ANY CAKE FROM THEM!!!!!

I had my wedding last Sunday 4/6 and had our cake made by Rolling Pin. They sent us a tasting a few…read moremonths before and we picked vanilla sponge cake with strawberry jam. Absolutely delicious and was even better in the actual wedding cake. The one blemish on a perfect cake was that we ordered lilac or light purple icing for flowers on the cake, they turned out to be a dark blue. But great tasting cake nonetheless.

Absolutely an inviting store, from the logo, to the packaging. Clean & inviting store. Staff are…read morealways welcoming & helpful. The kiosk is a challenge to use & I always ask for help. Unfortunately I will go there less, because Crumbl removed the Dubai chocolate brownie from their menu. Craziness. lol. It's that good & worth it for all of the calories & price.

Very happy to finally have a Crumbl in Suffolk County! It's located in a shopping center with tons…read moreof parking, which is also a plus! For their recent opening, there was a promo for a free chocolate chip cookie! I couldn't resist and I haven't visited this location yet since they opened recently. The cookie was delicious. Fresh and warm. It's clean inside and the lady working behind the counter was nice and welcoming. Welcome to the neighborhood!

I've seen a lot about this place and wanted to give them a try. They are not your conventional…read morebakery but have many different and interesting items sure to please almost anyone. There is street parking and multiple municipal lots within walking distance. The shop is long with many cases and displays of baked goods. Everything is labeled clearly and the packaging they use to wrap your purchases is very visually pleasing. Better looking wrapping if you are looking to bring something to someone's house. They have gluten free options and quite a few items you don't typically see other places. The employees working were friendly and knowledgeable. They were also extremely patient with the more indecisive customers. Overall I would recommend this bake shop for a fun change to your typical bakery.

We always visit this bakery when in town and bring back goodies. This trip we purchased a rainbow…read morecake (delicious) and got decorated cookies, plus some pink/whites. The decorated cookies were terrible, like biting into a brick. For paying close to $5 dollars per cookie, the freshness should be on par and it clearly was not. They were decorated beautifully, but quality/taste was not good. We bought six decorated cookies, so to spend that much and be a brick texture is no good.