The real thing, icing covered brownies tasting like old world heart and soul in every bite, flavor…read morepopping on all cylinders making your eyes water, wow, Highly, highly recommend!! Mike Guerra

Such a cute place. So happy to have found it. Hot coffee and some delish cakes and donuts too…read more Staff were so sweet. So peaceful to sit outside and enjoy the grounds there. We will definitely be back.

If you are reading this review instead of getting on the line to order you're already wasted too…read moremuch time. I didn't know what to expect when the suggestion came up to come here, or if I thought I could find anything to satisfy my ice cream fix from the looks of the old school store front. But I'm so glad I was 100% proven wrong, because this is a hidden gem and needs to stay that way to keep lines from forming. As soon as you walk in you could tell there were too many delicious choices to narrow down into an order including pralines and cream, banana nut crunch and bartman. And if something doesn't quite fit your fancy, you can choose to add toppings to your mix from the large variety of options. The line moves fast, and the friendly staff are super helpful and ready to answer questions. The menu also provides favorite concoctions and sundaes. The interior may seem small, but you don't need much room to get in, order, and get out quickly. The only problem is I only had two hands to hold my order as I wanted to try everything.

Don't be fooled by the outdated and small look - this is the most delicious ice cream you'll have…read moreon Long Island! Living close to this place is very dangerous, as we already went back twice in 1 week. From ice cream to pup cups to nostalgic candy, this is the perfect spot for someone with a sweet tooth. We tried the Mint Cookies & Cream (I usually never order mint) but it was perfectly flavored and not overly minted. Everything is homemade fresh - highly recommend!

Food & Quality: The shake was a solid 10/10--perfectly made and not overly heavy, which made it…read morereally enjoyable. Service: The staff was great, and the owner was especially friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Ambiance: The atmosphere was warm and inviting. It's also a nice touch that you can watch them prepare the ice cream rolls right in front of you, adding to the overall experience.

If you want to support a family owned business this is it. There products are beyond delicious,…read moreemployees are not just friendly they go out their way to make you feel at home. I would only like if there were multiple colored waffle shells daily but definitely not a deal breaker

I visited the truck at Ace Hardware after following them on Instagram for a while…read more I ordered the cookies and cream cupcake, peanut butter and jelly cupcake, tiramisu cup, s'mores cookie and chocolate chip cookie Doug cookie. You need to order the chocolate chip cookie, it is unreal!! The tiramisu was my second favorite, so delicious. Make sure to check their Instagram to see their menu and schedule. I highly recommend their baked goods.

I finally got around to trying the delicious desserts from here and it was well worth the wait! I…read moregot there right at 12 when they opened and the line was already so long. We waited about an hour but were able to get everything we wanted. I recommend going a bit before they open to be the first ones on line. We brought all the desserts to a friend's house and everyone loved it all! Our favorite is definitely the 5oz chocolate chip cookies. Will be back soon for more.

Been here a few times, and enjoyed it each time!…read more Went last night with my parents and fiancé. We each got something different, and all was enjoyed. There was something for everyone and when we thought we made our decision, we saw something else that interested us. I had a delicious oatmeal raisin cookie. I was only able to eat half, and I'm looking forward to having the second half later. My fiancé had the Tiramisu, my stepdad had cookies and cream cupcake and my mom had a cookie/tart. Service was very friendly! We sat inside. There are a few tables available. Yum!

Loved it -- lemon burst cake was moist and even better tasting than it looked. That's saying…read moresomething! My husband got a delicious ice cream cone. Great vibes and I loved seeing the people come in and out. Amazing service with samples!

Wife and I stopped by today after reading all the reviews. I had the banana split in a big waffle…read morecone. It had bananas and fresh juicy cherries in it. Wife had the Car 54 which was coffee ice cream with cut up chocolate donuts. Donuts and coffee, for the car 54 cop theme, get it? Very friendly employees and absolutely delicious ice cream. My wife can sometimes have stomach issues after ice cream but at this place she felt fine. Maybe it's better quality or something. Definitely worth a stop by if you are in the area like at lavender by the bay

Outstanding service, flavor selection, and delicious ice cream. I ordered the pistachio cherry and…read moredad got cherry vanilla.

I would give this 3.5 stars if I could, because I love the charm of this place and do think there's…read morea lot they get right here. This place has been here for so many decades, it almost feels like stepping back in time with the big wooden booths and pastry counter. It's giving old school diner. When you walk in you'll notice the bakery portion of the store to your right, where you can order any freshly baked breads, pastries, cookies and the like. Straight back is where you go to place food and coffee orders. You place your order on a kiosk. Options include a variety of egg dishes, omelets and frittatas, as well as waffles, pancakes and avocado toast. There's a full coffee bar as well with iced coffees, lattes and other espresso drinks to choose from. We went with a bunch of iced coffees, a "build your own" omelet, breakfast burrito and mushroom omelet. Despite the crazy line here on a Saturday afternoon our food came out very quickly. Coffees took another 20 minutes or so until we were able to ask someone about it (we felt bad, they were so busy), and they handed them over to us. The food here was good and fresh, but also very no frills and portions are small. The prices here are so high though that when we were walking by Donahue's on our way out we realized we could've had a fancy brunch there for just about the same price as we paid for a few small dishes.

Tables were dirty (as others have mentioned).... Food was okay but very expensive. It's nice they…read morehave that back lot for parking. Pastries were very good.

A breath of fresh air for downtown Riverhead, this charming little spot offers homemade frozen…read moreyogurt akin to Pinkberry (or Buddha Berry in the Hamptons.). I loved the fresh selection of fruit and the plentiful toppings. You pay by weight so go as crazy as your pocket can afford with the toppings. Delightful!

Stick to serving frozen yogurt, if you can't make an açai bowl the right way do not sell it. I'm…read morepretty sure the granola was rice crispy's and the fruit was probably two months old. An açai bowl and is not a smoothie and a bowl by the way, and super overpriced. I'm only giving this one star because I have to

What a fun shoot place. Interesting ice cream flavors like Biskoff! My favorite airplane snack!…read moreService is friendly n ambience is fun! But it's not cheap, like almost $8 for med 2 scoop ice scream. I suppose it's worth it.

My pineapple agua fresca was FIRE! This place is so fun with many fun treats and creations. From…read moreice pops with fruit slices to loaded Doritos in a bag. Next time I'm coming for the chocolate covered bananas. The place itself is vibrant and fun. Full on yellow fill the walls and it's amazing. It's more of a grab and go spot with a few spots to sit. We stopped in after our visit at the aquarium and my nieces loved it. They had non dairy options for them and they shared a watermelon ice. I have no idea what my sister got but I took a picture of her crazy concoction. I think she customized something and topped it with candy and tajin. The staff was warm and welcoming as well as patient. I'm sure they are used to it with all the families that must stop in being a block away from the Long Island aquarium. Still much appreciated.

Candy and ice cream shop. They have hershey's ice cream and soft serve... thier soft serve was…read morevegan. The staff is very nice and attentive. They give generous samples and the cones are massive!

New owner is great. New look is really nice. Love their selection of chocolate! Always stop in for…read moremy choc covered Oreo fix!!