As a self-declared EXPERT on the American original that is the pork tenderloin sandwich, I am prepared to name this establishment as GRAND CHAMPION for best tender in Northeast Kansas! Sorry Pad, you had a good run. ‍ read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - BEST pork tender in Northeast Kansas! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

See all

I am KCMO native and Sheridans has always been my go to for custard. But this location consistently messes up our orders. Things are way too expensive to not get what you pay for. I specifically ask for my concrete to be lightly blended but they continue to give me soup. I asked to have the toppings on the bottom of the cup and some on top because they usually put them all at top to mask the fact that the rest of the cup is liquid. They still put the toppings on the top. I've wasted almost $8 because it took forever to get through the line and way too crowded to get out and get my money back. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

See all

Sheridan's is my go to when in Topeka!! Mrs. Gay is one of my favorite ladies that I've met over the years, and I make sure to support her business each year, when in town. I love the tenderloin sandwich with extra red onions and pickles and friesssss with a side of BBQ sauce and more pickles! The milk shakes, concretes, banana splits, and brownie a la mode are binge and craving worthy! Service is always on point by the employees and they are always friendly! I do like to make modifications, but they roll with me each time! I love coming when the sun is setting or has set because the sky is beautiful against the Sheridan's sign! It gives drive-in type! Can't wait to see y'all again in July 2025!! read more

See all

A sundae. An American tradition. You get ice cream or custard. Whipped cream. Nuts a cherry and your topping . Here Yuu just get custard and a topping. Where's the whipped cream. The nuts. The cherry. A sundae isn't just ice cream with chocolate sauce on it. read more

awesome dinner , lunch or custard mixes. Open late for that late treat, great young people working there

Visiting from New England during some of the hottest weather evah! I loved my key lime pie. Don't get a "pot hole" in this heat--melts too fast! Overall good experience and if you've never had a frozen custard, give it try! read more

See all

Drive thru was incredibly slow. Need to work out a more efficient system. We were in the drive thru over 30 min and the line wasn't that long. read more

I love love this place! Food: we always get something new to share since the portions are extremely well. Service: since we are regulars when we are not traveling the staff treats us so well. This time we went inside to a corner booth and our food was promptly cooked. Ambiance: very cozy and quiet since ppl are too afraid to get out. Not us, we love going out, and trying new things. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Not too busy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

Very excellent food! First time eating Sheridan's and realized what I've been missing. Some of the best chicken strips I've had a restaurant. Hand cut fries and my wife's pork tenderloin sandwich was also superb. Everything definitely seemed made by scratch, good portions, and absolutely way better than fast food joints. Thanks Sheridan's for a job well done, which is rare these days! read more

We live in Kansas City but wanted to take our newly purchased car for a spin and enjoy a nostalgic frozen custard treat. What a great surprise to discover not only such great desserts but food items as well! The pork tenderloin & fries were the perfect savory set up before a Grasshopper concrete & Royal Turtle sundae. In addition, we encountered friendly, helpful staff, who let us enjoy our food before making our desserts. Unlike most Sheridan's this location has a small inside seating area, which was incredibly clean, as was the food prep area & restrooms. Well done! read more

Incredible food at a great price!! Friendly staff. Down home feel. Wish there were more restaurants like this. Happy to support this business read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Specials menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

Great frozen custard, the staff are always polite. great way to get family out of the house .

Sheridan's is a community and family centered business that employs caring and customer friendly employees like a young girl named Hannah. Today was my first time frequenting "Sheridan's". Hannah greeted me with a warm and welcoming smile. She allowed me to sit and wait, a few minutes, for the restaurant to open. I was impressed by her unusual kindness and consideration. Hannah affords Sheridan's a 5-Star review. I would reccommend the quality service and community spirit of Sheridan's to anyone in Topeka. read more

Open withvery friendly seevice with a smile! Enjoyed a pork tender and a cone in cup.

Great service, great custard! I would definitely go here to get a quick treat. So many options in the menu. Try it out!

I went to this place and OMG the food was great. I ordered a chili dog and onion rings and a cherry limeade. My goodness I was so surprised how homemade everything tasted. My onion rings were thick and cooked to perfection, my chili dog which was beef and this made me very happy was delicious and they have a homemade chili they use which was just right. The customer service I received was great as this place has a drive thru which made it very convenient as this place was packed with people. I enjoy there homemade cherry limeade as well. The cost of everything was a little pricey but hey what do you expect when everything is fresh and doesn't taste like it came out of a can. I will be coming back here again. read more

Very delicious custard, a bit pricey but worth it. Didn't try any of their other foods, will give it a try another time. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Brett's butter pecan concrete - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

I can go here daily but it wouldn't be good for my health. The frozen custard here is better than ice cream. I love getting the butter pecan concrete and the mocha almond. So good. I have also had the Dixie's Pie in the Sky. My advice is to share this because it's a lot of ice cream plus toppings and a brownie!!! OMG... so yum. read more

I would recommend their concretes with Oreos or Reese's or Heath bar, their veggie burger, or their hot dog. I've had all and all were good. A little on the pricey side but I feel like here you're paying for the experience so it's expectable. Not sure exactly what the experience is but if you're from Topeka you'll know what I mean. Good stuff here. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

The strawberries in my custard were way too bitter & the burger combo was pretty non memorable.

No judgment as I love a "used" building and this one is a little rough around the edges. However, you can tell they keep everything clean just by looking through the Order Window. The staff was very friendly and efficient. I knew that I shouldn't have but I ordered the Mount Rush Smore which was absolutely delicious. My regret came solely from misjudging my stomach and ordered a larger size than necessary. I may or may not have felt slightly nauseous while not letting any of it go to waste. It's no one's fault but my own. It was a nice treat going with my brother and his little family. Plus it was a gorgeous, warm day. Next time, I will order the smallest size. read more

Sheridan's is the go to place for a delightful sweet treat in Topeka! They have a wide variety of delicious custards, frozen treats, and real food too. Pairing any of these tasty options with their exceptional customer service and the nostalgic atmosphere makes Sheridan's the best place to take the family for miles around. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Dolly's Pie in the Sky - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

Best Pork Tenderloin Sandwich in Mid-West! The combo cost me around $7.50 with White truffle fries and a large Cherry Limeade. They also have the best chicken fingers here. Well seasoned and great portions. This place is a spot you've got to try when you're in town. Their Mango Dango is the perfect balance of sweetness/tartness and a great way to end a meal. The service here is always outstanding. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Pork Tenderloin meal with limeade - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

Running late I stopped for lunch to go. Drove the 20 minutes home& opened the carry- out . The veggie burger had old lettuce evident by the blackened edges. The pork tender was dry and actually hard. The fries were limp & had been cooked some time earlier. I have purchased the same items previously & had no problem. Guess the trick is to get there earlier before the quality diminishes. My partner put his fries and sandwich out back near the woods for the coons. They'll eat anything. read more

Booo.... Stood at window forever. Finally got in car and used drive thru. Choc shake half mixed/ half a-- Not what they used to be read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Care a little more - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

Stop here every time we are in Topeka, like their assortment of toppings, turtle sundae, strawberry, and also the mango

Food so fresh you would think they have the cow right in back. Locally sourced within 30 miles of the location.

This is simply the best ice cream in Topeka. It's a litte expensive but well worth it. If you like sweet and salty things I highly suggest the Carmel Pretzel Crunch! read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - The best ice cream in Topeka ! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

Our fries were burnt. When we went up to the window the people at the window didn't wanna help and weren't very nice. We kindly asked for new fries. When they called us up for our new fries we grabbed the bag and went back to the table and it was just a bag full of napkins. They didn't wanna help and I guess didn't appreciate the fact that we asked for new fries. Needless to say. We didn't appreciate the rude gesture. read more

My first visit to Sheridan's Frozen Custard was not a disappointment. We went there for an ice cream treat, but no dinner. I didn't want the walk up window, so we dined inside. The inside is large and very clean with booths and tables. It reminded me to the dairy bar when I was a kid. (Fresh ice cream at my home town dairy processing plant.) I ordered the Royal Turtle sundae. The sizing is a little different here, but the wait staff will explain. I got the "Regular" which was the smallest size, but it was filled to maximum capacity with vanilla frozen custard, topped with hot fudge and caramel, then sprinkled with warm pecans and a cherry on top. I didn't know about frozen custard versus ice cream, so the young man explained the difference to me. I learned that after all these years, I've been making home made frozen custard instead of ice cream because I always add eggs to me recipe. I've got to return for the Salted Caramel Brownie Sundae! read more

Average and over priced is how I would describe this place. Had the large Dirt and Worms Concrete and found it to be very average. Will be sticking to Freddy's henceforth. read more

Fun fun fun! Great size for the price and creamy custard. Lots of pecans and caramel on the sundaes. Kids behind the counter were great and friendly. read more

Custard is good but that's where the good experience ended. If you are going to serve food on your menu it should at least be edible. Ordered from drive thru and was asked pull into a parking spot to wait for food. I'm fine with that but 15 minutes later they finally bring it out. Got home and...was missing part of our order, fries were too salty to eat (we like salty fries as much as the next person but this was excessive), pork tenderloin was burnt, and my daughters chicken strips were inedible. Literally. She tried to bite through one and couldn't. So I took one and could not even rip it apart with my fingers. I would not recommend this place for their food ever. Stick to the custard. read more

Icecream is delicious and very quickly severed. Friendly staff as well! Have been back twice so far

If I could give no stars I would. Not another customer in sight and they still managed to get my order wrong twice after I returned my first concrete because there was a large black hair in it. Not impressed. Won't be back. read more

Very good. Fast and some cute named options. No one had any complaints. Got grasshopper, dirt cake, Mt rush-smore and turtle sundae. Tried them all. Smores was probably best read more

Well gotta say been coming here for awhile now and tonight these employees have no clue whats goin on there takin forever and theres not even that many people here and they are goin so slow the drive thru is getting backed up and they are getting the orders wrong so a lot of ice cream is getting wasted. read more

Take a break with a friend. We like to go inside. Free WiFi and a great place to relax. Sad they don't serve coffee, but I bring my own. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - You can go inside too. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Topeka, Kansas

See all

This place couldn't be any cuter. It's so cute, I want to pinch it's cheeks. It looks like a 1950's diner/ice cream parlor with metal accents and plenty of fluorescent lights on the outside. The staff is friendly and the custard is always incredible and very well made. Service is super quick and you are usually satisfying your sweet tooth less than five minutes after walking up to the window. A great addition to the Topeka restaurant scene that just feels like summer. read more

Cheapest and tasteful ice cream in topeka and no one can't find a place that beats this taste with such a low price and there are few benches outside this place and breezing evenings are perfect for such a places to hangout with some friends read more