Fish and Fancy has always caught our eye and we finally made the stop. Fair prices for seafood. I…read morehad the Baltimore crab cakes which comes with two sides. My daughters had the fish and chips and scallops. The scallops were easily the best dish. Broiled. Nice outdoor seating so we could bring our dog.

The best cooked shrimp in Cape May! We love this place! We prefer to cook our food at home, but you…read morecal also have them cook it . Highly recommend!

Fabulous meals and phenomenal service. This restaurant is run like a finely tuned watch. Sue and…read moreSharon treated us like their only customers, every request was met with courtesy. Steamed and broiled lobsters, salmon and steak dinners were delicious and plentiful. Thank you for a lovely evening.

I haven't reviewed this place in awhile. We go eat on the outside deck as a yearly tradition…read more Maybe that's why I give it a higher score.... If you want to sit on the outside deck, you order at the fish market/take out section and wait outside for them to call your number. I think it's a great system. Never have trouble finding an open table. You sit next to the commercial fishing boats so if you're looking for a pretty water view, this isn't it. I had the broiled seafood platter with a baked potato and coleslaw. It came with a decent sized piece of flounder. It was very meaty but not much taste. The 3 shrimp and 2 scallops had good flavor but were small. I liked the deviled clam. My favorite was the crab cake. No filler at all. The baked potato was cooked perfectly and they don't charge extra for sour cream. The coleslaw is very good. It's a nice platter for the price. I found it filling. I also had some of the fried clams. They are big pieces of clam and very tender. I got pumpkin cheesecake to go and that was soooo good. It had a spice cake layer at the bottom. Wish I took a photo.

We had family visiting down the shore and wanted an easy, different dine at home experience. After…read moredriving by Topsail one day I checked them out on Yelp and decided to give them a try. What a great decision! On their website I decided to order the Wrighstville, which was a combination appealing to me and our guests. The portion says 5-6 people: we had four adults two teenagers so to be cautious I added an extra pound of shrimp. It was a perfect amount of food. I opted for pickup and it was ready at my arrival time. Some instructions given verbally, accompanied by a cooking instructions card. I got home, fired up the electric stove and within 50 minutes we were eating a delicious, perfectly cooked meal. I will definitely do this again with Topsail, like once a summer. This is not inexpensive. It is a splurge. I could prep it all myself but it would be complicated, time consuming and I'm unsure I would get the items to all come out cooked correctly. So I recommend this steamer experience at least once for a unique, dine at home dinner.

I am writing to express my dissatisfaction with your steamer pot. My son was in from Denver…read moreColorado with his wife, and my daughter and her family were visiting as well and they all love seafood. We planned a big family seafood fest with The Miss Emily II High Tider. I paid over $250 for this steamer pot. I listened to the directions given by the girl who waited on me at the store, and even joked that I was glad the instructions were written down. I followed the directions to a tee, even allowing 4 extra minutes for the shrimp and lobster. I drained it and poured it onto the table for dinner. Well it was pretty much a fiasco. Most of the shrimp were not cooked, so I had to gather them all up and cook them longer. The potatoes for the most part were hard and not cooked, so I had to remove those and cook them again. The sausage was pink inside, so that needed to be re-cooked. And lastly, the lobster tails were so rubbery that we could not eat them. So instead of enjoying a nice seafood dinner, my time was spent jumping up and down from the table re-cooking the uncooked food! We were all very disappointed because we had been very much looking forward to this family dinner. I wish them much success, but I don't think that we will be back and unfortunately, I don't think that I would recommend their business to my friends. (I reached out to customer service via email twice to express my concerns and received no reply!)

Casual dock-side bar with lots of seafood plus non-seafood options. Plenty of beers on tap…read more Oysters on the half shell. Cold or steamed lobster. Service is good. Plenty of seating. Been here many times. Family friendly tables or can sit at the bar.

Best Raw Bar in Town! Love my clams on the half shell and Cape May Salts never disappoint! Plenty…read moreof choices for the seafood lover in you!

Hubby and I went today around lunch. Staff were pleasant and when I tell you the scallops were the…read morebomb! Seriously the best I've had! We also had extra large shrimp and cucumber salad which both were delicious! We will be back next year on our yearly trip to the coast!

Bought 2 live lobsters on Friday, 15 minute ride and they were DOA…read more They exchanged them and the next 2 barely made it, signs of life we cooked them. Ridiculous for a mere 78. bucks.

Ordered online & picked up the order. My daughter had the kids hamburger with fries. We had the…read moreseafood boil with seafood seasoning. Everything was good, but what would've made it better would be if they season the butter. Just taste like hot butter on all of the seafood as it drowned out the little seasoning on top.

The clams and shrimp were good. The vegetables were good. I did not like the mustard underneath…read more The salmon service was quick.

Always the Best ! Love the Coffee shop !…read moreWe are Local residents and during the summer months when all the tourists are here in Cape May ... if you don't want to wait the Coffee shop is the Best

While the restaurant is great and nostalgic and we enjoy it, we never knew about the "other"…read moreLobster House. A locals secret. The coffee shop has no signs outside and when you walk in you'll find a retro coffee shop/diner experience. Now for the secret....they have their own menu with lower prices than the main Lobster House restaurant but share the same kitchen. In fact you can see the kitchen from the swinging doors behind the counter. This is great in the off season but when it's nice grab it to go and head to to the docks behind the restaurant where you'll find plenty of tables and also some walk up raw bar and drink spots.

From Breakfast to Dinner Mermaids did not disappoint. This is an excellent casual dining…read morerestaurant - we visited twice - Thanks for including Muslim staff! It feels inclusive here with excellent service! I loved my shrimp and scallop dish for dinner . Huge clean space for dining! We sat overlooking the dunes.

We made the mistake of going to this place based on the recommendation from a couple of travel…read morefolks on YouTube. They said the food was excellent and relatively inexpensive. Well, it was not our cup of tea for a number of reasons. First, the food was not inexpensive. I included her menu to let you judge for yourself. You could say that the ambience was what could be best described as "rickety quaint," and if you were expecting to get a view of the ocean, the best that you'll get is a window seat with a lovely view of a grassy dune. I got the fish and chips and my partner got a crabcake sandwich. We both were on par with what you'd get in the cafeteria. although the fries were nice and crispy. Somewhat mentioned that the table ketchup tasted funny in a different post and we can confirm that that's true and we have avoided it after the first taste. Although we left a generous tip, it certainly was not inexpensive and a value in any which way and won't be coming back.