I stopped by The Lobster House area to see the famous schooners and waterfront views, and it was a beautiful part of Cape May. The marina atmosphere, boats, and views create such a classic coastal feeling. Even if you're not stopping for a full meal, it's worth walking around and taking in the scenery. It's a great photo spot and a nice addition to a Cape May day exploring the waterfront. I'd definitely recommend adding this to your Cape May itinerary. Be aware there are a few parts to the lobster house in general. It's confusing as a first timer but then you get familiar. I ate at Schooners dock at The Lobster House. Menú is limited. You can't order from other parts like the raw bar and sit in Schooners. I enjoyed fried oysters and a burger with fries. Service was good despite it being busy. Fries arrived cold but in no time they sent it back to get a new batch. read more

See all

If I could, I'd give negative stars! I've been coming to The Lobster House for decades. Tonight, I expected to take my family out for a nice meal. We waited in excess of an hour for a table. It smelled so bad inside of mildew and mothballs when we were seated, we should have left then. There were five of us. Half of us got water the others didn't receive any of their drinks. The appetizers were cold when they were dropped at our table. It took another 40 minutes for 2 of our 5 meals to be served, while the other 3 meals didn't come out for another 15 minutes and they were cold, uncooked and disgusting. Tonight is the LAST time my family and I will ever go to the Lobster House. $350.00 for dinner and we literally had to stop for fast food on the way home. I'm in the bar/restaurant industry and I will be sure to advertise how horrible this business has become. Save your self respect and your money and go ANYWHERE else!!! read more

Best in South Jersey Man, this place is huge! Our dining room was epic - great views of the marina. Lobster Bisque - best we've ever had. Scallops - big portion! Like 10-12. Sautéed to perfection. Our server, Destiny, did a great job! read more

The Lobster House - Scallops; tomato stew; roasted red potatoes; garlic/poppy seed bread. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

12 of us for dinner! Service was OK, but our server was remarkably impersonal and not as pleasant as we have always found lobster house waitstaff. Not sure why but it seems like he just didn't want to be there and we had remind him of things to bring that normally come out without us saying anything. An occasional smile would've helped. Tried the daily special, mini crab, and shrimp cake appetizer. No crust like you normally find on a crabcake. Almost tasted a little doughy. I would not order again. For entrées, the lobster was fantastic as usual. Five stars for the one, one and a half, and 2 pound lobsters read more

See all

1921 this local establishment began. 105 years ago. Sure, my solo dining for over $100 with tip was out of kilter with the value but there's are good reasons this institution is still here. Staff is one - a thrum of hive-like busy bee activity - they all worked hard from I could see and since this is a volume business, that is a backbone to their success. My Latino server was attentive and upbeat. Nice guy. Next - the food wasn't that bad at all. The Lobster Bisque was pleasant and the Flounder Francaise was fine - not $37 fine but hey, you're paying for location too. Plus I'm sure the fish was fresh. Shane they didn't have filet of sole. Coffee, apple pie with ice cream, and baked potato were each unremarkable - on par with diner chow. But again, it's not the Coffee House or the Baked Potato Mansion. I saw many families here and I suspect for many of those families, toddlers and elders in tow, years of their memories here with families is a valuable reason for them to go. Tradition has a place in a long term eatery. Like Sparks Steakhouse. Wait. My bad example. Like Krogs Fiske Haus in Copenhagen. I'll die childless and all my family are long gone so I'm afraid the other memorable aspects of this sprawling seafood beer hall (in appearance - not literally a beer hall) were just observations - like the bare breasted sea ship carvings on the walls - won't prompt my return. Fun fact: why they are bare-breasted: according to maritime folklore, showing an exposed breast was believed to "shame" the sea into becoming calm. It also served to appease the angry spirits of the ocean. For me, it just was a bit embarrassing to have the mammalian protuberances monitoring my feeding. read more

The Lobster House - wall art of immodest wooden maiden - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

There's a seafood market in the front where you order fresh seafood and sit on their back patio overlooking the harbor - don't miss this! It's a quick and casual spot that's perfect to enjoy delicious and fresh seafood. We ordered the soft shell crab, stuffed shrimp, calamari and clam chowder and loved everything. The clam chowder might have been one of the best ones I've ever had with lots of clams in it. Then, there's the indoor restaurant which is a bit fancier with checkered tablecloths and warm wood interior. My group ordered the baked clams casino (large clams!), lobster bisque (thick and delicious), crabmeat au gratin, crab cakes, lobster house specialty (seafood linguine) and sautéed crabmeat. We loved how much seafood came with every dish and how quick our service was. read more

See all

Definitely a go-to stop for lunch or dinner in Cape May! There's lots to choose from - raw bar, restaurant, boat bar, or pick up window. Lobster salad with fries, and the fried combo platter is what we ordered from the pick up window and our tummies were very pleased! We ate outside on the dock and enjoyed watching the boats come in. Cannot wait to go back! read more

See all

We went for lunch and decided to order "to go" and dine on the outside deck overlooking the fishing boats. For to-go, you order in their seafood store and they call your number out back when the food is ready. To-go dishes are reasonably priced and ordering and pick up was easy and efficient. Food was tasty and reasonably priced. We tried the clam strips platter with a baked potato which was great. The lobster salad sandwich was tasty with fries but beware, we found a few small shell pieces in the sandwich. We ordered a pitcher of Cape May IPA at the outdoor raw bar and enjoyed outdoor dining overlooking the fishing fleet. Great lunch, cold beer, and a nice atmosphere. Can't go wrong with this arrangement for a casual seafood lunch. read more

The Lobster House - Dockside views - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Over the years I've had my share of great getaway meals at The Lobster House in timeless Cape May. It's a tradition you want to start earlier in life, so you can one day look around and watch as a new generation starts creating those lifelong memories of lively dinners out on the peer. It gives you a whole new appreciation for it, for how it's been able to not only last and stay pretty much the same across decades, making the nostalgia hit just a bit harder. People who have aversion to crowds probably read that and think I'm insane, and I wouldn't blame you. I can't think of a time when that place isn't a mad house. It's frantic, there are multiple queues all over the place, people are shouting, fish is flying, tables are being sniped. There's always some parent yelling at their kid or in-law to get over to some table 100 yards away they just happened to see open up. You have half a dozen poor grandmas sitting at a table all alone, feeling the pressure. The pressure and eyes of every other family waiting for a table bearing down on them. So yes, for certain people, every visit would be a nightmarish hell. Like think about the introverted pescatarians, they must be completely torn on this place. Even with the prominent signage, it's easy to get disoriented in the market-style layout. One time I waited 15 minutes for a softshell crab sandwich in front of a parking validation kiosk. Just remember there are two sets of bathrooms, one near the entrance and one lesser used one in the back. That is one benefit of sitting farther down the pier and not feeling bad about it. There is no such thing as a bad seat at TLH. Eventually once I did locate my softshell crab sandwich, I enjoyed it's soft, crab-like texture. Well, enjoyed is a strong word. Let's just say that will be my first and definitely last time I ever order softshell crab. I like crab, but, while soft, I do not enjoy the texture of the shell. It's like these thin sheets of leather strips. It's probably my fault, it's not like it's called "no shell" crab, but I think maybe they overdo it with the "soft" angle. Anyways, once I pivoted to a classic burger, all was well again. And I got more of those bangin' thick-cut steak fries. On this particular visit my two companions got an assortment of crab claws, fried calamari, clams casino, and the rest of my softshell crab, so yeah, everyone did pretty well for themselves. Also snagged a prime table right in the thick of things, on the pier in front of The Schooner, which doubles as a sailing vessel and outdoor cocktail lounge. Just another fine summer memory to look back fondly on. read more

See all

We had such a nice dinner, I had to update my review. We come to Lobster House from time-to-time throughout the year. We figured we would get in an off-season dinner before the crowds come and that we did! We arrived just before they opened at 415 and hung out at the bar for a few minutes. Dinner is served at 430pm! The bar is open, so you can get drinks while you wait if you like. There is a full service bar and you can order from a plentiful wine and spirits menu. Our awesome server for our early dinner was Trisha, and she could not have been more hospitable! She was very personable, attentive and provided excellent service! She was just a delight. I ordered the Flounder special which was delicious - - each element in the dinner was great - and you can see all my coordinating photos. The dinner comes with a nice fresh -chilled salad and of course, the yummy hot, fresh onion bread! The flounder was cooked to perfection and those Fried String Beans, kinda like french fries were really good and very creative. They came with a nice "Petal Sauce" that is going to have me coming back again! Thank you, Trisha and Lobster House for a great pre-season dinner. It's nice to have the whole restaurant to yourself without the crowds! Get there before Memorial Day weekend for a nice treat! There's also an incredible fresh fish market attached where you can get anything and everything from a fish market you ever dreamed about. They also have a decadent area with so many drool-worthy desserts that you can take out along with your seafood. All in all, Lobster House is a great local favorite that has consistently great seafood and service. read more

See all

We felt the food at The Lobster House in Cape May, NJ was a very good value and the service we received was very good. We would have had to pay at least 30% more for the same meal back home in Metro Atlanta, GA. We went at 5:30 pm on a Saturday and we were number 57 on the waiting list. We were seated in about 45 minutes. My wife and I each started with an escargot appetizer. I also had a bowl of snapper soup with Sherry. This was followed with a 3 lb steamed lobster. My wife had the Lobster House special which is linguine with lobster tail, scallops, and shrimp. Each entree comes with a salad and at least 1 side. I had a baked potato and stewed tomatos. My wife had a zucchini blend. We both had a diet coke for our beverage plus water. I would definitely go back. read more

See all

Food was just okay. The ambiance was really great loved the history and the historic photos but food was just fair. Had a crab cake that was definitely premade from somewhere else, likely frozen and had a lot of breading. read more

I have dined at the LH hundreds of times with memories of my family The Lobster House never disappoints The fish market has the freshest and widest selection of succulent seafood to take home The take out where you can dine dockside is Cape Mays best kept secret and the prices are incredibly reasonable Julie our back clearing the tables is friendly hard working and a true asset to your Restaurant Do yourself a favor and next time in Cape go directly to the LH and enjoy the best scallops crabs fish this side of the Mississippi read more

See all

The spice is old-school and has been here a very long time. There is a ton of parking, and the restaurant has an incredible view. I might come back just for the views and the feel of the place. Take a moment to walk around and look at all the old pictures to see the history and the massive boats outside of the lobster house. This place is enormous, so I doubt there is ever a wait, but if so, the staff is friendly and helpful. We were here for lunch and began with six salt-bay oysters, which were tasty. We kept looking for a lobster roll, but they only had lobster salad, so we got that because I was here for a lobster roll. Lobster salad was OK, but, as expected, there was too much other stuff and not enough lobster. I should've looked before we picked this place, but I just assumed that they would have the regular lobster roll. I got French fries and a side of their creamy Caesar because I like to dip my fries. read more

See all

Emma the bartender on the schooner was having fun with the patrons and not attending the bar very well. She should spend more time addressing ALL patrons rather than giving service to the few. On a positive note, the hamburger and other food was good. Also, have to assume dogs are allowed on the boat with diners and also in the raw bar. Don't know the house policy. More importantly, why no barrier to keep out the sea gulls from eating at the tables. A few things to consider if this place is your choice for a meal. And don't forget to tip the restroom valets. read more

The Lobster House - Doesn't need words. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Looking at the reviews, saw there is much confusion regarding the different dining options with some inaccurate naming of dining options with the reviews, so wanted to clarify. There are 5 distinct areas here to obtain food, some are eat-in, some take-out: 1. The Dining Room: eat in, also bar area. Most formal, lunch and dinner. Priciest 2. Fish Market and Take Out Shop: Can order raw fish items and take home salads from fish market area or go to the take out section for cooked platters to take home or can eat out on the dock (no service, tables first - come basis). Lunch and dinner. More affordable menu 3. Coffee shop: small counter diner for breakfast, lunch or dinner. limited seating, more affordable menu. Can also order take out or to eat there from the dining room menu, but will pay full price for the dining room menu. 4. Schooner: bar and lunch and dinner option on a boat. More limited menu than dining room. Bar type setting 5. Raw Bar: Separate seated dining area out near the dock for lunch and dinner. Despite name can order cooked meals, as well, such as burgers, etc. More affordable menu than dining room and informal. Hope this helps clarify. All are delicious, just need to decide what type food and setting you would like to eat in. All are pretty much busy year round, so be prepared to wait, but worth the wait!. read more

The Lobster House used to be a solid choice but recently the food was inedible. The soft shell crab and other dishes were fishy and hard to eat. The service has remained consistent and the views are great but the food is disappointing. I hope they turn around because it was a great Cape May eatery! read more

See all

We've been coming here for well over 30 years and the food has been consistently good the whole time. We do take out and eat in the back, which is much better than the fancy dining in my opinion It's such a nice relaxing summer night to sit on the back door enjoying your seafood meal watching boats come and go. The prices are reasonable, considering how expensive everywhere else is these days. They have not jacked their prices up like most other restaurants have lately. The crab bisque soup from the raw bars to die for. It doesn't matter how hot it is in the summertime, I will always get a cup of soup to start my meal. They sell quarts of it to go in the takeout section of the seafood area. The broiled salmon is always cooked to perfection. Tender and juicy meat with a great flavor. The lobster is always very tender and juicy as well. The scallops were buttery melt in your mouth. Pretty good selection of beer, wine, and other alcohol. read more

See all

As you can see from my last review I have been here many times before for lunch, when we lived in Bergen County. Cape May was a popular town to visit when we lived in Bergen County. We always enjoyed our lunches here. We were on our way back from Bergen County to the Cape May car ferry to Lewes Delaware so we both stopped here for a light early dinner before driving to the ferry. This restaurant is not too far from the ferry. We were seated at a nice table on the window overlooking Schellenger's creek. Most of the tables on the window were occupied. We were lucky to score a table on the window. I enjoyed my bottle of Yuengling beer for $5.50. I also enjoyed my bowl of lobster bisque for $14.95. See my pics. Lisa served us very well. My total bill was $51, excluding gratuity. After we ate we drove to the ferry in time. We will do this again. read more

See all

Our yearly visit. This year was a step up from last year. One broiled seafood combo, one crab cake sandwich. It took forever to order in the fish market but not any fault of employees. For the life of me I don't understand some people. You've literally waited 20 minutes to order but you wait until your number is called to look at the menu. We finally order and find a table on deck. 15 minutes later our number is called. Our food was amazing this year. My stuffed clam was outrageous. Baked potato perfect. Scallops and shrimp large and sweet. Fish cooked nicely and mild. The best part, our meals combined was the same price as our dinner the night before in Wildwood for one of us and it was better. Words of advice. Eat from the Styrofoam container and sit outside. It will be half cost of the restaurant, you just get a loaf of their bread. $42 for two and atmosphere is better. Just watch out for the seagulls. read more

See all

My wife has come here all her life so she was super excited to take me here. I loved it. You come up and just grab a table. Then you go and order from the grill or the raw bar. They call your number and you get your paper plate. I got shrimp cocktail. It was shrimp on a plate in ice. They were delicious. My wife got us a grilled chicken sandwich to share. It was huge. Packed with veggies and cheese. The bread was large. She also got crab cocktail. I tried some of that too. It was so nice to sit outside and watch the water while we ate. This place should be a staple of anyone's vacation in Cape May. read more

The Lobster House - Grilled chicken and veggie sandwich - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Tonight was an off night. The fried scallops were small and chewy, muscles were large and tasted to fishy. Shrimp with crab meat was tasteless. I usually don't complain. The place is still beautiful, service was pleasant. Maybe it will improve after summer. I'll try again. read more

Came in tonight for a special night. I've been here plenty of times and this place never disappoints. The inside is large and decked out all in Nautical stuff! Our server ,Zack , was amazing and the food plentiful and delicious. As desert was served I proposed to my girlfriend and she said yes. All in all a magical night with Great food read more

See all

Glory days are long gone. Are there new managers or owners. They screwed up our last 2 orders, it's smaller than a happy meal and the chowder today was literally watery and cold. Like they defrosted from a can. Sad to see it go down. We were surprised it was slow for a Friday dinner holiday weekend too. read more

The Lobster House - Boiled Seafood Combo - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

We stopped in during peak dinner time on a Saturday and got seated right away. The place was nearly full, probably packed with tourists like us. It was a bit loud, but the old school ambiance made it feel cozy with a delicious bread and butter to start. No beer on draft, so I went with a whiskey straight, while my wife opted for a non-alcoholic beer. We ordered a steamed lobster and got to cracking The lobster was good, and if you're in town, you won't be disappointed. It's got that old-time vibe, which is great if that's your thing. read more

See all

We love it here!! They have a quicker outdoor to go area and the formal dining. Amazing seafood options for decent prices. We went 30 min after opening and did have to wait over an hour for a table. Luckily you can pop over to the boat for a drink and apps while you wait. The Lobster House Speciality and Scallops were AMAZINGGGGG! Our group didn't love the chicken or the sauce of the stuffed flounder. You get a lot of food with every meal (bread, potato, salad, and veggie). read more

See all

Been here many times, it's one of those places to eat at at least a few times if in Cape May regularly. Consistent quality, great view.

I had dinner at Cape May Lobster House and thoroughly enjoyed my twin lobster dinner. However, when it came time for dessert, the server failed to clear and / or clean my table, making it impossible to properly enjoy my dessert entrée. This lack of attentiveness and service was disappointing, especially considering how wonderful everything had been up to that point. While Cape May Lobster House isn't a five-star or Michelin-star restaurant, at its high price point, diners should still expect a level of service that reflects respect and professionalism. Unfortunately, that expectation wasn't met during my visit. atmosphere is old and dating. read more

The Lobster House - My Tab... - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

I decided to stop in at the lobster house on a trip to see a friend play music in Cape May. I can say that the server was good and atmosphere was very nice, being right on the water. I ordered the Fisherman's Wharf Platter and clam chowder. I can honestly say that all the seafood on the platter was unseasoned and very bland. It was difficult to finish. The dish had shrimp, scallops, crab cake, flounder, and clam casino. The chowder was ok, but I can say that I wouldn't visit this place again, as they missed on top many areas. read more

Five stars for excellent service! Rita is fantastic--she is professional, attentive, and does her job exceptionally well. Her warm and welcoming personality makes you feel right at home. It's great service like hers that makes you want to keep coming back. read more

Overall the food was good, however the oyster stew was terrible, so salty I couldn't finish it, never again.

I went to the Lobster House for a luncheon and since it was toward the back in a private room I really got to see how big this place real is! The layout was beautifully spaced and overlooked the docks. The wait staff was fast and courteous. We had a 3 course meal with table bread that was to die for! The soups were pretty good but there was some confusion about the snapper soup. Some thought snapper (fish) others thought turtle. It was turtle- for warning! The chicken dish and broiled flounder were flavorful and a decent size portion. Overall it was a great event and the staff went above and beyond! I wasn't overly impressed with the food besides the bread! read more

The Lobster House - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

There is no better place to have seafood n drinks. $8 jack n cokes and 2lb lobster first for $55 you will not get better. All there seafood dishes are as fresh as it comes. Bring your cooler n ice and you can bring any seafood they have from there fish market read more

Fried seafood, fried potatoes can never be bad unless its over fried or way too much breading. It was perfect. The price just made it better. The soups on the other hand was not worth it, even for the cheap price. I could've gotten very unlucky and the person that scooped just wasnt feeling it or something. The clam chowder got a total of 3 pieces of clam and the snapper had just a couple of strains in it. Flavor of the soup was good, so you can tell they are not cheap about it, but it felt like was just given the top of the soup with no substance. read more

The Lobster House - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Definitely a Cape May landmark. You have a few options as they have the Dining Room which has a full menu. The coffee shop with counter seating and smaller menu. The outside deck which has seafood appetizers and raw bar with tables, self serve. Always a busy place. They don't accept reservation. Huge parking lot. read more

The Lobster House - Sautés soft shell crab - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

If you're into cold french fries served in a styrofoam tray then consider The Lobster House for all your fried fish needs. I hate to write three start reviews, The Lobster House was actually a hoppin' spot. The dining restaurant was packed with a 30 minute wait so we decided to order take out and sit outside. I grabbed a cold beer on tap while sitting by the dock of the bay. Lots of picnic tables with umbrellas, folks had their dogs on leashes, its a real casual, local spot. I'm not going to judge, if you like hanging here then bully for you. I must point out, there are a lot of aggressive birds. I had to shoo away a few of them when they were slowly making their way towards my fried delights. Look at my picture, lots of french fries and a few pieces of shrimp and fish. My platter came with pre made tartar sauce and cocktail sauce. Like I said earlier, there were more cold french fries than fish. 3 stars is the best I can give, it was just an average experience. read more

The Lobster House - Beer - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Shrinkflation at the shore. My wife and I have been going to the Lobster house for many years. She always gets the shrimp salad sandwich. It had pretty big shrimp and was so big she often took half home. We went this past Thursday and not only were the shrimp much smaller, there was much less, barely covering the bottom of the roll. I got a spinach salad with about half a hard egg, a bit of bacon crumbles, mushrooms spinach with a large bowl of sweet sauce that could have covered a bunch of salads. read more

The food was bland, clams were chewy, steak was overcooked and burnt, the lobster and filet mignon were bland and had zero flavor, the New York strip was overcooked and bland, and the shrimp Parmesan lobster was incredibly bland, greasy, and had zero flavor, store bought sauce would have been better. read more

The lobby smells, they don't enforce the dress code, food bland and WAY over priced. Lobster bisque was horrible. They don't know how to make a lemon drop martini lime garnish. Stuffed shrimp dry and all filler. Bring a cushion for the chair because they are very uncomfortable. Wait staff have way to many tables took a long time to get our whole order. DO NOT RECOMMEND read more

This place is huge and a local staple for a reason! They do not take reservations so we put our names down and waited roughly an hour. The ambiance inside is cozy, warm, and feels nautical. Warm loaves of onion bread (tastes like EBTB seasoning to me) and softened butter were set in front of us very quickly upon seating. I started with the clam chowder which was perfectly seasoned, rich, and had an abundance of clams. The lobster pasta house specialty is a must try. The seafood is generous and cooked perfectly. It comes with a veg and carb side too which makes for a filling meal. read more

The Lobster House - Seafood Markets Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey