What a surprise. I knew it'd be good, but was not prepared for HOW good it was…read more Casual, laidback ambience. Easygoing, friendly, attentive staff. Incredible food that I'm Gibbs dream about for a few more nights yet. I had the walleye, my fiancée had the pot pie (called something else on the menu; I forget exactly what). She only didn't finish hers because she eats like a bird, but I finished hers even after I'd inhaled mine. I came even describe the flavors (except to say the horseradish mixed in the potato top of the pot pie is inspired!) I will just say that each bite hit the sweet, savory, and salty notes just right all at the same time. Can't forget to mention: the service was lovely. Our server was very kind, personable, and relaxed, and she offered us great recommendations, and boy am I glad I listened. I can't recommend this place enough. I hear the James Beard nominations may be snooping around, and they'd be right to.

I love a visit to Pennyroyal when I am home visiting my parents in Saugatuck. The food always…read moretastes fresh and well made. The service is typically very friendly and the vibe is always cute for a Sunday morning. I recommend coming ready for a wait, but grab a coffee and enjoy the sun while you do.

The question isn't whether to eat here, the question is how many times you will eat here (you'll…read morewant to a lot). Get the chicken biscuit with the honey butter. Nice views and friendly wait staff. Something really special

Lovely gem down by the river! This place has a fantastic vibe and happy atmosphere. We had the…read moremac and cheese and the fried chicken. The mac and cheese was really delicious, but the fried chicken was the real standout. It was perfectly crispy and juicy without being overly fatty. The service was also good and attentive.

We had brunch here over the weekend, and it was absolutely amazing! The food was delicious, the…read moreatmosphere was fun and inviting, and the whole vibe made it such a great experience. Everything from the service to the ambiance was spot on. If you're ever in the Douglas, Michigan area, this place is definitely worth checking out. We can't wait to come back!

This place and the staff were a relaxed, hippy chic vibe - bright and cheerful. My eggs were cooked…read moreperfectly to order and the hash brown patties were like McDonald's but with more flavor and less grease. The sourdough toast was crispy and chewy, as you'd hope. The coffee was very good as well.

There are coffee shops that serve great coffee... and then there are coffee shops that make you…read moreinstantly feel something. The second I walked into Uncommon Coffee Roasters, I was hit with the smell of fresh bread. It immediately took me back to my grandma's kitchen. She used to bake a loaf of bread just for me--with no nuts, because she knew that's how I liked it. Walking into her house, I always knew exactly what she was making. It's funny how a smell can transport you somewhere in an instant. Then I looked over at the bakery case. Mistake. Everything looked fresh, homemade, and absolutely beautiful. We had plans to spend the rest of the day walking around Saugatuck, so I talked myself out of buying a loaf... and regretted that decision before we were even back out the door. Despite the line stretching from the counter almost to the entrance, the staff handled it like absolute pros. Everyone behind the counter seemed completely in sync, moving quickly without making the experience feel rushed. Watching them work was almost entertaining in itself. The shop has a colorful, artsy personality that fits Saugatuck perfectly. It feels modern without losing that cozy small-town charm. Between the artwork, the cheerful cups (seriously... how cute are they?), and people scattered throughout reading, chatting, working on laptops, or simply enjoying their coffee, it felt like the kind of place you naturally want to linger. As for the coffee... We ordered three different drinks and somehow all landed on winners. My Don't Be Salty cold brew (cold brew with caramel and salted caramel cold foam) was phenomenal. Another in our group ordered the Caramel Silk latte, and judging by the smile after the first sip, I'd call that a success too. I honestly couldn't tell you what our third friend ordered... only that all three of us agreed we'd happily order our drinks again. Some coffee shops are just a quick caffeine stop. Uncommon Coffee Roasters feels like part of the Saugatuck experience. We'll absolutely be back... and next time, I'm buying the bread,

Amazing coffee and friendly staff. They bake their own stuff. Good coffee and all the other good…read morestuff too

Solid breakfast spot. Everything hit the mark. Service was pleasant and prompt, coffee was hot &…read morerefilled often, and the food was great. We especially loved the potatoes and the extensive jelly selection at the table.

Got right in seated at the counter. The waitress was very nice. The coffee was good, especially for…read morecafe coffee. I felt like there may have been a hint of chicory in it. It wasn't as watered down as most cafe coffees. The Denver scramble was a bit lackluster. It was big but a bit watery and bland. The potatoes are very strange. Greasy and most were more like potatoes chips - hard. Overall, food was just ok.

Food excellent, Alyssa server excellent! Way better than 3.2 stars!…read more Steak frites w truffle fries, very good 8oz filet w mashed Yukons- sooo good Shrimp scampi - very good White chicken chili could use more beans and chicken chunks but very good flavor. Live musics on Friday that wasn't overbearing so we couldn't talk.

Try the Bluegill. Loved it! Very light and zero fishy taste. My wife had the fillet. Excellent!…read moreSeriously. Go for the food! Oh, and the staff is fantastic as well.

Positives: Food was good quality and fresh, vibes and decor/furniture super cute…read more Negatives: super long wait time for food, it look 40 minutes for 4 Deli Sandwiches to be delivered. We did come on a Sunday for lunch so I'm sure their high demand time. Then when we got our order it was missing one of the sandwiches, so that took another 7 minutes to get. I also had to check on my order as I saw others getting theirs before ours. Bathrooms ran out of soap and paper towels. The process for getting your food was a bit confusing as there wasn't any order numbers so you couldn't tell how many other orders were in front of yours. Would only come back if I had plenty of time to wait for food.

I am in love with this place - it is our go to for lunch or an early dinner after the beach. They…read morehave a good kids menu - my son loved his PB&J sandwich and they had options for my other son with lots of food allergies. Their chicken salad croissant is the perfect sandwich. The service is super friendly and helpful, I really appreciate the employee who brought us waters outside. The vibe is chill and cute, with indoor and outdoor seating.