Very quiet and low traffic place to enjoy a lunch or dinner. Service is very friendly and fast to notice you. As for food, I loved the garlic bread, never had with tomato sauce and raw minced garlic on top. It was good and more mellow in punch compared to garlic butter. Chicken soup was good, the noodles were very al Dante, but way more celery and carrots than chicken. Jamaican beef patty was good, nothing dissimilar to what you get elsewhere. The zuppa di pecse , the penne I got with was good, very al Dante. Plenty of mussels and clam, all cooked great, but man only like three shrimp which was a letdown. But credit to them they butterflied shrimp and cooked so it was tender but not rubbery. The sauce was flavorful but wish it could thicken since it was watery. Credit to them for having cheap lunch specials if don't want dinner portions on their menu. read more

See all

Let's begin shall we? April 17th I ordered a cranberry walnut salad and seltzer with delivery off the slice app. Salad arrives with no salad dressing or cranberries. I call and they say they can't do anything and if I can drive in to pick up the dressing and cranberries. So I say to myself ok "small business" it's a mistake don't worry I'll give them another shot. I was wrong. April 19th today I ordered a pasta dish. 2 seltzers, rice ball & a cranberry walnut salad. Again the salad has no dressing, the seltzers are missing and no rice ball. I call again now a-little more angry than last time. Request a refund. They tell me they can't do anything. To call the app and ask for a refund. I call the app to request a refund for the salad that has no dressing for a second time. And they only refund me for the missing dressing? Where they said they will give me a refund for the salad. Who eats salad without dressing? I do not recommend this place. I only recommend if you like eating dry salad without dressing. read more

Siena's Torteria Pizzeria - Dry ass salad without dressing - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

So it's my family's last night in NY and agreeably we waited a bit too long to decide we wanted dinner on a Sunday night in Pine Bush. After driving along their main strip, we weren't able to find anything open. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw a shiny neon light and decided to investigate. To our delight the place was open for another thirty minutes so we hopped out the car and made our way in. I immediately noticed how clean the establishment was when we walked in, and that there were no customers inside. Normally this would bother me just a smidge because it was obvious no one had been there for a while. However the employees were so friendly that we sat at the booth near the door and looked over the menus. I ordered the cheeseburger (no bun) and broccoli. My cousin ordered a slice of za and cheesecake to share. She thoroughly enjoyed her za! The burger would've been great with more seasoning but the broccoli made up for it! Very impressed with the seasoning - which included fresh garlic- that was added into the pan. The cheesecake was really great too - especially for the price! Very reasonable for everything we ordered. If I am ever in the area again, I would definitely stop by for some late night cheap eats. read more

Siena's Torteria Pizzeria - a piece of pie with whipped cream and chocolate sauce - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

See all

What a disgrace. Ordered a plain cheese pie, a jamaican beef patty and 2 cannoli's. Paid to have it delivered. The food arrived and was left on the front porch. The pizza was ice cold, it's 30 degrees outside and you just leave the pizza on the porch!?! Moving on to the beef patty, we all know these are pre-made, frozen, and pre-packaged, but this was definately old, freezer burned, and rock hard. Even my dog wouldn't eat it. Lastly, I should have known not to order the cannoli. It you can't reheat pre-packaged food, how would you know how to make an Italian dessert. Lesson Learned! read more

Very good pizza/Italian restaurant Our service was good, the food was good, solid Italian and reasonably priced. The restaurant is a little dark and the decor is dated. Pine Bush, NY is a small town with not a ton of restaurants, so Siena's is a pretty good option. read more

Had my sisters baby shower catered by Siena's, and everyone enjoyed the food. Still picking at it 2 days later!

Very good pizza here! The texture was good, I'd definitely love to come back. Genuine little place!

My business friend referred me to service this store,outstanding,perfectly kleen kitchen you could eat off the floor Blows away competition product Thanks guys see you soon read more

Nice option for Pizza locally. They don't know exactly how to makeup face pizza right now, Margarita( comes Out all juicey), But I appreciate that they try. Service is good. Polite and helpful. They are quick too, maybe 15 minutes to prepare pizza. So a nice option for something close to Pine Bush. read more

Visiting NY from Kansas, and found this place near our hotel, so decided to check it out. Very good! We had pizza slices, all-meat Stromboli, chicken Stromboli, garlic bread- yuuuuuummmm. Everything was delicious!! We went the next day and tried different pasta. OMGG!!! I had the spinach ravioli! WOW! My son had rigatoni alfredo- DELISH! And the hubby had seafood pasta- YUM!! Really nice people, and while we were there eating, customers came and went picking up to-go orders: so it seems the locals really enjoy it too! read more

See all

Have to leave this update - it appears there are new owners. Their prices seem to have gotten a bit higher, and the pizza just wasn't the same. Still good...but somethings obviously different (not in a good way). I can't honor my original 5 star review anymore. Thanks for looking. read more

I order from there often and I am never disappointed. Great alfredo sauce. Great pizza

Siena's catered our Christmas party this year. The food was amazing and plentiful (which has also been my experience when dining in the restaurant as well)! Staff was informative and genuinely seemed to want to make sure we had everything we needed. We would highly recommend and would definitely use them again. read more

I like this restaurant on a variety of levels. Friendly staff who seem to want to please. I get take out only due to the pandemic. My favorite is Chicken Cacciatore. Excellent sauce with a good mix of onions, peppers, and tender chicken. Sufficient portion. They make an outstanding tossed salad. Fresh ingredients, with a really nice mix of all the right stuff for a salad. Everything I have had here is above average. A convenient little place with much to offer. Overall grade B+. read more

Siena's changed hands in the past few months. New owners are awful, and so is what they've done with the place. Barely ever see anyone inside. Cook handles money and then fixes food without washing his hands- Disgusting. Tried pizza, was bland and undercooked. Also tried garlic knots- never had garlic knots be stale, greasy, and sour before. All at once, no less. Items are very pricy on top of all of this. Give it a miss if you value your tastebuds, wallet, and intestinal health. read more

The food is typical pizzeria style. No beer or wine. Dining area is clean. Not many people here for a Saturday nite. Nothing out of the ordinary to expect here. read more

This is my go to place for pizza! It's the best pizza in Orange County that I've gone to. I order take out here quite often. The prices at average and the food is great! I would definitely recommend coming to this restaurant. read more

I don't know what happened to Sienna's. We were getting pizza there every Friday and it was always quite good. Recently on two separate occasions the pizza was horrible. I hope they fix the problem, but I will not be buying pizza from them again. read more

Okay restaurant - typical small town pizzeria. Waitress and cook(s) carried on an extensive conversation that was too loud. Wish waitress would have spent as much time with customers as talking with other staff. Not appropriate. Not interested in hearing how one if the staff understands English better than she lets on, or how they watch the cameras. Better pizza places in town. read more

My son and I walked in from next door after his dental appointment .. the counter had a variety of pizzas and the most delicious looking garlic knots.. we got a box sampler to go and omg we will be back .. read more

worst ever! december 2019-2x used their delivery through slice app, both times got food almost 2 hours later, told them the second time when almost 2 hours to cancel & slice app wont refund nor sienas!!!!!! only raining & they lied to slice app roads were bad. my daughter drive & got pizza another place right down the road instead! First time the delivery guy said sorry when he picked up the food to deliver it was already cold. *husband saw a man waiting forever to pick up his pizza who was told it wasn't ready; it was on top of the oven for almost 20 minutes! my husband saw & realized it and told the customer! they ripped us off, top 5 worst ever in my life & we will tell the tons of people we know in the area what a scam slice app is & what a lowly establishment this place is. Complain again next day to Slice & got refund read more

Best pizza in Pine Bush. Excellent paninis and cheese steaks. Best calzone I've ever had. Delivery is quick and consistent.

This place probably makes The best calzones in Pinebush! Pizza is OK but you must try their calzones!

White pizza was very good, and a hearty amount of ricotta cheese. Delivery was prompt and courteous. Would definitely recommend

I only bother to write reviews if the product is great or terrible. In this case it is the latter. Pizza was too big for the box so they folded the outer crust in toward the center. The crust under the pizza was doughy, gross. Honestly, the only somewhat edible part was the outer crust. read more

This pizzeria opened in place of Antonio's Pizzeria with in the past year. I decided to try them out on November 9, 2015 and to my displeasure I found staff to be less than or at least not so friendly. Paying attention to the customer and being warm and welcoming is important to me but non-existent here. I ordered a slice of pizza, which was not burnt by the ovens like the previous owners pizza occasionally were but that is as far as I can go with the pizza. I also ordered the pasta fagioli, which was satisfactory for a run of the mill pizza house. To be honest Pudgy's down the street is better but making a trip to Franco's Brick oven in Walden is even more worth the trip for the pasta fagioli. Last, I ordered the Penne Vodka and this was the greatest let down aside from the small side salad that came with it. The sauce was basically a marinara with some seasoning and a little cheese but no hint of vodka or cream. Not worth the trip and definitely worth a formal refund not just for the food but for my effort ordering. read more

Pretty good. Better tasting than other local places I've tried. Pizza and calazon are good.

The best pizza I have ever had! I definitely recommend the Chicken Alfredo pizza. It was also a very nice restaurant that played nice music. I will definitely want to visit again in the near future. read more