The food is fantastic. We came here once last year and have been waiting to return. I ordered off-menu, seared scallops and my husband got the clam strips. This place has a very authentic NJ feel and the food quality you'd expect in our area. If you eat here, you'll be glad you did. read more

After reading the reviews, we wanted to give this place a try for dinner. The place is small and very minimally decorated, with the restaurant being comprised of plain white walls and 3 gray tables that seat up to 4 people. There is also a 2-seat table near the back as well. A mounted TV sits above the middle table and right below it is a small wooden panel that has the shape of a mermaid carved into it. The ordering counter is off to the side and has an adjoining display case that holds soda cans, condiments, bottled water, and a couple of bags of lettuce. We ordered the following: Crab cake platter. These were 2 jumbo lump crab cakes and the order came with fries. Daughter ate almost all of the fries. I had to fight her for it. LOL. This order was delicious and freshly made. Tuna tataki, which is seared rare tuna with pepper crust, ginger and soy sauce. Daughter liked this a lot. This was a nice presentation which made us wonder if the chef worked at a 5 star dining restaurant instead of a shack. Surprise, surprise! A lot better than we expected. Pint of New England clam chowder, which has clams, bacon and potatoes. Daughter loved it and thought it was delicious. Hubs said that he usually prefers the Manhattan clam chowder but he loved this a lot. He loved that he was able to munch on clams at every spoonful and that it wasn't too thick for him. Manhattan clam chowder wasn't available when we were there. Hopefully, they'll have it the next time we return. Sirens House Salad, which has spring mix, tomatoes, bell peppers, red onions, carrots, parmesan and croutons. The dressing was homemade balsamic vinaigrette. We thought this was pretty good and I was obsessed with the croutons. They tasted fresh and crunchy. I liked everything about this place. Everything tasted freshly made. Service was friendly and quick. Will definitely return to try other items on the menu! read more

I always try to patronize the local mom and pop shops. But I have to say my order was a little subpar. Ordered fish and chips and it was more like fish sticks and crappy fries. I was very disappointed. Maybe they were having a bad day. It happens in business. Being a local business owner myself, I understand and I will give them another try. read more

I had the fisherman's platter ,it was the best I've ever had,from the clams to the coleslaw everything was awesome plus nice people working there, great food ,great people what else can you ask for. read more

We ate at the Sirens seafood tonight. The staff was wonderful, service very prompt and the food was fresh. We sampled tuna takaki, the clam strips,the tuna tacos and fried calamari. They offer different sauces including a spicy remoulade and a lemon aioli both delicious! The fish was fried perfectly, breading was light and not greasy. The atmosphere is casual. You can sit at a table and BYOB. Looking forward to warm Weather to be able to sit outside! Highly recommend this place for fresh fried seafood. read more

The local buzz about Sirens is it's awesome and the buzz was spot on! First off this is a fun spot. The former pizza/BBQ/ mini golf spot on 36 has always delivered great food and a place to putt. I popped in around 3 for a late lunch and they were all there doing a bunch of maintenance. The happily and efficiently served me. The gentleman at the counter gave me the rundown on their po boy sandwiches. At this time I wanted to go light so I had the flounder sandwich. It was huge!!! 3 filets on a ginormous brioche bun with lettuce and tomato plus their delicious tartar sauce. It was a lot bigger than I expected and the portion of fries they give you is astounding. So glad we have Sirens so close to my home. Il be back. read more

See all

So happy this place is back after the terrible fire they had. The best New England Clam Chowder I've had in NJ. More brothy than heavy cream like most, good mouthfeel, great flavor and perfectly tender clams. The sandwiches are delicious and prepared with great tasting batter and sauces. Everything is jumping out of the ocean fresh. Highly recommend! read more

Food tasted decent but a $20 shrimp po boy only had 4 shrimp on it. Tails were still on shrimp as well. Don't want tails on shrimp when it's on a sandwich. read more

Love the cod and flounder sandwiches, definitely recommend. Plan to work my way through the menu

Very good seafood for sit down or takeout. Fun summer vibe, indoor cafe seating and an enclosed porch with picnic table seating. Fast service, permenant menu and daily specials with a surprising variety and top quality fresh seafood. The owners are friendly; the portions are generous and prices are fair. Or even has an outdoor play area where n the warmer weather. We really enjoyed eating here and we're looking forward to the next time. read more

See all

Sirens is a little hole-in-the-wall hidden gem. Reminds me of a place I use to go to in belmar as a child (zelbies). The food is so good. Tonight I had the blackened scallops and shrimp over rice with asparagus. My husband had the Mahi tacos. Everything was delicious. They also have the best coleslaw! They now sell fresh fish too! read more

Sirens Seafood - Shrimp and scallops over rice - Seafood Near Me - Middletown Township, New Jersey

Loved the crab cake. Seasoned creatively. Counter Service good. limited fresh fish choice but local fish avail. Has a mini golf set up outdoors ! read more

I love that it's a slightly different fry/batter on each type of seafood. The fish was amazing. Clam strips were top-notch. Highly recommend this place if you like fried seafood. read more

Was referred here by Captain Frank of Fins on Feathers. He said "I'm picky about my seafood and this place has the best crabcake sandwich I've had in a long time." Well three orders placed, three 10 out of 10! Crabcake was made to order, fresh, 90% crabmeat (not breadcrumbs or fillers). I ordered the blackened mahi mahi taco special. Wow! The nice sized tacos with plenty of fresh mahi, perfect hint of lime and not over sauced. Do yourself a favor and stop in but don't be fooled by the low key building. The chef/owner just opened in December 2023 and they are still settling in. Enjoy! read more

I went here with my friend who is in a wheelchair and there is handicap parking and they accommodated her wheelchair very well inside although there is limited seating inside there is plenty of seating outside and it will be great in summer. The outside seating is a covered area so even if it's a rainy day if it's a warm day, it will be fine. my friend loves scallops, but cannot eat fried food and I asked them to accommodate her with sautéed instead of fried and they did so great results they were seasoned and perfect also to accommodate her special needs they prepared a beautiful salad as she could not eat the rice and asparagus that was offered with the platter my other friend and I had the fish and chips small portions but very good served with coleslaw and your choice of sauce tartar sauce or cocktail sauce prices are competitive I can't complain for three people. It was $65 so that'll give you an idea. I'll be back in summer when they have miniature golfing in the back, I love that. Hope they do well. read more

Stopped in for lunch at this family-run place and regaled myself with the pan-seared scallops served with rice medley and blackened asparagus. Presentation of dish was classy, scallops were local fresh and buttery soft, sides were perfect complement. My partner chose the crab cake sandwich - a family recipe - delicious and yummy, not too sweet, cole slaw. We sat inside but there are picnic tables outside and even a miniature golf out back that they inherited with the place. Chef/owners were welcoming, really wanted to know what we thought. This place will be our regular stop when headed to the beach! read more