I enjoyed my meal at the Navesink Fishery The clams casino were excellent The crabcakes were outstanding Service was solid Lovely dining room in the back of the fish store The fish is fresh I would stick with traditional meals and steer away from fancier sauces I will definitely get the broiled or fried fish platter next time. read more

You can't go wrong having dinner here. The food is delicious plus it's BYOB. I hope it never changes. It's one of my favorite places for seafood. read more

A hidden restaurant that is nestled between a Goodwill and Liquor store was not on my radar until a friend invited me to dinner. The food was fresh and gave me old school nostalgia vibes. The little fish store in the front also had baskets of vegetables for sale. I will probably swing back to pick up fish to bring home and cook. The place was definitely family run and not that busy on a Sunday evening. Total of 3 tables. The service was pleasant and the ambiance gave Midwest or old fashioned Florida boonies. The basket of bread was perfect. The Chilean sea bass with a tomato oyster sauce was good, sided with a baked potato and squash. The fried oyster appetizer was definitely freshly battered and not a Sysco mass produced dish! If you like old school and seafood this place is worth a visit. read more

If you aren't a local dont bother been here several times but not enough times to be an actual returning custome, but noticed the treatment of other locals was far more different than the experience we got. 1st of all food portions have gone down our sweet potatoe and baked potatoe were very very small compared to other tables Out waitress was not very attentive and forgot many things we asked for mind u was not a busy Sunday night Some of the entrees lacked flavor May order fish for take out to make home but not return to dine read more

Navesink is a fish market with a BYOB restaurant in the back. The parking lot is large is location easy to visit. The decor is cozy and they serve nice crusty bread at the tables. We were a party of 6 and had a couple carafes of water on the table when we were seated. Menu prices are fair. Portions aren't large, but generally adequate if you eat some apps and bread with your meal. All fish is very fresh and makes it a great experience if you're craving fish. This place being a fish market, that have plenty of fish choices on the menu and everything was delicious. Shrimp, halibut, swordfish, scallops. My favorite were the raw clams. Super fresh and very affordably priced! You can even choose between littleneck and top neck. Bathrooms in the back don't have the cleanest feel to them. They're also used as stockpiles for cleaning supplies. There were even two ladders in the men's room along with a ton of other stuff. Yes, there's a toilet and sink so you can manage. Prices by the seafood market in front seemed rather high compared to grocery stores or even other fish markets I've been to. I'd recommend it for a fresh fish dinner although. read more

See all

Navesink Fishery is a gem!!! Right in the middle of a strip mall is a really top shelf establishment serving fresh hot mega outrageous food. The dining area is a bit tight but it's tasteful and perfectly lit. There are no reservations but they have a really comfy living room up front to chill if you have to wait for a table. The entire staff are just great! Everyone is happy and helpful like going to visit family or a friend's house for dinner. We started with a crab cake appetizer that was top shelf and served with a slightly spicy fresh salsa and mixed greens plus a house made tartar sauce that was made with fresh herbs. They don't miss a tick here. Both entrees were served hot and fresh at the exact same time. Somebody runs an excellent kitchen here! I had halibut and my Mrs. Has shrimp scampi and both dishes were amazing. I was amazed how awesome the green beans were prepared and we both had herbed rice that was cooked to perfection. If you are reading this don't think twice go have dinner here and see for yourself. They also have fresh fish and prepared items for quick takeout and a little farmers market with fresh veggies for you do it yourselfers. Don't miss the desert case. Enjoy! This place is a real local gem and great food find. read more

See all

Met with some longtime Friends. The waitress was excellent. The food was also very good. The owner of the place was absolutely horrible. We asked waitress to spilt the bill or give us three separate check. The manager gave one bill and told us to break it up. The waitress redid the bill and gave it to us. The manager owner of the place came to the table and why didnt we ask for separate checks to begin with. I told him we did and walked away saying don't bother to come back I told no problem we will never be back and we will tell our families and friends.The waitress was very suite but this owner is not worth the aggravation. read more

I'm not a diner that typically orders fish, but when I'm in the mood I come here. Nice and fresh, bright flavors, byob-what's not to like?

I had a delicious experience with friends at The Navasink Fishery at the Jersey shore.. The front of this shop is a fish shop selling fresh local fish of all kind. It also sells local produce. The back of the shop is a casual, family restaurant with an extensive fresh fish and seafood menu. All 3 of us ordered the sea scallops with a baked potato and string beans. 2 of us started with a a tasty shrimp cocktail and my other friend got an order of clams. Absolutely DIVINE! It's a BYOB so we had a couple bottles of white wine with us. We ended our epic meal with a slice of key lime pie. We split a piece, but we really should have ordered a piece each. This restaurant is a gem! read more

See all

Hidden gem in a strip mall. Have walked by it before and never knew it was a restaurant. Came towards the end of the night and there was no wait. Service was prompt. The decor was quaint but could use a little lift (add candles to table, paint ceiling tiles, freshen up walls by adding more eclectic frames and pics to existing). So much potential! The tablecloths and paper were clean and floor well maintained. As for the food, great selection of fish and food was cooked really well. However, the broiled combo plate was underseasoned so my tender scallops were looking for a little butter or garlic. The homemade tartar sauce that I dabbed on my fish was simply amazing. The seafood with penne with brandy wine sauce was nice but sauce was watery and would have been wonderful if thickened. Bread served with meal was warm and nice. The real hit here was the creamy corn and crab soup - velvety and butterey. Absolutely friggin outstanding! read more

See all

It was our wedding anniversary and we decided to give this place a try based on reading the reviews. We were immediately seated after arriving. There were a couple of tables occupied when we got there. At the front of the restaurant is the deli, where you can buy any fish you want. However, the back is a whole other world, as it is a dimly-lit room with flowers on some of the tables and an overall romantic vibe. Lamps dangle from the ceiling and framed paintings adorn the walls. We shared an arugula salad tossed in vinaigrette with tomatoes, beets, pecans and blue cheese. We thought that this was delicious and juicy. Hubs loved the salad and thought that it was a great mix. Daughter ordered Pan Seared Tuna with wasabi sauce and pickled ginger. She also got a side of rice and string beans , as well. She loved it and thought it was delicious. She said that it was the thickest tuna she ever had and she loved every bit of it. The tuna was nice and raw in the middle but it was a little sinewy. It wasn't enough to deter her. LOL. I had the Linguini with white clam sauce. Hubs and I thought that his was delicious. The entree is served with whole little neck clams and they were nice and large. Hubs and I were fighting to finish it. LOL. Lastly, Hubs ordered Seafood Creole on Herbed Rice. The seafood consisted of shrimp, scallop and lobster meat. He thought the creole was ok, but it could use a little hot sauce. It was definitely not as spicy as other regular cajun restaurants serve it. He didn't really care for it but we got it packed to go. We didn't realize that we left it behind until we got home. Considering the amount of money we spent for dinner, I'm disappointed that they didn't come after us that we forgot our leftovers. It's not like we dined and dashed out of there. We took our time leaving the restaurant and got into the car. Service was ok. We barely saw our server except to take our order and give us the bill. Glad we got to try this place but if I was going to spend that amount of money for dinner, I'd expect better service. read more

Is this the best BYOB seafood spot in northern Monmouth County ? We think so. And they make their own whitefish salad !

I can't believe my parents never brought me here when I visited. I think it's because they consider it to be an excellent place for lobster, and I'm allergic to lobster. Well it turns out that Navesink Fishery is great for other food, too! Upon the recommendation of our attentive waiter, I ordered the Crusted Halibut Dijonnaise. It was fantastic. In fact, it was so good that my sister, who LOVES lobster, declared that although her lobster was excellent, she preferred my halibut. Navesink Fishery isn't the fanciest place, but it's friendly and cozy, perfect for either a meal with friends and family or a romantic dinner. I'm so glad I finally made it there! read more

See all

We finally made it here after going past Navesink Fishery for so many years. We arrived almost past the lunch time window but the owner graciously sat us. The market and restaurant is dated and has a simple ambiance. We had: Corn and crab chowder Fried shrimp platter Flounder sandwich platter The French fries are sprinkled with dill- delicious. Food was fresh and nice portions. A good stop for fish/seafood. read more

Navesink Fishery - Seafood Markets Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

Excellent food. Feel's like home, and more affordable than the other seafood restaurants.

(Not sure how many of my reviews start with a variation of this, but...) "Thank you Yelp, once again." My family had a last minute idea to hit Sandy Hook for the sunset and needed a good spot for dinner and this is where Yelp led us. File under 'Don't Judge a Book...' because it's located in a (typical) run-of-the-mill (down-the-shore) shopping center (I've passed countless times back in the day) and from the outside it didn't look like much. Walk in, pass the store/market portion (and friendly squad of workers behind the counter) and head into the cozy back restaurant part. And proceeded to be blown away. Linguine with clams. Bronzino. (My kids were completely fascinated with the eye sockets and mouth/teeth on this fish.) Rainbow trout. Swordfish. Good portions. Incredibly flavorful and well-seasoned and properly cooked all around. (Even the complimentary bread - two huge portions, no less - was better than you'd expect it to be.) Pricing was legit, the staff were friendly. If I had to rant at all it might be that the food did seem to take a wee bit too long to come out. (But that might have to do with our stomach pangs making us a wee bit too impatient.) BYOB (with a liquor store just feet away). This place is fin-tastic (I've got a tackle box full of awful dad puns!). Two enthusiastic thumbs up. read more

Delicious food and great service. Knowledgeable staff that are very nice and professional. A great place to enjoy a bottle of wine, conversation and fresh seafood. read more

Navesink Fishery - Shrimp Scampi over Rice - Seafood Markets Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

See all

One of my favorite places to dine. Food choices are plenty and always have enjoyed the presentation and fine service. read more

Bought some fish dip here. The young lady behind the counter was very helpful and friendly. There's hope for customer service after all! Fish dip was great too, as was potato salad, which was almost as good as mom's read more

Read some reviews about this place and wanted to try it. The place is located in a strip mall and definitely needs updating. We ordered the fried shrimp platters, the shrimp were not butterflied the backs were sliced down and they were coated in a differant type batter kinda of like a cornmeal, they had no flavor at all. It is a BYOB as I seen customers bringing in bottles of wine. The waitress was very nice. For me, it was not what I expected and I will not return. read more

See all

Well, where do I start. As many reviewers elucidated, this unassuming gem of a restaurant is also a fresh seafood market. My wife was in the mood for seafood for our anniversary and wanted to try something new. Reviews on several platforms seem to be in agreement that Navesink Fishery would be worthy of visit. Upon entry, we noticed there were few tables remaining. Lucky for us, we were able to be seated right away. The dining area in the back of the seafood market was kind of drab and in need of restaurant make over. That was my first impression. My second observation was the entire dining room was filled with old farts like us. I doubt there anyone under sixty years of age. I guess wisdom and knowledge come with old age as these diners know good food. Speculating, the clientele must be locals that know where the "good taste" is being served and the service is expedient and caring. I debated giving Navesink Fishery 4 stars, knocking off one star for the lack of ambiance. However, the quality, freshness, portion size and menu variety make up for that. I can't say the prices were inexpensive but were very fair and competitive for the menu items. Our combination seafood entrees and mussel appetizer were prepared to perfection and were served quickly. Add the the stellar value is the BYOB option. If you are thinking about just the waterfront location, that's ok but honesty, value and quality and freshness served at the Navesink Fishery can't be beat! read more

We went here again last evening and their fresh fish dishes really are FRESH and cooked to perfection! It's a simple, no fuss casual dining. Love that their veggies are steamed but could probably be steamed less, so more Al dente & creative with their veggies. All in all it's probably one of the best fresh seafood restaurants in Monmouth County! Our server Ashley was attentive, accommodating, efficient and very friendly. We will definitely be back to try some other dishes! read more

The food the service and the ambience were perfect. This evening my girlfriend and I ordered the broiled trout. The trout was perfectly made and the baked potato was cooked to perfection. The string beans were delicious. A wonderful meal and we will be back again. Nicely done. Gene and Ann read more

The dining room was unexpectedly nice, considering that it's a fish market. An extra is that you can have a conversation without shouting. Finally, the fish is fresh as can be, and the chef knows how to cook it. read more

From the outside you would never expect such a nice, ambient indoor seating restaurant with incredible food!

Freshest caught seafood on the Jersey shore. Friendly, efficient and knowledgeable staff! BYOB!

Always a pleaser. An excellent variety of seafood on the menu, including steamers. The staff is friendly and professional. Fish is cooked to perfection. read more

Can always rely on fresh seafood, with a wide variety of filets and shellfish. We had a nice treat of 1.5 lb lobsters that were very fresh. Great seafood spot for takeout or filets read more

See all

I went here the other day and really enjoyed it. It has a little fishery in front and small restaurant in back. Started w a great soup. The fish was super fresh and very tasty. This is a byob which was nice too. Pricing is not cheap but worth what you get read more

A five star+ restaurant. Unassuming strip mall location and decor but delicious fresh seafood. I had three courses and all three were 10 out of 10. I started with the oyster soup that is made to order and as I was eating it I told my wife I would come back just for it. I wish I took a picture as it was loaded with oysters. Then my scallops arrived and they were pan seared perfectly with a healthy amount of eight mid to large scallops. Lastly the key lime pie dessert could have fed four and was delicious. The service was prompt and friendly and the prices are good. read more

Navesink Fishery - Scallops on sautéed spinach - Seafood Markets Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

See all

Would have given it 5 stars but I tried to order take out from the beach and they did not pick up the phone so I drove there and waited 45 mn for my order but it was worth it delicious combo platter broiled not fried and served with cocktail sauce Tartar sauce and sour cream for bake potato everything tasted amazing and fresh. I also ordered the corn crab showder but it was bland and I could not taste the crab pass ... read more

I was looking for something different for dinner this evening and decided on seafood. We went to this place and was very pleasantly surprised. We ordered New England clam chowder and steamed Little neck clams in broth and calamari. The chowder was great as were the clams. The calamari was just ok. For mains I ordered a 2lb stuffed lobster and it was delicious. Lots of crab stuffing (basically crab with a sprinkle of breadcrumbs). For $66. Great price, great service. I'd go back in a heartbeat read more

Navesink Fishery - Seafood Markets Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

We ordered takeout shrimp cocktail, fried calamari, smoked white fish dip and steamed lobster. We decided to eat it there on their super cosy outdoor seating and enjoyed this amazing meal that was cooked with a lot of Love. Staff and Chef were very nice and friendly as well! We will definitely be back! Loved it! read more

Navesink Fishery - Steamed lobster yummy just perfect - Seafood Markets Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

See all

I can't believe it took us this long to try this place out .. we spend most of the summer in the highlands area and were looking for something new to try. I called ahead for a takeout order and I was very impressed at how good of a job they are doing with the social distancing and the offerings they had.; some market items such as produce and also toilet paper rolls.. great idea and fair prices . We ordered baked halibut, so delicious, generous portion and fair price.. omg and the broiled stuffed lobster... I can't wait to get it again , so good.. big lump crabmeat and barely any breadcrumbs! The woman at the counter was nice enough to bring everything out to my car when the order was ready!, thank you so much and we will be back!! read more

ARROGANT OWNER!! i've been cooking shellfish for 20 years,, bought 2 dozen clams couldn't get them to spit out the salt or open in anyway i called them telling them they were dead and he told me they were clean and i didn't know how to cook them. don't go here if u want dead fish! read more

Seafood was fresh and good. The service was exemplary. The restaurant is just behind the market was very cozy. A great place to take a date or celebrate anniversary or birthday. read more

The seafood is fresh but giving it 4 stars as the prices deserve a view or at least better ambiance. They should update the restaurant in the back. The prices are not what Google's site lists them as. Go to their actual website. Better off getting take out from here if you are local. read more

We have family in town and placed a large take out order. Everything was excellent, whole lobster, scallops, lobster roll, crab cakes, soft shell crabs and steamers. This is one of the few times during Covid that I have placed a take out order and got exactly what I ordered. This was perfect. read more

Excellent all around fresh fish and amazing service was the immediate take away. Nestled in a small strip mall with a liquor store next door! This is a BYOB and plentiful parking as well read more

"Where fishermen dine" is what we were told when we moved to Atlantic Highlands. These fishermen have good taste! I also love to buy my fresh fish, "company" shrimp, crab cakes and chowder here. Ruddy also sells fresh vegetables and bread. read more