We're driving through and stopped for sit-down pizza lunch. The pizza is tasty, but I am perplexed…read moreby the previous reviews that say this is a pizza buffet with great atmosphere. This is definitely neither a place with atmosphere nor a buffet. This spot is a walk-up counter with an open kitchen. Seating consists of a couple of mismatched tables in an atrium outside Pizza Pub and a couple of health- and fitness-oriented businesses. Our pizza order took about 20 minutes to make. We received a box with a pizza in it. The pizza box was an ingenious style I've never seen before that matches closed and then opens out flat. It's hot and tastes good. They didn't have any napkins but gave us a couple of paper towels when asked. The restroom was clean. The canned soda tasted as expected.

Not your Grandma's pizza...we tried their "DaButta" (i.e. PEANUT BUTTER PIZZA!). So after a nice…read morebike ride to Lupulin Brewery, all the bike riders suggested Pizza Pub & the PB Pizza. As I was drinking a CPB (Chocolate Peanut Butter Porter), it sounded like a good idea. It was! The peanut butter was cleverly placed in the pie, along with nice slices of pepperoni & jalapeños! Sweet & spicy! I would recommend this pizza to the adventurous out there...even better, pair it with a nice CPB from Lupulin Brewery!

We hosted a milestone birthday party for 15 people at Willy's On the Water this past Saturday, and…read morethey were outstanding from start to finish. They seated us together, even though it was their lunch rush, and the staff took care of every detail for our large group. Service was excellent; servers were always nearby checking on beverages, food, and anything else we needed, without ever feeling intrusive. Everyone at the table commented on how good the food was - great flavors, generous portions, and well‑made drinks. We've always loved Willy's On the Water, but this experience really confirmed that they're a fantastic choice for larger parties as well. The manager, Gavin, and his staff--from hostesses to servers--were amazing and incredibly helpful throughout the event. I would highly recommend Willy's On the Water for both everyday dining and special occasions.

My wife,Grand-dog, and myself went on a beautiful Friday for lunch.Got a great spot on the patio…read moreoverlooking the lake. The burgers were cooked perfectly with quality meat.My walleye was delicious but I still brought half home.Servers were super attentive and knowledgeable. Hostess brought doggie treats and lots of water on a 88 degree day.We used the umbrella for sun protection and the light breeze made for a perfect experience.

Love the pizza! Worth the wait, best pizza in the area for sure... I've only ordered takeout from…read morehere, it's best to call ahead

Great food and a very nice owner who was working by himself when I picked up my pizza. Still got my…read morefood on time and I can't wait to go back!

The calzone was fabulous. Crust was yummy. Service was fast. If we were driving through MN again,…read morewe would go out of our way to eat here.

Thee most delicious Pizza ever!! The crust was thin & very crispy! The sauce was super good & the…read morecheese was sooooo cheesy!!

I had heard from several people that I needed to check this place out and I'm glad I listened. The…read morepizzas are unique and the flavors blend beautifully together. I thought the service was very efficient and it's a cute local shop. I'm looking forward to going again.

I absolutely love this place. The pizza is amazing and the staff is nice however I unfortunately…read morehave to take away stars from my rating due to this being my fourth time in a row the restaurant does not add the toppings I paid for I'm not sure why this keeps happening. Maybe the staff needs to highlight the tickets whenever there's additions to the pizzas? Not sure. The last time I approached staff regarding rhe missing toppings they did make it right and gave me a free pizza. So I do appreciate the service, just need consistency. I was too tired to approach staff today about the exact same issue

We came for bingo on a Wednesday night at 6:00pm (bingo starts at 7:00), I recommend arriving early…read morefor bingo because it is a popular spot! I ordered the cheese curd burger with tots. The cheese curds were so good, I would order that separately as an appetizer next time. The burger itself was grilled perfectly medium, I would ask for extra Chipotle ranch. Service was attentive and seating for sitting for bingo for 2 hours was comfortable.

G O O D F O O D…read more Attended a Rehearsal Dinner here upstairs. They have a nice cozy area complete with a bar. Attached is a good sized deck with lots of seating. Our delightful bartender wore a cool Friendly Buffalo shirt, I guess she has been there quite some time! Honestly, I liked the old name better! We were served home made lasagna that was damn near as good as mine! Respect! E A T HERE P A R T Y HERE

Alex from the big lake caseys location took time out of his day to pump my gas due to im in a…read morewheelchair. I will be going back

If you wanna be disrespected by the people at the counter then come right on over here. This one…read moreold guy with white hair and a small goatee/beard that was yelling at me to get out because he thought I was talking to him when I was talking to my friend. Absolutely ridiculous.

Papa's Italian definitely feels more like a casual neighborhood pizza spot, and for that type of…read morerestaurant, it mostly met expectations. Customer service was fine overall, though there was some confusion finding our order at pickup. The food unfortunately seemed like it had been sitting awhile, as most of it was not very hot when we arrived on time. The bread side was extremely hard and crispy, the mac and cheese bites were overcooked, and the pizza itself was okay but lacked flavor. That said, the fettuccine Alfredo was genuinely tasty and the favorite of the night for everyone. The restaurant seemed busy with lots of regulars coming and going, so perhaps we caught them on an off night. Perhaps we'd give them another try in the future if we travel back that way.

It's nice to have good food and good service in a local restaurant. A pleasant experience.read more