I got the ice cream that was mixed with everything. I would try this spot again. Nothing crazy…read morespecial inside

My favorite ice cream place for my grandson and I yet today the ice cream was so soft it fell into…read morethe cup and the scoop was like 3/4 scoop. Even my grandson said it's the least ice cream he ever got. We'll go to carvel so he doesn't fell jipped. He is 5. He shouldn't have noticed yet it was bad enough that he did

This frozen yogurt is amazing and tastes so fresh! We come here very, very often (multiple times…read moreeach week) and always find it delicious. All the staff we've encountered so far have been very helpful and kind!

Tastes great! Waaaaay too overpriced!!!! $17.62 for a 13…read moreyear old is insanity. The cup was like half filled. Wow

Milky Ways is a dessert lover's dream! Not only is the ice cream top-tier, but the endless array of…read morepossibilities makes every visit feel like a new adventure. With so many cereal mix-ins, toppings, and flavor combos, you can get as creative as you want--there's truly something for everyone! What really makes this place special, though, is the fantastic staff. From the moment we walked in, they were welcoming, patient, and super helpful in guiding us through all the options. You can tell they genuinely love what they do, and their enthusiasm is contagious. The ice cream itself? Absolutely delicious. Whether you go for a classic combination or something totally out of the box, every bite is packed with flavor and nostalgia. If you haven't been to Milky Ways yet, you're seriously missing out. Great treats, amazing people, and endless ways to customize your perfect dessert--what more could you ask for?

My daughter absolutely love Milky Ways, if you not familiar with their style of ice cream let me…read moretell you. You pick a cup, cone or shake. Then you pick an ice cream, next you pick a cereal, which they blend the ice cream and cereal together after it's blended you pick a topping then a drizzle. The Staff is super friendly and very nice. Sometime the service can be slow but that's because they making the ordered to perfection. The store is very very clean. And each table has a game on it like, Guess who, connect four, tic tac toe and uno. Which makes the wait extra fun. It's not too pricey. Oh, and for my non dairy peeps. I was told today that they have a non dairy vanilla options.

Great ice cream. Recommend the cookies and cream oh and I saw alpacas today so look below and…read moreyou'll see.

The one star is for the good ice cream but that's really all I can say which is positive. TLDR this…read moreplace isn't careful about allergens. I ordered an ice cream cake for my mother in laws birthday and it was completely wrong. As soon as we cut into it, I was confused by the chocolate cake as I had clearly ordered vanilla cake (see order picture). We thought they had just given the wrong cake type which we were annoyed about but willing to look past and decided to dig in. However, the mix ins were all wrong and the worst part is, there are tree nuts in the mix in which my MIL is allergic too!!! She has already taken two bites before realizing. Food allergens are super serious and we were so lucky that she didn't have a very serious reaction. This is completely unacceptable and I didn't get the feeling that the store manager understood how serious it was. He apologized once and that was it. He was more focused on trying to work out which employee it was. I was issued a refund and walked out. I've bought cold stone cake from various locations multiple times a year and this was seriously the biggest f up I've ever seen.

The best fro-yo/smoothie place I've been to in a very long time. I stopped in yesterday because it…read morewas super humid and I wanted something refreshing. The store had a lot delicious looking fruit smoothies so it was hard to pick. However, my pomegranate pick was absolutely delicious. As I was waiting, the owner and I got to chatting and he informed me he has been in business for over 30 years and I completely understand why! The smoothie was super light and refreshing, he was super hospitable, and the location is conveniently located on Jericho Turnpike. They also sell froyo, cookie ice cream, and more!

wow, just wow this frozen yogurt was absolutely divine. I'm currently sitting in the parking lot,…read moreeating it. if I could, I could write a whole paragraph about how happy I am and how satisfied I am with my coffee, frozen yogurt and the huge amount of fudge the guy at the cashier put it in my ice cream. thank you for

Amazing ice cream! Made on site and there's tons of flavors. My new favorite is lemon poppy. I can…read moreeat that all day which might be a problem. This place rivals any ice cream around. I'll be coming back often!

The Ice Cream Social has come to Greenlawn. So let's congregate and be social over ice cream. Great…read moreflavors like Raspberry Chip. Or let's get tipsy with a scoop or two of Boozy Egg Nog, they have the classic flavors too. The owner will go out of his way to make sure your experience at the Social is a good one. Seating is limited and the parking is not a problem. CIAO FOR NOW.

It's a real old-fashioned ice cream parlor. SOFT SERVE…read more with cream. Numerous ice cream flavors. Ices. Egg creams. Floats. Milkshake and so much more Old fashioned glassware. A must!

Timeless and classic. Stepping inside the Northport Sweet Shop brings me nothing but happiness. In…read morethe summer their ice cream is perfect. In the winter we pop in for some of their chocolates. This year we tried the egg nog bon bon. The whole box was devoured.

Stopped here for a quick treat on a recent hot day. They have such a wide variety of flavors,…read moreranging from classics to unique. I had a blueberry muffin and early gray double scoop and I have to say it was DELICIOUS. The blueberry compote was so refreshing and the early gray was spot on. Service was so friendly and quick. They allowed us to sample a few things before ordering which I always appreciate. I wish the place had some seating inside to escape from the heat, but alas. Overall, great place and would come back.

My wife can't eat regular ice cream, so we are always on the lookout for some form of dairy free or…read morevegan ice cream. This place had TWO delicious sounding Vegan Ice creams so in we went. This place makes all their own ice cream, gelato, ices, vegan and yogurts which is exciting. They have 70 flavors. 70 DELICIOUS sounding flavors! We tried both the Peanut Butter Oreo and the coconut chip vegan flavors, both were fantastic and I (who didn't want ice cream) wound up with a salted caramel ice cream that was. so good. This is definitely a place to go back many times because everything looked so good and what we had was rich and delicious and made you make all those embarrassing yummy noises.

I usually get my Sundays in Syosset, but I was in the area and I ordered two Sundays and was very…read moresurprised they charge me extra for toppings so I won't be back

Kind of baffled I'm writing this review, but this location just charged us $4.39 for chocolate…read moresprinkles on a Jr. Cone. For reference, the Jr. Cone cost $3.89. I went back inside after to ask why Two Jr Ice Creams ($3.89 each) with chocolate sprinkles on one of them cost $13.20, and she said "Tax and Sprinkles", well, after accounting for taxes, I did some math, they literally charged me $4.39 for some chocolate sprinkles. That's it.

Amazing new ice cream shop!! The shop is super clean and cute!! The staff are super kind and…read morehelpful, the place is accessible to wheelchair users too! Had an amazing time and we ate everything.

Waffles make anything better. Love that they offer bubble waffles here. Cute little spot with great…read moreservice. Thanks! Will definitely be back and I love that they have vegan and dairy free options.