Hands-down, still the best costume shop in the area. Looking for fairy wings? They don't just have…read morefairy wings, they have a dozen different shapes, sizes, styles, and colors. Need a wig? They have a whole wig section. Need a rubber rat? They have small, medium, large, squeak, non-squeak, and realistic-feel rat. The people here know their stuff and they'll help you find things or put together an outfit.

I had a great experience and the owner has a lot of merchandise. I would highly recommend you to…read morecheck this store! It has costumes, masks, wigs, makeup and accessories galore!

Don't waste your time or money!!! Apart from bad customer service and management, the stock is low…read morequality and deteriorating. In my opinion, if you want better quality costumes by professional stitchers, you should rent from Tina's Productions Broadway Costumes Norcostco Also in my opinion, you can get just as good, if not better quality mascots and save money by ordering directly from Alinco Costumes or International Mascot Co.

They are very professional. There are few places as well run in the area. They have a tremendous…read morevariety of costumes to choose from.

This store is no longer existence and it's closed. It was a staple of the childhood. I hate to see…read moreit go. I wish it was open. I would've bought hundreds of dollars worth of tricks my kids were very disappointed.

A best kept secret of party goer's, party haver's and magicians! I have been coming here for 20…read moreyears to get fun quirky stuff and rent costumes for Halloween and parties! I recently rented a "Mr. mouse" costume for my daughter's first birthday which was a mickey and Minnie mouse theme. I looked into several places and ken's was def the cheapest by a long shot!. My daughter loved the costume and thought mickey was real... As always the owner was very nice and answered all my annoying questions without hesitation... Great little store on Broadway in Fair Lawn...

Amazing people make this an amazing costume shop. We happened to be in Scranton and needed a…read morecostume for a Yelp Elite event featuring a 1920's theme. Of course they had everything we needed and were helpful and very cheerful in assisting us. Prices were great (same as Amazon) and being able to try on the dress (my wife, not me) before buying was a huge plus because she got the correct size. The first dress would've been too big, even though the size should've fit. Can't say how valuable this was in saving us time and hassle with a return and potentially not having the proper clothes for the party. This store offers rentals of so many amazing costumes year-round, so there's literally everything and anything you could imagine to get you dressed up for the occasion. The two ladies that helped us were absolutely wonderful and sweet and we were so delighted to stop in. See you next time!

Staff is always very helpful in finding what you need Great selection of costumes and accessories…read more My go to place for costumes

Easily the best Halloween store I have ever shopped it. They always have stock at reasonable prices…read moreand lots of collectibles for horror fans. The staff is personable and always helpful.

I have been going to ScarePros for the past few years. It seems that these guys have the best mask…read moreselection in the area. It must be a "pro" shop since, they carry some pretty awesome animatronics and decorations. I haven't seen this quality of product at any of the pop-up halloween shops that sprout up every season. I don't know much about the normal halloween costumes, but they definitely have a large selection. This place is a warehouse overflowing with stuff. The staff has always been really helpful. I have no reason to shop for halloween stuff anywhere else. I go for the props, my wife loves the costumes! They carry things that you just can't get anywhere else.

Unbelievable choice of costume rentals. Friendly, fast customer service. Ask for Dave. I needed a…read moreMarine Corps fighter jet pilot jumpsuit. THEY FREAKING HAD IT! !!! I won a contest too!

Don't let the Modest Entrance fool you, beyond these doors are the costumes that will transform you…read moreinto the character you long to Be!

I have seen many shows that this company provides clothes/costumes and props for, they are as good…read moreas anyone in the business. Period pieces,weather it be now, in the future or in the past, nice eye for detail. I would hire them in a second if I were to do a show. Their hearts are in it, very professional Love their work!

I am a dance teacher in a public high school and working with Playtime Costumes was so easy. They…read morewent above and beyond costuming one of my dances and had such great rapport with the students. Attention to detail, fast and friendly costumer service and awesome costumes make them a company I would definitely recommend and work with in the future.