Attempted a meal at Bay Harbor last night with a large group, and the experience was exceptionally…read moresubpar. Our servers and trainee were polite, but the bar drinks and food were inexcusable for a pricey dinner service. Gordon Ramsay would've been screaming. 1) Everything took forever to come out. It was 2 hours from being seated to being served entrees. We had a large group (18), but the restaurant was not busy at the time we were eating, with only a handful of other tables occupied. Our servers claimed that the bartender and kitchen staff were both new, but I have no way to verify that. 2) My wife and I ordered the vegetarian dishes, which turned out to both be completely absurd. $40 for "Mushroom Risotto" that had either been cooked without any sauce whatsoever or thoroughly mummified under a heat lamp while the other dishes were being prepared. It was crispy! Risotto is, by every acceptable measure, not crispy. The veggie burger was somehow more depressing, but was edible - in the same way that Soylent is food. A pale, dry, flavorless rice patty, with lettuce and a slice of tomato, on a decidedly *not* Brioche bun. Just use an Impossible burger or Beyond burger, at least those are expensive enough to justify the cost of the dish! 3) My bar drinks, both Lemon Drops (as listed on the menu!) came in different styles of glasses and were very different pours. The 4 kids at our tables that ordered Shirley Temples received what could be charitably called "a variety of recipes" with some having cherries, some not, and immediately sparking arguments between them. Overall, the service could not save what turned out to be a disappointment for our entire extended family. Flee, and do not return.

Definitely a 3 Star experience at 4 Star prices. I took my parents here for dinner while I was in…read moretown. We enjoyed the shrimp cocktail and the stuffed mushroom appetizers. My parents ordered the Prime Rib for $54 each. They were very generous cuts of meat but unfortunately not the most tender or flavorful. I ordered the Blackened Grouper and it was good but for $50 the portion size was a little small. The restaurant itself is very dated, 80's or 90's at best. Time for a refresh. The best part of the meal was our server, Selena. She was very nice.

-30 Food was terrible. We had nachos, pretzel, and wings…read more Wings were okay, but the other two came with flavorless queso and the nachos just had salad greens on top. The worst part of our entire trip to Put-In-Bay was the Ray Fogg show. He was way too vulgar, and our entire table hated having to sit through his show. We all have a twisted sense of humor, but he was too much. He was also way too loud so it was impossible to enjoy our time without hearing his garbage set the whole time.

Our favorite bar at Put in Bay! The atmosphere here is…read moregreat. Great service, one of the bartender here got best /top bartender in Ohio. The Monea brothers were playing, they are very good and they get everyone involved. They plays music you can sing along with. Now the food, absolutely delicious. Had the bourbon burger, omg so good. Made perfectly. We also had to Brussels sprout taco, surprisingly very delicious as well. Had to try and see. This place will not disappoint.

Nice atmosphere, friendly staff. Brats & pierogies were good and the prices were decent. I'd go…read moreback

Stopped in on a busy island Saturday yesterday for lunch. Was seated immediately in a charming old…read morebooth with a view of the main drag and The Boardwalk. Lunch was great! We both had the cup of soup and half turkey sandwich on sourdough. I had tortilla soup and my husband had chicken noodle. Both were liked. Turkey on the sandwich was far better than standard gluey deli turkey. Decaf coffee was surprisingly good. Server Austin was helpful and cheerful. We will be back!

They have a very nice menu. Service is a little slower here. I was very satisfied with a half…read moreCaesar salad with shrimp. The shrimp was very nicely sized. My husband loves the brunch burger, which is a burger with waffles for the bun.

Bar and grill with view of the water right in the middle of all the fun! You can sit outdoors and…read moreenjoy the people and activity. I would not bring kids here and this isn't the place for romantic or quiet conversation. The food is pretty standard bar fare and about the price you'd expect in a resort area

We came here after my sister got married and had an absolutely wonderful meal!…read more First off our server Will was awesome and very attentive. He was on point and had a friendly personality which was perfect for our celebration. Everyone absolutely loved their meals too. My crab cake salad hit the spot, the kids loved their burgers and the buttered lobster roll was definitely the star of all the meals. Soo soo good. We were so glad we picked this spot and now we have a wonderful memory for life. Thank you!

We came on a day trip. Recommendations were en pointe. Get some type of fish. We shared a fish…read moreplatter$38 (6 pieces of fish-- perch, battered fries and condiment cup of coleslaw) It was worth it minus the slaw. I saw the lobster bisque after and got instantly jealous. No pics due to starving Later went upstairs and got a margarita Great views

Stopped by for a cocktail and snack. Our server Sam was prompt and cheerful. We sat outside on…read morethe patio. People watching is the best! Especially when early 20 something's are almost drunk by 1 pm! Haha. Happy Birthday young lady in the golf cart! The hostess brought our dog a big bowl of ice water and a treat, She made a friend for life We got ice water too in human cups. Hahaha I ordered the Garden Gimlet which was Bombay Sapphire Gin with Muddled Cucumbers, Agave Nectar, and Lime Juice strained and served with a cucumber garnish. My husband enjoyed one of his new favorites - New York Whiskey Sour which is Bullet Rye, Lemon Juice, and Agave Nectar, topped with a Pinot Noir Red Wine Floater. We shared a Brisket Poutine. The fires were like potato scoops the gravy was just the right amount so the potatoes were not soggy. The brisket was flavorful and not fatty. Nice snack and cocktails for the afternoon! I'd definitely come back! Stopped by for a cocktail and snack. Our server Sam was prompt and cheerful. We sat outside on the patio. People watching is the best! Especially when earlym20 something's are almost drunk by 1 pm! Haha. Happy Birthday young lady in the golf cart! The hostess brought our dog a big bowl of ice water and a treat, She made a friend for life! We got ice water too in human cups. Hahaha I ordered the Garden Gimlet which was Bombay Sapphire Gin with Muddled Cucumbers, Agave Nectar, and Lime Juice strained and served with a cucumber garnish. My husband enjoyed one of his new favorites - New York Whiskey Sour which is Bullet Rye, Lemon Juice, and Agave Nectar, topped with a Pinot Noir Red Wine Floater. We shared a Brisket Poutine. The fires were like potato scoops the gravy was just the right amount so the potatoes were not soggy. The brisket was flavorful and not fatty. Nice snack and cocktails for the afternoon! I'd definitely come back!

A great Irish bar. All the usual Irish things a bar will have. Have numerous board games to play…read morewhile waiting. Guiness of course. Overall a 7

Wow! What a spot! Wanted an approachable dinner after a long day on the point and this place…read moreknocked it out it out of the park! Easy dive bar vibe with a superior menu of drinks and eats. They have lake perch dishes that are an absolutely must. For the win: Bavarian Pretzel, Lack Perch Sandwich, and a Dortmunder Gold

This place was amazing. They offer non alcoholic and alcoholic beverages. My mom got the hamburger…read moreand fries and I got the walleye bites and fries, everything was delicious. The people were very kind, friendly, and treated you like family. It has a very laid back atmosphere with beautiful views of the waterfront and downtown Sandusky, Ohio. There is also a pet friendly area on the outside patio area.

Listened to the karaoke from our rental the night before so had to try it. The tacos and queso were…read moregreat!! Worth the visit.

Unfortunately, not the best experience. The menu looked really promising, but the service was…read moredisorganized and inattentive from the start. It took quite a while before anyone came over to take our drink order, and I eventually had to ask if we could put in our food order. Three of our four main dishes came out together, while the fourth person in our group was left sitting without her meal for another 10-15 minutes. Then, somehow, our appetizer--chips and dip--came out another 10 minutes after that, when most of us were already finished eating. To make things even more confusing, there were only two parties in the restaurant, yet several of our dishes were initially brought to the other table. Meanwhile, our drinks sat empty while three staff members were behind the bar talking, and no one seemed to notice or check in. The whole experience just felt very uncoordinated. Food coming out in the wrong order, meals going to the wrong table, long waits, and empty drinks would be frustrating in a packed restaurant, but it was especially surprising considering how few customers were there. The menu has a lot of potential, but unfortunately the service really took away from the experience.