Ordered in at 6:12, walked out at 7:05. Couldn't even ask for a refund because no one behind the register would talk to us. I'm not even going to eat it, I think I'll give it to a homeless guy. This place just celebrated 20 years? This is how you treat your customers? Maybe learn some customer service. read more

The best food and customer service. I stop by everytime that I visit. The catfish fillets are my favorite.

Terrible service!! The young lady was on a personal phone call and my order sat for a least half an hour! In the end my food didn't even taste good because I was so angry!! What a waste of time and money!! read more

I Love your Philly cheese steak sandwiches. They are BUSSIN. An that means better than good.

So good, on par with the cheesesteaks I had in Philadelphia! The lady at the counter was very nice and sold me on trying one of their slushies, said they were the best ever and I think she's right. 2 bites in to the steak Philly with peppers, onions and white American cheese and I felt like it deserved a great review, it's very legit if you're looking for an authentic Philly. Will for sure be back when I'm on the area for work. read more

I haven't been here in 4 years, and boy have things changed! Ordered a cheesesteak and a turkey cheesesteak. "Where's the beef???" 4 years ago, my sandwich my was filled with meat. Look at the pics! Look at the pics now and compare them to the past. There is more bread than meat! Pitiful! The turkey cheesesteak is all lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo! You don't see any meat and I didn't taste any! If I wanted a veggie sandwich, I would have ordered one! Is the sandwich filled with meat? Nope! Is it worth going to ghetto Gary, for this? Nope! Am I ever coming back here? NOPE!!! read more

See all

Ok so I'm not going to add inside pictures because it appears they are updating their menu board/ doing updates...inside is small and not much to see, but I was greeted and the cashier helped me by explaining the difference in each cheesesteaks...the order did take to some time to get but I don't mind for freshly made food! I liked the food but it was nothing to die for or worth all the hype I was hearing! read more

SteelCity CheeseSteaks - Chicken Philly - Sandwiches Near Me - Gary, Indiana

Honestly, this place slaps. The bread could be a bit more stout, because it kinda crumbles as you eat your sandwich, but other than that it was delicious. Don't let the location keep you away. read more

SteelCity CheeseSteaks - Steel City CHEESESTEAK. - Sandwiches Near Me - Gary, Indiana

Good food The Cheese Steak sandwich is the best since I had at Taurus Flavors in Chicago read more

When I come in town for the holidays we venture out to Gary. This was the first time, and it is a gem. Had the cheddar cheesesteak and family had the catfish, and wings were delicious. When I come back I will make sure to stop by again. The woman behind the counter was so nice as well. Customer service is so important these days! read more

SteelCity CheeseSteaks - prices of cheesesteaks - Sandwiches Near Me - Gary, Indiana

It's str8 they just don't follow instructions well. They seem to close early a lot and always don't have no fish whenever I come lbvs!

You want to get the best cheesesteak. Steelcity is the place. Never a complaint. Make sure you get mayo on your steak sandwiches.

I recently ordered food to pick up. I was somewhat early for the pickup so I expected to wait. I let person working the counter that I was there. They had trouble finding the order. I waited about 30 more minutes for the order and took it home. The order was incorrect but tasted great. While I was a little disappointed with the service I really enjoyed the meal. I will still go back but I'm a little less excited about it. read more

This food is "The Best In The Midwest", and fresh, and hot, don't sleep on the location! The whole menu is "FIRE"! Steelcity Cheese Steak sandwich and Steelcity chicken & Steak fries are "Killer"! They prepare it just like you want it! Let the family know Bro. Zamar recommended you because I'm sure you will go back again and again for good quality food. Thanks, Ms.D, Jim. B, and Mike, peace to you all family. read more

Best cheese steak I've had in the country.... Went to Philly to try some cheesteaks and immediately wanted to come back to this place.

A greasy spoon restaurant but in the best way. Sandwiches are delicious with plenty of meat and cheese. It's best to call in your order (if you can). I tried the Steelcity fries but I'm not a fan. The sandwiches are better. read more

The wait is pretty long, but the food is worth it. Only thing I don't like is the parking.

No consistency but if it's nothing to eat then you have no choice so they will never close and I didn't know they are affiliated with Bigcity cheesesteak.... read more

Food is great... service is VERY slow though, even when you call it in. I hate to wait 30 minutes after I got here for a call in order, which I called in 25 minutes before and I was on my lunch. I wasn't happy, but the food was great and the staff was friendly. They just really need to prioritize getting your order done in a timely fashion. I've only ordered here twice and that's the main reason, because both times I had an extremely long wait. The second time they also mixed up the orders a little bit. I'm definitely willing to give them another chance because of the quality of the food, but I'll call way ahead of time. read more

This a MUST anytime I'm in town. The food is always fresh, hot and DELICIOUS . Steel City never disappoints! They've been around for a long time and the quality and taste has remained the same. read more

Our food was cold and under cooked we did not get our full order just poor across the board

Decided to try this place because I was working nearby. The place looks sketch as hell but don't let that put you off, the sandwiches are phenomenal! I had the PepperJack Cheesesteak with all the fixin's they put on it. Never had mayo on a Cheesesteak; unexpectedly tasty tbh. Fries were a bit under salted but, still good. Worth a check out if the exterior doesn't scare you off. read more

SteelCity CheeseSteaks - Large Pepper Jack Philly, came with a messa fries $12ish - Sandwiches Near Me - Gary, Indiana

They food always hot they have the best cheese steak in lake county.

AWESOME place great food and service. A hidden gem. Plenty of meat the large will fill you up for sure great tasting steak as well. Must try. read more

This is the best in the city for cheesesteaks!! Hell the state! I have been going here forever and don't care that it's attached to the gas station! The food is good every time! I even take my business folks here even in our suits lol! read more

Hands-down the best cheesesteaks in the city. Doesn't look like much from the outside, but the service is great and the food is unparalleled. You will not be disappointed. A perennial fave. read more

They slow ass hell even with a call in They need to do better but the food taste great

Delicious true cheesesteak!!! Only wish I could eat more but its a big sandwich. Fries were great and I loved the cheese sauce I ordered for my fries. If I'm back in Gary I will certainly order again. read more

Made my first stop here because a lot of my Yelp friends wrote good reviews about this place so I had to try it. The reviews were pretty spot on too. They make a pretty tasty cheesesteak for a place in the hood. I also had the Steel City Steakfries which were good as well. They don't skimp that's for sure. They give you a huge container of fries topped with melted cheddar cheese, bacon, jalapenos, and a mountain of steak! I would certainly consider coming back the next time I'm in the vicinity. Even though I could never rate this place as 5 stars due to its' location in a sketchy part of town. read more

See all

I give them Five on the black hand side the SteelCity steak sandwich was truly a surprise to the taste. This was a great experience to have I had never been before but I've been supporting Black Owed business is this is a great one. See you soon SteelCity CheeseSteaks! read more

Good sandwich put always out of something! Go there cause it's right around the neighborhood

I love the food but the place is falling apart. They might have some shady looking men in there too. I dont want to say crackheads but they look like they in something just hanging around. Went in the around the first jan2020 and the ceiling damn near fallling our . The gas staion is abandon but the food still good . read more

The Steel City CheeseSteak is nothing short of amazing! Always served fresh and I never have to worry about my food being cold before I make it home. For years I've been a fan of the CheeseSteak but now my new favorite is the American Steel! I can always appreciate a restaurant that gives you great food, service CONSISTENTLY! They definitely deserve 5 Stars. read more

When I discovered this place I was so excited. The food was soooo good. I had the Pepper jack cheese steak. They had the best French fries ever. I went there recently, yesterday and the food is not the same. I don't know where those fries come from but please take them back. Bring back the other fries, also the bread is different. Makes the meal totally different and I did not like it and won't be purchasing anything else from there. read more

I could swear I've written a review before but I don't see it! I'm in shock. I've been out in Gary for work for about 11 years. This sandwich will sure give you a heart attack but it is so good. I usually go out to Philly's Best in Chicago for a great cheesesteak but it's a far drive just for a sandwich. This by far is the best Philly in Indiana. They use cheese whiz or you can get white American cheese which is the best. Love this place. Don't expect anything fancy from the inside, it's next to a gas station. It's a dive and my feet stick to the floor but it's always packed and food is always delicious. read more

Was seeking to find a good hoagie place in NWI. Found steelcity. Hoagie was just ok. Not what I'm used to. However the fish n fries were delicious! Whiting was seasoned,breaded, and cooked perfectly! I will return to try other menu items when I'm in the area. read more

I would have to admit in the past a few times they had fell off but I guess it depends who is working because I went from being very pleased until not so pleased. However my last two visits would make me take them back to 5 stars. Great job guys! read more

Bomb! A definite must if you are in the area. My husband and I both ordered the steel city cheese steak. I have no other words besides DELICIOUS! read more

Stopped by the place just to get some fries but saw the chef wrapping up a sandwich that looked so delicious that we had to at least order a small "Steel City Cheese Steak sandwich" Man...it was really juicy and filled with the taste of every ingredient throughout the sandwich. Must admit...it was one of the BEST cheese steaks I ever tasted! And I've had quite a few from all over America. We also ordered two slices of the vegan/gluten-free pies (Pecan and also Apple pie). They were OK, but thought that it would taste much better! Note: You can miss the spot, since it is connected to a gas station. read more

See all

Really surprised because this is the best Philly I've tasted in Indiana and Chicago!!!