Stefano&#x27;s

I ordered my food online for dinner for pickup. The order was ready on time. The establishment was…read moreclean and very busy. They had customers coming in and out for pickup orders. The phone was constantly ringing. They had tables for eating in but nobody was sitting in them. We ordered a large specialty pizza , wings and a salad. The food was delicious and tasty I would order again and recommend the food.

Ordering was easy, staff was friendly. Food was made in a timely manner for being a Saturday…read moreevening. Ordered philly cheese pizza, pepperoni & buffalo chicken pizzoli'

See all

Rebel Pie

4.5(120 reviews)

1.5 mi

This place is Amazing! From the moment you walk in the…read morestaff is friendly, the restaurant is clean, the appetizers are delicious, and it just continues to get better! I definitely recommend this place, it was well worth the hour I drove to try it! And the prices are great too!

When only the best will do! GREAT pizza! Love their cinnamon bites and all the rest of their…read morefood! Recommend you try it.

Wood fired oven

Smores pizza

See all

Storefront

Mellow Mushroom Florence

3.0(216 reviews)

4.9 mi

We ordered for pickup. Restaurant seemed dirty - like half the staff had called out and the half…read morethat showed up didn't know how to clean it. They forgot my kids order so the pizza sat there getting cold while it was being made. No attempt was made to keep it warm - just sitting on the shelf for 15 minutes. I don't know if it's just this location but nobody seems to give a sh*t. We had a "supreme" Caesar salad and I have to say that if putting whole leaves of wilted romaine, a few croutons and Parmesan together in a bowl is what you consider supreme, then you aced the supreme disappointment of it all. The only consistent thing was that the wilted room temp salad matched the wilted room temp pizza. First and last time we will ever eat at mellow mushroom. Pizza is just okay - I've had better and worse but generally not worse at almost $30 for a medium. Nothing about this is worth a second try. Not even meh. Just ugh.

This place is disappointing. It's busy .... I think the area needs more food options. Our pickup…read moretime ended up being 31 minutes later than told online. I went in at pick up time and calzone was ready...other two items delayed the pickup. Calzone was not good...dough was not fresh and was greasy. Staff is active but readiness was not there and food was not good. Not going back Had three of these in another city and they all eventually closed....

Bruschetta

See all

Pizza

Mamma Mia

4.4(21 reviews)

12.2 mi

Mamma Mia's has been our favorite pizza spot for the past several years. Our favorite is the cheese…read morepizza. The crust is perfect- not too thick and not too thin. It has just the right amount of crispiness. Delicious! The staff is always very friendly and personable. We look forward to Friday's- our pizza night!

This is now my go-to for pizza! The calzones are excellent as well. (We have only sampled those 2…read moreitems on the menu.) No dine-in option but we live nearby so that's not a problem. The food has been consistently excellent. Everything tastes fresh and like someone actually cares about the food they are serving. I have never really liked pizza crust and usually just eat the toppings. But I will scarf a whole slice of this pizza and actually enjoy the crust. Just the dough alone is that good! Service at the drive-thru is prompt and friendly. Can't recommend them enough!

See all

Pizza Hut

3.1(15 reviews)

2.1 mi

cashier been cool ass hell and chill everything came fast and straight order decent no bad remarkread more

No bacon was added onto my pepperoni and bacon pizza. One of the pizzas was undercooked. Overall,…read morethe pizza is very sad and bland.

See all

Papa Johns Pizza

1.3(9 reviews)

2.6 mi

Pizza wasn't even warm when I got it, more like room temperature. The driver got here earlier than…read morewhat the app said so they probably threw something they had lying around in a pizza box and brought it to me. That's the last time I order from this place.

Ordered pizza to have delivered to our hotel room, place was 10 minutes away from our hotel..said…read morewe should have it in 30 minutes..hour later we still didn't have it. Called to complain and cancelled the order which was supposed to be refunded to my CC. The next morning I found it outside of our hotel door on the ground..in the trash it went

Pizza Hut

2.0(23 reviews)

2.5 mi

Worst service ever!!! App says pizza is done but they just turn it off. 30 minutes late. NEVER BUY…read moreFROM HERE

Horrible attitudes very uncomfortable environment. Foods stale. Like what on earth is issue with…read morethese people. Crazy. Learn to keep life at home away from work stop being disrespectful. I came in for someone else not my issue your having a bad day. I would not even rate it honestly.

See all

Cicis Pizza

2.2(35 reviews)

3.5 mi

The food was great the bathroom was nice and clean l came here with my uncle he said it was great.read more

Rude manager and charged us for someone that even told her they were not going to eat! I've never…read morebeen to a restaurant with buffet and you HAD to eat!!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

19 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jacob w.

0

1

0

5 years ago

It's an Italian Restaurant so spaghetti or lasagna is a no brainer you won't be disappointed!!! But if you wanna great sandwich try the Italian grinder just like it comes maybe a little extra toasted same for their pizza top notch also ask for this one to be extra crisp you will love it!! Great service great family!! read more

Denise B.

0

3

0

9 years ago

Have been searching for good pizza and subs since I moved here a couple years ago and finally I have found this wonderful place. It is comparable to a pizza parlor in the NJ/NY area. Excellent food, decent prices, nice and clean with friendly staff. read more

Janna C.

0

1

0

10 years ago

Best pizza in town in my opinion. Love the thinner crust, awesome cheese, friendly staff. The price is about right for the kind of pizza you are getting. Other menu items were good also. We order mainly takeout and are always satisfied. read more

Erika J.

Elite 25

219

164

237

2 years ago

Our waitress was amazing, she was so nice and very attentive. The food was really good and I definitely don't mind going to try other food options. The place was really nice and I can see why it stays pretty busy. read more

Jan D.

1

6

0

16 years ago

Never had a bad meal here! The only reason for no 5th star is that sometimes it takes a while to get seated. Food is wonderful! Ann and Steve are always so willing to please, I just love it! read more

Sarah R.

0

3

1

11 years ago

I have been a customer of Stefano's for a very long time. Their food is always so fresh and delicious. I've never had anything from there that wasn't amazing read more

Andrea S.

3

1

0

5 years ago

Such an amazing dining place! The food was absolutely amazing and so were the staff. Hands down the best Italian food I've had! Please check them out read more

Its R.

0

1

3

8 years ago

The bread and the food is so so good so so so so so so so so so so good good good good good good good so so so so so so so so so good

Nisha M.

0

5

0

4 years ago

I would recommend anyone to try this restaurant the food is very amazing here & good definitely should try . I loved the food here

Geo F.

0

7

0

8 years ago

Great place for amazing food. This place has the best Italian food in the area! Service is always great. Love eating here

Donna S.

0

2

0

9 years ago

The food here is so good. i have never had anything at Stefano's that was no amazing. great pizza, even better pasta.

Keith C.

0

1

0

11 years ago

The stefano pizza is one of the best,along with the steak and chesse. MMMMmmmmmm goooooooooood!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Kathy H.

9

5

0

10 years ago

I love this place! The food is awesome you absolutely get what you pay for and the people are great.

Anne P.

2

1

12 years ago

Amazing first visit here, will definitely be coming back to try more!! Excellent service and food!

Jourdon W.

0

1

0

5 years ago

Just plain slack I hate it and then I saw roaches all up in the place just baby roaches everywhere

Visible Changes H.

37

5

0

13 years ago

Authentic taste, large portions, great service!

Tihn N.

0

3

0

9 years ago

Quaint fresh and delicious. Will be back.

Steve F.

19

9

0

11 years ago

Good food, I wish they delivered

PeeDee F.

0

1

0

17 years ago

Absolutely a must-do in FLO.

Stefano's - italian - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Stefano's also viewed

Cibo by Stefano's

3.7

(83 reviews)

We visited Cibo by Stefanos today for a casual family dinner -- our first time there. My wife, our…read moretoddler daughter, and I were hoping for a chill family spot, and the restaurant did have a "hole in the wall" vibe that felt casual enough. Unfortunately, the food and service didn't live up to expectations. I ordered a calzone, my daughter had spaghetti with Alfredo sauce, and my wife had shrimp scampi. The only positive was portion size. Everything else fell flat: my wife's meal came out cold and bland, the shrimp was tough, and the sauce tasted canned. The bread was stale and cold, and my calzone felt more like a Hot Pocket than a freshly made dish. Service was slow and unenthusiastic, like the staff didn't want to be there. Considering the prices, the experience was not worth it at all. I would not return or recommend this place -- I would give it 0 stars if I could.

Ordered take out based on the reviews here…read more.. Calamari was soggy but it's takeout so it was expected. Cavatappi pasta with meat sauce was so salty and overly cooked. The bread was stale. The Stromboli was okay. Nothing spectacular. Maybe we missed the mark and should've ordered the pizza instead.

Mamma Mia

4.4

(21 reviews)

Mamma Mia's has been our favorite pizza spot for the past several years. Our favorite is the cheese…read morepizza. The crust is perfect- not too thick and not too thin. It has just the right amount of crispiness. Delicious! The staff is always very friendly and personable. We look forward to Friday's- our pizza night!

This is now my go-to for pizza! The calzones are excellent as well. (We have only sampled those 2…read moreitems on the menu.) No dine-in option but we live nearby so that's not a problem. The food has been consistently excellent. Everything tastes fresh and like someone actually cares about the food they are serving. I have never really liked pizza crust and usually just eat the toppings. But I will scarf a whole slice of this pizza and actually enjoy the crust. Just the dough alone is that good! Service at the drive-thru is prompt and friendly. Can't recommend them enough!

IL BUONGUSTAIO

3.6

(36 reviews)

We arrived about 45 minutes from closing. I was concerned because I know service can go downhill at…read morethis point. It absolutely did not! The waiter was extremely pleasant & helpful. The decor was so nice & it created an atmosphere that was so welcoming. The food was so delicious we made plans to visit already! The hubby had the swordfish dish. The ravioli was freshly made & cooked to perfection. I opted for vegetables instead of pasta. Everything was seasoned perfectly. My only disappointment was they ran out of risotto & that was the dish I initially came for. That was my fault for going so late though. Overall, highly recommend!!

Food A+ Services A+…read moreAtmosphere A+ My date said the reservation process was simple and accommodating. This is one of our "Romantic Spots"

New York By The Slice

3.9

(65 reviews)

Ambiance was nice. Service was good…read more Food was good. Pizza was 4/5 Wings were 3.8/5 They say I need eighty-

I ordered a Deluxe 18" pizza to go, took it home, was in a 14" box, measured it, it WAS14", but…read morepaid for 18" pizza, can't fit THAT in a14" box, box even says size on bottom, 14". It was delicious, just beware, maybe just an error, other entrees looked/smelled awsome. Just an error, DEFINITELY GO THERE, greeted by attentive waitresses, food is Excellent!! Next time , Chick Parm!!

Miguel's Grill

3.7

(24 reviews)

Food is horrible. They treated me badly . The ambiance is bad! I would not recommend this!read more

the owners are so nice, family owned and are all so nice! food is always fresh and very good. The…read moredecor is very home feel and friendly.

Town House Drive-In Restaurant

3.3

(43 reviews)

Our ladies group went there with a group of 9. There were no complaints on the food or the…read morepricing. So that's a plus. All was delicious & plentiful serving. I had a Gyro with Fries & it was enough for 2 people & as I looked at others meals I think they all would agree as most took to go boxes. Service was OK though they need to use a mike to call out the numbers. Maybe cause it was full & the conversations going around were all enjoying each others company. I would return!

Was catered this restaurant at work and wasn't disappointed. The flounder was very good and fresh…read moreand I thought the meal sizes were fair. Not having paid I'm not sure if it's worth the money or not but it was a good little meal all together. That said, I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here. I also want to note I didn't visit this establishment and can't vouch for anything there.

The Peddler Steak House

3.3

(55 reviews)

We had a party of 20 for dinner at Peddlers. The food was exceptionable, but the cocktails, not so…read moremuch. What REALLY ruined it for us was the very poor service. When we arrived, the hostess gave us a half-hearted greeting and pointed us to our dining room instead of escorting us. The waitress was cold, never smiled nor did she introduce herself. For the most part, the men were on one side of the table with the women were on the opposite side. The waitress started taking the orders of the men before the women. The food came out in a reasonable time and we all enjoyed our meals. Once we paid our checks the waitress disappeared. There was no "goodbye and thanks for dining with us" along with an invitation to return, and we won't. I hate to go there but the entire service experience wreaked of discrimination, because that atmosphere did not extend to the rest of restaurant patrons which were mostly Caucasian. My husband and I were visiting from Georgia, but our family lives in and around Florence, SC. Needless to say that's 18 other people that will not return and will likely share their poor experience w/others. In case you were unaware, word-of-mouth advertising is worth its weight and gold for a restaurant.

This place was surprisingly good. Staff is friendly and the food is better than expected.read more

Tubb's Shrimp & Fish Co.

4.6

(792 reviews)

Let me start with the service, it was kind of crowded, but the hostess told me I arrived after the…read morewait, so I was seated immediately. I ordered the fried fish and shrimp combo with Brussels sprouts and Hoppin' John. My server recommended the Hoppin' John and I am so glad she did. It was delicious, perfectly seasoned and just so freaking good. My fish and shrimp was fried to perfection, crispy and melt in your mouth good. My Brussels sprouts were good too, but after I finished my delicious foods, I had to take my Brussels to go! Nice setting, lots of space and the servers were spot on, they did not miss a beat. Definitely making a special trip back to Florence to eat at Tubb's. Highly recommended.

Starting with our server Angel, she gets five stars, maybe 7, nice personality great follow up,…read morealways checking to make sure everything was right! And the blackened shrimp and flounder and the sides, grill squash out of this world, and I'm a fried everything guy. Been back in two weeks and had seafood 3 times, and we live in Horry County, seafood Capital of the world. Got to get the support our local hookers t-shirts. Great great place!!! Try it you love it!

Lil D's Dugout

3.0

(24 reviews)

My 1st since they moved on S. Irby St. The double cheese burger and fries were really good! I will…read morebe back. I want to try the A1 burger, my bestie said it was good as well. The staff is very nice.

We decided to try the Wing Buffet for $9.99. We were outraged when we received our check and they…read morehad charged us $5.99 kids buffet for our 16 month old grandbaby! NEVER have we had to pay for a child under 2 years old to eat buffet ... that is absolutely ridiculous! The wings were okay ... the rest of the food wasn't that great. They kept our glasses full and empty plates removed from the table, but they are very unfriendly and seem "stuck up" and bothered by serving you. I doubt very seriously we will bother them with our presence again!

Venus Restaurant & Catering

3.4

(37 reviews)