Came to Stella's after doing the Polar Express with my son and the larger family. Got parking right out front which was a nice surprise. We chose this because we thought they had a ton of holiday decor, however was mistaken; it's just an old school bar that serves Italian food. Service was very attentive and friendly. In general, everyone in there was chill and happy which is always a good sign. Ordered a few negronis which were all well made. We got the eggplant rollatini, fried calamari and house salad to start. They really don't skimp on the portions. Calamari included tentacles which I didn't expect from this kind of place; it was fresh and pretty much as good as it gets, especially upstate. Eggplant rollatini was well made and showcased their really good sauce. House salad is loaded up with cheese (parmigiana and gorgonzola) however I mean that in the best way; it eats like a Caesar, and it's a massive portion. Got the penne ala vodka with chicken cutlet for my main although I was tempted by the bolognese special. It was damned good. Vodka sauce was fantastic, and chicken cutlet was plentiful and on the well done side. I think I got 3 meals out of this and I'm not a small dude. Great meal all around and the perfect cap to our day. I don't make it to Kingston much however I would come here whenever nearby. Vibe is great and the food is better. Never a bad thing to have another reliable Italian place around! read more

Best salads! Tender steak. House combo was delicious. Roasted vegetables with Asiago My favorite for Italian food in the area. Staff is friendly and helpful. Not too noisy. Feels like and old school neighborhood spot. Parking on street or in lot. Just a heads up: I was charged a "to go" fee for an item I ordered to go. If I was aware there was a fee, I would just have ordered it and packed it up myself.‍ read more

Stella's Italian Restaurant - a painting of a baseball player - Italian Near Me - Kingston, New York

See all

Blown away. We weren't expecting to be... The Kingston Car Show was happening and we were hungry, we had the dog, where to have lunch? Well Stella's has a hidden outdoor patio, gorgeous bar. And the food, I felt like I was in Europe~fresh, delicious, "Mmm" is an international word. Service was excellent. They even put on the EPL game for the hubbyOur new favorite local place read more

Fried calamari was great got dinner and salad to go not soo good. First off the pasta was obviously not home made paid 33$ for pasta that probably came out of a box.yeah not happy disappointed.they say restaurant based on grandma's recipes I doubt grandma was using store bought pasta read more

Love the atmosphere. It has a classic Yankees motif. It's in uptown Kingston, but it's priced right anyway. However, I ordered them that we need and clam sauce which is my go to test for any Italian restaurant I got linguine with spaghetti. Really! I came with a decent salad. It was kind of oily. My son can enjoy his burger very much clam appetizer. It was good but not plentiful, and the bought overnight table was a different color from the other yellow lights. The bathrooms were in meh condition which always gives me an idea of what is happens in the background. The service was excellent, but the food not so much. read more

See all

We had dinner here last night and it was wonderful. The bartenders were very nice, our server, Cara, was terrific and the food , perfect. Looking forward to returning. read more

So here we are starving and in Kingston. The historic district with quaint colonial houses We tried one other place, who's name will not be mentioned. They couldn't accommodate us because of staffing issues! So around the corner we go We come in and are greeted by Barbara the owner. She has some Brooklyn roots and is cool Our waitress is Jess and we ask to see the wine menu. Barbara recommends the Hess Cabernet.L and it is delicious! For beginners we start with minestrone soup. Fabulous. The taste was amazing. For entrees we do a salad with steak. The steak is on the side no strips! Wow. Salad portion, not even Buggs Bunny could finish. I order the rigatoni with sausage peas in tomato cream sauce. Unbelievably good. Tasty sauce seasoned just right We finish off with espresso and tartuffo. Well you can stick a fork in us! So much much take home food! Barbara and Jess are delightful and we promise to come back!! read more

Great service , Great Lasagna, alway a pleasure . Ate at the bar to watch the Ballgame. Good time

Another small biz in Downtown Kingston, NY. I had the spaghetti and meatballs with a ginger ale. I got greens with crumbled cheese that was a nice start. The meatballs are huge. And the seafood Ning was perfect. The pasta was cooked very well, and the whole plate was delicious! I am very full- packed most of the meal up for later when I get home. read more

The food is perfection. From the insane white bean dip they serve with the bread to the best salad and garlic bread.. the crab cake was divine, the penne vodka beyond and Nonas Apple crisp with the best crust ever. I mean this place BLOWS Cucina in Woodstock out of the water with it's authenticity and love in every dish. It's as close to a family Italian meal as you will ever get. Service was spot on and genuine. Sure there are alot of tvs and the art and design is meh but who cares when the food is this good. read more

My family and I love coming here. We were on our way up from NYC to go snowboarding and it happened that Kingston was just about the halfway point. We used yelp to search for restaurants and we settled on Stella's. The bar area can be a little noisy but the food is so good you forget all that. The house salad is so simple and yet so good, it might be the best thing on the menu. Entree wise I've become partial to the house combo which consists of eggplant parm, lasagna and a stuffed pepper. I have difficulty in trying not to eat the whole thing. If you happen to be in the area, check it out. read more

This place has always been great. My friend and I came here a few weeks ago and the food was great as always but the prices have one up so ridiculously, we will never be back. Most restaurants in the area have gone up but holy moly not this much. The new place across the street steals all the business now, or even Hoffman House. Hoffamans went up too but their portions did not change and you can eat a meal for two days. read more

Excellent hearty portions & service was exceptional even though we were close to closing time. Highly recommend.

Love this place. Everything I have had to eat is delicious, tried a little bit of everything my favorite was their filet. You won't be disappointed. Great service! read more

Everything is awesome! The meatballs are spectacular. WARNING- they use ALOT of salad dressing. Make sure you ask for it on the side. Otherwise, they will drench it. Like swimming lettuce... While the price point is a little higher than other area establishments, they have good portions, aren't afraid of garlic, and the staff is very kind and attentive. read more

I have visited Stella's three times for dinner and the food and service has been consistently good. Not 5 star, but a solid 3.5 to 4 star visit each time. They have a nice selection of beers on tap, including the seasonal Sam Adams and there are flat screen TV's in the bar. The restaurant side is somewhat small, but we always make a reservation in advance to avoid waiting. There are also a few tables in the bar side if the restaurant side is full. The bread/breadsticks basket with hummas is a nice change from the standard butter or oil/vinegar usually served at Italian restaurants. However, they will definitely give you those condiments if you ask. The salad looks deciptively plain, but it's actually a robust romaine salad with a garlicky dressing and huge pieces of bleu cheese. Tonight I went old school and ordered chicken parmigiano with a side of penne. The red sauce is fantastic- chunky tomato that is a little tart, not sweet. The chicken was pounded thin and fried to a perfect crispness and topped with cheese, but not an overpowering amount of cheese. The penne was al dente and served with the same tangy red sauce. read more

Stella's Italian Restaurant - Chicken parmigiano - Italian Near Me - Kingston, New York

Still great food, clean bar, outdoor seating in back was done very well. Buffalo Calamari isn't on their menu but they do make it, and it's the best in town. Filet Mignon is my favorite. Owner and staff are friendly. Only down side is they are closed Monday and Tuesday. read more

Wow, this place is seriously overpriced for the rather mediocre "Italian" food they serve; it seems to mean that putting a lot of garlic everywhere makes it Italian. Simple fried calamari appetizer set you back $18, the special menu has no prices on it and the sever is not volunteering to mention them without you having to ask. Be aware: a mixed cheese/meat appetizer platter is $35 and the filet is $57! Really! Even pretty plain salad with shrimp or chicken puts you in the upper $20s, same for plain pasta dishes. Sides: $10.50 for vegetables and 12.50 for for example sausage??? I'd this were great cooking, fine, but....Rocky, dry mashed potatoes are their staple side dish. Slightly oily and over-salted salad. Similar, drinks and wine, nothing special. Adding tax and tips . Portions are good, and so are atmosphere and ambience. Except that on cold days, the wind blows in with every person opening the door....curtain anyone? read more

One of the best family owned spots in the Valley! Everything is fresh and you never leave there hungry. This is a go to place for us.

We were forced into a 3.5 star spot because of limited options on a COVID Sunday afternoon so TBH I had almost no expectations entering this place. It was a little run down on entry so I was even more pleasantly surprised by the food. The salad that accompanied our shared fettuccini Alfredo was so fresh and green with this light oil and vinegar dressing and the breading on our calamari was light and not super deep fried. I'm kind of a pasta snob having traveled Italy quite a bit and the Alfredo was great. I recommend this place on a Sunday with no options or any day with all the restaurants open. Kind staff and good food. read more

Great food. Portion sizes are huge. Their meatballs are like small meat loaves. You can get full just eating that alone. The salad was good with gorgonzola cheese. The fettuccine Alfredo had enough sauce it wasn't dry. The marinara sauce was seasoned just fine. No room for dessert read more

Really good. Old school Italian. I was here several years ago and re-visited this past week. I went with 2 others and had a blast. First - the bread basket is practically a meal itself. Warm Italian bread, sesame breadsticks and a fabulously dense roll all make for a carb-lovers par-tay. These are served with a white bean dip; a nice alternative to butter or olive oil. Appetizers? We shared the baked clams. Quite good - lots of garlic and not too greasy. Nice chunks of clam to keep you busy. Then they brought out a giant caesar salad for us all to share. I could have eaten that all day. The small chunks of cheese (guessing parmesan), tossed with the crisp, cold lettuce in a wonderful dressing made me very happy. For main courses: I had the salmon which was served in a lemon sauce (not too buttery - which was perfect) and black olives. Loved it. I asked for the salmon to be as rare as possible - they delivered. Perfectly cooked. The others had linguine with clam sauce and a sampler (which included lasagne, stuffed pepper and eggplant). Great reviews all around. The linguine had an insane amount of clams - a few really big ones in the shell...but the rest were chopped up throughout the rest of the dish. No room for dessert. Great Italian in Kingston. I would definitely visit Stella's again. read more

Great Italian food and great bar come here from palm beach Florida my friend Lilly grandparents own this place good people and outstanding food good little shopping area to read more

Stella's Italian Restaurant - a plate of chicken with gravy and pasta - Italian Near Me - Kingston, New York

This restaurant is so delicious and the staff very attentive. The outdoor area is so nice! Casual but THE BEST.

Food was OK but not overly great. Service was terrible. Waitress took 10 minutes to get to us and her first comment was "so you ready to order?". She barely spoke to us. Cleared plates timely but with out asking how things were. Took my beer glass without asking if I wanted another. Prices way too high. Mediocre at best. Probably won't be back. read more

This review would be more of a 3.5 star but there's no halvesies on Yelp. Sometimes... foodies like me need something a little more 'classic' and last night... that's exactly what I got at Stella's. Sure there are some great foodietastic eats options in uptown, but last night I was hankering for something a little more old school. I was jonezin for Veal Milanase and the chef made it special for me without hesitation. It was delicious, fresh tomato and arugula on top, mmm freakin awesome. The house salad was divine and I scarfed down the huge portion of penne ala vodka which they also offered me instead of regular marinara. The wine situation was a bummer, when I asked for wine list, and wanted to know what they had, there were the usual pinot grigio, sauvinon blanc etc... but man the one I got was pretty cheap and not tasty. There didn't seem to be much option for wine choice just white house, red house or buy a bottle. One other bummer was the service, or lack thereof. It took a very, very long time before someone acknowledged us. Once she did come, she was ok, but when I asked if something was 'good' or for recommendations the girl seemed to draw a blank. If you've read my other reviews, you know I get so annoyed when a server can't speak to the menu. RESTAURANT: FEED YOUR PEOPLE YOUR FOOD SO THEY CAN SAY SOMETHING ABOUT IT!! I'm also dumbfounded as to why we were given one bruschetta at the beginning of the meal instead of one for each of us. My kid and I shared it, which was sort of weird for what we spent, I wish they gave us both one. While there were nicer tables by the window we were relegated to a table behind signage, and the waitress seemed to not know we were there. The hostess came and took our order for drinks after noticing we were forgotten where we were seated... behind signage not at the nice window table where she sat 'regulars' she seemed to know over us. I figure if we go back a few more times, we won't be relegated to 2nd class seating. Despite the crappy table and the off service, we loved our food and I'd definitely go back soon to try their other offerings. read more

Went with a good friend for lunch and we both ordered a salad with shrimp. A large bowl of lettuce and 4 large shrimp, no tomatoes, no cucumbers, no red onion, just lettuce and blue cheese. An Italian restaurant without tomato's? For $15.00 seriously? The shrimp were a good size but bland in taste. Very disappointed. Properly won't go again... read more

Amazing authentic Italian food. Period. There are the classics like lasagna, ziti, chicken parm, etc, and some other specialty items that typically aren't done by other restaurants due to their complexity. They put their own spin on several typical meals, and the specials (although I did not have one) sounded on the exotic side of Italian food, but delicious. Expect lots of dishes that mix up interesting flavors and different uses of meats/vegetables that may surprise you. read more

So I wish we could give a 3.5 star review. We have been to Stella's a couple of times when we go home to visit family. We love the sauce and good food which normally would get a 4-5 star review. However this past weekend we visited and the food was just ok. It was VERY salty including the bruschetta. I love salt and this was way over seasoned for even my taste. I hope to increase the rating on our next visit so we can write this off as a fluke. read more

Excellent assortment of classic Italian food (lasagna, shrimp & chicken parmigiana, pasta) and new specials every visit. I've never had a meal that I didn't like, and I've been there over 20 times. Their steamed clams, fried calamari and fillet Mignon are real standouts, in my opinion. I'm a in a wheelchair and both their new or old sections are handicap accessible. The serving and bar crew are staffed by the owner's family members and friends, which I believe allows the staff to be spend a couple of minutes chatting with the dinner patrons, which I enjoy. read more

We loved this place! It came recommended by my brother and his gf and boy was it scrumptious. We got Chicken Parmesan, seafood in broth and a grilled veggie plate. Wow! The house was salad was to die for! Service = amazing. I live in LA and am from NYC, this rivals any of the best restaurants in either city. Go! read more

This place is very much your classic old school red sauce joint. Very lively crowd on Friday night, and our waitress was very gracious and warm. I'm pretty fed up with fancy Italian restaurants in NYC that charge $25+ for a fussy serving with like 5 raviolis....this place does not mess around like that. Portions are HUGE, and your money definitely goes a long way here. I had enough leftovers from my pasta entree for lunch the next day read more

Great Italian food. Great portion size. Very reasonably priced. Great place for a shared app, two entrees, and a bottle of wine. The lasagna is delicious. read more

We've eaten here several times and it's always an awesome experience. Wait staff is stellar and the food is incredible. Our favorite is the filet (a huge portion always perfectly cooked) and the shrimp francaise with its extra large shrimp and amazing sauce. read more

Decent Italian menu. Had the lasagna and daily special of pork chops. Came with a side (delicious garlic broccoli), house salad and trio of breads with addictive white bean spread. Portions are large. On the pricier side. Star off for the tomato wine sauce for the pork chop. It seemed like the wine was added as an afterthought; a lightweight could realistically get tipsy drinking it. Good music selection. Dining room is a bit dark though. Meh+. read more

We went here for dinner with a couple who are regulars over the years. They did a good job with service and the food was good quality. The fritto misto appetizer was very good - they know how to cook calamari and the dipping sauce was nice - aoli instead of red sauce. Chicken sorrentino (prosciutto, eggplant, mozz) was unusual and satisfying. The spinach ravioli in alfredo sauce were excellent. Meatballs are huge - the size of softballs. All in all, a good local family run italian restaurant. read more

Went for some drinks before dinner across the street and were pleasntly surprised with the reasonable prices, friendly bartenders and similar atmosphere to our favorite local, hometown bar! Will definitely be stopping in next time we're up that way! read more

Wow! Can't believe it took so long to try this place out. It is exquisite! Gives Guido's off Broadway a run for their money. Brasciole was exceptional. Rare to find that done well, Stella's knocked it out of the park. We will absolutely be back. In our opinion, it's the best Italian in Kingston. Atmosphere is great too, cozy and intimate. 5 stars all around. And I don't give those out often! read more

We have been going to Stella's for many years and two things we can always count on is great food and excellent service, both at a great price. One of our favorite restaurants! read more

We checked out every restaurant in downtown Kingston and chose Stella's because of the ambience . I did read a review that raved about a salad they had there. We ordered the salad of the day for our lunch which was chicken on arugula with avocado etc and it was beyond delicious. Loved the ambience and the wait staff read more