Nice spot. I went with a group of thirteen people which is unusual for me. Young waiters did quite a good job in serving the table which wasn't easy. Food was good. I had an Aperol Spritz which I enjoyed. Rigatoni bolognese was very good. It was very noisy at first but as other diners left it really mellowed out. The nice thing was our group stayed quite late and the restaurant emptied out but they graciously let us stay and not feel uncomfortable. Very classy. read more

See all

Went to Market Street for a friend's birthday party. I'm the only vegan. No matter where I go, I can usually survive with spaghetti and marinara sauce, and an iceberg lettuce salad with a tomato wedge. So here I got an upgraded meal: penne pasta putanesca and an arugula salad with pears & pistachios. Nicely done. I'm grateful for at least a meal. Some restaurants, I cannot get a meal, I order 3 side dishes. The back room is nice for parties, a little quieter than the front. Service was perfect. That makes a big difference in the experience. The parking lot adjacent was full, but there is plenty of parking across the street and also on the other side. Bathroom was clean. The birthday girl enjoyed trout, and a small warm chocolate cake with ice cream, with a candle. Delicious! She had to ask the waitress, what is gluten free because the menu is not clearly labeled. I think there is room for improvement, that is easy and cheap. We got a bottle of wine , it was served in regular glasses, we had to request wine glasses for wine. My wife got Swordfish. Enjoyed some and brought home the rest. Asked Google if she could give it to the dog. Google said No! Don't feed your dog swordfish because of the High Mercury! If you can't feed it to the dog, people can't eat it either! So she threw it in the garbage. I think Market Street should re evaluate their menu choices. Also, Market Street could do better than inexpensive pasta for vegans and vegetarians, at this price point. Something with beans or soy meat, vegan Italian sausage, there is so much out there in 2025. We left the 1900's a long time ago. Even the CIA in neighboring Hyde Park is teaching vegan cooking. How about an upgrade? Please? Helpful? read more

See all

Visiting one of our favorite places, Rhinebeck. I've always wanted to try Market Street, but for some reason never did up until tonight. And we are so happy that we did. The vibe, the people and the food were fantastic. We shared a delicious salad with artichoke, shaved Parmesan and arugula in a balsamic dressing. For our entrées, we enjoyed pasta with peas in a slightly spicy marinara sauce and crispy squid with aïoli dip. Everything tasted very fresh and super flavorful. So glad we finally made it there! Our server was so friendly and knowledgeable, and upbeat, and she really elevated our experience. read more

See all

My spouse and I had a nice time while at Market St. The service was great! The food was good! We split a Caesar salad, which was huge! Then we both ordered a pizza. The crust was great! Thin, crispy but had some chewiness to it too! Ambiance was cozy, but it was a bit loud. I will say I was disappointed in the chiffon cake. Typically, that style of cake is light, and fluffy. This one was dense and dry. Big thumbs down for me. I ended up getting a scoop of the Carmel gelati, which was delicious! read more

Market St - I don't remember the name of this special pizza, but it had kale, mushrooms and balsamic. - Italian Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

Great place for a date if they don't care how the food tastes. Atmosphere: A+. Great vibe for date night. Perfect soft lighting, not too loud even when busy. Service: B+. Friendly but a little slow and disorganized. We were seated for 15 minutes before we had drinks in front of us. Drinks: B+. The mixes seemed off. She had a margarita that seemed super strong, like it was almost all tequila. She would normally have two, but didn't finish the first one. I had a Moscow mule that was super weak and I couldn't taste the ginger beer. Food: C. Except for the meatballs appetizer, it was all really bland. Also had the arancini, and the texture was perfect but the sauce it came with had little flavor. We actually used the leftover marinara from the meatballs to give the arancini some taste. I had the steak. Perfectly cooked, buttery texture, but just really bland. She had the pork chop and the same experience. Perfectly cooked, just without any distinct flavor. Dessert was a puzzle. We ordered the butterscotch budino to take home. Bizarrely, it was topped with what appeared to be a dark chocolate mousse rather than butterscotch. It had very little sweetness and was also thin in flavor. We only tried a couple of spoonfuls before throwing them out. $300 for two, including tip. Too much money for too little flavor. Maybe the pizza is good. read more

This restaurant was such a wonderful surprise. We could not decide where to go on a Tuesday night when so many other restaurants are closed and luckily found this restaurant! Immediately when you enter you are greeted by a friendly hostess. The vibe inside was a rustic homey environment. Outside had both covered and uncovered seating. Service was friendly and I never felt like I had to ask for more water. Lastly and most importantly, the food was fantastic! We tried the special pizza which had a perfectly crunchy pie with a chewy soft crust. The sauce was sweet with a perfect consistency. It had eggplant and mozzarella cheese which were a great combination for both texture and taste. We also had the salmon dish which was perfectly cooked. Normally salmon comes too raw for my taste and this was flaky and buttery. I highly recommend this restaurant and can't wait to return soon! read more

Market St - Slow Baked Salmon, corn pudding with a tomato vinaigrette - Italian Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

See all

I'm giving 2 stars because the service was great! But the food, a whole different story. They managed to kill the Rib-Eye steak again, completely burned on the outside and a chewing gum inside. The veal was half done and with no taste and a chewing consistency, a shame. We brought a friend who came for a visit from overseas! Over the $300 for low grade cooking. read more

This restaurant is such a cute date spot or night out! The ambiance and decor is super cute and the food is also really good! We made reservations so we got seated right away. For appetizers, we got the clam chowder which was a special and it was pretty solid. Really generous chunks of clam which was surprising. For entrees, we got the rigatoni and the caprina pizza. The rigatoni is popular here but we honestly loved the pizza way more. It was so unique and different and I highly recommend getting it! The rigatoni was okay, but the peas were undercooked so they were a bit crunchy. I honestly think the rigatoni was our least favorite thing the whole night. The dessert however was sooo good. We got the butterscotch budino and it was so so good. Definitely try it if you're here! Overall, definitely recommend this place for a night out or if you're visiting the area. We were visiting for the weekend and it was definitely the best food we had. read more

See all

It's good! Good service, decent portions, but def overpriced lol. I've had food just as good at cheaper places. Idk if I like it enough to return. read more

Dinner at market Street is always a scene. Even on Wednesday, when we visited, it was busy. We had to wait about 15 to 20 minutes for a table but they do have various spots to wait comfortably. You can always go to the bar, which is almost always full when I have been there, or you can take one of the low tables across from the bar that have two seats each. Once seated, service was prompt and very friendly. Multiple people stop by to refill water, drop off drinks, and of course your service takes your order and engages the most with you. Very friendly and knowledgeable servers and staff. The ambience is always fun. Really good vibes in this place. It's services clientele of all ages, but it is very much a Rhinebeck type crowd. We ordered several things. We had the pizza special that night, pasta, puttanesca, and fries. Oh, we also got a salad. All of it was very good. I find the food a teeny bit salty, but overall the ingredients are fresh and it taste delicious. This is a very reliable go-to place. I would definitely recommend calling ahead for a reservation as they do get very busy. The food and the service is always very good. I would highly recommend it and definitely go back. read more

Market St - Salad and pasta and fries - Italian Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

With a warm and inviting atmosphere, Market St. delivers on ambiance as well as delicious food. Service was friendly and attentive, without being excessive. It's a great place for a group dinner or a romantic evening out. Definitely recommend a reservation. This neighborhood gem is a standout. read more

Fresh food, abundant waiting staff and nice ambiance ... what can go wrong with this combination? It was a mystery why we had to wait 45 minutes before our food turned up, while watching table after table of those who came after us receiving their meals. We were 4 for brunch, two ordered Eggs Benedict, one ordered Grilled Cheese Sandwich while I asked for Avocado Multigrain Toast (lactose-free vegetarian). The food was fresh and tasty, although we kept wondering where the other half of the bacon was on the Grilled Cheese Sandwich ... Our local Rhinebeck friend said this restaurant was her favorite spot in town, and alas! it sure let her down for wanting to make it our favorite too. read more

See all

Everything we are was delicious and generous portions. Bright might flavors without overwhelming the primary ingredients. Super service a.d nice atmosphere. Wine list good. read more

We enjoyed our evening at Market Street. We were staying at the Journey Inn and they highly recommended this restaurant. We arrived a little early for our reservation and so sad at the bar. Service by Ashley was fantastic. She shared with us a little bit about the area and her drinks were perfectly concocted (Old fashion and martini). Good Service continued with Liam at dinner. Food was very good. They allow and encouraged half orders of appetizers and salads, although surprisingly they charge you much more than half price, which didn't seem right. Their calamari is among the best I have tried anywhere. Other highlights were the lentil soup, the gnocchi special, and the pork scallopini. The mozzarella salad was a bit disappointing. No dessert tonight but they looked like there were several very interesting and good offerings. Maybe next time read more

Market St - Pork Tenderloin Scallopini - Italian Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

See all

They're nice and they're trying but the food is really not that good. Caesar salad had no dressing, same with the pasta special. The steak was all fat, a little disappointing with the higher prices... read more

Probably one of the most lively restaurants in the Rhinebeck area. Market St. is the perfect restaurant for any occasion--whether you're enjoying a casual dinner with family, date night or evening out. The restaurant is cozy and beautifully decorated. We sat on a table near the pizza oven but sadly none of us ordered pizza. I thought the service was excellent, especially for how busy they were. Our server asked us if we wanted lemon slices for our water and brought bread right away. As far as food, the portions were big and everything was cooked excellently. I loved the calamari, my pasta and the hazelnut gelato for dessert was amazing!!! The gelato was probably a standout alone. I would definitely recommend Market St. read more

See all

we loved our meal... All the dishes and drinks were so delicious and flavorful. It's a treat of the evening with our Server AK - what a fine young man. read more

Came here for the first time for after work drinks and snacks. We ordered drinks, the Wood Oven Roasted Brussels Sprouts (Wood oven roasted brussels sprouts, chorizo, pomegranate, spicy honey) and Robbiola Pizza (Robiolina cheese filled pizza, truffle oil, sea salt. Neapolitan style, wood burning brick oven). They were so delicious. We expected the pizza to be bigger but it was good. We had the Brussell sprouts because we just needed vegetables since we had just had drinks and fried food at the Beekman Arms. Lol The drinks were also good but they really didn't rock our world hence the four stars. The bar opens at 5 pm but we showed ups little earlier and they turned on the outside heaters which was so nice. The bartender was super friendly and attentive. The Rosemary popcorn was great and she kept refilling the bowl. The place filled up by the time we left so the entrees must be pretty good. I'd like to v Im me back for dinner. read more

We had a very disappointing dinner last night. The fish was of poor quality and both the fish and couscous were slathered in oil. We requested seats in the back because it is always noisy at Market St. however there a loud unpleasant sound coming from the refrigeration. The manager said there was nothing to be done about it. Really? The last meal I had there was also bad. The kale salad which I used to order quite often was too chewy and tough. The waitress Juliet was wonderful, warm and cheerful. This was always my family's go to restaurant. But we are done with Market St. read more

One of our favorite restaurants in the area that never disappoints. This place gets packed on weekends so you definitely need a reservation and for good reason, great food and service. The meatballs are always great and recently tried the shrimp which was also very nice. On our most recent visit really loved the pork entree but have tried virtually everything on the menu including the pizzas (which are perfect to share with a group). We also always love the rosemary fries which are a must as a side. read more

As residents of the Rhinebeck area for nearly a decade, Market Street has been one of our standbys. Friendly and attentive staff, great for family night out, date nights and large parties with warm and homey vibe during the colder months. Love the whole roasted chicken dish and puttanesca but overall the menu is well balanced. They keep the specials fresh, our son likes to watch the fire grilled pizza oven at the tables in the back and they're often accommodating with walk-ins. A great neighborhood spot. read more

Great food and drinks in a beautiful atmosphere. But the staff. Oh the staff!! Beautiful, knowledgeable young staff who are seasoned with the best of them. Bravo!! read more

Nice cute place. Excellent team service. We had our server, but everyone made sure we were taken care of. Wife had eggplant parm which was great and a salad. I had the quinoa bowl with salmon. Salmon cooked perfectly. read more

Great food, incredible service. 5 stars! Loved everything. So much better than "Pretty I Think So" down the street. We will be back! read more

Market St - Affogato - Italian Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

Quaint little spot in Rhineback right off the Main Street. Although the pizza was slightly under done the flavor was great. Bartender Gabby and staff were extremely friendly. read more

Market St - Prosciutto, arugula, & mozzarella pie - Italian Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

This was an excellent Italian Restaurant. The place was nicely decorated and the wait staff was very attentive. My wife and I had a tasty green salad to start. Then we both had pasta dishes for our main course. The dishes were both excellent. I had clams with spaghetti and the sauce was very flavorful. My wife also enjoyed her tagliatelle with red sauce. The only negative about the place was that it had a fairly limited choice of main courses, even with daily specials included. read more

Very nice experience all around with good food and service I would come again. The appetizers and entrees tasted very good

The food was complete garbage which is hard to achieve being that all the ingredients are locally sourced from farms, my pasta came cold and when i informed our server (she was nice) the food went to the kitchen to get "nuked" aka micro waved and came back hot and disgusting I dont know who goes out to eat and willfully spends 30 dollars on some microwaved leftovers?! Only eat here if you feel like getting completely ripped off with over priced trash read more

Great food , great service. The shrimp and gigantic bean appetizer was delicious. Pasta bolognese was the best I've had in years. Rib eye steak was perfect. The waiter was a gentleman and on top of everything read more

Delicious food and wine. Good service and we liked the ambiance. A bit noisy for us after 7:30 due to two quite noisy tables. Otherwise great. read more

We over-ordered takeout on a quiet Sunday night and tried roast chicken, farro salad with grilled vegetables, charred eggplant w smoked cheese, pasta with wild mushrooms, margherita pizza. Food was uniformly superb. read more

This was the highlight of our trip to Rhinebeck. From the moment you walk in, the environment feels inviting and cozy due to the warm lighting. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. My husband and I ordered the rigatoni and salmon, respectively. The salmon was the best salmon I have ever had. Would definitely be back!! read more

What a great looking place- casually chic with very good food. Came here on an early Saturday night with no reservations. We had... Meatballs... yum Kale salad... ok .. needs more excitement. Squid - wow the calamari is very tasty Risotto with crab- very tasty but I didn't really taste the crab! Feel a little cheated. Duck leg - very good Linguine with shrimp- good Bolognese - good Budino dessert - very good and the touch of salt is killer! read more

See all

We are from San Francisco and recently traveled to the Adirondack Mountains. We happened upon Rhinebeck on our way back to NYC. I told my husband pull over. The town was so cute and charming. We googled restaurants and ate at Market St. We had one of the best meals on our trip at Market Street. The service, the ambiance, the food were amazing. The bread, the food and even the tap wine was excellent. I would love to return to this cute town and visit Market St. I plan on telling all my friends that visit NYC and upstate this restaurant is worth the stop. We had a $500 dollar meal in NYC for 3 of us and this place hands down was superior. We even had left overs to eat on the plan back to SF. DELICIOUS! read more

One of the best in Rhinebeck. Cozy atmosphere with a variety of plates. Went this past week for our second time and will be returning again soon. Note to restaurant: please put your "special" bacon and carmelized onion on the regular menu because we haven't stopped talking about it since! read more

A disappointment last night. I come here, and Cucinni, a lot . . . and have never had anything but an exceptional experience in terms of food, ambiance and service. Last night we had some visiting celebs from out of the country and, after feeding them Italian in a hot Manhattan spot the prior night, brought them to Rhinebeck, bragging about the food. The service was the great disappointment and this is a rare occurrence at Market Street. The food was good, but not the "ohmygawd" great I've become accustomed to. I'm chalking this up as a one time anomaly. I'd certainly recommend it and will be back within the next several days and am eager to see if what we experienced was a trend or just "an off night". read more

Just returned home from celebrating my husbands birthday, service was good, food was very disappointing . The Pizza, although perfectly cooked, with wonderful crust had barely a full slice of cheese on it ....very disappointing . Sablefish was ok , nothing special for one of the specials , the rice cold and the asparagus salty .. the steak and fries were good but overcooked , ordered med rare and served less then medium. The pork scaloppini with capers was extremely salty and the polenta watery... the chocolate cake my husband enjoyed, we live here and Rhinebeck , my husband a former Culinary Chef Instructor ...sad to say we were hoping for a night to remember but food wise we'd prefer to forget . read more

Strangely, the item that enticed me to order the soft shell crab special, the pickled ramps, was either not included or quietly blended into the sauce. I wasn't disappointed, since this was an appealing dish that made excellent use of the unglamorous duo of peas and carrots.These were fresh enough that they could have been from Dutchess County. In any case, they were not from Del Monte. The crabs, a dish I wouldn't normally pursue this far inland, were fresh and well-prepared. They were large enough so that they didn't fall into that "fried generic snack" category. The cherry soda was very refreshing. The menu has many interesting-looking appetizers but I kept it simple so I could catch my 10:00 Amtrak. read more

Market St - soft shell crab special - Italian Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

The green salad was a bunch of greens taken out of a plastic pre washed container nothing else. We were charged 15 dollars for a 4.99 package with no flavor. The eggplant appetizer wasn't even enough for one person. The size of 4 fingers and no cheese. Just a waste. And they served my daughter tap wind in a mini glass because we didn't order a more expensive glass of wine. Go to the pizzeria down the street read more

Third visit here not quite as enjoyable as first two. Being seated in the far back by the restrooms and having the heat associated with the pizza oven made for a rather unpleasant ambiance. Now, the in the fact that the fish was seriously overcooked and you have the recipie for an unpleasant experience. Not sure I will go back to this location. There sister restaurant in Woodstock has better specialty pizzas and a better ambiance. read more