I'm shocked by some of the mixed reviews for Straight From NY Bagels as I had the best experience! The amount of bagel and cream cheese flavors they offer is amazing! If you're looking for the classics done extremely well, this is the spot. Give yourself a little bit of time for ordering as it gets crowded; but thankfully when I visited, I just beat the line. I got their Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich on a Garlic Bagel. The bagel tasted so fresh and it was the perfect thickness to enjoy the inside flavors. Even as the bagel was toasted, my garlic topping did not get burnt and flavor was great. My husband got their Everything bagel with Salmon CC. The cream cheese was a tad expensive but you get actual salmon chunks throughout! My aunt loved their Poppy Bagel which is always a fun flavor to offer. Overall, this is a great bagel spot in Naples! I'm shocked by the mixed reviews and I had a great experience start to finish. Staff were so kind and our order was turned around quickly. I'd definitely revisit when visiting next! Tip: Check out their online ordering process to see some of the alternative selections for cheese types, egg preparation, etc. read more

See all

Silly expensive & unreliable service. The line every time I come in here is out the door which is great for the shop, less great if you don't have 20 minutes to kill. $9 for a bacon egg and cheese - $10 for Taylor ham. read more

Straight From New York Bagels - $17 worth of food - 2 sausage egg and cheeses. They're good but not very reminiscent of home. - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

Great bagels and cream cheese excellent coffee choices very friendly and helpful staff. It's my new go to coffee shop

This is definitely our favorite breakfast stop when in Naples. The breakfast sandwiches and coffee are excellent!

Kurt (owner?) Been coming here for years... ...food i- excellent ...staff - friendly, smiling, courteous, hustling doing their best ...Customers - disgruntled & frustrated with wait times, (especially for sandwiches and grill orders) ...Bottleneck - the grill - too small and only room for one person to cook ...Delivery of food after order- chaos... Also need to improve efficiency and prioritization of call-in/online orders vs in-store orders...a real problem... A year ago or so Lori stated much of the same in her review...you responded that changes and improvements were in the works...haven't seen any... read more

This is a gem. A little hidden from the main road. Fantastic bagels. They really got it right in fact, all the food is fantastic, as well as the coffee. Really friendly service, five stars all day! read more

Straight From New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

We used to come here multiple times per week. Was a great spot. Unfortunately, the entire business has completely gone down hill. Service is horrendous. New staff is extremely rude. Their payment system regularly fails, which has caused us to be double charged numerous times and have to come back for refunds. Prices get higher, quality and service gets lower. Today will be the last time we visit this place, unfortunately. They charged our card, it hit the bank, and then told us that it didn't go through. I had to open my account and prove that it went through. They pushed back and fought with us about it in front of their super long line. We then waited over 40 minutes for our food. People behind us in line all got theirs well before we did. We were long time customers that got completely mistreated due to their own systems fault. The only positive note, is that Peri is a 5-star employee. He has been around a long time and always treats people well. They should give him a raise and have him train the others around him! I truly hope they take the recent increase in negative reviews seriously and do something to fix it. read more

I think the bagels are not fresh and service should be more courteous. it had been a while and thought I would give them another try.

One of the best bagels we've had in a while. Got a bacon, egg and cheese on plain, as well as a sausage, egg and cheese on jalapeño cheddar. Bacon could've been a little more crispy, but it was otherwise perfect. The staff was really friendly, too. If we're back in the area again, we'll know where to get our breakfast. read more

Friendly service. Large selection of bagels and salads--they also have bialys and NY-area treats like crumb cake and Italian cookies. Bagels have the chewy texture and blistered skin that I enjoy, though the dough is a little sweet. The veggie cream cheese was excellent with fresh vegetables mixed in. When we were there, it was busy, but the line was kept moving and orders were filled swiftly. We did not eat in, but it felt like a typical NY deli with small tables and a busy environment. Bagels are 15 in a dozen. read more

See all

There was a long line when I walked, had a solid lox and bagel from here. The flavor combo of the everything bagel and smoked salmon with capers made my morning. It was chill atmosphere with sitting outside to enjoy the bagel. read more

Straight From New York Bagels - Lox and salmon bagel - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

The service is always excellent, and the bagels are fabulous. The baked goods also look amazing read more

....and then Keto said, no bread! Muahaha. That was up until I met an everything bagel with Lox and the works. It's our cheat-day treat so at least we split the it between the two of us. Always fresh bagels and while I hate waiting the month in between, this is so worth it. When ordering online I failed to scroll far enough down to hit the 'loaded' button so be cautious. You will definitely want to make sure you add the tomato, red onion, and capers! Treat yourself! read more

Straight From New York Bagels - Everything bagel with Lox and cream cheese! - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

Service is way too slow. One person taking orders on a Sunday morning. Not close to being a NY Bagel place. Very high prices. Bacon, egg and cheese $9.50. NY/NJ that's $7. Why? read more

We have been going here for years, and over the years the food has slowly gone down hill. Today will be the last time I eat from Straight from NY, I say eat but I threw my roll in the trash. Not only has the cost out weighed the food, the food is just flat out bad. The last 5x the bagels and rolls are just not good. I figured the first time maybe they had a bad day. Then the 3rd and 4th...now today. 1 bagel toasted with butter, 2 egg sandwiches (bagel + roll), 2 drinks. Came out to 36 dollars. I know everything has gone up in prices but this is just outrageous...raise prices and lower the food quality. Sadly will be looking for a new Sunday breakfast for my family. read more

This is a great no frills bagel place. The bagels are huge and delicious. Plus they are generous with the cream cheese which my daughter loves! Highly recommended. read more

Straight From New York Bagels - Bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

It's been a long time since I have had an authentic NY bagel and this one did not disappoint. I got an everything toasted with cream cheese and it was perfection! The wait was a little long but it was a Sunday morning. read more

Sooooo over priced, 16$ for a bagel with lox when I asked for a bagel with lox spread. I paid left and was happy, but not what ordered, eh bagels are decent just way over priced. I live down the road from here... read more

Omigosh! The salmon cream cheese! Wow! It's got chunks of salmon you can see! Hubby loves a good pumpernickel bagel schmeared with salmon cream cheese, and Straight From New York delivered. This joint does a hustling business in the morning so be prepared to wait a bit, but it's worth it. There's outdoor seating out front which is east facing, perfect for enjoying the morning sun on a coolish morning. The almond-studded pastry was less stellar than the bagel, especially when it costs two and a half times as much, so you might want to stick to the bagels. read more

Straight From New York Bagels - Chunks of salmon in the salmon cream cheese! - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

Delicious!!! The service was great, everyone was very friendly. The steak and egg bagel was mouth watering, flavorful! Highly recommend getting it with the jalapeño bagel! I will be sure to save this location for the next time we are in the area. read more

Straight From New York Bagels - Steak and eggs on a jalapeño bagel - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

It was my first time here. The place is a lot bigger than I expected it to be. You order the food and they call your name when your order is ready. I ordered the egg white tomato and spinach bagel. As you can see from the picture there was close to no egg white in it. My husbands bagel the bacon eggs and cheese was delicious, I had a bite. Coffee was good too. The tables were all dirty. read more

Straight From New York Bagels - Coffee and sitting area - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Good bagels l, soft and flavorful like NY. Service too robotic like, hardly crack a smile. Morning rush, prepare to wait a bit.

This place is great! My grandson comes in town several times a year and his only request several times is to get bagel sandwiches from here!

The food was amazing! Very filling and they have always gotten my order right, I got their bacon egg and cheese egg sandwich on a plain bagel with an overeasy egg instead of the scrambled. I recommend them if you are in the mood for some egg sandwich's or just picking up cream cheese as they have a lot. I took away one star as when I went there were flies everywhere! It was so disgusting. They were going Into my food and everything. I will say that it is a bit dirty inside but other than that it is a cute little bagel shop. They do lack options which is another reason for the star removal. I love their bagels though! read more

See all

Efficient ----& AWESOME BAGELS!!! Try the French Toast - cut in half & grill in a buttered skillet - it's heaven!!!

Delicious, memorable bagels. Warm service. Has a nice interior. Definitely pricey, but my love for the food overpowers my financial gripes. 4.5/5 read more

The bagel sandwiches are amazing! I've never had such an amazing combination of ingredients on a turkey sandwich. Giving them 5 stars! read more

If your looking for the best hot pastrami on rye, delicious knishes, moist corned beef, dense New York bagels or delicious cookies and desserts.... I'd hate to let you down but go somewhere else. I've been there 3 times and they're managed to piss me off everytime. The first time the I got into an actual fight with the manager ladt over lox. How absurd. All I did was ask if they had lox. Not nova, but legit, salty, belly lox. The lady condescendingly asked me "what's the difference". Well I happen to know the difference. Nova is smoked. Lox is cured. And the flavor is completely different. It's not just about how salty the fish is. She wasn't expecting a coherent answer and was even more rude that I knew the difference. Could have simply said no! Fast forward a few weeks I went back to get a dozen bagels for the family and I asked for lox again. This time really just to screw with her. Guess what, they had lox. But it was uncomfortable again. The same lady was in back of the counter talking shit about me to the cashier. To the beat of my ability in pretty sure she was saying it was leftover from a special order and something about it being disgusting and too salty. Too salty? The limited edition lox was perfect. It's the bagels that are too salty. I'm unsure why but they're using super coarse salt all over the everything bagels. I'm not against salt or Tina of flavor but arguably it was kind of hard to eat salty lox on their over salted everything bagel. So if your lucky enough to find one of those super rare events where they have mor leftover lox I would suggest ordering it on some other flavor of bagel. So I went back the third time and now I'm totally pissed. I ordered a kniish and a pastrami sandwich. Well I guess whoever is making the knishes used up all the salt on the bagels because they were totally devoid of salt or really any other flavor than potato. And what about my pastrami sandwich. You know... The New York deli standard... (Should be) Piled high with fresh steamy pastrami, stacked so tall you can't even bite the sandwich, served on fresh rye bread with deli mustard and a pickle wedge. Maybe even some potato salad or macaroni salad. Well the pickle and macaroni was ok. But the sandwich was quite literally the worst pastrami sandwich I've ever been served. I guesss they don't have a proper steam table. Hell, even a microwave would have been better than the atrocity I was served. They re-cooked the pastrami on a flat top. The meat was black, burned, greasy disgusting mess. I literally chocked it down. Anyone who would murder a sandwich like that clearly knows absolutely nothing about deli food and shouldn't be serving it. Might as well put ketchup on the sandwich. Would have been an equivalent mistake. So after trying a few things I don't plan to go there for a meal... Might buy their bagels again unless I can find something better nearby. Also absolutely not looking forward to the nasty lady behind the counter. read more

Straight from NY Bagels should go Straight to NY and see how a bagel shop should be run. The bagel is so hard that it is tough to bite into. I ordered a ham & Swiss on a plain bagel and it took 20 minutes until I received it. In NY you order and they make it right away. No standing around waiting 20 minutes to receive it. It's been 2 years since I went here and was hoping the wait time for a sandwich had improved but it did not. I think 1 person makes all the sandwiches. Hire more people and maybe you could get the food out quicker. Sorry will not be back! read more

Definitely not straight from NY, that sign has been taken off and it only reads "Bagels". I was super hungry, just have landed at Ft. Myers and didn't really know what to have for breakfast so I decided to try their bagels. Of course I'm not expecting NY/NJ bagel quality lol, something about the water makes bagels outside of the NY/NJ area taste a lot different but this definitely did not make me feel at home. The service was super nice, the lady at the counter who took my order was very patient with me. They don't have turkey bacon available though, maybe it's a Jersey thing, so I settled for an everything bagel toasted, scooped out with egg and cheese. The bagel tasted like some bland bread, didn't have that brownish toast and it tasted somehow plain. Felt like they just threw and egg and some cold American cheese, I ate the whole thing because I was hungry. I wish I could explain, but can't lol. Coffee was normal, this isn't a cafe so I wasn't expecting anything more. The tables were somehow dirty so I had to clean it myself, no big deal. I can get pretty crowded though, I mean it was full when I arrived. Maybe if they work on the quality of the bagels, or take a trip up north to taste some real bagels, then that would be a hit. The service was great. read more

Straight From New York Bagels - A good cup of coffee after a long day and last minute flight. Let's see if these bagels live up to the NY taste. - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Unfortunately there is no zero star options. If you are ordering for the Holidays beware! Ordered 6 bagels, thinly sliced nova (0.5 pound), quarter pound whitefish salad and pickles. We received, half filled of the small container whitefish salad, 2 acme packages of nova, and no pickles. My wife called and the business response was there is nothing we can do. Jamie who took your order is new and does not know we don't slice nova. It's pre packaged (the same you get at any grocery store)! Disgusting customer service! read more

See all

Amazing bagels! We got a few bacon egg and cheese sandwiches on different bagels, all amazing. Love that they have egg bagels as well. Jalapeno cream cheese is killer. read more

Bagels are delicious. Great sandwiches. I got the nova andcream cheese. Nice staff. Clean

They are probably the worst bagels I have ever had. They make a Costco bagel look good. They were filled with sugar and hard as a rock, plus they were costly. Don't bother coming here; what an insult to New York. read more

Excellent bagels!!! Great service! Best bagels in SW Florida! Sandwich selection is great! read more

No longer STRAIGHT OUT OF NEW YORK anymore. Closed many months ago, was told by a worker there. That's why the signs only read BAGELS on the storefront and elsewhere. Not the same taste and not as good. Lot of us complaining. Hopefully SOONY bagels are still at the farmers markets here in Naples and Bonita Springs where I caught them once. Naples: Airport & Vanderbilt (Shoppes) Bonita: Coconut Point Mall read more

The bagels were delicious, truly tasted like a New York Bagel!!!! They also had a great selection of flavors.

Straight from New York has about the best bagels in the area. I went to the Immokalee location. They also have a new store in Bonita. I bought a dozen assorted bagels because I was invited for brunch. At 9:30 it was very busy. They have a nice selection of appetizing. Prices are very high. Food is good. Check it o read more

Straight From New York Bagels - Good bagels - Bagels Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Best bagels in Naples! ::: mic drop ::: Everything bagel is my go-to, just wish they had a wheat version. Whoever makes the bagels now as to two years ago adds the right amount of salt. Before, the toppings were unbalanced, however the problem had been fixed. Thank you new baker or enlightened veteran baker. Second choice, jalapeño cheese. Crisp cheesy layer that cuts through the seeded heat. The lines can be out the door, so I normally call ahead. read more

Levels above the other bagels shops in the area. Old school compared to other places, but in a good way. Good coffee and great service read more