Stopped for an impromptu visit with my husband and we just shared a pepperoni slice for $3.50 and it was SUPER good! It was thin but crispy and had a lot of flavor, so much that we want to stop by a second time to get our own! The service and ambiance did feel like I walked straight into New York, a kind of good chaotic feel to it. Lots of flyers on the wall which I love so that was fun too! We'll be back read more

Straight From New York Pizza was good and it's a small restaurant with seating inside and out. Slices are about $5. The slices are less if you go within the hour before closing. Service was friendly. I didn't look at the specials and the woman preparing my food to go pointed them out. I ordered three slices of pizza: pepperoni, chicken bacon ranch, and bbq chicken. I liked all three of them. If I had more time in Salem, I'd go back! Try it out if you're in the area read more

See all

Had a really strange interaction with the guy at the counter, got the veggie it was good. I will try again later date and see how things go, for a new ratng! read more

Was lucky today and had a dentist appt which meant I had to leave work early which also meant I got to stop by the one and only straight from New York pizza downtown. I love this place. Small, narrow and a perfect place to grab a quick slice or two as I did. I wish Salem had more places to eat like this. Kind of like the original ventis when it was at the reed. I must say it was a cool Friday and the inside was a little cold but that's just a minor comfort thing. The pizza I chose today was the combo and Hawaiian. Both were great and exactly what I was craving. It hit the spot. I wish the prices were a little better. I paid 5.50 and 5.75 a slice. Dollar cheaper and it would be five stars for me. Anyways if you have not been here come check them out and make sure you're going to the right location. The downtown one. read more

Straight From New York Pizza - SFNY Combo and Hawaiian* - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

Reminded me of a New York pizza place the place wasnt at all fancy and thats where u get the best pizzas in new york lol. I didnt take pics im sorry I totally bla ked on it but rhin crust hand made pizzas. You can even see them make the crust. Love ut will visit again I got a big half cheese half pepperoni pizza. The service was warm and inviting. Come and get yourself a slice or a whole pie. read more

There pizza is outstanding and certainly is NY style as I had never tasted anything so delicious in Oregon.

Best pizza I've ever had. Crisp was perfect, great flavor in the sauce. Super friendly people. If you haven't been here yet... I don't what you're waiting for! I stop when I'm out on a long bike ride and man... Always puts a smile on my face on that first bite. 10/10 get the Dave pizza guy out here. read more

Straight From New York Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

Been going there since 1988. Had lunch there everyday (almost) for 5 years. Now go as often as possible but usually to the Owens street location. Good pizza, decent pricing. read more

Taste better here than in New York lol... I always enjoy this with my friends and family or when I want something quick while I'm in town

Live this hole-in-the-wall pizza spot. Reliably fast, hot and delicious - and they always have plain cheese or veggie by the slice on offer. If you are looking for authentic East Coast style pizza with plenty of cheese, perfectly doughy-crusty crust and bold sauce then you will love it. read more

Straight From New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

Came to salem to visit family and this day we decided on pizza to deliver to the house ( they don't deliver but did thru doordash) by the time we recieved it , it was a tad cold but even with having to heat it up , it was delicious!! The crust is hands down one of the best crusts I have had in a pizza !! So yummy! read more

See all

Their pizzas are amazing. I've been back a few times. Friendly service. Highly recommend to anyone wanting great pizza. Only con is finding parking and having to walk at least a block (in the rain most likely). read more

Straight From New York Pizza - 1/2 14" veggie; 1/2 14" Cypress Hill - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

Best pizza in Salem, staff are very friendly. Fast service...great menu, great beer, breadsticks WOW! read more

Straight From New York Pizza - Half pepperoni, half margarita...yummy - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

Love both places. Buying your slices the last hour or happy hour is a great deal. They are generous with their toppings compared to what i see at by the slice pizza's at our health food store or costco.they also allow you to pay $.50 extra for more of your favorite toppings. Also staff ate great, and don't forget to tip. My dad was a barber and he took us out to Sunday brunch on his tips. read more

Timely delivery. I got a half and half pizza. One half Hawaiian with marinara or red sauce and the other a margarita with a garlic olive oil instead of sauce and added crushed garlic. It was cooked okay, I forgot to have it cooked well done so the tips of the slices were wimpy and a step up from soggy. The Hawaiian half was flavorful and made me want more. The margarita was okay but I wouldn't order the olive oil instead of sauce again as I believe the lack of sauce left it bland and lacking flavor. read more

straight from New York Pizza in downtown Salem on liberty Street is an all-time staple. It's been there forever. I love that they have a 14 inch gluten-free pizza. I'm not sure that it's the best gluten-free pizza but thank goodness for the quality of cheese, pepperoni, and olives that they put on top of it. It certainly didn't feel skimped for the $25 that I spent on my to go order. I'm satisfied. I can't attest to how well the pizza will reheat but at the moment, it's filling my craving. I'm not exactly being focused with this particular establishment. It's a pizza joint. You go and get your pizza and get out. Go about your business I give them five stars just for longevity I'm friendly service. read more

Straight From New York Pizza - gluten-free pepperoni olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

See all

Im a pizza snob and this is really good pizza. Thin crust good undercarriage great flavor. Definitely recommend and can get by the slice and two slice deals. Price is 4.50 and very fair. read more

I'm a born and raised New Yorker which means I'm a bona fide pizza snob. This is one of my spots to get pizza when I miss the mom and pop pizzerias on the east coast. Nothing can replace NY pizza but this gets really close. I recently tried their gluten free crust and it was delicious! Their garlic knots are bomb too. Repeat customer for sure. read more

Pizza was good. Super small place no big deal. Slices were a bit soggy, breadstick was delicious. I'd definitely go there again. Got two slices and a bread stick for 9.50 during happy hour. I'd definitely go back. Bathroom was clean also. We were in and out of there fast. The outdoor seating was very nice. read more

See all

Honestly great pizza I've ever tried!!! The service is nice very cool people. Especially the Spanish guy making pizza he needs a raise.

As someone from New York living in Oregon, I'm routinely underwhelmed by the pizza scene (with a few exceptions). Straight from New York is like a real deal NY slice. Even the shop feels like I'm back in the West Village having a slice. read more

Straight From New York Pizza - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

In an area of 18 dollar burgers, this place is a great find for an out-of-towner. 2 slices and a drink for under 10 bucks. I worked all morning and didn't eat so most things would have tasted good, but this pizza tasted great! read more

Straight From New York Pizza - Hawaiian and veggie slices - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

Just disappointing. I am used to a good amount of toppings on NY style pizzas and this one did not meet my expectations. The pizza was indeed large but lacked the large amount of fresh toppings. The staff behind the register seemed confused about everything I asked. They might have been new but they really seemed like they were on drugs. Sorry. The place is decent in size but kinda cramped. I won't be coming back. read more

This pizza is so good and the breadsticks are super good. It's really small though. Pretty cheap too

I used to love this place. Now it tasted like week old Chuck E Cheese pizza. I rmailed them to complain and got zero response. Any respectable pizza place would respond, even if it is to say "Oh well." Their product and service are trash. Avoid. read more

Straight From New York Pizza - This was the pizza I got - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

See all

ATTENTION ALL THIN CRUST PIZZA LOVERS!! This should be your new go-pizza place. A legit hole-in-the-wall pizza place that is my absolute new favorite. I've been called boring for this, but my favorite pizza is cheese pizza and boy do these guys have a good one. I've never ordered off the menu. They usually have slices ready to go that I choose from. Not the best place for a sit down bite but great for a grab-and-go meal! read more

Straight From New York Pizza - Liberty street hole in the wall - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

See all

I was extremely disappointed with the quality of pizza. By the slice it was cold, extremely thin crust with almost no flavor. How this restaurant received any positive reviews is a mystery to me. As a previous resident of New York, I can confirm that this pizza is not in any way remotely similar to authentic New York pizza. I will never return to this restaurant or recommend it to anyone. read more

Both locations that I have been to are cozy and adequate. The pizza is delicious and affordable. Love coming here with my wife for Friday night dinner and a beer. Carry out is fantastic too. Don't forget the bread sticks! read more

Delicious pizza!! And great friendly service. Large slice a pie at reasonable prices.

UPDATED REVIEW I originally reviewed this place around seven years ago. I gave it 5 stars. I don't know what happened but in my opinion it just isn't quite as good. I do love the Margherita slice but it's like the pizza is way greasier than before. It doesn't seem to taste as good as it used to either. read more

First and last. Really disappointed. Ordered from GRUB HUB so you know I already paid too much for the convenience or delivery. The driver was fantastic and was quickly ruined when I opened the box. The toppings (vegetables) are raw, the bell pepper is cut thick and is still cold to the touch. The crust is not crispy as promised but soggy like it had been sitting in a puddle of water so unappetizing. I made a point to say no olives and guess what was all over it? If it was just one problem I could look past it but when all three and I have to put it in the oven to try to cook it and hope it tastes good enough to eat because I am hungry... never again read more

Seriously delicious pizza. Thin crisp crust, good ranch. The breadsticks they sell are worth every penny. The owner is super cool and very friendly. The space is very small but fits the theme of New York. read more

Food is definitely a four stars. Service- well overall I'd say a firm 3.5 stars Just check the pizza for the correct toppings before you leave if you are picking up. read more

The only great pizza in Salem! Pizza is delicious, wings are REALLY delicious. Literally the only really good pizza we've found in this town. read more

If you like dry cheese, flavorless sauce, and OK toppings on cracker-like cardboard, or just need single-slice calories, go ahead. There is better pizza ANYWHERE else in Salem. read more

The pizza slice is very large similar to New York. The slice is thin and crisp. The place is very small and works well for a quick walk-in or a small get together. The pizza is really good but the place is not really organized. read more

The service was good but the pizza just wasn't my type of pizza. I was expecting a crisp crust but both pizzas were very floppy. I also didn't care of the sauce. Some on my family did like the sauce however but also didn't like the crust. read more

I order a med 14" cheese pizza for delivery through grub hub. Pizza arrived burnt. There were 2 extra cheese slices that I did not order. I physically drove to the restaurant today with entire burnt pizza and asked to remake. I was told that she realized that it didn't look right and she included thr 2 extra slices. I told her that did not equal a whole pizza. She gave me 2 additional slices and called it even! Lol. I'm lease try and do better!!! read more

Straight From New York Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Oregon

Best pizza I've had in a while! We got 2 larges, one with pesto sauce, artichokes, kalamata olives, and ricotta. The other one was red sauce with pepperoni and TONS of mushrooms, plus fresh mozzarella. The pesto one was the biggest hit, but both were delicious. Definitely pricier than chain choices, but worth the difference. read more

Not my favorite place but not the worst. I've ordered here many times hoping it would get better but it hasn't. Several times the order was not cooked all the way and it was still doughy. It is inconsistent. I tried it the first time and it was ok. It was what New York Pizza should be... Then, it started getting worse. The dough was consistently undercooked on one side and burnt on the other. The dough even tasted worse. I had a problem with their pizza recently and I won't be back. I hope they raise their quality standards read more