This is by far the best Italian ice you can find! The combination that they offer with the ice cream and ice is literally next level. They are cash only and only have a few old and dingy picnic tables outside. But this place will not disappoint. I always get the raspberry ice with vanilla ice cream read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Staff was incredibly rude !!! Would not serve ices on a cone ! Ridiculous. I drove a half hour to get there. And left with nothing because of their rude and nasty attitude read more

Love Strollos! Ordered red raspberry, passion fruit and vanilla. My husband had mango and vanilla. Both were amazing. Wish they had a few more dairy free options. Also wish they had the menu outside so people can check out all the options ahead of time. Can't wait to come more often. Really great spot! read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Strollo's has absolutely amazing Italian ice that's so creamy it's more like ice cream. The owner mans the counter and service is quick but not served with a smile. There's no small talk or thanks. But the Italian ice is so good. We all opted for small cups with multiple flavors in each, and servings are large. The issue with Strollo's is that you never know when it's open. We had been trying every day for 5 days to find it open. They seem to open randomly when the mood strikes them. I'm glad I got to try it before leaving town. read more

See all

The best Italian ice spot I've ever been to. I used to go here growing up and a few years ago, they moved locations across the street for a larger space. The pro move is to get 4 different flavors. You can get 4 different flavors at once and can even mix and match with ices and ice cream which is delicious. read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

When visiting belmar, my friends insisted that I try Strollo's. There were many people outside enjoying their Strollo's and there was a line stretching out the door when I stopped by. The line moved impressively fast and when I got to the window, I was served very quickly. The inside is quite small and there is no indoor seating or space to stand around. It is also cash only, but there is an atm conveniently right outside. Strollo's has an interesting concept of both soft serve and Italian ice, with the option to have both together in the same cup. I got the mango shaved ice with chocolate soft serve in the kids size (definitely enough) and it definitely lived up to the hype! read more

Strollos Italian Ice - two cups of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

It really is true -the best finds are the dinky little mom and pop places. Some of the negative reviews said the place is run down but there is a certain charm in being authentic and unpretentious. Someone in our group suggested ice cream after dinner. I ordered the peanut butter ice. Never heard that flavor offered in Italian ice and I like peanut butter so what the hell. Wow Just WOW. Whomever thought to machine whip ice cream and water ice together with the end result being the consistency of custard soft serve should expand and franchise this business today because it is really unique. It is hands down the best Italian ice, soft serve, ice cream I have ever tasted. It is outrageously good. read more

Went tonight for my first 2025 visit and it might be my last. The prices high and it's a cash only business. Sprinkles are an extra $1.00. The inside looks like you are walking into a toilet and it really smelled like a bathroom as well. The smell was horrific. It makes you think about how clean it is. The only person working who I think is the owner doesn't crack a smile. Do yourself a favor and drive in either direction to Hoffman's or the Beach Plum. The ice cream is just ok. read more

They have really unique "Italian Ice," which was more like the consistency of soft serve ice cream. The idea of peanut butter ice seemed weird to me, but it tasted more like custard. It was sooo good and I can't wait to go back. The only drawback is cash only, so you need to know that before hand. read more

My son & i drove to this location for the Rook collaboration. We arrived at 8:50. We'll ahead of closing we thought. Why on earth is a ice cream/ Italian ice place closed by 8:45 during the summer? There were other people also there.​ read more

Owned my home in Belmar for the past 15 years. Strollos has been a dessert shop favorite to my entire family up until this season. Been there with my crew 3 times. Each time the portion size was extremely small. Some (not all) staff clearly have very little interest working or showing any appreciation for a customers return. Finally each time we were there getting icecream and or ice, it was extremely soft and melted in a short period of time. Wondering if there might be new owners or a reason this place is not as good as it was. read more

Summer is inn the Air. This Strollos location is a family favorite. The cream ice is amazing. The combination choices are endless. Although pistachio was one a favorite and now a distant memory we still like to visit post beach. The line moves quickly so don't be intimidated. Great place to watch Main Street traffic and drawbridge activities. Don't tell the day trippers. read more

Stroll's may be small but boy is it good. The ice cream is a great consistency and tastes great. Their Italian ice is the best I have ever had and to top it all the service is quick and friendly. Only problem is the ambience very small and crowded not the best, also looks a little run down other than that great ice cream parlor must visit if you are in the area read more

I tried the red raspberry and the peanut butter. Soooo good, especially on a hot summer day. read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

This was so surprisingly delicious- it's nothing like what Italian ice is like in other parts of the country- it's smooth and soft and easy to eat and so so yummy. My husband enjoyed his peanut butter and I enjoyed my passionfruit, red raspberry and lime combination! I may have said this Italian ice was the highlight of our vacation... :) (It's actually across the street from where the address on Yelp says it is...) read more

This place has great Italian ice when you can get it. However there is no indication of when this place is open. So basically it says they are open then you drive there and it's closed. They don't answer their phone either. This might just be a front for something else ? read more

The best ice cream place I have ever been to! I got a small cup of Italian ice with the flavors: red raspberry, mango, and passion fruit. Out of the three, the mango tasted the best. It was so flavorful, very sweet, and it tasted very different from other Italian ice places. The consistency of the ice was perfect. It was very smooth, not chunky at all. It is presented very beautifully too. You can choose up to 4 flavors with a small and it was cheaper than most places! I also tried their vanilla and strawberry soft serve. It was so yummy-- I usually never get soft serve ice cream because I think the flavor is too strong and artificial tasting. However, the strawberry was spot on. It tastes like the strawberry flavor soft serves I get in China. It was so creamy and thick which I really like. There is very limited seating (no seating inside). However, there are a few tables outside for you to use. They have their own parking lot which is nice. The staff are very friendly and will answer any questions you have. read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Small Red Raspberry, Mango, and Passion Fruit Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Simply the best product I've ever had! I've been coming here since Dominic opened and it's always perfect. I'll be in for an orange and vanilla ice mix shortly! read more

Great little gem in a great beach town. Italian ice is not Italian water ice. It's so much better!

Always delicious!!! Good location, can sit plenty of space! My best flavor is vanilla Italian ice! read more

This Strollos location is alright, definitely not the best though. The ice cream flavors are limited. They only have vanilla and chocolate soft serve whereas other locations have flavors of the day and strawberry. They do have a lot of awesome Italian ice flavors though. Red raspberry, passion fruit, and mango are my favorites. I recommend coming here if you are really hankering for ice. read more

Strollos Italian Ice - the entrance to a restaurant - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

THEY MOVED ACROSS THE STREET! They also no longer serve Blue Raspberry Italian Ice. HEART BREAKING! We came here and had a heart attack when we saw the original location was under construction. We pulled off and coincidentally had to make a U-turn and boom! there it was across the street. I wish they put a sign there so I didn't have to die and come back to life. This place is simply perfect! I don't know what else to say. One bad thing, they don't have the blue flavor anymore. read more

See all

Honestly don't see the allure in flavored ice, but this this so much more than that. I was introduced to Strollos about 4 years ago. I remember driving up to the old parking lot and not even being able to find parking and when you did find parking you got to wait in a huge line.......all this for some ice? I scoffed a the very thought of it. However, after my first bite i was humbled. O M gosh so good. At the very end of the ice cream, yeah im just gonna call it ice cream thats how creamy it is, you get to look forward to devouring a fresh sugar cone. I cannot recommend this place enough. Goes to show, don't judge a book by its cover! read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Amazing flavors! The orange taste just like your eating a frozen orange! Many times there is a line But it moves very quickly !

This place is very popular and for good reason! Every time we've been here, we've had to wait in line. The new location is right across the street from where the original location was. It's easy to miss because they don't have a large sign with their name on it in lights anymore, but it's marked on the windows. I always order something different each time. This time, I decided to get vanilla soft serve in a waffle cone topped with rainbow sprinkles. You can't go wrong with that! This hit the spot after enjoying a sunny day at the beach. There are plenty of options to chose from. The options are only listed above the cashiers, so you have to wait until you get closer to decide what you want if you haven't been here before. The name says italian ice, but it's more than just that! Staff are friendly and kept the line moving pretty fast. There are tables outside to sit at and grabbing dessert from here has now become our "tradition" when we come down. read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Vanilla soft serve in a waffle cone with rainbow sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Best italian ice I've ever had! Many flavors to choose from!...just wish they would open earlier then 2pm!

Was excited to try this ... I was disappointed not only in the taste of the ice/gelato but in the service as well . Chocolate flavor mediocre , passion fruit bitter .. cherry too sweet . My son was happy because he got a chocolate and vanilla twist on a cone . My sister in law got chocolate and cappuccino flavored(cappuccino was actually good) Serviced sucked , the man running it was so obnoxious. Every time we would say one order he would say ok and anything , yea anything else , next , and .. like chill out . Never going back read more

I'd really like to review Strollo's, but as this is the FIFTH time we've visited during business hours...and it's been CLOSED all five times. I wish this business provided more accurate, up-to-date actual business hours. read more

Sad their hours say 11pm but they were locked up tight at 9:45pm... Perhaps they had an emergency... can't hire people... I'm just venting! read more

The employees that work there are really nice but as for the ice cream/ices themselves, there isn't much to choose from. Still glad I tried it though! read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Chocolate Dipped vanilla kid's cone! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Rushed service only gave a star cause I had to, The lemon ice was good I'll say but overpriced for a squeeze cup. Older Guy behind the counter made first time experience my last time. read more

As part of my day at the beach with one of my besties, I was so excited to go back to Strollos to try some new flavors. Not only did I love it, but I've made a Strollos fan out of my girlfriend. I love the fact that you can get 4 flavors in a small, it was enough for the two of us to share, and only $3.50. We went for the chocolate, peanut butter, mango, and lemon. We were over the moon with the chocolate and peanut butter combination. It was like a cold creamy Reese's peanut butter cup. So good! I no longer feel the need to continue experimenting with flavors; they are all good depending on your individual taste. But, I am absolutely sold on the chocolate and peanut butter. I'm still in amazement on how they can make Italian ice so decadent and creamy without the addition of a dairy product. (They do serve a few flavors that have a dairy derivative - Vanilla, Cappuccino, and Pistachio. So, if you have a milk allergy, stay away from these flavors.) Strollos Italian Ice: - Not too sweet - Creamy, creamy, creamy - Allow up to four flavors - Small size for $3.50 is an awesome price There are a few different locations along the shore. Go try it today!! read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Lemon, & Mango - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

This is normally the kind of place that we love and would want to give five stars to, but when we went for dessert last night, they were out of TWO premier flavors--the very two that we wanted (pistachio and mango). It's kind of an interesting idea: soft serve Italian ice, which you don't normally see (at least not where we live). We ended up with half cherry and half vanilla soft serve and our kiddo got half vanilla/half strawberry soft serve. Sprinkles all around, natch. The ice cream is delicious: great flavor and consistency, and we especially enjoyed the strawberry. While we liked the novelty of the "creamy" Italian ice, the cherry flavor was only OK. Would that they had pistachio!! Even though we're settling on three stars, we appreciated the vibe and atmosphere and concept of Strollos and have no doubt that we'll be back since one of our BFFs basically lives around the corner. read more

When I had a shore house one summer, I came here about every day.. It has the best Italian ice ever. It is different than any other ice that I have had anywhere else. For $3, you can get up a cup with up to four flavors. I like peanut butter, cappuccino, chocolate, and vanilla. But honestly all flavors are good. It can definitely get packed on weekends and on nights.. try to come during the weekdays. They have some tables to sit outside on. It truly is heaven in a cup... THE BEST!!!! read more

The only reason why this place has a star knocked off is due to the service. The owner is a NASTY human being. Otherwise, the best Italian ice ever. Don't waste your time at any other Strollos location. This is the only one that nails the consistency, flavors, portions, etc. They took away the coconut flavor years ago. It was my aunt's favorite. I know she'd kill to have it again. read more

This place is hands down the best Italian Ice place I have ever been to. My girlfriend got a small Italian Ice cup with three flavors (maximum 4 flavors) and I got a large cup of soft serve. To start off, their Italian Ice was beyond amazing. It was so soft, flavorful, and sweet. I've never had Italian Ice like this. If this place was close to my house, I'd come here every day. To add on to their amazing Italian Ice, their soft serve was also great. Don't be fooled by their small-looking cups, because my large cup of soft serve was a struggle to finish. But despite this struggle, I finished because it was so good. I got strawberry vanilla swerve, and it was worth every single penny I paid for. In my opinion, most vanilla soft serve tastes similar, but their strawberry was special. It's different from other strawberry soft serves because its taste was so subtle but so addicting. This place is definitely a place to go after you spend your day at the beach. read more

Has gotten very pricey and portions very small. Giving it a two star for being greedy and overcharging in my opinion.

Both the soft serve and Italian ice is sooooo good!! Also always friendly service. Always sad when the season ends read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Chocolate and vanilla soft serve on left and vanilla ice on right - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Strollo's is absolutely delicious. It's been a Belmar landmark for years and years, even before the borough had their rejuvenation. Their Italian ices have a great, flowing texture. They taste like no other dessert. Dairy free options are available. Just ask. My mom loves ice cream but is now lactose intolerant. Strollo's is the perfect solution. It's a great family owned business, too. read more

Strollos Italian Ice - Mango & passion fruit together, large size - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

BELMAR: for the best and most flavorful Italian ices, check out Strollos Italian Ice! They have many flavors and we love the peanut butter - it really tastes like PB and is so creamy! You can also get multiple flavors in one cup! Dogs are allowed at the outdoor tables and may try to sneak a lick of your spoon! read more

Strollos Italian Ice - a dog on a leash in front of a restaurant - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey