Callie's Creamery is honestly a hidden gem. But in a sea of famous Jersey shore ice cream towns, how do they stand out you may ask. Their ice cream contains the highest quality ingredients and all of their flavor flavors are handcrafted in house. You can really taste the difference! We tried a variety of amazing flavors like the mint fudge swirl, Nutella Graham, Callie's cotton candy, and the Dubai chocolate, but my favorites were Cookie Monster and biscoff cookie butter! You can order an ice cream flight which is perfect for indecisive people like me. Six flavors, sounds good to me! Their sundaes are huge and could be shared with 2 people. The brownie sundae was decadent and dripping in fudge. Yum! I like that it's indoors which means you can come here year round. There's plenty of seating in their adorable ice cream shop, which is adorned with painted sprinkles all over the walls! There's claw machines for kids and even a photo booth. Pints, ice cream sandwiches, and more in their freezer ready to go. Can't wait to be back for more! read more

See all

I have an unhealthy obsession with this ice cream. It's in a tie for 1st at all times. Specifically the biscoff cookie butter, cookies and cream, and s'mores are to die for. They also have a great rewards system where they'll randomly sent you a free $5 off which almost pays for a whole ice cream. The store is always very clean and you can try as many samples as you like. They clearly label the flavors with the allergens so you can be safe. If you ask them to use a clean scoop for severe allergies they are very accommodating. Another cute thing they do is theme night for kids so they'll have Bluey and characters come visit. Super cute, one of my all time favs. read more

Callie's Creamery - Desserts Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

I love Callie's like no other!! This is the best ice cream spot around - delicious, unique flavors and so many to choose from. Some of these flavors include Dubai chocolate, their famous blueberry cobbler, cherry vanilla, fudge stripe brownie batter, fruity pebbles, cinnamon bun, and right now they have a tahini mocha and a burnt orange espresso bean flavor. Every single flavor is a hit and they don't skimp on quality. Creamy, delicious, and homemade, Callie's is a local gem and you MUST try it. They also have Italian ice and ice cream flights where you can try 6 different flavors - so worth it, and you get to try all their epic flavors. It's also so cute inside - they have a Photo Booth machine and offer birthday parties with ceramic painting. Not to mention staff working behind the counter are always so friendly and helpful. Love Callie's! read more

Callie's Creamery - Cookie Monster Milkshake?? - Desserts Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

This place is very spacious inside and there is some parking for customers which is great for this busy area. The honeycomb ice cream was okay... but I loved the Dubai chocolate scoop!! The kids had soft serve which was also very good. read more

Callie's Creamery - Menu - Desserts Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

See all

Callie's Creamery makes AMAZING homemade ice cream! It has a lot of fun flavors that you can't find at other places. Their ice cream has the most mix ins I ever had at any ice cream shop! The fudge striped brownie batter is FANTASTIC! It has huge pieces of fudge striped cookies it! The Biscoff cookie butter is also another favorite! The only flavor that I personally found disappointing was the pb & j because it was more like peanuts and jelly ice cream. It had no peanut butter swirls just chopped peanuts. The jelly to it could have been better too. This ice cream shop is one of the best in NJ! I highly recommend coming to Callie's Creamery in Neptune City! read more

Callie's Creamery - Cinnamon bun, Biscoff cookie butter, & pumpkin roll good! - Desserts Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

See all

We stopped here after dinner and we love the ice cream, store is clean and the staff are nice and helpful. read more

Callie's Creamery - Fudge Striped Brownie Batter - Desserts Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

Great tasting ice cream! You can tell it's homemade! The cherry vanilla was soooo good!! The sprinkles (jimmies) were fresh too! We'll definitely be back! read more

Callie's emphasizes the cream in ice cream-the dairy component is sweet and dense, with terrific mouthfeel (hate the term but it's highly descriptive). Bright flavors too, and Callie's makes a great double dip with Local Smoke across the street! read more

Cookie butter and blueberry crumble flavors are to die for. Definitely my new spot! Very good selection of flavors and toppings.

Callie's Creamery was an incredible partner for the Day of Giving in July, showing their commitment to Big Brothers Big Sisters in a delicious and impactful way. They generously donated $2 from every pint sold to support youth mentorship programs, giving customers a fun way to contribute to the cause. My favorite? Fruity Pebbles read more

Callie's Creamery - Desserts Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

The ice cream was good. I got the blueberry cobbler flavor and it was really creamy and there were some chunks of frozen blueberries mixed in! Inside was quite nice and spacious. Very clean and a lot of seating available. the employees behind the counter were very friendly and helpful. I went around 4pm so it wasn't too busy. cute new place that opened up! read more

See all

Ice cream was amazing!!! The Biscoff cookie was the best ice cream I ever ate. I only wish they shipped it to upstate NY with some dry ice cause I would pay the shipping just to have it. read more

The owner is deeply committed to both her business and providing exceptional care for her customers."

Delicious and creamy! Our go to for ice cream for parties and cravings!! Family owned and operated! Support locals

Ice cream was delicious! But Single scoop on sugar cone was very small - hardly worth $4.00 Service was grouchy and acted as if I was bothering her with my order. I will not return! read more

Great to see an Ice Cream Parlor return to Neptune City! Tried the Espresso Bean which was delicious. Loaded with espresso beans. The store is bright, clean and very upbeat. Take out cases have cakes, pints and ice cream sandwiches. Staff was very friendly. Over 30 flavors so more to try. read more

Excellent edition to the area! Excited to have a new ice cream spot nearby, especially one with parking. Really liked the biscoff cookie butter and Nutella Graham. Lots of fun flavors, including snickerdoodle soft serve and 2 kinds of dole whip. They've done a great job decorating and can't wait to return to try more flavors. read more

This is the best ice cream I've had and reasonably priced. I think it's the best in New Jersey.

We had an amazing experience at Callie's grand opening! Kudos on a great all-around experience. We own Fox Meadows Creamery in Lancaster Co, PA and were just driving by. The ice cream was creamy and delicious (the Raspberry Chip is excellent), the hospitality was warm and inviting and the vibe of the building was fun. You have to try Callies! read more

As good as Hoffmans without the wait and cost. Locally owned lovely people. They also have sugar free and vegan ice cream.

Amazing ice cream. This area needed a new quality ice cream place and Callie's is our new go to. Great variety of flavors and quality ingredients. read more

Now I know what good ice cream tastes like! Amazing ice cream and terrific flavors. Highly recommend.

Great place but not great when the server scratches his hair with the fingers he going to scoop your ice cream with

I've been to pretty much every ice cream place within 10 miles of here and this is definitely my new favorite! I can't believe I haven't tried it until now. I can't wait to come back because there's just too many flavors to choose from. So creamy and flavorful and reasonably priced. read more

Great place! Nice variety of flavors. A little different which is refreshing. Nice space inside to enjoy your treats! Service has been always warm & frienfl read more

We had the chocolate peanut butter and the coffee cookie crunch (? Forgot the name) and they were both amazing!! Can't wait to go back and try more flavors! Love the sign too the aesthetic is adorable! read more

Can't rate the products because I never got any! I encountered the rudiest person working at Callie's! When I entered the store no one was behind the counter. After about 5 minutes the person appeared with a scowl on her face which was incredible like I was really inconveniencing her. I wanted to purchase quarts of italian ice for co-workers; I had even called ahead to make sure they carried it. Unfortunately all the containers in the case had only minimal amounts in the bottom, so I explained what I wanted thinking she'll say that either they didn't have anymore or she could get more from the back, something! Nope, she just continued to scowl and stare me down. It was super uncomfortable and weird. I ended up leaving without purchasing anythng because I felt like she didn't want to wait on me. My Dad had purchased ice cream there the week before and there were large chunks of ice in it. When he showed the worker there, they said "Sorry!" but didn't offered a replacement. We're done with Callie's! Negative stars! read more