Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Stuff-A-Bagel

    2.5 (41 reviews)
    Open 5:30 am - 3:00 pm

    Stuff-A-Bagel Photos

    STUFF-A-BAGEL ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Stuff-A-Bagel

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Storefront
    Dave A.

    HOLIDAY GO-TO FOR BAGELS on LONG ISLAND! Hanging out in Long Island, NY for Thanksgiving brings a definite change of scenery and atmosphere compared the hustle & bustle of The NYC. The drawback is that food isn't always readily available, like bagels. Day after Thanksgiving ALL the decent bagel shops in the area were closed except this Mom & Pop shop in East Islip. However, When we walked in around 9am, all they had were empty bins... DOH! Open but empty?!?! Luckily, one of the owners, Ms. Jenny is So DANG sweet! LOL! She sweet talked us into waiting, "only 10 minute" for the fresh batch that was cooking as we speak. WHOA?!? Fresh? As in FRESH FRESH?!? I can smell It already! BAGELS: 1 dozen is FOURTEEN here! And THEY WERE truly fresh outta the oven... Mmmmm :) EVERYTHING BAGEL (big hit with my local Fams), BLUEBERRY, CINNAMON RAISIN, PLAIN, and EGG. No Rainbow or French Toast unfortunately, today. LARGE bagels compared to what we have In California! AND... This FRESH thang is awesome! Soft, Flavorful and aromatic make this a delightful carb filled treat! We bought a bunch of cream cheese flavors too... blueberry, strawberry, chocolate chip, plain, and chives. Definitely a great compliment for the bagels! VERY EASY RECOMMENDATION! NomNom level is HIGH! Great customer service and yummy eats are a combination worth return visits all the time. They are open during the holidays, but come early or prepare for a short wait that's worth it! Enjoy :)

    Un -cinnamon raisin !
    Theresa S.

    I'm being generous with a 3 star review .. It's been many years since I was here at this bagel store but I remember them having fairly delicious bagels . Maybe they have new owners ? Sadly these bagels were on the cusp of adequate ! I picked up a few cinnamon raisin bagels ,several onion and sesame. Although the onion bagels did have plenty of onions on them they were pretty much bland and tasteless . We didn't try the sesame but I'm expecting the same quality. Lets call the cinnamon raisin bagel ... an Un- raisin Cinnamon ! I had one Raisin in my bagel ! Toasted with butter it was fine but also on the bland side . On a positive note they were not dry they were light and had good texture . The staff was very friendly and professional , wearing masks and following social distancing and the store was spotless . Since I purchased 6 bagels I got one free . I may consider trying them again , it could have just been an off day ?

    See all

    8 years ago

    disgusting place. bugs flying around. bagels are hard. no gloves when serving your food.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Stuff-A-Bagel

    Review Highlights - Stuff-A-Bagel

    Mmmmm :) EVERYTHING BAGEL (big hit with my local Fams), BLUEBERRY, CINNAMON RAISIN, PLAIN, and EGG.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bagels 2,822 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Hometown Cafe

    Hometown Cafe

    4.0
    (87 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    oh my god hidden gem along southshore of longb island…read morebreakfast lunch wow egg cream and all a must try customer service phenomenal cute

    Even though this place has been here for quite awhile this was my first time there as I very rarely…read morego out for breakfast, though they serve both breakfast and lunch. I got there a bit after 8am on a Tuesday morning and about the half the tables were filled with a mix of families, working people and I'm guessing a few retirees. Many must be regulars since they were greeted by name. I sat at the counter so as not to take the only remaining table for two that was available. I was greeted immediately and given a regular menu and a specials menu. A cup of coffee almost magically appeared and I have to say it was one of the best cups of restaurant coffee I've ever had! They have an extensive menu, everything from pancakes to waffles, eggs in every iteration you can imagine, to oatmeal! I decided on a spinach/mushroom/onion omelet with home fries a side of bacon and rye toast. You choose omelets come with one filling, additional are $1 each. The omelet was good but was helped by some salt & pepper. The home fries were tasty with just the right amount of onion but the bacon was overcooked for my taste though I know many people like theirs extra crispy. There were two waitresses and they both were friendly and attentive. By the time I was ready to leave every table was taken but there were still seats at the counter. Now I know why the parking lot is almost always full, especially on the weekend. If you are looking for Home Town restaurant with good food & great coffee this is the place for you!

    Photos
    Dining and bar area
    Dining and bar area
    Avocado toast
    Avocado toast
    Kids Grilled Cheese

    See all

    Kids Grilled Cheese

    Stuff-A-Bagel - bagels - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...