This was my first time going here after an appointment in the area so I figured I would give it a…read moreshot. The bagel store is in a huge shopping center right off Main Street, hence the name. When you walk in, you have a huge showcase of bagels, deli items, and dessert. You also have a coffee station and a drink station. The place isn't anything fancy and it is low lit. The staff were very nice and I was in and out of the store in five minutes. I ordered two bagels; one egg everything with vegetable cream cheese and one egg with chives. The bagels were absolutely delicious. They were soft, had a lot of flavor, and had the perfect amount of cream cheese. Some bagel stores put too much cream cheese where I feel like I'm eating an entire block and other bagel shops put no cream cheese. I think they did a very good job. Overall, I paid about $11 and change for the bagel, but I really enjoyed it and I would come back

Used to love this establishment for their vegan options, but they have really been going downhill…read morelately. I have had a negative experience 5+ times before I decided to update this review. For starters, even though this place opens 6am majority of the bagels aren't event ready until 7 or 8 so forget even ordering food at that time. Additionally, everytime I ask for the dairy-free cream cheese the counter guy complains and tries to say they ran out because it's too difficult for him to get it from the back and mix in some veggies. If you insist they check they end up having it every time. Additionally, when the owner is there I seem to get charged a few dollars more because he rounds up on the prices for whatever reason. I ended up changing over to Village Bagel & Deli which ended up having even better bagels and vegan options.

Great service clean and curtious service and the monte cristo sandwich is awesome! So bagel buzz is…read morethe place to be! The bagels are great as well as the egg sandwiches and it's nice an air conditioned.They even have cereal and muffins too .Whether on the go or need a place to eat they tables to sit at.i highly recommend this store located in West Islip.A good place to stop and pick up something Service is fast for morning rush to work - coffee & muffins fresh

Very long line wrapping outside the building. Service was slow, took over 25 min to get a single…read moreplain bagel toasted with butter. Bagel was fine but I can get better quicker elsewhere.

This place is awful. The lady behind the counter was very rude and was asking for tip. The lady…read morealso refused to write my order down. If I owned this place I would be embarrassed .

They dont listen to requests. I asked for light ketchup and had to wipe my sandwich down with two…read morenapkins from a swimming pool of ketchup. It seems like they give light amount of cream cheese automatically. They have delicious bagels though and they have amazing cookies made by local bakers which is great and delicious.

Went in for a basic BEC on a whole wheat bagel. It was made pretty quickly so not much of a wait. I…read morewanted scrambled eggs but she circled fried, which I didn't see until after, not a big deal. The only issue is it was SUPER SALTY. I don't typically eat or add salt to anything, so I tasted it pretty easily. Next time I'll say no salt. The coffee bar is a "do it yourself" which I LOVE so that you can make it to your liking. They have hot and iced coffee. I did like this place, staff was friendly, I would return and I would recommend it. They also have a coldcut section, so you can definitely order a variety of foods/sandwiches. There are a few tables inside so you can sit and enjoy your breakfast. $10 for BEC on a whole wheat bagel and a small iced coffee.

Long Island is home to oh so many bagel places and the Bagel Factory does an admirable job fighting…read morefor its place to be one of them. Came here for lunch, and my girlfriend and I had no problem getting our BECs. Despite the name, this place also does have a decent size deli inside too, so having that option for me I think always elevates any bagel place just a little bit more. Everything was fresh and delicious, even a little later in the day when you might expect that you'd get slim pickings on bagels. Coffee was only okay, but it's a bagel place, I'm not gonna ding them too much for it. There are a few tables indoors and outdoors if you choose to sit and stay, but you're probably better off to just grab and go. Parking can be a little tight, especially if you're going at prime time, but everybody moves quick so you likely won't be waiting long.

ZERO STARS. Ordered two bagels, half of each barely had any cream cheese and they charge over $4…read moreeach. Terrible scam. Go to Bagel Boss, instead or House of Bagels, they're better tasting and generous with their spreads. Then they charge me $5 uncooked bacon. ZERO STARS

Stopped in here on a whim the other day for breakfast and ended up having a rather yummy egg…read moresandwich. Got a BEC with hashbrowns on an egg bagel. Everything was cooked great and the bagel was delicious. Service was fast and attentive. Place is on the smaller side but has some tables and chairs to sit if you decide to dine in. Overall, it's a pretty solid bagel shop for LI.

Hidden gem in Deer Park! Found this spot when I had to get fingerprints done for a new company I…read morework for (they are right next to each other). Ever since that day, I've been a happy customer! The shop has lots of seating, and it is very roomy. They also have a good selection of bottled drinks, house iced tea, coffee, tea. The bagels and rolls are delicious, and yes, soft!

A good bagel today and always. The staff is attentive and eager to please. The variety of add ons…read moreis enough for the average customer.

Best bagels in the area. And reasonably priced. The owner is very fair and doesn't overcharge…read morepeople which is why I continue to go there.

Convenient space for my return home with easy online ordering. Sadly, their bagels are way too…read morebland. Even the egg everything bagels. Zero taste which would seem impossible. Also, they are not friendly or personable to warrant giving them a second chance. I had to practically beg to hand me my online order. Bummer.

Stopped here for a quick breakfast with my boyfriend before heading to Brooklyn for the day…read more Service was fast and effective. Bagels were fresh and yummy. I had an everything bagel with cream cheese. It was tasty and I didn't have a pound of cream cheese like most bagel places do. My boyfriend had a plain bagel with butter. No complaints from him either. For the two bagels it was just under $6, Employees were kind and provided service with a smile. I would definitely return for an egg sandwich.

We arrived to one of the servers smoking two storefronts down from the store. Not a good start…read more The bagels were soft, a different consistency than the usual Long Island Bagel, which my husband didn't like, but my son thought was OK because he had a "Godfather" sandwich piled high with meats and cheeses so the soft bagel was easier to eat. I had their eggsalad which was good - just the right amount of mayonnaise. The ambience is dark and the store felt cluttered. Loud television for a small place.