Sugar Plum’s Bakery

YES! Must stop in! Service was terrific! We called in and…read moreordered 12 chocolate cupcakes with vanilla frosting for a birthday party and they look like exactly like the vintage "Hostess" cupcakes we know and love. They taste AMAZING! Well worth the money. Beautiful cupcakes and cakes available in store too.

My daughter's wedding cake did not arrive at venue until one hour prior to start and Cakes by Ron…read moreforgot the wedding topper. We and venue staff were in a panic. Delivery person was very rude when cake finally arrived. Cakes by Ron offered us nothing but a canned apology. Will never use them again. It's such a shame their customer service is so poor because the cake was actually delicious.

Custom Airstream cake

TMNT Chocolate and PB cake

See all

Triple Chocolate Cupcake inside

CCSWEETS

5.0(1 review)

4.1 mi

There are not enough words to explain how immaculate her cakes are! I ordered a cake for my…read morehusband's 30th birthday and she went over and beyond the design I even had in mind. She also was very friendly and got back to me in such a timely manner. I could not express a thank you deep enough. Not only did the cake turn out beautiful but the taste was incredible! We will definitely be ordering a cake through her everytime we need one. Highly recommend!

From the owner: CCSWEETS offers Custom made to order Cakes and Desserts!…read more All custom edible art is specifically designed to meet your needs. Let’s create a delicious and tasty memory for your big day! ServSafe certified, Award winning, featured on the Knot and Wedding Wire

See all

Sarasota Bakehouse

4.7(91 reviews)

3.0 mi

Fantastic selection of delicious cupcakes and an amazing variety of gluten free cupcakes. They…read morewere awesome. You got to go if you need a cupcake fix.

Looking last minute for German chocolate cupcakes, an I stumbled upon Sarasota Bakehouse, what a…read morehappy accident! Fresh and delicious cupcakes, definitely will be back for more.

Red Velvet Cupcake

Chanel Themed Cake

See all

Peanut butter chocolate and mocha cupcakes

A Slice of Heaven

4.3(64 reviews)

6.4 mi

•$$$

Let me tell you - this place is fantastic!! We made a last minute decision to invite 40 people to…read morethe house for cake and champagne. The mistake we made was it was for Jan 2nd. We had no idea it was pretty much impossible to get a custom cake following the holidays on short notice. Well--- it was no problem for A Slice of Heaven. We decided on three gorgeous and delicious cakes from their online options. They were ready in three hours. Our guests raved about the cakes and all wanted to know where we got them. We will certainly be picking up cakes from Slice of Heaven for future parties with zero concerns. THANK YOU Slice of Heaven.

I had the best cake I've ever eaten. It was the first time using Slice of Heaven/Sarasota Cakes…read morebut it won't be the last. The price was right, the German Chocolate Cake was truly amazing. Thank you Slice of Heaven!

Another amazing cake! This was coconut cream, and if you like coconut, it was absolutely delicious.

Cake

See all

Beautiful birthday cake for my wife

Argentinian Pastry

4.7(34 reviews)

1.1 mi

Hard to find a place around that sells medialunas…read more Excellent service They also have these Argentinian style empanadas and alfajores

Fantastic pastries. I love that they taste just like back home. The owner was very friendly.read more

See all

Paisano's Italian Bakery

4.3(178 reviews)

3.3 mi

Oh, my Italian roots are tingling, and so are my memories! This place brings me back to my…read moregrandmother and my childhood. The glorious scent just walking in, then the cases of rows and rows of delightful Italian homemade pastries, cookies, pies, and refrigerated meals as well. If you've never been, what are you waiting for? If you're not Italian, what are you waiting for? Get in here and have your taste buds ignited with pure delight! The ladies who serve you are as delightful as the delicacies they box up for you. There are also two tables out front if you can't wait till you get home to dig into your treats. Ciao!

As part of a walking tour of the Gulfgate area in South Sarasota we began here(trouble in a good…read moreway). This Italian bakery reminds me of Mike's pastry and Modern Bakery in Boston's North End. Incredible array of baked goods that are mouth watering. I tried a pizza strip and was hooked- bought many more plus muffins and cake slices. Service was with a smile and I Will return! A MUST stop

Baked goods in the display case

Fresh baked muffins.

See all

Rendez-Vous

4.6(308 reviews)

2.6 mi

I got a chocolate tart and a cinnamon roll. They were amazing!! The little cafe was so cute!!read more

This French bakery is very popular during morning hour. The cafe serves breakfast and the bakery…read moregoods. Obviously the breakfast and coffee are very welcome by the customers. I got the almond croissant. The croissant is big enough for morning breakfast. The sugar powder is good. Service is good.

Seating area

Le Rendez-Vous breakfast

See all

To go cup of coffee

ofKors Bakery

4.5(58 reviews)

1.9 mi

Love ofKors Bakery. I visited my in-laws during the holidays and we went to ofKors probably 3/5…read moretimes during the week because it was such a vibe! The coffee tasted amazing and the food was delicious. I ordered the Stuffed Egg Croissant and did not regret it. If you are looking for some fresh coffee and baked goods, this is your spot! There are limited seats at this location, but it is so worth it.

This bakery has a great selection and the pastries are usually fresh and delicious…read more There is lots of place to sit, including a small patio. Service is usually pretty quick.

Dessert case

Fresh bake croissant and more

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Angelo D.

0

1

0

7 years ago

Melissa Wright recommends Sugar Plum's Bakery. April 10 · Best cupcakes EVER! I shared with friends and co-workers and everyone went gaga!!! read more

Sugar Plum’s Bakery - cupcakes - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Sugar Plum’s Bakery also viewed

A Slice of Heaven

4.3

(64 reviews)

•$$$

Let me tell you - this place is fantastic!! We made a last minute decision to invite 40 people to…read morethe house for cake and champagne. The mistake we made was it was for Jan 2nd. We had no idea it was pretty much impossible to get a custom cake following the holidays on short notice. Well--- it was no problem for A Slice of Heaven. We decided on three gorgeous and delicious cakes from their online options. They were ready in three hours. Our guests raved about the cakes and all wanted to know where we got them. We will certainly be picking up cakes from Slice of Heaven for future parties with zero concerns. THANK YOU Slice of Heaven.

I had the best cake I've ever eaten. It was the first time using Slice of Heaven/Sarasota Cakes…read morebut it won't be the last. The price was right, the German Chocolate Cake was truly amazing. Thank you Slice of Heaven!

Cakes by Ron

4.5

(82 reviews)

YES! Must stop in! Service was terrific! We called in and…read moreordered 12 chocolate cupcakes with vanilla frosting for a birthday party and they look like exactly like the vintage "Hostess" cupcakes we know and love. They taste AMAZING! Well worth the money. Beautiful cupcakes and cakes available in store too.

My daughter's wedding cake did not arrive at venue until one hour prior to start and Cakes by Ron…read moreforgot the wedding topper. We and venue staff were in a panic. Delivery person was very rude when cake finally arrived. Cakes by Ron offered us nothing but a canned apology. Will never use them again. It's such a shame their customer service is so poor because the cake was actually delicious.

Sweet Doctors

4.6

(90 reviews)

Let me start off by saying I'm giving five stars purely based on customer service. I live out of…read morestate and ordered some cheesecake cupcakes for my friend's birthday to be delivered to her. She LOVED them, so I know they are delicious too! But Cheryl was so helpful and sweet on the phone helping me decide which flavors to get and inscribing a message for my friends birthday on the box. My friend also lives pretty far away but they delivered it to her anyways :) Please support this family business they deserve the world!! Thank you again!

NOT to be missed! Such a sweet shop filled with amazing treats. The owner is awesome and they craft…read moreeverything beautifully. Make sure you try the cookie butter flavor in anything, it's divine.

Edible Elegance By Eli

(24 reviews)

I ordered a cake for my mom's 80th birthday. I live in New York and took a chance based on the…read morereviews and the wonderful photos on Eli's website. I decided on the Rose Cake, with a chocolate, gluten free cake. The results were spectacular and delicious. Eli and her staff were wonderful to work with. I can't recommend this bakery enough. Thank you for helping to make this special birthday so memorable.

Eli never disappoints! Each cake I've ordered is absolutely gorgeous! Here's one I picked up the…read moreother week for my son's first birthday!

Euro Crave Bakery

(2 reviews)

Amazing sourdough Bread. We had a cinnamon bun, keylime pie and slice of Blueberry lemon cake all…read morevery very good. Owner very friendly pleasure to talk with. When i walked in first thing I saw a beautiful blooming cherry tree. Love this place.

Ivona was extremely friendly and very professional. I was all the way in California and I was…read morehaving my destination wedding in the beautiful Anna Maria. With this being said Ivona was very communicative through the distance and was able to accommodate my dream cake! Not only was the cake beautiful and match my wedding colors, it was EXTREMELY Delicious!!! Fluffy chocolate cake, fresh bananas, with Carmel drizzle, oh my goodness! It was perfect! Thank you so much Ivona, you are an amazing baker! My family is still raving about your cake!

The Cookie Cottage

4.5

(29 reviews)

Mrs. Catherine did outstanding! she matched the pictures exactly and understood the vibe we were…read moregoing for and expecting. she followed up before making them all and had them ready for us early when we asked to change the time. They taste amazing, and all out guests complimented them!

Don't go in the cottage. Owner is rude and frazzled, there are no cookies to be purchased. She…read moreshould keep the door locked.

Hometown Desserts

4.6

(95 reviews)

Being a lover of GREAT coffee and not tons of syrup... we found this little gem. A wonderful iced…read morelatte every day. And it was perfection. And don't get me started on their key lime coconut cake! Wow. Friendly barista!

We got this cake last minute for our son's 16th birthday in Anna Maria Island. The cake flavor was…read moregood. Frosting was a little on the sweet side. It's a cute and welcoming bakery on the island. The service was good.

Sugarpaste Cake Company

4.6

(11 reviews)

Stephanie was so easy to work with from the very beginning. When we met her at our wedding cake…read moretasting we knew right away that the flavors and styles she offered was exactly what we were looking for. We ended up getting a 4-tiered cake as well as our groomscake with Sugarpaste. I didn't know exactly what I wanted for the groomscake and showed her several pinterest ideas, and she proposed the perfect cake. The guests absolutely loved our cakes! We are looking forward to our anniversary cake and will be returning customers in the future for other events. Thank you for everything Stephanie!!!

Poor service and does not keep commitment. Lack of communication. I arranged to order a custom cake…read morefrom this company for my daughter's birthday. Once we agreed on the design and price I never heard back. I reach out several time's to finalize the agreement but never got a response. I ended up ordering from another vendor.

Express cakes and more

(2 reviews)

5 Star experience! Natasha got back to me quickly, and was able to make the two very specific…read morecakes I needed for my father-in-law's 90th birthday. They were very tasty and just perfect! Two Thumbs Up for this business! I will definitely patronize again when I'm in the area.

This was a beautiful cake that tasted even better than it looked. We ordered Chocolate Cake with…read moreChocolate Buttercream with a Strawberry filling. Everyone loved every single bite!

Canopy Road Market