Sully's is always a good choice when you're looking for an easy spot to eat in Medina. Pretty much everything I've had here has been very good! Highly recommend the corned beef egg rolls. I also got the potato and leek soup and it was DELICIOUS. My salad was ginormous but just okay flavor wise, not loving the cold corned beef but not sure what I expected. My partner really loved his breakfast burger! They usually have live music on weekends and had trivia tonight (Friday night). The service is friendly but not always the fastest, and they are pricier than you would expect for an Irish pub! read more

See all

It's been over 10 years since I ordered food at Sully's, which was a bad experience, (see old review). I rolled the dice last night and order 6 chicken wings. No bar that I know can mess up chicken wings. The wings came out dried out, not a hint of garlic parmigiana favor, and slightly cold. They had all the rich flavor of packing foam. Well at least Sully's is consistent. read more

Very solid food and nice atmosphere. I really enjoyed the Irish beef stew.....a hearty meal for a cold day. The ambiance is a quintessential Irish pub and the prices are reasonable. Our server was attentive and very friendly. I told the rest of my party that since I had just returned from a Dublin trip, I'd have to see how this measures up to the "real deal". I would say they did a pretty solid job! They know how to pour a pint of Guinness. And the food was generous in portion and flavorful in taste. Slainte'! read more

See all

The BIGFOOT Burger! (Special for the Curiosities and Cryptids Festival) perfectly cooked (medium-rare), great burgers (Yes, TWO!), awesome fries and a Guinness (do they serve anything else? And if so WHY?) What an afternoon!! read more

Sully's Irish Pub - Bigfoot Burger! - Irish Near Me - Medina, Ohio

The food at Sully's is always very good! Our server was Barb tonight and she was very personable and efficient! We had shepherds pie which was excellent! Always a favorite! We also had the French onion soup! Absolutely delicious! The Hamburgers are also good and made correctly! The Bailey's cheesecake is very tasty! A must try! Nice place to hang out with friends or go for a date! read more

See all

Came for fish as it's Kent.!We both had the perch dinners. Portions small. Service was good.

Quite possibly one of the best Irish pubs in the Northeast Ohio area! Food is fantastic, and of course they have all the popular Irish / English beers. A pint of Guinness here in this authentic environment transports you back to Dublin. They have lots of live music and several times a month have traditional Irish pub music. The folks tending bar know their trade and keep the drinks flowing. Great service and great experience! read more

See all

Ordered a hamburger which was pretty good but they could've used some salt and pepper on the patty. Ordered onion rings that were bland. Service was impeccable. Son in law ordered shepherds pie. Presentation of pie was awful. Looked like it was slopped into a bowl. read more

Looked like a good place to eat. Had great reviews when I looked. Had planned on eating here on St. Patrick's Day but apparently they don't do food on this day? Was def PACKED! Looked like a great place for some drinks & a popular spot on this holiday. However, we had kids & just wanted to eat there & didn't feel to do that. So my review is just to share info for anyone planning to eat here on St. Patrick's Day! I also didn't see it listed anywhere out front or on their FB. Unless I missed it! read more

A really good pub, where you an almost always get a seat. Everything is good, but try the Angry Mussels for an unusual, very tasty, dish.

I always look for Irish Pubs when traveling to a new area. Sully's proved to be one of the "Golden" nuggets that you rarely come across. Had every intention of corned beef and cabbage but the bartender mentioned they had a Prime Rib special so I jumped on. For sure an amazing surprise, the best that I have had in years. Tender, delicious and cooked to the perfect med-rare along with a side salad and terrific Garlic mashed potatoes. After dinner a talented 4 piece Irish music group lite the place up! The only downfall was I didn't find the place until my last night in town. If you are in the area I highly recommend you put Sully's on your must do list! read more

Sully's Irish Pub - Irish Near Me - Medina, Ohio

Can't recall how many times I walked past this place without stopping in. I regret that now. The Brunch Burger and Pot Roast sandwich were both excellent and filling. The homemade chips were also very good. Great ambiance too. Definitely recommended. read more

Sully's Irish Pub - Brunch Burger and Pot Roast sandwich with Homemade chips. - Irish Near Me - Medina, Ohio

Was there this Monday with a group for the first time. Irish stew and Sully's Red were awesome! Gillian our server was quick and insightful. My wife finished her dinner and got the peanut butter brownie- another great choice. Great food, great service, great prices! read more

Stopped by with my family after visiting Castle Noel. Freezing outside but cozy and welcoming as we walked in the door. We were seated in the Vault, complete with the old safe door and safety deposit boxes. Service was friendly and prompt. QR code provided local beer list on tap. Burgers were juicy and tasty. Generous portions and awesome fries. Buffalo Mac was good. Nice location and lots of local parking. read more

crab cakes were phenomenal. just the right amount of salt. Can't wait to come back 10/10

Stopped by Sully's for another taste with my wife since our first experience with them was excellent. This time, I ordered a grilled cheese and a bowl of tomato soup. My wife ordered a cheesesteak sandwich. Our entrees were served with home made potato chips, which were a bit greasy and just okay tasting. My grilled cheese had some yummy cheese and tomato on it, but the bread tasted a lot (too much) like the grill that it was cooked on. The grill flavor was overpowering and not particularly appetizing. The tomato soup was the best I've ever had. I love that stuff. My wife was full, so she gave me 1/4 of her cheesesteak sandwhich, which was very tasty. I would definitely order that again. I'll pass on the grilled cheese next time, but that tomato soup is a winner. Excellent service! read more

See all

I have been here twice now and ordered the exact same thing each time; the Sheppard's pie with the noodles instead of the salad for my side. The first time my meat was so tender and delish (this was the week before Saint Patrick's Day). The second time was tonight. The first time the meat was so tender and the mashed potatoes were spread over the dish. Tonight, the meat was difficult to eat, and I had to put several pieces into my napkin after I tried hard to chew them. Also, it was a scoop of mashed potatoes over the dish instead of a layer like before and like traditional shepherds pie. Service was great and the Baileys cheesecake was delicious. read more

Food was amazing. Meat loaf sandwich was to die for. And the ruben was the best. Homemade chips perfect. Brendan was the best.

This is a cool place to gather with friends and have a nice meal and drinks. Everyone is nice and if you sit towards the back you can have a nice time and conversation. read more

Sully's Irish Pub - All done - Irish Near Me - Medina, Ohio

See all

Great pub to hang out in. It's a fantastic stop on Saint Patrick's Day, but very crowded!

Good food and nice size portions. Good service. It seems like they're a family run restaurant. It's got a nice old-school cozy Tavern bar feeling to it. read more

This was our first time here and we came the night before Thanksgiving!!! First of all, we had the Thanksgiving egg rolls. They were unique and a great idea! (I forgot to get a pic) Then we tried the pulled pork waffle fries - wow! So good I had the Turkey Rachael and my husband had the chicken pot pie. Both were good. The turkey Rachael is served warm, so if you don't like warm lunch meat, ask for it cold or don't get it! It is served with homemade fries which are delicious!!! The cider boys peach was amazing as were all my husband's beers read more

Sully's never disappoints- I once lived in Medina and we used to meet friends there quite often - it's a great place for that! A visit took us back and Sully was a must for lunch! I love their Reuben's, wraps, soups and so much more! Fun atmosphere and great beer. Service has always been great! read more

Sully's Irish Pub - Dining & Bar - Irish Near Me - Medina, Ohio

Our first visit here on a Saturday evening with a party of four.. Busy but still a couple of open tables. We sat in the back room away from the music so we could have a conversation.Our server was Neal, a little curt but attentive and efficient. There were no service missteps.I had a Smithwick's draft to start. I intended to order the shepherd's pie, but when I found out the daily special was a 12 oz piece of prime rib with potatoes and broccoli for only 18 bucks, I got that. A real bargain and it tasted great. Very little fat. I started with fried pickle spears which tasted good, but all the breading fell off, so they need to adress that dish. The bowl of chili was HUGE. It was obviously homemade--not much spice but it was marginally OK. Everyone else liked what they ordered. Two of us got bread pudding for dessert. A little on the dry side, but OK. All in all, I would give this place 3 and 1/2 stars and I would like to return and get the shepherd's pie or maybe meat loaf. read more

Hands-down the best pulled pork sandwich with coleslaw I think I've ever had. Maybe I was just super hungry, or drunk, or it was really just that good - but I basically inhaled it and I would give my firstborn child to eat that again. 10/10 recommend. read more

I've been to this pub a few times and have really enjoyed the food and drinks. The atmosphere is a great pub environment. Service was a bit slow the last 2 times I've been there, but nice servers. A bit pricey on the drinks. Food is average price. read more

Awesome food and service. Came in to town Beer Fest weekend and had to stop at an Irish Pub, this one did not disappoint. Clean establishment and friendly staff. We tried the fish and chips and smothered pork fries, both solid recommendations. read more

Sully's Irish Pub - Fish and chips. (The size of your head, the bartender compares.) - Irish Near Me - Medina, Ohio

If you're in the hunt for a truly outstanding fish sandwich, keep on driving. Today I had the displeasure of experiencing one of most dreadful fish sandwich's of my life. Honestly McDonald filet of fish is better than this. I sent the first one back as apparently the cook didn't seem to understand Blackened only applies to grilled rather than fried fish. The second was marginally better but still dry as a dessert and tasted solely of the bread attempting to hide the poor emaciated fish beneath it. To think a poor perch gave it life for so poor an effort is an affront to Poseidon himself. read more

Great food and a decent drink selection for those who indulge. They also have pub trivia and live bands. Every dish has been fantastic.

Met a friend who is from the area. It wasn't crowded when we walked in but about 15 mins later is was slammed. Glad we went in when we did. Server was very nice and accommodating . We never ate there and had a few questions. I ended up getting the Irish Cobb salad. It was great. Large entree salad. Lots of stuff in it. No complaints. My 2 dinner companions got different things. 1 got wings. Which looked big and meaty. The other got the veggie wrap. She loved it with home made chips. Ample parking. They have ciders on tap. Which is awesome. And they aren't angry orchard or redds. They are real ciders. We got the pineapple which was really good. Good experience. I'd try them again. read more

Waited 45. Minutes and no food, very disappointed. Use to like this place how ever last time was not to par .

As a homeowner in Medina, we love this place!!! Before Covid it was great! During this crap storm , we have repeatedly supported this any most of the other businesses in our awesome town!! We have a great community, and great business owners as well! Love your place, love your food, and love the staff!! Keep up the the great work! Will be sitting on patio again very soon! Thank you!!!! :) Thanks also to every business in our extremely unique and awesome square!! We all appreciate every one of you!!! # LoveMedina read more

We sat 7 at a table for lunch. Huge menu. I ate a gigantic Chef's salad which was good, but they missed a big chunk of rotten lettuce. Some winners were the Reuben sandwich and pulled pork. Fabulous onion rings and pretty decent fries. They pour a glorious Guinness pint and free refills on soft drinks. Nice, prompt service. Many Pokemon hunters enjoy this gym spot. read more

Sully's Irish Pub - Irish Near Me - Medina, Ohio

See all

Tried to get dinner here but couldn't even get anyone to acknowledge us so we gave up and went somewhere else.

The service was quick and efficient. The bartender knew his beer and was able to serve my husband his beer correctly. The pizza was amazing and fresh. Can't wait to go back. read more

It really is like an authentic Irish pub. Nice array of beers on tap and several that are not. Good pub/bar food and friendly service. The only recommendation I have would be to put some lighting on the patio so the guests can see each other and not need flashlights to read the check. :) We've been here many times and have never been disappointed. read more

I was waffling between 3 and 4 stars, but ultimately, I would come back here. The menu is awesome and offers a lot of things I'd like to try. It gets pretty crowded in here. We stopped in on a Saturday night and was lucky to find 1 table open for the 2 of us. WE sat down and-- OUCH-- these are the most uncomfortable chairs I've ever sat in. I actually thought at one point I might be more comfortable standing up. Food came and distracted me a little from awful chairs. Our service was a little slow, but friendly and efficient. I mean, it was Saturday night. Lots of people sitting around drinking and not ordering food. :-( We started with the Reuben Egg Rolls. Life changing. These were so amazing. Filled with corned beef, cheese, sauerkraut and fried to golden perfection. Served with 1000 Island-- I honestly could have made a great meal out of the Appetizers. the Mister ordered the Bacony Goodness Burger and it earned it's name. Lots of thick bacon, thick cheesy sauce and an expertly grilled burger patty. His only complaint was that it was finished too quickly. I ordered the fish sandwich. I probably wouldn't order this again only because it was a mess. A delicious mess, but just really hard to eat. It was too large for the bun, so it fell apart the second I picked it up. read more

Service is lacking, minimal contact by server and had to request everything (condiments, more drinks). The food sucks.

Good irish pub. Good food. Good irish beers. The first irish pub in town. Only irish pub with a proper ourdoor patio.

Overall a great place. The staff is always friendly and it has that great hometown feel. I love their Reuben Egg Rolls and their Peanut Butter Cup Martini. They always have live Irish music too! read more