Supreme Pizza is always reliable -- great food and a super friendly family owns the place. My job orders from here a few times a month and we've never had any issues with quality or customer service. Highly recommend checking them out! read more

Over an hour late, freezing cold in the trash. Very disappointed, store doesn't care xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Fabulous service from Nancy and the crew! Delish and fresh greek salads and pizza! Clean eating area.

Anyone giving this GEM fewer than 5 stars has either not visited in the last couple of years or thinks haute cuisine is cold ravioli from a can. The minute you walk in you notice the cleanliness..place is spotless. Lovely, bright decor, and a warm greeting at the counter. The owner, Arz, takes obvious pride in this place, explaining hiw he makes the pizza dough daily. After ordering a steak and cheese sub (more about that delight later), he gave me a complimentary slice. The crust was pillowy with just the right crunch- fabulous! That steak and cheese? Unlike ANY I've ever had. Instead if the usual rubbery meat on a cold sub roll, this thing was amazing. The steak was so tender and flavorful, and the roll perfectly toasted. I am literally waiting for them to open at 11am to return to this slice ( see what I did there?) of heaven in the CVS plaza!! read more

Service is super friendly for sure. Seems like a similar atmosphere to the previous owners. However, just ordered from new owners for the 2nd time. Everything was average at best. Their Greek pizza used to be my favorite. I don't know what it is now but for some reason it doesn't taste the same. The chicken bacon ranch sub was extremely disappointing, falling apart, very minimal dressing, unsure if it was even ranch, and maybe 2 thin slices of bacon total. The chicken itself was delicious, however. The steak and cheese sub wasn't anything special. Cheese pizza was okay but not as good as it's been in the past. Just overall pretty underwhelming. Had planned on giving this place 1 more try, but we just opened our tiramisu and there's mold on it. It was $5 for 1 slice. Incredibly unfortunate and really gross. Won't be returning. read more

Supreme Pizza & Subs - Moldy slice of Tiramisu - Pizza Near Me - Walpole, Massachusetts

16.00 dollars for a burger and a Dr. pepper.... Let that sink in. Burger was dry and so was the bun. No flavor. Price gauging for mediocre food is bad. read more

This place was way better (which is saying something) with the old owners. The new owners couldn't care less about their customers. We order there at least twice a month, specifically because they have a gluten-free pizza option that tastes good. We'd spend at least $50 every time we went-a decent amount at a pizza shop. Previously they followed universal precautions for allergens -cooked it in a separate tin pan, put it in the box to cut it with a special gluten free cutter that was stored safely away. So this time I go in to pick up my order. My regular pizza is ready. They take out the gluten free and take it out of the tin and put it directly into the box; the boxes sit on the shelves prefolded so can gather flour particles. I mentioned that it seemed that it was not in the pan, and asked if it was cut with the gluten-free cutter. They said it was fine, right into the box and with the cutter. When I walked out of the store it was observable through the windows they were talking about me, just because I asked a question about my son having an allergy. I had been polite. I just got in the car and drove home. I called and my son who has celiac and asked him if it's always served in the pan, and he said it is. I called Supreme back and mentioned that I had just been in the store and spoke with my son and he said it is always in the pan. The guy who answered the phone doubled down and somewhat aggressively asked me if I wanted to speak to the cook because he watched him prepare it. I mentioned the difference of the pan, and that the reason we go there is that they always follow the same precautions. Then he said that they were busy that night (there was no one in the place) and THAT was why he took it out of the pan. He guaranteed that the next time we went in that it would be prepared correctly. Well, when you have an allergy, there is no next time. Indeed, my son did get glutened and has been up vomiting with diarrhea most of the night. The concept of the customer being right, or perhaps someone with medical concerns being taken seriously is not the case at Supreme. He could have offered to make another pie. Not even in his wheelhouse. They're right. They're always right. There will be no next time. I advise you if you have celiac or a gluten allergy to not go to Supreme. I can suggest better places in town that have great reputations for all kinds of pizza shop food! We'll try Family Pizzeria or Biancos for gluten-free and let you know. Jimmy's might not have gluten free, but they're super nice there! read more

Heads up, this place charges 5.25 for a Gatorade, 4.75 for a bottle of coke (20 oz), and 4.00 for a small bag of chips Completely ridiculous read more

I really wanted to like Supreme under the new ownership. The pizza quality is generally decent - inconsistent - but if you get delivery it's almost always cold. The recent order had a burger, which was awful - paper thin with stale fries. And cold. And they forget part of the order. Forgot the Cole slaw with the burger, and the dessert in a previous order. Very disappointing. read more

This place was Amazing best sub I've ever had!! The new owners Arz and Nancy are extremely nice, and know how to make a kick ass sub!! You are missing out if you don't stop by. 10/10 read more

Stopped by for a quick sandwich. Service was super friendly, food was fresh, and they made it custom for me exactly as I asked. Great sandwich. Didn't try the pizza. read more

ordered two steak and cheese subs. If you want a salt and steak sub with no cheese, very little steak and not the way you ordered it. order here. called to find out why and they hung up on us. Won't use them ever again. 2 subs both wrong. nice job. read more

Very good Greek style pizza and salads. Bread is always fresh. The staff is always so pleasant. Speedy!

man, the roast beef was spectacular and the sub roll was fresh. I will say the customer service was weak. Rushed of the phone when ordering and felt like I was bothering her. The sub itself was rushed and if I didn't open it up and spread out the ingredients myself I may have thought with several bites there was no roast beef. I never do reviews but had to say something because the quality of the product was so freaking awesome. Staff needs to be more on board and proud of what they are delivering. read more

I have never had a bad anything from SP& S!! Typically I'm getting a Greek salad with grilled chicken or a rollup and have never been disappointed! read more

They same nice, but I'll never eat there again. Took a half hour for one steak & cheese. Place was so hot I almost walked out before I received my sub. read more

While not the most aesthetically appealing (this plaza is sort of a dump!) pizza shop throughout Walpole, it's an awesome little joint, sitting innocently on Main Street. I like this place (hence the four star review), but have one MAJOR issue! Small things really irritate me and for some reason the management haven't decided if this pizza shop is at 883 or 885 Main Street! On the menus it says "885 Main Street", but on Yelp and on the businesses website it says "883 Main Street"! Ironically, they made another mistake regarding the location! On the map of the location on the back of the take home menus, the map is wrong and indicates where Hanson Avenue is, but not Maple Street. Increasingly annoying (these may sound 'piddly'.... but still should be fixed!). Definitely annoyed with that, and will update to five stars if they fix BOTH the address miscommunication issues. Anyway, this is a clean place, decent for eating in or taking to go. Delivery is also available, but seem to have long wait times as it clearly says on the menus "Delivery times vary and may sometimes be at least 45 minutes on busy days". They are not open late (like Domino's is.....), but have decent hours of Mon-Sat 11-10 and Sun Noon-10. Overwhelmingly large menu, for such a small place with tons to choose from. Guaranteed to have something for everyone in any family with different tastes. Subs, calzones, salads, pizzas, pasta dinners, "on the grill", dinners, and sides, are the sections on the menu. Each section is full of tasty meals. Everything is reasonable and everything I have tried has been great (especially the onion rings and chicken wings). Prices are pretty good throughout, and only a few things seem "overpriced". Employees are friendly and keep the dining area spotless, and the shelves of drinks and chips fully stocked. The kitchen also looked very organized and well maintained. Nice to see at any restaurant! Also, great deals to go along with your purchase! On the take home menu, coupons including a lunch special, buy 4 pizzas get 1 free (that one may not be the most appealing....), or $5 off $30. Good pizza / sub shop in Walpole Center. Try it out, even if you're skeptical from the plaza! read more

See all

Great food. The people that work here are so nice! Their pizza is great... I also love their subs. Definitely try it!

Such great service today!! I really wanted a Gyro and Supreme, being Greek-owned has a great one. Tonight was no exception! Also ordered two pizzas for the fam. When my husband arrived to pick up, he was told the cheese came out a bit dark, so they had put in another one. They showed him the pizza and, when he said it was definitely too well done, as our daughter prefers them very lightly done, the owner at Supreme went back and took the re-do out early. WOW!!! It would have been very easy to just let us walk out without a word; I'm sure many places would have. That didn't happen. A replacement was in the works before we arrived. Then, learning my daughter's preference, that pizza was cooked accordingly. Again, WOW!!! Thank you, Mike. Job well done. read more

Terrible. I came in to get a meatless wrap and this kid took his sweet time putting a small handful of lettuce in mangled sub roll and dressed it with a piece of onion and twice midget tomato slices. This is the same greasy teenager that worked the counter the last time I came in - that time, for a turkey sub that was as as tasteless as it was awful. The only reason I even gave this place 2 stars instead of a justified ZERO stars is because it has a tv. How do places like this stay open?? So if you feel like hitting up a really good pizza joint and end up at Supreme Pizza - SPOILER ALERT - you will be disappointed. read more

Food is great. I had the Fenway sausage sub and the bread was perfectly toasted. It's not your traditional sausage as they slice it length wise into slices and then add peppers and onions. The peppers have a nice sweet taste that makes the sandwich not need any type of condiment. Great pizza as well. Will definitely be going here more often. read more

My boyfriend and I moved to Walpole last week and were looking for some delivery nearby. We went on a whim and ordered from Supreme and LOVED their pizza! We got a bacon, onion, and chicken pizza and it was delicious. The buffalo wings were a bit on the hot side but it may just be because I don't like them anymore than mild. The food was also delivered right on time, definitely recommend! read more

This is one of my go-to sub shops in the area. It doesn't look like much from the outside but they care about their customers and products. Every order is made fresh, customizations are possible. It's no frills but that is exactly what I am looking for in a local sub shop. read more

Good quality pizza with flavor. Fast and friendly. Shop is a bit dingy but pizza is good a quality product.

Supreme pizza. I order 2 grinders . Repeated myself 3 times saying toasted with mayonaise on them. And I still got cold ass fucking sandwiches.. I order there every week same thing. So I am furious at this point. I got delivery and tipped $6 for a whole messup .. we walked back because they refused to drive back and they only 2 minute drive if that from my house. She said cant you just toast them in yourself. I said well I could but that's not what I ordered.. last time they did that they gave me 2 free grinders. Because there fuck up of people not hearing me. She even repeated my order and on receipt says toasted. Then she said they was toasted lmao okay. So walking 10 minutes to go bring these so called toasted sandwiches to the store. Even I asked delivery are these toasted because they feel cold and he said should be. Fucking stupid people man . Cashiers attitude was horrible for the phones with her disrespect and tell me to toast my sandwich.. tf .. never going there again. Should of just went to crazy pizza like I been doing since they open. Supreme is horrible now... read more

My favorite pizza. Doesn't look like much from the inside or the outside, but the customer service is above average and then know how to make a classic pizza. It's all preference but, would recommend to a friend. read more

I don't care what so called "pizza snobs" have to say. This is some delicious Greek pizza. My family's been coming here since I was young and I've always loved their pizza. They rate high above anyone else in the area in my book, and their subs are great too. There is nothing I don't like about this place. The staff are also very friendly. I've eaten in many times and I always feel very welcome there. They recently started delivering, too! I'll never have to order from Grande or Domino's again! read more

Supreme makes delicious and very large pizzas. They are reasonably priced and are very quick. Even on a Friday night, which seems to be "designated take-out pizza night", they produce your order at rapid speed. They are also very fair people. If you order a pizza a few minutes before they close, they are more than willing to make your order. They have a lot of seating and are very clean! read more

Love this place! It's a great and fast delicious pizza place. It is a little on the pricey side however it is definitely worth it. Plus they deliver! read more

One star for steak b cheese sub. A very sloppy sad sub

Open till 11 on Thurs, Friday, and Saturday. Everything good nothing great, have had pizza, hot and cold subs. Basic sub shop nothing special read more

Terrible pizza. Everything else is excellent. Their pizza is saltier than the Atlantic Ocean. I can't eat it. Everything else - great! I love their hot veggie sub. Their veal parm sub is great too! Their staff is also very friendly. ....and for the first time ever (mind you they've been open forever) now offering free delivery! I guess the recession is good for something! read more

Was roaming downtown Walpole for a quick bite too eat. I noticed Supreme Pizza on part of a strip mall right near the center of town. I went in and three kids looked about high school age or perhaps older were in the kitchen and were surprised by my visit + the place was empty. I asked if they had slices. "Nope". So I left and went next door to Ginjos. I'll be sure to rate again when I actually try their food. read more

Best meatball sub in Walpole! The delivery is always fast and the counter help is great. The pizza is just so-so in my opinion. Salty and it doesn't stand out but it's edible. Also, the onion rings are amazing. read more

First and foremost this is my FIRST review. Im never one to be negative but a place that FILLS there italain subs with bologna needs a negative review!! I ordered a small Italian w everything. To them everything is brown lettuce tomatoe 2 slicked pickles hots Somalia and bologna!!!! Grosss! Whoever uses bologna on a italain sub obviously is trying to save $$ and has VERY LOW QUAILTY meats. Needles to say ill never return ate half and tossed it. Browning on the lettuce was gross to..just a place trying to save a buck. Word of advice skip the bologna get real italain cold cuts!! read more

Service is great. Super friendly and delivery is quick and accurate. Food is consistent, although we tend to have better luck when we eat at the restaurant vs delivery. read more

yummmmmm! :P currently eating it as I type. BEST GREEK PIZZA EVER! This pizza shop is open later than others which is a plus, and they sell my favorite type of potato chips (Wachusett) read more

Supreme Pizza & Subs - Patriots fans too! GO PATS IS RIGHT - Pizza Near Me - Walpole, Massachusetts

I am a pizza snob and proud of it. I hold all restaurants to high standards w/ respect to thier niche. Pizza has to be Italian. The dough must be stretched by hand and cooked very crisp on a stone. Greek pizza is the same everywhere you go. The same dough,sauce and cheese and baked in a pan. A friend in the restaurant supply business once told me that all the Greek pizza shops buy from the same supplier who is also Greek! Have some originality. As far as Supreme- I had a steak n cheese there and that was ok- but the pizza was the same old song and dance- No disrespect to other yelpers- but as I read positive reviews for Greek pizza shops- I know right away that that yelper is not as in tuned as pizza afficianados go- and I view thier reviews with a squinted eye. Of all the best pizza places named on other review sites and other renowned circles, none are Greek style. ALL are Italian- Regina, Santarps, Peppe, Bianchi's, Original Ray's(New York) and that should tell you something. As far as Walpole is concerned- I would go to Leo's, Papa Gino's, Pizza Grande or Guito's before I went here or any other Greek style place. read more

Pizza here is ok. Nothing special. They used to have a fish sub. That was good so of course they don't sell that anymore. Don't bother attempting to call in order for subs anyhow. They never get the order right. Just give up and go someplace else. read more

Been going here for years and recommending this place to everyone. Tonight I was met with heavy dose of disappointment. I had a very tight window after a graduation to pick up pizza and get to a party. Earlier in the day, I stopped in and placed my order for 8pm pick up. I even paid at that time - something I don't usually do but I absolutely loved this place. When I showed up, they had forgotten the order totally messing up the rest of the evening. I waited around and they managed to get it all done in 20 minutes but did not offer anything else - partial comp, additional items, etc...I guess they didn't care if I came back so I probably won't. Even deleted their contact from my phone. read more