Surf City fishery offers a fine selection of fresh fish. The service is excellent. During the summer season, they also sell fresh Jersey corn and tomatoes. read more

Got day-boat scallops and stuffed clams today. Not disappointed!! Everything was so fresh. The scallops were tender, and not gritty.the stuffed clams were seasoned perfectly and so didn't have fillers. Will definitely go back. Highly recommend. Did I mention that they are very nice, and kind. read more

Sadly it looks like this great fresh seafood store may be closed permanently. Hope I'm wrong and that we see them open later in the season as we've been going there for 15+ years. read more

It has been a pleasure to shop for our family's seafood at Surf City Fishery, as they have one of freshest seafood markets on the island. Both the brothers, Gary and Marty bend over backwards to accommodate your needs. Salmon, Tile fish and halibut are a weekly purchases for us, along with their wild shrimp from the gulf. Scallops are sweet and tender. If you are traveling a distance, ask for a bag of ice. Their prices are excellent and their service is 5 star. Confidently recommending this store. read more

I've been the The Fishery twice, once last summer and then again today. The purpose of today's visit was to get lunch for my step-dad and I. They had lots of fresh fish but we wanted cooked items. They have a nice menu but it was a little pricey. I ordered a shrimp and scallop platter and my step-dad got a shrimp platter. Each was $19 and came 2 side items. It's worth noting there are only 3 side items to pick from: corn on the cob, fries, and coleslaw. We both picked fries and coleslaw. With our platters in tow we walked back to our beach house. My platter had 5 shrimp and 3 scallops. They were fine, but nothing to rave about. The coleslaw was homemade and a little sweet, which is what I'm used to. The fries were just typical fries and could have used another min to get crispier. The shrimp platter had 10 shrimp. The breeding seemed to be cornmeal based. So, nice lunch but I think it was a little expensive for what we got. read more

Surf City Fishery - customers at the fish market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

See all

I hadn't been to this Fishery for a couple of years but excellent quality continues. We bought fresh clams and tilefish for dinner tonight. The seafood was pricey ($20 per pound for tilefish and flounder) but absolutely delicious. Clams were very tender. We will return. So happy they were there and offer local fish and clams. read more

Fresh fish was unreal and the steamers were sweet and delicious! A great go to when in LBI!

Ordered a crab cake sandwich...$10.99-it was honestly more like a slider...on a huge bun!! Small portion of mediocre fries along with it...such a disappointment! Lobster bisque was just ok...rest of our order was ok-but definitely portion size and price were inconsistent...really disappointed in this visit read more

I love this place. Local guys own and run the shop. They only carry what's fresh and are so helpful and friendly. Every weekend I come here and stock up on fresh fish, stuffed clams, homemade crab cakes and key lime pie. I nearly just cleaned them out of their blues (which finally came in since the winds stopped). If you have a few minutes - have them shuck some clams for you and fry them up for an amazing dinner. read more

Heard nothing but good about this place and my own experiences were good as well. Had take-out from their limited menu (no eating on site, it's mostly fresh fish sold here) and crab cakes were tasty though small with little filler, breaded flounder melts in your mouth. They close early so go before dinner time. Another time we bought salmon to bake at home, and although its a testament to the chef more than the store, the salmon was to-die-for! Pr ice wasn't bad. read more

Great little seafood market! The sea food is fresh and delicious, the people are friendly and helpful...the true star of the show? THE KEY LIME PIE!!!! It is so incredibly delicious, almost unbelievable. You're doing yourself a disservice if you don't try some when you go. My friend and I stood over the one we got and ate the entire thing in one shot, THAT GOOD! read more

Needed to pick up some clams for steamers for Labor Day on LBI. The Little Necks they recommended were fresh, clean, and not chewy. Very reasonable prices. Friendly help behind the counter. Will be back for some Tuna steaks that looked outrageous. read more

Surf City Fishery - Little Necks. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

We went to purchase some fish.... knowing that this place has quality products. We got a dozen oysters, and had them for lunch. Clean and tasty. We bought some tuna... threw it on the grill... perfect dish. The fish was super fresh. Had a talk with the proprietor... very nice fellow. Great experience. read more

I really appreciate this place. Nothing pretentious or "fancy," just some good seafood to choose from. We go each year during our visits to LBI. They always have good corn on the cob, awesome tomatoes, and pasta and local sauces. They also have ice - always helpful. The prices are reasonable and the service very friendly. We will keep coming her for our clams and mussels. read more

The BEST seafood. Not cheap- but why would it be? Family owned business, great guys behind the counter, very knowledgeable about fish & seafood. They'd never sell anything that wasn't grade A. We've been shopping there for a long time and will continue to do so. And, they're still open after most of the other places close for the season, so you can still find good fish after Labor Day! I've never bought the prepared foods- I hear that they're family recipes. We just buy the fish/seafood and take it home to cook. I always ask for their recommendation as to what to buy that day and have never been disappointed. Go! read more

Always get takeout at The Surf City Fishery. We've never been disappointed. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable-just nice people that appreciate your business. Looking forward to stopping in again next week. The peel and eat shrimp are fabulous along with every other dish we have ordered. Prices are reasonable for where you are. read more

We love stopping here when we come for our vacation in Ship Bottom. The seasoned peak and eat shrimp are my favorite and I cannot come to LBI without getting. They have the best cocktail sauce, and a nice selection of tomatoes and breads if you need to add to your meal. The fish is always fresh, and very delicious, and the staff is always nice and helpful. read more

I've been going to this place since I was a child with my grandparents. She would buy little necks for her Manhattan Clam Chowder (which could compete at Chowderfest), and they always seem to have what you're looking for. If they don't, they'll recommend something that has just come off the boats in Barnegat Light. It remains our generational place to go, as others on the Island are overpriced and usually carry seafood that isn't local. Family owned by a really nice family, so I always try to make a trip to support them when I'm on the Island, which is frequently. read more

Stopped by Surf City Fishery yesterday on the way home from a day at the beach. Upon entering the store a strong bleach odor is what I first noticed. Bought a lb of medium shrimp and had the man put some ice around the shrimp and we put the bag in a cooler for the hour ride home. Decided to grill skewered shrimp. Shrimp had a bleach odor like the store and some were mushy. If I lived closer I would have returned the entire bag. The shrimp were marinated with olive oil, garlic, lemon, salt,pepper and cilantro but were not flavorful and had a weird taste. Needless to say.... 1/2 lb shrimp was thrown out! Never again will we stop at this supposingly fresh shore fishery! read more

Ordered large take out shore dinner for big group. Lobster and crab legs were average. The Cole slaw and potato salad that come with it were the most amazing I've ever had. Also great clams casino. Quick take out service. read more

Excellent food, but only offers take out. If the owners put a few tables outside, this place would be a homerun! A wide array of seafood is available, either in cooked platters or raw to take home and cook. Reasonable prices. read more

This place is the BEST - iconic, old school, LBI like it's been for generations. Great, fresh seafood. Concrete floors, guys in rubber boots hosing it down between orders. No nonsense. Plus...key lime pies, bread, tomatoes, pasta, rice...why go anywhere else? Seafood is local, reasonably priced. Support this place - it's a mainstay on LBI! read more

I'm 48 and have known these folks since I was a kid going with my Mom to get clams and mussels. All those years ago their father owned the shop. Now its theirs. Always great customer service. The fish, clams and mussles are always fresh. The stuffed clams are awesome. Give them a try. If you need local fishing knowledge, they will help you. Give the Surf City Fishery a try for your fresh fish needs. read more

I had local oysters on half she'll & king crabs cooked to go. Food was fresh and prepared well & ready when promised. This is not a sit down place but nice place 4 fresh local seafood you can cook yourself or have prepared 4 you. read more

5 platters and soup was $108. Food was excellent and fresh but still hungry afterwards. We opened the platters and were baffled by how little we got for the price. Again food is good but the proportions are definitely not worth the price read more

As good as it gets on LBI. Been a customer here for years and never had a bad experience. All the shellfish is a fresh as you can buy. I drive up from N Beach Haven to shop here. Pass 1/2 dozen others suppliers to do so. read more

The original LBI fishery is also the most authentic! The fish smell that hits you at the door tells you that it's all so fresh!! My kids love the thick white flesh of their flounder fillets, tastier than any other place. Nice "brotherly" service, great selection and fair prices: it's worth the trip and our loyalty!! read more