This was my first time at Cassidy's. The interior was super clean and there was a decent selection…read moreof fresh fish, shrimp, scallops, and oysters. They also have sauces, marinades, and lemons for you to season your seafood of choice. I had major sticker shock as I'm only used to buying fish from the grocery store. The prices here for seafood are a premium. However, I trust that buying fish this way supports your local fisherman, is ethical, and is much fresher than what you'd ever get from the grocery store (most likely frozen before) My friends and I decided on tilefish as we all have never tried it. It did NOT disappoint. It had a nice "chew" to it, and it picked up the flavors of lemon, salt, pepper, and blackening seasoning so well. If it's a special occasion or you just want to buy fresh fish directly on the island, give Cassidy's a try!

Let me start by saying I have always LOVED Cassidy's--both the quality of the fish and the service…read more But today, I got real attitude from one of the guys, to the point that it upset me. I said I didn't love the way they cut my halibut (long thin strip). I was nice, not angry. He snapped at me and said: "What do you want me to do?" Now meanwhile I've bought Haibit from them 20 times. Mean guy who has clearly never heard "the customer is always right."

Wifey has wanted to come here for years and on our first night on the island this year we made it…read morehappen. After looking over the menu I was expecting this to be an inside, sit down restaurant, but it's completely open air seating, you order at the counter, and then wait to be called...everything is made fresh. Just so you know the seating is limited, only ten tables, and most people seemed to get meals to go. We lucked out and a table opened up as we got there so we stayed. I ordered a cup of the New England Clam Chowder and the Broiled Viking Village Scallops (all the meals came with 1/2 a corn on the cob and smashed potatoes). Wifey ordered the Broiled Shrimp meal, daughter had the Grilled Shrimp meal, and my son and daughter's boyfriend both ordered the Grilled Atlantic Salmon meals. We all really liked our meals. My clam chowder was a little salty, but had lots of clam and was great. The corn and smashed potatoes were also very tasty. If you like garlic, order the scallops...they didn't scrimp. We all walked away very full, very happy, and very much willing to return.

Very underwhelming experience... Portion sizes are pretty much robbery given the prices charged…read morehere. Never in my life have I ordered tacos and received one single taco? Which seemed to be a frozen fish filet which is Strange since this location is right next to the docks where fresh seafood is brought in at on the daily. Girlfriend got the scallop poke bowl which only had 3 scallops... sad. Also ordered the "boneless wings" which appeared to just be Tyson frozen buffalo bites.

Fabulous, fresh seafood! Mussels were beautifully prepped as well as the clams…read more The stuffed clams and crab cakes were delicious! Such a pleasure to prepare and serve to guests at my dinner party!

Bought some New England clam chowder twice now both times hardly any clams mostly potatoes you…read morecould do better at the gateway Both times I mentioned this to the workers there and the owner was in earshot and he just ignored it I don't know where these people are getting five star reviews from Just goes to show you that this is a tourist area and people are happy with anything even bad Coffee

Incredible service and food! Had Evan as our server. He was wonderful! We were seated quickly and…read moretreated so kindly by staff.

Food and drinks are always good and reliable. Service friendly and ambiance especially the outside…read morepatio is great no matter the season!

Finally made it to the BEST seafood market in Atlantic county! Such an excellent variety of fresh…read morefish! So many choices! Shout out to the employees, so nice and friendly, thank you!

Love this place!! When you walk into the store it's so cool. It's a fish store. We got artic char…read moreand tuna last time, fresh and delicious. The time before we got clams and some didn't open. I mentioned to one of the people who worked there. Well they more than made up for it. It wasn't necessary but well appreciated. Our favorite fish store.

Met the owner today. He fried up some of the best fried clams south of Massachusetts. Damn near…read moreperfection. Driving back next week!

This is for takeout that was picked up…read more Flounder Sandwich - my usual go to is ship bottom shellfish which has been shaving on portion size and sides. Found Boulevard version with great breading/coating that was crisp and fries were nice and crisp. Salmon Sandwich - nice sized portion for the price. Good taste - would think about what kind of sauce you would recommend - like an aioli - was not quite sure what to eat with. Small thing - they could have remembered some ketchup in the bag for the fries. Totally my 2 cents - coming in, would put the clams front and center walking in. Instead, had a bunch of different things for takeout. It's your name sake. Also, the fish in the display was a little sparse. If you're using the online ordering, you have to submit your order to find out how long the wait til pickup is.

Best seafood takeout on LBI. The flounder was fresh and flaky and the scallops were to die for…read more Kudos to the chef.

Amazing food great value always consistent just wish we could dine in addition to takeoutread more

ALWAY great!! Open all year!! The food, the service, the space are all great!! Never…read moredisappointed!! Their chowders are magnificent!!

Hi Shore Fresh here! Wanted to let everyone know that we have opened a second location here.The old…read moreCo-Op seafood is now another Shore Fresh, so come by and check us out!

Kelly's has good, basic food. They coukd extend the time they serve breakfast since they close by 2…read morepm every day. They are more like a diner than a restaurant. Service is good, but they have a waitress there who likes talking to the men when they come in and igniores the women. I find this very rude. She could pissibly be one of the owners as well, but that does not give her the right to be rude. Ambiance is typical diner with an outdoor area that is a bit buggy. They usec to be very good, they were opened in the evenig, and even had luve entertainment fir awhile. But, now it's just a basic diner with pretty goid food. I give it 3 stars because of the rudeness, no excuse for that!

What a great place at lbi. Good food and vibes. Love to visit on the island. Sometimes the…read moreswordfish is great

Please support Mustache Bill's - they are trying to sell the business…read more Keep our beloved diner open! Nick has been a server for 15 years! Cash Only. Excellent Blueberry French toast. So many memories here. Love this place. PLEASE DON'T CLOSE it nor Bulldoze it.

Overcrowded. Basic diner food. Even the coffee is basic. Not worth the wait for food I can make…read morejust as well at home