With this bakery being so close to us, my partner and I eat here often. It isn't simply out of convenience. The food is amazing! The undisputed crown jewel of this place is the Key Lime Pie. It is an absolute masterpiece. read more

I had heard good things about T Distefano's bakery before and happened to be in Mebane for the day. I'm so glad I was because everything we tried was delicious. The shop has the display cases right when you walk in the door and there is a little cafe area off to the right which seemed cute. We were greeted when we walked in and the girl who helped us gave us plenty of time while we decided what to order. I asked what her favorite thing was that they had and she told me the danishes or the cheesecakes. I ended up ordering several things to try: a glazed donut, glazed raspberry filled donut, powdered raspberry filled donut, cheese danish, chocolate chip cookie, and cinnamon roll. The donuts and cinnamon roll were given to family who already knew how good the donuts were and we tried the chocolate chip cookie and cheese danish. The chocolate chip cookie was huge, chewy, and had a great flavor. I think my favorite thing I tried was the cheese danish. The dough was buttery and the filling wasn't too sweet. It was a great suggestion from the girl working there. Also, all of this was under $18 which is crazy. Will definitely be coming back. read more

See all

Pumpkin cream cheese muffin for the win-it was delicious! I would say that the service was average, the young ladies working seemed a bit overwhelmed when three of us were in line waiting to order. The display cases of the sweet treats looked well organized and the presentation made it really hard to choose just one thing, as there were so many items on display that looked absolutely inviting! read more

T Distefano's Bakery - the outside of the building - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

Permanently closed. Not sure why Yelp hasn't caught up with the fact that this place is closed. Drove 10 minutes out of my way for a cup of coffee to only find an empty building. read more

Mebane is a haven for chains, so it was a pleasant surprise to find this small independent bakery so close to all the national retail. It reminded me of Amoroso's in Greensboro albeit with a more limited selection. That said, everything that was in stock - cakes, cheesecake rolls, traditional Italian desserts, and more - looked appealing. The woman working the counter was patient while I looked everything over. In the end, I opted for a cannoli, and it proved to be a good decision. Even after the drive home, it was still tasty. Mebane is far from the first place that comes to mind when you think of Italian bakeries, but if you're out this way and looking for one, Distefano's is the first name you should think of. read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Cannoli - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

I found this gem while finding a local coffee shop while driving. I was not expecting a bakery full of massive desserts, which got me more excited that I stopped here. I got the Boston Crème Cake and a peppermint mocha latte. The two ladies behind the counter were extremely helpful and knowledgeable. I also noticed how this is a Christian friendly and super laid back environment, which is definitely a plus for me! I will definitely be back to this spot in the near future! read more

See all

I stopped here on my way to shop at the outlets. I wanted something sweet and tasty and this place was recommended by Yelp of course. Wow, once entering the smell of fresh my baked goods hit you. They have tons of choices of sweets, from cupcakes, cookies, pastries, donuts, I feel like I'm missing something I was so overwhelmed...lol. I ended up getting raspberry twist, raspberry cream cheese filled pastry, apple dumpling cupcake, and a cream horn. All were fresh and very tasty. The cream horn was not overpowering with the icing inside, it was fluffy and delicate if that makes sense. It was so good. I highly recommend stopping here if you have a sweet tooth craving, you want he disappointed!!! I look forward to stopping again when I'm in the area!!!!!! read more

The place is very cute and the people were very friendly but I have very opposite opinions about the two items I got. The tiramisu was amazing but the eclair was dry and overall not the best. Seems like the kind of place where you need to know what is good to order and what you shouldn't. read more

Great desert! The service was good! It felt like home. I loved the treat I had below in the photo! read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

What can I say. Tom and his employees have knocked it out of the park with this bakery! We went for the bagels (which sadly they aren't making currently) but we stayed for the people and the sweets! They helped us turn around a day that was otherwise pretty dreary and made it so sweet! The tiramisu was hands down my favorite (and I'm a tiramisu lover!) but we didn't try anything we didn't like! Would highly recommend supporting this wonderful, local spot! read more

Food is sooo good. Service was decent. Very cute place. One of the better Italian places in Mebane.

This bakery is great! Coffee is good and a nice place to hang out a little. I really hate they stopped selling donuts because they were the best around especially the frosted chocolate one. I'd give 5 stars but I miss the donuts! read more

This bakery is consistently amazing. The donuts are incredible, the bagels are phenomenal (these are real NY style bagels!) the cakes are as delicious as they are beautiful... I've been going to this bakery for YEARS and I'm ALWAYS happy!! Get the Apple fritter and thank me later!!! read more

The cake roll, oatmeal cookies and caramel latte were amazing. The young lady at the counter was friendly and knowledgeable. The ambience was great for the season and the kid art added warmth and cheer. read more

They have wonderful pastries, pies, cakes, etc!!! I love to get some beautiful desserts there as often as possible! The service is great!

The BEST Bakery! I have had a lot of their goodies from cakes, cupcakes, coffee, doughnuts and these are the best doughnuts around!! This time we ordered for my daughter's first birthday read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Doughnuts from T. Distefano's - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

We went in for donuts and found out they don't make them anymore, that's okay! Best pastries I've had in a long time. The raspberry bear claw was amazing! We will definitely be back. read more

This is a great spot for pastries and bagels. I've been a few times before and each time they have a different selection. I went about 15 minutes after they opened and they were still bringing out some of the items. The bagels were so fresh and delicious and still hot when I got home. We got the cheddar bagel and sun-dried tomato bagel, both were so good! We also got a few muffins, which were also amazing. The blueberry muffin had so many big, fresh blueberries in them and the cinnamon crunch muffin was also good. I'm so happy I found this yummy bakery! read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Fresh bagels - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

See all

I highly recommend Distefanos, my family has ordered all kinds of cakes for Birthdays & other parties for years. I have never had a pastry there I didn't enjoy. The front door should have a warning label telling people to enter at their own risk cause it's that good. read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Welcome - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

This bakery has the BEST donuts I have ever eaten, and I'm over 60 y years old! It's only 2 minutes off the highway and we'll worth the stop. Simply amazing!!! read more

I called on Labor Day to ask about there hard rolls and was talked to like I should've known they stopped makeing bread a year ago. First of all I don't live in mebane so no I wouldn't know, second of all stop using of we don't have help. Those rolls are very popular and would sell our hence why I was calling early was to have some put aside read more

Excellent food and service! Love this place! We always get the Swiss roll and the key lime pie!

The crumb cake is amazing. Anything else I have tried has been somewhat ordinary and plain.

Got a bunch of sweets to try from here. I believe they are known for their cream filled donuts but anything here is delicious! They also have a drive up window so you don't even have to exit the car. I think my favorite thing so far has been the red velvet cupcake and donuts! It's totally worth the drive for some food sweets. They also have bagels... the jalapeño cheese bagel is awesome! read more

See all

Best Bakery in Mebane. With great people that are knowledgeable about the items they sell you.

As per the norm, other Yelpers suggest and I obey (particularly when venturing forth into the smaller towns of NC where no Baker has gone before). As per the norm, I'm very glad that we listened, as T. Distefano's Bakery takes 'pastry power' to a whole other level. Let's get things straight here: despite any hint or suggestion to the contrary, this isn't a 'coffee shop'. It's a bakery that sells drip coffee, which is quite different (as has been explored in an earlier review). Don't get all worked up if you think that donuts, muffins, and more should automatically come with espresso delights - that's just your not-really-European-but-you-think-it-is-because-you're-a-Starbucks-bred-American caffeinated sensibility talking. Distefano's isn't about waking up; it's about bringing about a delicious-induced carb coma, with occasional jolts of sugary goodness. We stopped here prior to venturing into the maw of the capitalistic beast (i.e. Tangier outlets), and it provided our two nap-less little girls with just enough M&M cookie energy to carry them through the outlet-shopping without a complete and total meltdown. The cookies seemed massive prior to our actually holding them, and when our girls actually had their little paws on the things, it became apparent that distance and non-glare glass doesn't skew the actual size of baked ridiculousness. See the photo - their cookies were as big as their faces, and they loved them. I got an apple turnover (crispy, chewy pastry crust spewing forth chopped apple gooey sweetness - 'spewing' isn't usually a great verb, but trust me - it works here) and my beloved got a almond something-or-other (that's portrayed in another of the pictures here). She geeked on it, describing it as densely sweet and crunchy. She also bought a half-dozen of their glazed donuts (some stuffed with fruity stuff, some plain). When it was all said and done, it cost us just over $12, which wasn't bad at all. I ended up going back in to get one of their huge blueberry muffins, which I ate today - even a day later, this thing held its moist, berry-stuffed consistency. Friendly, helpful, and patient service, with the fellow helping us talking through each pastry with my wife (who, bless her soul, loses all ability to make food-related decisions when it actually comes time to order anything). It had plenty of tables inside, and a couple of outside tables with chairs, where we sat and stuffed our faces in the warm North Carolina sun. We'll be back. read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Just a couple of amazing cookies. Seriously, these things are the size of dinner plates. - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

WHAT HAPPENED??? We started going here shortly after Tom started DiStefsno's. The pastries were SPOT-ON and the fillings were MORE than adequate, BUT, that was then.....this is now! I paid (and I do mean paid) a visit just a couple of days ago and purchased a dozen of Tom's offerings, all white cream except for four combo white cream/raspberry filling. No longer were any filled to capacity, no longer were any fresh and puffy, now they had a minimum, stingy amount of cream and jelly. They were no longer light and fluffy, now they're coarse, dry, and almost stale. Tom: The exceptional amount of filling and the absolute freshness was the very factor that made your product(s) head and shoulders above your competition! I understand the rising prices, BUT, due to past temper tantrums and severe drop in quality.....this Veteran will not darked your threshold again. read more

This bakery is a GEM! The baked goods are always fresh, taste amazing, and come with superior service! They have a drive thru and full barista services as well! read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Our favorite cake from there, decorated for New Years - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

Before all the delicious Christmas cookies are gone, I remembered to take a photo. So light and delicious. We're so glad I took a trip through Mebane as recommended by friends from the SECU Family House in Chapel Hill. Some new cookies we haven't had before and other favorites from childhood neighbors. I certainly will be driving the longer path again. We also enjoyed the crumb cake very much. read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

They have the best strawberry cupcakes. I hate they stopped selling smoothies. Always great food

2015 FB review: I have loved your sweets, from Chocolate Chess Pie, to Doughnuts, to the best Cannoli ever, to Cream Cheese Pumpkin Muffins. Five Years and counting. Even after moving 30 miles away. I miss coming in many times a week for coworkers' dirty dozen ;] Best customer service and freshness ever! DiStefano's rocks and may they continue to prosper and persevere! Never did think that Atkin's diet was a good idea... And Distefano's is still setting the bar high. Monthly excursion here now whenever in NC fore health care visits...doctors loooove that I supplement my GI special diet with rich sweets in moderation. Sure they do! Right before a blood pressure reading ; ] Best coffee this side of the interstate. Chocolate chess pie to knock the socks off friends' sweet tooths...teeth? Love picking up holiday pies and breads here, also. read more

T Distefano's Bakery - The face of Distefano's definitely lifted since their infant years! My dogmobile parked with recently vetted doggage inside that icebox. - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

This place looked like they were closed for good! We stopped there on a Monday morning and thought maybe they were close on Mondays even though the door said they were opened. It was dark and there was nothing in the cases or anyone working . We can back a couple of days later and it looked the same. So said because when we travel that way it's our favorite bakery:-( read more

Excellent Latte's and the best donuts anywhere. If you like the crème filled donut it will stand out in your mind as the best in the world. Yes, it is the best bakery in Mebane. read more

Great bakery for Mebane. Lots of options from donuts, pies, and cakes. The service isn't always the best, sometimes I've asked about favorites or what's the best pastry to get on a day and the staff has been rather cold. But regardless for an in and out shopping it's pretty good. read more

It's hardly ever open. Every time we try to go it's closed with a hand written sign on the door

This place is the real deal! What a happy coincidence we found it. On our way from GSO to the coast house shopping we needed a coffee stop. After stopping at Distefano's it makes me think "maybe we should be narrow our online search for homes near places with good bakeries." We did have a good cup of coffee and a latte as we were searching for. In addition we had the most delightful, if slightly unconventional, bagel - light and tender inside and gently crisp on the outside. They even have bismarcks made of a delicious donut, buttery angel cream filling and raspberry jelly. Everything was fresh and fully homemade. Maybe I'm glad we don't live closer. read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

See all

Donuts are delicious. We miss the savory choices. It's what made this place five stars.

Delicious! I've had a ton of danishes before and this was probably the best I've ever had. A great selection of treats! So glad I stopped in! read more

T Distefano's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mebane, North Carolina

See all

Wow ! I thought the pumpkin cream cheese muffin would be good ...but not THIS good ! I almost ate another, but... Stop by and try their muffins , and the several doughnuts that I'll be enjoying later ! read more

Excellent pastries and cakes! They have the best donuts in the area. The customer service was wonderful.