Just passing by this small town while really hungry when we saw this pizza place and wanted to give…read moreit a try. Most orders are takeout but they had a small seating area. The pizzas are between 15-20$ for a good sized pizza and was pretty average overall. The service was okay and the bad part was loaded breadsticks came with this fake artificial nacho cheese with bacon bits which I would have never expected and was not even able to take one bite of it to enjoy it. Probably wouldn't go back but was very hungry at the time

Pizza was good. Owner was server, and likely chef cook and bottle washer, as they say! He was…read moregreat. Went there for the GF pizza and it was very good. Will return. I little bit . . . okay, more than a little bit . . . of a hole in the wall, as I think there a only three small tables. I'm guessing, it does quite a take-out/delivery business. Not a place for a date night, but worth giving it a try for a bite!

Great little place for a cozy pizza dinner. Friendly, attentive staff. Pizza was perfect…read more In from Alabama and was really wanting a good pizza. This place did not disappoint. Really fills you up. Looking for a great local pizza place, this is it.

Nice local Italian restaurant with tasty food. Will definitely be going there again soon.read more

Cute on the inside with a nice patio area. They did NOT skimp on the toppings and all the workers…read morewere really lovely.

Awesome stop for the whole fam. Spicy, sweet, savory, all the bases. Plus they have VEGAN options…read moreincluding non dairy cheese, tradition red sauce and the traditional crust are also vegan. Service is fast and easy. Chill vibe with good tunes. They used to turn this place into a dance party at nights but I don't know if they still do it.

I'll admit I was skeptical walking in. The restaurant is attached to a hotel that isn't the nicest,…read moreand the entrance had a strong hotel‑cleaning‑supply smell that made me apprehensive. But from the moment we sat down, it was all uphill from there. The Italian wedding soup was excellent, rich, flavorful, and clearly homemade. The pizza was decent, nothing extraordinary but solid with plenty of cheese. We also ordered the lasagna, the spicy chicken dish, and spaghetti and meatballs. The standout was the spicy chicken: the "spicy red sauce" turned out to be more of a creamy, spicy blend, and it was fantastic. Everything came out piping hot, which I really appreciated. They also bring out warm rolls, and those were surprisingly tasty, soft, fresh, and perfect for dipping. Overall, I highly recommend this place. Despite the rough first impression, it turned out to be one of the best restaurants in the area.

Oh my goodness--I truly felt like I was back in Italy while dining at Mike's! My husband and I…read morefirst met Mike when he was part owner of Mama Mia's on the square in Baraboo, and now he's opened his own restaurant as the sole owner. Mike immigrated here legally from Albania and became a U.S. citizen, and you can taste the pride he puts into every dish--everything is homemade, even the pasta. I had the spicy chicken arrabbiata with Alfredo sauce, and it was absolutely delicious. The homemade garlic knots were mouthwatering, and the salads were fresh and crisp. My friend ordered the shrimp pasta and loved it. I also brought home two pizzas for my family, and they said it was the best pizza they've ever had! The service was excellent, and the restaurant itself is spacious with a great bar area. From now on, Mike's Italian Restaurant will be our go-to spot whenever we're in Baraboo. If you're in the area, give Mike a try--you won't be disappointed!

we stopped as we were passing thru after reading the reviews and it did not disappoint. The food…read morewas amazing. And at a great price. Very clean inside. There was a sweeter older gal running her ass off. Her service was quick and just the sweetest person ever. well worth the stop

The food was good, but there were a couple things I would change. Namely the small portion of…read morecurds, the seasoning and the restroom situation. There are no indoor bathrooms. You have to use a porta potty outside. That was not a great experience for me. Service was great and the restaurant was clean.

Usually really happy with the food. Today our pizza was overcooked. Crust was way over done, too…read moredark to eat.

Uptown pizza was tasty. The service was friendly and speedy and the place was clean and quiet. I…read morecant give it the full five stars until I try it again ( I got an upset stomach immediately after leaving so I need to try it again to make sure it wasn't just a coincidence) , but if you're ever in Tomah check them out!

I bought the frozen pizzas from my kids school for a fundraiser. They are great…read more Whenever I go there the pizza is also delicious

Permanently closed. Only took cash, check or debit card. Placed was outdated and need some…read moreremodeling.

We visited family in town and enjoyed a pizza night at this restaurant. Despite being packed with…read morecustomers, the place was impressively clean, and the staff handled the busy crowd well. The atmosphere for dining in was basic, but the cleanliness and efficiency stood out. The pizzas were exceptional--bursting with unique flavors and cooked perfectly. I highly recommend trying this pizza shop. I'll definitely return on a future visit!

Fast, wood fired pizza that's delicious! Great drinks! Will be back! Heads up that the line can get…read morelong if it's a busy time.

We've been by this place biking a number of times. It has limited hours, but our timing was right…read moreSaturday. Great stop for Bloodies. There's a bowling alley and arcade, full bar and menu. Owners were on sight and really nice. There's also ample outside seating and more activities to be had outside. I'll be happy to go back next time through town.

Food and service was great. Nice atmosphere. Can't wait to go back…read more Restaurant and Bowling alley renovated beautifully.

This is the best pizza place ever in my life I love it here so much and the family is so nice…read more Also, the owner(?) gave me fist bump. Awesome

The food is always delicious and the service excellent. We visit as often as we can because we love…read moreMama Mia's so much. If you're in downtown Baraboo, Wisconsin, please give them a try, you won't be disappointed if you love good pasta and pizza!