Great prime rib on Saturday great views and friendly staff! Perfect view at sunset. A little bit…read moreof a wait but can't complain with the big area in the back to chill and relax. Kids had fun exploring the shoreline

Very Disappointing Experience Unfortunately, our experience…read moreat Sunset on the Water was very disappointing. The service was extremely poor. We waited about 30 minutes for our food, and when we were ready to leave, we actually had to track down our server just so we could pay our bill. What makes it even more frustrating is that this is the second time we've experienced poor service here. We gave it another chance hoping our previous visit was just an off night, but unfortunately, it wasn't any better. The food wasn't anything special either and certainly didn't make up for the lack of service. After two disappointing experiences, we won't be back.

The waterfront location is definitely the biggest draw here. Sitting outside overlooking the harbor…read moremakes for a really nice setting, especially during the summer. Unfortunately, the food just didn't live up to the view. We tried the nachos, mahi tacos and drinks, and while everything was fine, nothing really stood out. The flavors were what you'd expect from a lakeside bar. Service was very friendly, but overall the experience felt more like you're paying for the location than the food itself. I'd come back for a drink on the patio, but probably not for dinner.

The overall experience is pretty good, but I don't think I would consider anything exceptional. The…read moreservice was very friendly. A few things to note, their cocktail menu is amusing because their specialty drinks mostly seem to be five different standard recipes with slightly different preparations to turn them into Mojitos or spritzes or margaritas. Do you want something with blueberries? Pick your preparation. All of them are too sweet. Their peanut butter crème brûlée was tasty, but doesn't really qualify as a crème brûlée. It was basically a runny, peanut butter flavored almost pudding. Their pizzas were really good though. Frankly, I was most surprised by the ambience. For a place that looks so big from the outside. It seemed really cramped inside I walked around all of the seating areas and it was the same everywhere. While they bill themselves as being on the water, you really can't see the water from any seat in the house from what I observed, even if you're out on the deck, which is terribly uncomfortable in July. We actually were seated at possibly the worst table in the house. In a back corner behind the first floor bar next to a window that only showed you the backside of another building and a sliver of grass. The upstairs seating is truly undesirable because they've converted an area that wasn't meant to have tables in. It is super cramped up there and also everywhere on the first floor. The only place with a little bit of elbow room is the deck. You know a place is to cramped when the servers have to negotiate moving between tables to avoid patrons and other servers.

We stopped at Becket's after Oshkosh, expecting a nice meal to cap off a great trip. Instead, we…read moreaccidentally participated in what felt like a live kitchen stress test. First, the good news: the atmosphere is beautiful, and our server, Marcus, deserves a raise. He was friendly, attentive, and handled a table full of increasingly confused diners with remarkable professionalism. None of what follows is on him. Now for the food. The mac and cheese was mostly mac with only a passing acquaintance with cheese. My mom ordered the halibut, and I'm fairly certain the chef mistook the salt shaker for a seasoning suggestion rather than a serving size. It was so aggressively salty that we asked Marcus to taste a bite from the untouched side because we honestly thought maybe we were crazy. He took one bite, his face instantly said, "Oh no," and he apologized before offering to replace it. Since the rest of us had already finished eating, my mom just asked for a salad. Somehow... that was worse. The blue cheese dressing tasted like blue cheese that had filed for retirement weeks ago. Vinegary, strange, and just plain off. My half chicken was the smallest half chicken I've ever seen. I'm still trying to figure out what happened to the other half of the half. It was cooked fine, but "not ruining chicken" isn't exactly a culinary achievement. My brother's prime rib was... okay. Not memorable, not offensive--just existing. The cocktails joined the theme. We sent two back because they simply weren't good and switched to beer. Thankfully, whoever made the beer knew what they were doing. I completely understand that every restaurant can have an off night. But when the mac and cheese has no cheese, the fish is inedible from salt, the replacement salad tastes questionable, the cocktails get sent back, and the rest of the food is merely surviving, it's hard to chalk it up to bad luck. Five stars for Marcus. One star for the kitchen. If those two teams ever get on the same page, this place could be excellent. **Update:** I want to give credit where it's due. After my wife posted her review on Google, the owner responded very thoughtfully and acknowledged that our table clearly did not receive the attention it should have. We never asked for a refund, and I wasn't expecting anything, but the restaurant refunded the bill and made sure our waiter was still compensated. That doesn't change the fact that the food and drinks that night were really disappointing, but it does say something positive about the ownership. Mistakes happen, rough nights happen, and I appreciate a business that takes responsibility instead of getting defensive. Marcus was excellent, and the owner's response was classy. I hope our visit really was just a bad night, because the way they handled it afterward deserves credit.

We made a reservation for 6 PM on a Saturday for four people. The view from the restaurant is…read morebeautiful and the ambiance inside is romantic. The waitress Kayla was great and super friendly. She checked on us just the right amount and even asked if we needed water way after paying our bill. The reason for the 3 stars is because my food was lukewarm at best. I ordered the salmon with French fries. The French fries tasted like they were under a heat lamp for 24 hours. My husband had the prime rib and he said it was good. I had a spicy margarita that wasn't great as well. This place has the potential to be amazing. It definitely fell short of expectations.

The food and service was excellent! Unfortunately, it is…read morenot a place for anyone handicapped. No handicap parking and on a main road so can't even drop off in front of establishment. Stairs, no ramps. And for a Thursday evening, it was jammed packed. Tables are extremely close together to accommodate as many people as possible. I had to wait for half the party to get up so I could push the table away from me so I could get out. One in our party had a walker and one a cane. On the way out, we ran into gridlock as there was another customer trying to get up the steps and into the building with another walker and there wasn't any room for anyone to make room for either walker! There was also a throw carpet in the main doorway the kept curling over and created a tripping hazard.

I was invited to dine at Cedar Lodge for a wedding rehearsal dinner. The bride is from the area and…read morecoordinated the dinner for about 20 people. It felt like home upon entering, friendly faces and the brides family knew most of the wait staff. The interior reminded me of up north/cabin like. The space is quaint and intimate. We we're divided into 3 table near each other given our parties size. They were staffed well, our table of 5 had two servers checking on us often. The menu had old school supper club vibes, with each entree you had your choice of soup, salad, AND potato(it's been a while since I had to make soo many options for dinner )! I opted for the strawberry soup-served cold, salad, baked potato, and chicken tenders. All meals come with a warm cinnamon sugar fritter before the meal. The strawberry soup, was amazing and perfect for a June evening! They also bring a basket of fresh baked bread and muffins with the soup which were delicious. Others in my group had steak, stir fry, and frog legs. Everyone enjoyed with no complaints! By the time we left every seat was taken! I'd definitely return again!

I loved this place. From the charming location, local bar, and outdoor patio - it's a gem! What's…read moreeven better is that for a local watering hole, if your party is big enough they'll actually take a reservation, al biet, it will probably be outside, but still no waiting is a win, especially on a Friday night!! I was going to get the fish fry but my partner decided to get the walleye, so I swerved to the prime rib. Which, spoiler, even with the princess cut, is MASSIVE. Include the salad and soup for the table, you will not leave hungry- that's for sure. The bartenders are super friendly and will give you a great pour with some good conversation. Overall, I enjoyed this spot greatly. It's a solid dinner with friends and family that just makes your heart happy.

Arrived at 5pm on a Saturday. Packed was told an hour wait and if we wanted to go outside it was…read morefirst come first serve. We did get a table for 4 and started our waiting. Outside bar took 15 minutes to get a drink (due to people there for Saturday music). Band speakers were loud + loud people talking over band (horrible band by the way), at 6:30 we were moved inside. Wait staff took our order and ordered the potato skin fries as an appetizer and our meals. Took 30 minutes for salads to appear but no appetizer. Was told the kitchen forgot and they would be out in 10 minutes. 20 minutes later cancelled appetizer. At 7:30 talked to owner to complain about wait time for food (60 minutes so far) and was told "we're very busy we have 150 people outside " (and then huffed off since we complained) maybe yea drinking your alcohol but not eating. Finally at 7:45 our food came. My 2 piece of deep fried chicken looked like it came from a deep fat fryer fire and even smelled burnt. You could actually use the leg as a nail hammer!! No apologies or nothing from ownership. Another issue is the "150" people coming in from the rain to use the bathrooms was not acceptable in our minds. If you're gonna have music outside, get portable potties.

Was in the area with a friend so we stopped in for lunch. Menu is really impressive- I had a hard…read moretime picking a sandwich. Our excellent server recommended the Reuben so I went with that. I really wanted to try more. House made chips were fantastic. Also, this place has a beautiful view out the windows and they placed a bird feeder directly outside!!

The salad was good and the service was great! However, the rest of the food I couldn't even eat…read more Not even the mashed potatoes were food as they had way too many green onions. I had ribs and my husband had fried fish.

You had me at frozen mugs of Root Beer with self serve refills off the tap for $5!…read more I had a great hot dog and truffle fries. Liked my meal. Another person in my group had the burger which was also great. Cool place, fun t-shirts and great music playing. Smallish outdoor area too.

The service was horrible we got our food and she never came back to check on us and then she was…read moreMAKING THE SHAKE FOR HERSELF my mom and my friend was waiting to get the bill for 20 minutes and then we had to go up and get the bill and then she still asked for the tip...this is unacceptable for this new place do not recommend

We got there late on Saturday night. They held the restaurant open for us. We are so appreciative…read moreas the food was outstanding!!! Two of us got the filet which was excellent. One of us got the Walleye which was also outstanding. The desserts were great! I will return to this restaurant the next time I am in Oshkosh. It is outstanding!

Some of the best gnocci I have ever had. Very soft and pillowy. Very apparent that it was homemade…read more Appetizers were fine- didn't get a picture. Same with drinks. Definitely get the pasta if you come here- cool front area with a large range of alcohol for purchase as well Service was not the best. I've been before with better service