I've been to tailgaters many times and the service is usually decent. I recently went and our waitress was high as a kite. Other staff noticed this and began taking over portions of her service. Other customers noticed. My beer was taken to the wrong table, order was wrong, and she was seen stumbling and walking around aimlessly. Food is always good but this is unacceptable. read more

We came in last night for the packer game and had the best time ever! The place was very bright, vibrant and energetic, plus the bartender Christian was very funny, outgoing, and made the best Bloody Mary I've ever had for only $5! I would highly recommend to anyone read more

Tailgaters Bar & Grill - Sports Bars Near Me - Caledonia, Wisconsin

This is a spacious bar with a good dart section indoor and outdoor dining and was overall impressive place I would highly recommended. This place looks to be a cool place to watch sports or hang with friends and there is nothing to knock about this place as it is a stand alone rural country redneck bar that will have you aching to come back read more

I am a summer visitor to the Caledonia, WI. area and have become a weekly regular to this great establishment. The service team are very personable and genuine. My go to has been the cauliflower crust pizza which is delicious every time. There fish fry is one of the best in the area. The experience is great in this comfortable place I recommend it strongly! Enjoy and be sure to meet the owner -Sam He is committed to making all visitors feel welcome. read more

Great food and great service. There were four in our party and we all loved what we ordered: meatballs and spaghetti; BLT; chicken nachos; and a ribeye steak sandwich. We will definitely be back! read more

Open face sandwich and Wisco tailgate burger we're great. Nice atmosphere great service

I don't know how you do it but keep it up! Food is always fantastic and the service, even when you stumble you seem to land on your feet. Every new staff member seems to try hard to please which is just unheard these days .Shit happens sometimes, it's inevitable. You guys own it, no excuses and I can't help but respect you for that. On top of that, you serve the coldest beer around which makes me so happy to support you. I can't believe that ice cold beer is not important to a lot of places in the area. Please don't ever let your guard down and continue to deliver and improve as you have been so you stay better than the rest. Cant wait for my next visit!!!!! read more

Have been there several times at first great service but every time we have been there service has gone down and tonight was the worst Long wait for a waitress. Drink order sat at the bar for 15 minutes. Girlfriend's food was cold read more

What a great find. We are camping at Yogi Bear and decided to head out for a bite to eat. The food was great, the service was excellent and all reasonably priced. To top it off, they have a cauliflower pizza crust for anyone that may have a gluten allergy or may be on a Keto diet. Highly recommended!! read more

Nice bar,had a couple of beers,and shots, with some cheese curds. The bartender was really friendly, I am definitely coming back .

Excellent pizza! First time trying the pizza, my picky eater husband keeps saying..."that was really good!"

We recently stopped here for a quick meal on a Friday night. We were greeted as soon as we walked in by a very nice bartender. She passed us off to the hostess when we indicated we wanted s table. Every one was very nice. I asked for a special accommodation with my meal and they were able to honor my request. Food was pretty good and it came up fast. Great neighborhood place. read more

Great food! Nice staff. Love the curds, eggplant fries, wings and pizza! Spacious and clean

I love their eggplant appetizer! I've had their pizza and it's pretty good, I'm not a pizza fan but I like their thin crust. One of the best pizzas in Caledonia area. read more

This place is a hidden gem on this countryside of town! This is a best kept secret that needs to be let out into the light! Food is exceptional and you have a lot to choose from. The staff is cordial and on point with all of your dinning needs The old bad thing I could say is, they are closed Mondays. What a wonderful spot! Give 'em a shot and enjoy!!! read more

Wow what a place . I had stopped in maybe a week after it opened and was disappointed. Have it a second chance and BOOM they blew me away. The wings where spot on best I tasted around town in a long long time. The nachos where absolutely excellent. Beer was perfectly chilled and the waitress was HOT! Bill was reasonable , she got a big tip for excellent service. Definitely will be back. Great job guys and love the new menus from what you opened with. Nice job read more

Our first time here was great. Food came out hot and quick. A little pricey but worth it due to previous comment. Second time, hot mess. Sat right away but waited 20 minutes to get a drink. Food came out lukewarm. The hot beer cheese Hs a hardened top layer. The potato pancakes were cold to my touch. Waitresses were overwhelmed and kept apologizing. Probably won't come back. read more

Great service, great drinks. Kristian was our bartender and was awesome. Bar had a good vibe. Lots of TVs and good music.

I've been coming to this bar for the past two years. Thursday I had their hamburger special. The third of a pound hamburger wasn't even a quarter of a pound. It was over cooked very dry. Bun was so stale I had to remove outer edges that were so hard before I could eat the burger. The bartender was working the bar and the restaurant so I didn't complain to him because he was so busy. Had been happy with previous eating experiences. Just won't order hamburger again. read more

Looking for a place to hold a baby shower? Awards ceremony? Christmas Party? Retirement party? THIS is the place to call. Sam, Kim and Stephanie are so easy to work with, listen to what you might want or need and have great suggestions of their own to add to making sure your event is marvelous. We were able to get in early and decorate, the food was fantastic and the staff, not just our outstanding waitress, Cheyanne, but all of the staff from bartenders on down, were wonderful. I have to tell you from the roast beef and rolls, to the potatoes and gravy and down to the fruit plate and coffee, everything was totally top notch and tasty! I highly, highly recommend Tailgaters for any event you might have in mind. On a personal note, there is nothing on the menu that isn't really great, and I have tried almost everything on the menu, and the pizza is out of this world. Wings too, so birthday parties for kids, or baseball events?? You just can't go wrong doing your event at Tailgaters! read more

Great food. Whether it's just me and hubby or the whole family or big group we are always happy with this place. The burgers are terrific.

good food, clean, and nice waitress. would live to come back but i live in illinois. i had the buffalo mac and cheese. im picky with chicken but this was perfect. everyone else at my table enjoyed their food. overall good experience read more

I tried tailgaters. the food was excellent.the server Madison was wonderful.Because the food was great and the sever main made us feel special I will always go back. read more

They have awesome cheese garlic bread!!! Good pizzas too!!!! Yum!!! One thing bad is that it is super bright in there... talk about fluorescent lighting! Lol read more

Wait Awhile for service food took a while to come out food was less than average and the place did have a Musky smell

As mentioned in my prior review, I do frequent this place quite a bit. Went back (yet again) yesterday and decided to try one of their specials. I've made and eaten A LOT of lamb and I can only say one word about their lamb shank special - WOW!!! It was, by far, the best tasting lamb I have had in many years. Extremely tender and the sauce on it and the rice was simply perfect. Would definitely get this again if they run the same special or if they add it to their menu. read more

We stopped here for wings two days ago and I must say dont waste your time. The wings are the smallest I've ever had and the sauce is typical store bought. Service was slow and the waitress was kind if rude. The inside was nice and updated since it's been closed for years. Lots of TVs which was nice and will be great for Packer games. I didnt have any beer but seemed like they had a good selection. I'd stop in again for a beer or to hang out with friends since I like the inside but doubt I'd have any food. Hope this review helps your decision. read more

Stopped in today for lunch. Good food, fast service & nice and updated bar & restaurant. Very clean & fresh look. As a another local small business owner, we are glad to have another local non chain option. We will certainly visit again. read more

Don't go to this restaurant. I do not want my new favorite restaurant getting too crowded. Food is good, service is great and the place looks spectacular. You can see a TV from everywhere. The pizza was very good and the burger was cooked to perfection. Can't wait to go back and try something else. Hope I don't see you there. read more

My family and I ate dinner here tonight we were so excited to try the food because the parking lot is always packed- we loved it!! The food was delicious, hot, and fresh. My fish sandwich was so fresh and the batter on it was outstanding and the bun was soft but held together well. The coleslaw and fries were perfect (I honestly think I'm going to get a full side of coleslaw next time it was sooo good). My daughter who is picky sometimes loved the chicken tenders and the chicken noodle soup. Our server was super friendly and gave wonderful service!! We are already planning to come back and try the pizza next weekend it looked delicious when we saw another table get it. Highly recommend giving this place a try!! read more

ordered wings from 5 minutes down the road via door dash. got reheated on the grill wings from earlier in the day absolutely disgusting.