We have driven past here a few times, I follow them on facebook (which is a good idea) and today we finally stopped in. The place is quite big, if you see a full parking lot, don't worry, between the large bar, restaurant area and patio, you will find a place to sit. We went for Taco Tuesday. All of the food is great! The quesadilla had a lot of cheese and chicken, his taco's were as full as you could get them. Just because it says Taco Tuesday does not mean they only serve tacos. They have a great selection of Mexican food on Tuesdays. It was hard for me to choose, but I finally decided on a quesadilla for $9.50 and added rice and beans for $1 each. My husband chose the taco place for $10. Sour cream is an extra $1, salsa $.75. Bailey our server was great, she was spot on. Every employee greeted you with a smile and a hello. It is a nice atmosphere here, very friendly. Upon leaving, there were a couple at the bar that said goodbye and to have a nice night and chatted with us for a little bit. I am thinking they are regulars, It is so nice to have people do that and you never saw them before. Anyway, while we were there someone ordered spaghetti and meatballs, that is something I want to get from there. I almost asked if I could get a picture. 3 good size meatballs. We will definitely be back. Side note, we always go out early to avoid crowds and wait times. We were there around 4:30ish. read more

See all

5 STAR REVIEW FOR MASON This review is soooo overdue. I was purging my camera roll and came across this pic. That beautiful, glorious grouping of cheese resting between two slices of toast was lifeboat in a sea of despair. (I can be slightly dramatic at times) Their menu is large and so far everything looks so delicious. Hopefully if you go you'll enjoy your food and be blessed by Mason's presence read more

Tailgaters Bar & Grill - The Cheesehead..... Grilled cheese with: Cheddar, American, Mozzarella AND cheeses curds served with marinara dipping sauce!!! - Sports Bars Near Me - Caledonia, Wisconsin

My husband and I stopped to see this place. We started out at the bar. While sitting there today, we over heard the most rude waitress I've ever came across. The women was there with what appeared either her son and his girl or vise versa. The Waitress said extremely rude to the Women, you need to learn how to read a menu. Who says that to someone your waiting on. We decided to leave and probably will never go back, not after hearing that from one of their employees. read more

Came with a group on a Saturday evening. I have been here before and had a much better time this night. I ordered the Ruben which was huge and absolutely delish! Others in my group got an omelette with their breakfast all day and steak and wings. Someone also ordered liver and onions and said it was fantastic. Drinks were good and serve Kyle was great. read more

See all

I am server at tailgaters and apologize if I came off as rude. It was not my intention. I was a bit frustrated with needing 3 times to get it right for the customer. I've been a proud server for over 5 years at this establishment and hope to serve many more . We have great food and lots of great servers ! read more

Food is pretty good! Service was quick. The chicken salad was delicious, the pizza was great. The rest of the food was very tasty. I was here with friends is the perfect place in the middle of all of us. Great place to meet. Lots of TV's with close captions available. Background music can be better suited for dinner other than that is was good! read more

See all

The food was terrific! I had the hot meatloaf sandwich & it was delicious. My friend got the chopped steak & fries, she added brown gravy to her fries & loved it! Definitely worth a visit! read more

Went for lunch on Saturday. It was very clean. Our waiter was very good. He was friendly, helpful and quick. They have all day breakfast so I ordered the garden omelet with wheat toast and a side of sausage links. Nothing was greasy! It was cooked to perfection! My husband had the pizza burger and was very happy with the sausage and sauce. The bill was $40, including a 20% tip. We'll definitely be back! read more

Food and drinks are always great, but the bartender Christian is what keeps us coming back. Great staff and amazing service

AMAZING! My family of five came on a Thursday afternoon. We were immediately greeted by the bartender and told to take a seat. Because there are so many positives, I'll number them. 1. The server was amazing! She was the only one working the tables and she hustled and took great care of us. She was so nice and attentive. She also recommended that my kids could share a meal because of the serving size (she was right!!!!) 2. My pizza was legit! I've been craving it the whole vacation and it hit the spot. 3. My husband loved his ribeye. Cleaned the plate! 4. The Italian wedding soup was awesome! 5. The tvs were great and our server appeased my husband by putting on golf. 6. Loved the hometown bar feeling! Only improve: Wish I found this place at the beginning of our vacation. read more

Tailgaters Bar & Grill - Pizza! - Sports Bars Near Me - Caledonia, Wisconsin

Came on a Sunday morning for breakfast. Food was outstanding, service was fast. Miranda was our server and was very pleasant and helpful. Will be back! read more

Service was great at the bar when we arrived but went downhill after shift change at 7. Pizza was just ok, not much flavor and not cooked long enough. On the other hand my eggplant fries came out burnt and cheese curds were so overdone there was no cheese left in them, which tainted the rest of the appetizer basket they came with. Staff never asked how we were doing or I would have told them. I'm normally one to write only good reviews and to give not so good experiences a chance but when we were ignored the whole time and had to ask for drinks, I feel compelled share my experience. read more

Waitress was inattentive and when we asked for something we waited and waited and finally had to ask another waitress to help us. The fish was way overcooked and dry and you could tell it was not fresh at all. This was our third time there and we won't be back. read more

Fun place, nice service. Pretty crazy good food considering it is a bar. Happy that we went

Let me put you guys on. Get the jumbo wings with serrano chili sauce and buffalo sauce. Out of this world. You will not regret it. We tried one wing and had to get 12 more. Everything I had here was at least a 9/10. The wings are amazing. The cheese curds are quality. The pizza has a great sauce and cheese flavor. Very white people dominant but the server was really nice. A fun ambience where everyone seems like this is their "go-to" spot to drink and have a good meal. Highly recommend! read more

See all

We are visiting from out of state. There is a place we frequent at home with the same name. While we knew it wasn't the same, we thought we'd give it a try. So glad we did! We were greeted right away. Told we could sit where we want. We chose a high top near the bar. The inside is nice. Good size bar. There is a bar area and an additional area with high tops and tables. Pool tables and slot machines along with several large TVs. Clean and modern. Our server was new and very nice. She was personable and answered our questions about the menu and drinks. We ordered cheese curds and the po' boy. Both came out quickly. Really good! Food was hot. Tasted fresh. Our server checked on us several times. Got us refills. Prebussed our plates. Excellent service. Will come back when in the area!! read more

See all

I've loved this place ever since I discovered it! Huge menu with great salad and wings and bunch of other stuff are all good. Daily specials. Friendly atmosphere. read more

I had the hands down best Garden eggs Benedict! Lots is spinach, tomatoes and broccoli. Sorry I didn't take a picture to share. Yummy!

Love having dinner here with my family! The atmosphere is perfect for a night out with or without the kids! The service is friendly and quick and the food is delicious! read more

We had a small gathering at our house and we needed something quick to eat for our guests that was close by. We actually used DoorDash to order from here. As soon as I placed my order - the restaurant/bar called me to confirm they had the order right (above and beyond service). We never ate here before so we were taking a chance on taste- quality of food. Im glad we did! Pizza and wings were delicious! Great taste and good quality food. I was pleasantly surprised. Will give them our business again! read more

Great pizza and great people. Walked in hungry at 9 pm and they turned the pizza oven back on for us, even though we'd never been there before and they didn't know us. Susan and Christian were great about making sure we had whatever we needed. Felt right at home. Large clear television screens. Well stocked bar. read more

Our first time here and was very nice atmosphere and good food and service. Would stop again if we were back in the area

Went here on a Sunday evening. Not busy, there were two waitresses for the six tables being served. Should be plenty. We put in drink orders and ordered an appetizer. After more than 10 minutes waiting for drinks, we asked the waitress where are drinks were, she simply said "they're coming" and walked away. The bar was not busy as you can see it from the dining area but the bartender was visiting with bar patrons a lot. Our appetizer came before our drinks. The only time the waitress visited us was to bring our drinks and food and a glass of water which I had to ask her for. One of us had asked for sour cream for the baked potato but she never brought it. The only times she approached our table was to bring what we ordered. Other than that she was not around to ask for anything else. Once home, I checked my bill and was shocked to see a $1.50 charged for the mixer in the bourbon sour mixed drink I ordered. The bill reads : 2 x Rail Bourbon 7.00 - Sour (squirt bottle) 1.50 I did not ask for Squirt specifically simply ordered a Bourbon sour mixed drink. Is a bourbon sour or whiskey sour or any other drinks using sour mix extra? Which is ridiculous but if so, the customer should be told that. Any bar has sour mix along with other mixes on hand. I would have changed my order to a different mixer if I had been told that, just on principle. I am a local and have eaten there on many occasions prior but the service has deteriorated. Although the food is good, service is just as important to customers and both the bar and dining service were poor. I'm in no hurry to go back. read more

Our family of 5 went here last night for the first time. The bar area welcomed us immediately when we walked in which was nice. We sat down at a table off to the side of the bar and we did have a waitress come up to us almost immediately. She wasn't the friendliest but she was okay. We ordered a 16" pizza to split between my husband, myself, and our very hungry 12 year old. Half cheese, half pepperoni, sausage, mushroom. It was delicious! My 7 year old son had the shrimp basket that was on special and he loved it. And my 6 year old daughter had a kids cheeseburger. She is pretty picky when it comes to how her food is prepared (sigh) but they did it right and she loved it too. The seasoned fries were excellent. Definitely will go back again! Hope for a bit friendlier wariness next time though! read more

Tailgaters Bar & Grill - 16" pizza 1/2 cheese and 1/2 pepperoni, sausage, mushroom - Sports Bars Near Me - Caledonia, Wisconsin

Great new spot. * Very open with nice natural lighting * Nice variety of seating options * Waitstaff was friendly and helpful * My table had the bison burger, po'boy and the hangover burger. Everyone was impressed with their meals * Fries are delicious We will definitely be back! read more

Tailgaters Bar & Grill - Hangover burger with fries and pickle - Sports Bars Near Me - Caledonia, Wisconsin

I had liver and onions haven't had that for years it was so good. Nice place good service

Popped in for lunch after watching this place get remodeled for over a year. It was bright and open on the inside with darts, golden tee and two pool tables. Plus a long bar and lots of really big TVs. Bar and wait staff seemed friendly and attentive. My husband ordered a burger, said it seemed like a solid pub burger. I ordered the dozen wings, half with buffalo and half with Korean BBQ. The wings were awesome, with crispy skin and grill marks. I think the Korean BBQ was the winner, it was spicy with a sweet edge. Next time I'd order them all that way. The blue cheese sauce was filled with big chunks of blue cheese and a nice cooling element to the spicy wings. We look forward to coming back and having a great place for wings close to home. read more

Tailgaters Bar & Grill - Wings - Sports Bars Near Me - Caledonia, Wisconsin

We've been so many times I've tried just about everything. Never had a bad thing. It's one place the whole family agrees on!

Food was great. Service was on point. Brought my family of 4 here and everyone left satisfied. Texas meatloaf was excellent. Wife had the Pizza burger and said it was one of the best she had ever eaten. Both kids scarfed down their meals as well. We did this as a premise to the lights at Jellystone. Very convenient for get into park after meal. Same side of the road. Our waitress definitely made sure a glass didn't go empty. Make this a must stop in your future. read more

I am a elder 60+ family-historian and genealogist, and love anything built between 1800 and 1945. We two teetotalers live in Oregon (Wisconsin) having moved there in 2020. My mother-in-law was visiting from out-of-state. She wanted to get a cheese gift for a neighbor, so we found "Cheesers" online. We took a short car-trip to Cheesers in Stoughton, and ordered a custom Wisconsin-cheese gift platter she could take on the plane. By then it was 1 PM so we sauntered down the street in search of a diner to get lunch. I was looking for a "Diners, Drive-Ins & Dives" type place. A few storefronts down was Tailgaters Bar & Grill. It looked like nothing from the outside but I was wise to such things: You can't tell a book by its cover. I peeked in the window and said, "Ooh, ooh, an old-time storefront, just my kind of place." ("Ooh, ooh," from Car 54, Where Are You?", early 1960s) We went in and glanced at the menu. Ooh, ooh, burgers! We sat ourselves down, and looked at the menu in depth. A lot of appetizing stuff. During the first five minutes, several people walked in and everyone greeted each other by name. Then I said, "We are in Mayberry!" (Andy Griffith Show, 1960s) Or Cheers. (1980s) Take your pick. We three all ordered burgers. At first bite, I was in love. "This is the best burger I've had in decades." Crunchy, crispy grilled to perfection. We all loved the burgers. I said, "I think we may have found 'our burger joint.'" The bar has eleven TVs, at the time, all on "no sound," just the way I like it. One thing I was disappointed about was I asked for a cup of regular coffee and the waitress said they don't offer that. Was it just for that time of day? I wondered if they offer coffee at 2 AM to get people cogent after getting tipsy. This place is a cross between the Andy Griffith Show and Cheers. No pretensions. The overalls are real. Had the sound of any the TVs been ON, I wouldn't have liked the place nearly as much--but they do have "take out." read more

Had a great meal, twice now. Clean, open, fun bar. Great food, great atmosphere. Giant pretzel was crispy outside soft inside, beer cheese dipping sauce was very good. Burger was large and juicy, not dry at all. Spicy cheese curds are delish, not crazy blow your head off spicy , but you better be ready for a kick! Strawberry salad was very tasty, fresh and raspberry vinaigrette was perfect. We will be back for sure read more

See all

Spicy cheese curds are legit. Spacious with lots of TVs and pool table. Outside patio.

The food selection is great. From burgers to pizza to entrees. Friendly bartenders and a fun pull tab happy hour!

Delicious food!! One of the servers needs to work on her serving skills; constantly forgetting things, super slow, hovering, etc. Overall, pretty good place! read more

Stopped on the way home to Chicago. We ordered the wings. They were great! The wings were on the smaller side but perfectly sauced and made your lips burn for about 30 minutes after eating. I would stop and try something else. The wait staff was very nice and fast. The food came out quickly. read more

Awesome small town pub and restaurant, food has been top notch every time. The servers are on top of everything to may your lunch or dinner perfect. read more

New place with great food and natural lighting... well lighting while the sun is up right! read more

See all

Took the family for dinner after we were ignored at Cabbage Heads. Food, service and value were all excellent. Bartender/server did a great job of remembering all 8 orders and numerous drinks. Everyone loved the food. The nachos are excellent. read more

We order pizza from here all the time and love it ! The service is good and pizza is fresh tasting and a solid thin crust with fresh toppings. read more

I've been to tailgaters many times and the service is usually decent. I recently went and our waitress was high as a kite. Other staff noticed this and began taking over portions of her service. Other customers noticed. My beer was taken to the wrong table, order was wrong, and she was seen stumbling and walking around aimlessly. Food is always good but this is unacceptable. read more