I've been a long time customer of this place. My wife and I went out for what would've normally been a nice evening at Talaricos. However the waitress and manager had different plans. After waiting 15 mins to be acknowledged the waitress brought us waters. We were ready to order at that point and placed cocktail and food orders. After another 20 mins or so the food came out. Then a few mins later the waitress comes to apologize for the bartender slacking on drinks (since he was apparently having his social hour). No biggie. Oh you don't have the ingredients for your most popular drink... cool I'll take something else. Finally get the cocktails and since it was the waitresses social hour now we finished our drinks and food without anyone checking on us and eventually got the check. The waitress was nice (likely overwhelmed) brought us the check and kept apologizing for the slow service. Again, I was just gonna throw a 10% tip and be on our way with the most subpar experience I've ever had at Talaricos (that's as low as I'll tip even for poor service). So let's pay the bill..... wait... 10 mins later their system "won't process the payment". Waitress says " we're gonna comp the visit have a good night." I thought that was a little extreme so I throw $40 on the table and we make our way to the door. Now Mr Manager guy stops me at the door and wants to write down my credit card info so they can process the payment because he doesn't want to "lose money". I tell him he's nuts and walk to 7/11 pull out cash and give him $90 for our visit. Obviously I took the tip back. Manager guy is now trying to justify their lack of competences. I tell him to please give me my change and I don't care to hear why he thinks they are right. He keeps blabbing so I say keep the change and leave. So with the $6 my wife left and the $5 I was tired of waiting for they got a decent tip (for now) I drive a few blocks away and check my phone to see the original transaction they said timed out actually cleared but their lack of competence led them to think it didn't. FFS I turned around and went back in to collect my $90. Again the manager is attempting to justify his actions and I'm over it. In the end they got $84 for the meal and a $6 tip (which is $6 more than they deserved. Rant over. Enjoy that $90 because I'll never spend another dime there. We've spent thousands of dollars at this place and I didn't even get my ATM fees reimbursed I'm just glad I didn't leave the $40 because after I saw the transaction cleared I wouldn't have went back for the tip. Edit: The next morning management reached out and made a kind gesture to make us feel better about the situation. Now maybe they can teach the manager we dealt with that same hospitality. I've never had a complaint about this place until now. Food and service is always good but usually great. I'll edit my review to reflect my overall experience instead of this one horrible experience. read more

We ordered a slice of meat lovers, the meatballs, the beat salad and a couple drinks. The beat salad is like nothing I've ever had before. The beats are so tender and they also use golden beats. I will ask for extra goat cheese next time. The meat balls are huge! Very delicious and well seasoned. I really enjoyed the sauce. And slices 3 times the size of a normal slice. We went on a Saturday evening, it was quite busy, but we were able to get our salads, followed by our entrees in a timely manner. Love the big open window! read more

Their pizza great! Great environment! Their karaoke nights are fun. Service is fast.

At first I was a little hesitant about the price, but it did make more sense once you see the size of the slices. They are about twice the size of a pagglicci pizza slice. Might be twice as good, but I only had a single slice of the Tarantino, so I can't yet say that for sure. It tasted great, if a Lil light on the cheese. I also got a chop chop salad which I felt was a little more expensive that id wished for the small, but it was really damn good! I loved the pepperoncinis in it. I was quite full after the salad and a single slice. I'll definitely come back to try a pepperoni, and the Sinatra looks good too. There's actually a few things I wanna try. Oh I almost forgot to mention both the servers that helped me, the guy who sat me down and the girl who served me were super nice and professional / accommodating. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Chop chop - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Wanted some pizza and had to swing by this place. Walking inside it's dim lit and plenty of seating. You're greeted walking inside...you can walk to the bar or be seated by a hostess. TV's on the walls and a lot of people inside. Nice size menu with plenty of options. I ordered the Swine Lovers Pizza Slice (Meat Lovers) & Kauai Slice....(Hawaiian Pizza). Slices of pizza range from $7.99 - $9.99. Swine Lovers Pizza was good and Kauai Pizza was good. I think Talarico's has the best pizza in Seattle. If you're in the area definitely swing by and check this place out! read more

See all

My work team stopped by here for a group dinner. We got the biggest size to share and it was soooo big! Great pizza, thin dough and not super oily! The topping was great! Fast and friendly service read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I honestly just think this place is okay. Pizza is okay. The food is okay. Drinks kind of pricey. I will say the location itself is cool! Nice and big with friendly staff! read more

I went here with a friend on a Saturday night to a sizeable crowd that was inside. It's a restaurant and bar with karaoke on Saturday nights so there were a ton of people packed in during my stay here, which added to the very noisy vibes here. The bar is situated in the mifdle of the place, and it's dimly lit inside, somewhat perfect for both big-group casual hangouts and maybe even casual dates. You get a menu and order what you want from there. Service was very fast, direct and wr got our pizzas - along with any water and napkins we wanted - very quickly. As for parking, you'll need to rely on street parking for the most part to get here. And parking is TIGHT on a Saturday night like for most places. The pizzas (and even the pizza slices) here are humongous! I heard they're 14-inch slices, and that's pretty much what it was when we got our swine lover's and Kauai pizzas. The swine lover's had pepperoni, bacon, Italian sausage and tons of cheese. The Kauai pizza was akin to Hawaiian pizza, and had pineapple and bacon. Both slices were huge though pretty thin. Regardless, my friend and I got full from each of our slices, and even shared a caesar salad on the side! Our salad was a side that served two people as a side note. My swine lover's pizza was dang delicious, and came out piping hot and fresh! The pepperoni was done well, and the sausage and bacon added even more savory taste onto the pizza. It was just awesome all over! And the Kauai pizza was too with its not-that-mild taste. Great place for great pizza and appropriate vibes for those who want to go out in West Seattle! This place made it feel like there was a nightlife I was missing out in this area. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Caesar salad (side, not entrée) - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

These pizzas are beyond big. They are enormous! For real. We thought they were just joking when they advised us, and even asked twice if we were sure about ordering one. We'll, it was true. They are quite something. But they are amazing! You can eat big slices. They were able to do half and half as we were ordering one each week :) They have this particular alarm drink like Punch and is also enormous. It arrives on a mini cute mini bucket. Weve taken some time for parking. Last time we ended up in parking lot not that far. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Good service-delicious food-great pizza-big place lots of seating -went to birthday party there-our waiter was amazing

Service is normally great, but hit or miss. Trinity Is great, she keeps things moving and is nice to all. Be prepared to keep your cold weather gear on, they have AC blasting even in the winter. No neighborhood feel or warmth, nothing for locals. Great for watching games... other than that, not welcoming, no allure. I would think a West Seattle place would be more friendly overall. read more

Guys the al pastor pizza was actually heavenly. So so yum I will be getting it again. The pizookie was also yummy! Super kind staff as well. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - AL PASTOR - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Food was absolutely amazing service was amazing and the vibes were immaculate! Our server Michelle N was our server and my husband and I came in on our first night of our honeymoon and she was the best to say the least! She is a killer at amazing customer service and made us feel so welcomed!! We are natives of Oregon and this experience we will remember forever! Thank you so much Talarico's for an amazing first night on the town!!! read more

See all

Excellent giant-sized pizza slices, great for sharing. Good number of vegetarian options and great taste. Tried the Margarita and Veggie Supreme slice. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Margarita Veggie Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

The place is huge. Its an interesting place. The bar is what you first see when you walk in, but as you go to the back, there are more tables and kids friendly type of vibes with games to play. The pizza was ok. It was not my favorite. The crust or the toppings or nothing really stands out. They are a big slice if you want the individual pizza and they have varieties to order from. read more

Love the food here and service! Trinity was so fun and quiet the character being our server! love the vibes too after the Seahawks game!

This is my favorite karaoke spot right now. Staff is always doing their best to make sure everyone is happy and having fun. The food is always quality, I can order anything knowing it'll be good. I come here every weekend! I love when the staff joins in on karaoke night. read more

This place is great, good location and awesome food! Food wise, they have these giant slices of thin slice pizza which are amazing. We also got a couple pastas which was very flavorful, and a good amount of garlic flavor in the alfredo which is a plus! I got a arugula salad with chicken, and the grilled chicken was very good. Price is very reasonable too for the west Seattle area! Service was great also, the guy was super attentive for how busy it was. He was very quick and everything came fast! Ambiance was fun! It turns into more of a Karaoke bar on Friday and Saturday night, so people are jamming and vibing so you get a dinner and show kinda deal. The place is pretty clean too! Overall, I really enjoyed this place last night! It's in a great location with other bars in the area. Opens till late also, so you can always grab a bite and a beer with the gang and end the night on a bang! read more

I tried two of their pizza slices & their fettuccine Alfredo and wasn't impressed. The pizza wasn't super flavorful, and the pasta wasn't either. The service was good, and they do have a lot of TVs which would be great for if you want to have a drink and watch a game. I won't be back for the food, though. read more

See all

I'm back yet again! I still can't get over how amazing the pizza is here! I always get the original and it's great every time! Service was good, and ambiance was good as well! I had another great experience here! read more

See all

I came here with my family on a Friday night and unfortunately left feeling extremely disappointed and frustrated. The service was truly unacceptable. While a large party next to us was being attended to, our table was completely overlooked. We sat for a solid 20 minutes without being acknowledged, despite making eye contact with a server multiple times. When we finally got his attention, he told us that the other waiter assigned to the large party was supposed to be serving us. I'm not sure how table assignments work at Talarico's, but it was very clear that we were forgotten and even after kindly asking to be helped, nothing changed. We waited another 10 minutes and still received no service, so we decided to leave. I don't normally leave 1-star reviews, but this level of service - or complete lack of it needs to be addressed. While I understand table mix-ups can happen, the lack of responsiveness made it clear that our presence wasn't a priority. read more

So happy with the food, service and atmosphere. Trinity is amazing. Thank you for a great time. read more

A local sports bar serving slices of pizza, as well as other items. The service was adequate; it was busy, but the servers stopped by to check on us. We sampled a variety of food. While the slices were huge, the dough was limp and overall a bit greasy. I didn't try the wings; one sibling said they were cold, the other liked the flavor. The house salad was plain iceberg lettuce with crudely chopped vegetables. The beet salad was tasty though, as were the meatballs. read more

See all

This happy hour is one of my faves and cheap !! This is also a great place to come party

Our server, Trinity, was so nice and food was delicious! Great banter and felt so friendly. What a fun night out with my gal!

I was here for a Mariner playoff game. Good HH offerings. Great service! I am also here for the incentives. ;) read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Beer and sportball - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I had the fettuccine Alfredo with chicken. Was not sure whether to get the blackened or grilled chicken but Trinity came in with the win by recommending the blackened chicken. It was soooo good. My husband and his friend were clearly on something thinking that two men over 50 can take on two slices of these fabulous pizza slices. The pizza was so good, they ate till they hated themselves! Highly recommend this joint, ask for Trinity, she's a fabulous waitress! read more

Trinity was an amazing server, with great recs. 10/10 experience would 100% recommend coming in for some delicious pizza !

The pizza slices are huge!!! Lots of cool flavors and extra points for them being named after film directors. Great service, great atmosphere, highly recommend the swine lovers slice if you're a meat lover. Their ranch is also amazing to dip the crust in. Biggest and yummy pizza slices in Seattle! read more

See all

Great Crew. From the start of our experience, Mitchell was so kind and patient and offered great recommendations. she was bouncing around everywhere helping other guest and still made sure we had our food in a timely manner. Thank you to the cooks too! The bartender was super nice and helpful as well. they all worked in unison together. The food was amazing. The Mozz balls are totally worth it. The bufflo pizza was amazing. I am so happy Talericos have people like that servicing our community here in West Seattle. We'll be back again soon!!! Thanks to everyone 8/11/25 evening crew read more

Our server TRINITY was amazing! she was very helpful and kind. The restaurant was very good bringing out our food in a timely manner.

When you hear that each slice can be up to $9, you might think that this place is quite pricey, but it is in fact the opposite: each slice was gigantic and this was well worth the price. Honestly, just one slice was enough to make me full. The pizza quality itself was also quite good. I personally enjoyed the crust as it was not too chewy and crisp. The diverse pizza choices is also amazing as there should be a pizza for everyone. 5/5 just for the great pizza deal, but the servers and bartenders were also very nice and accommodating even though we came pretty close to closing. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Sinatra Pizza, sweet mia pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Noah was friendly helpful and had a fun story to tell. Cool bar to stop at. Thanks Noah! read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Noah was great! He was friendly, helpful, and had a fun story to tell. Cool chill bar to stop at :) thanks Noah! - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Some of the greatest pizza, highly recommend the butternut squash! Amazing bread pudding and atmosphere!

This is a West Seattle institution. But sadly, the service has really slipped. In two recent visits I had really, truly, terrible pizza. The dough was significantly undercooked. Worse off, we had a server, Erin, who was incredibly rude - we decided we wanted a table and tried to order drinks with our pizza, however Erin seemed more interested in hanging around the bar than checking on their tables. At one point I tried to order a drink from the bar myself since we hadn't had any service at all to our table post our first round, and Erin quickly found us and tried to scold us for not ordering directly from them. Their attitude and apathy was super off-putting and this isn't a one-off, sadly. Overall, this is a fun place but the bad service and inconsistent food has definitely dropped it down the ranks this year. Hope things improve! read more

Definitely the food, service, and ambience for sure, as well as our server Trinity who helped us out tonight

Stopped in and sat at the bar for happy hour. Kayla was our server and helped us decide what sounded good. Was a good mid week night out. Atmosphere was good and servers were friendly. Thank You Kayla for great conversations and service. ​ read more

Best HAPPY HOUR IN TOWN!!! $4-5 14' inch pizza slices (HUGE SLICES) Cheap appetizers $5 dollar beers/wines/drinks Our server was super friendly and told us about the specials and everything in there menu looks amazing! Must go to pizza spot here in West Seattle (: read more

See all

Agree with many others that the pizza is subpar. It's precooked cheese pizza lacking sauce with toppings thrown on during the reheat process. This was obvious when my slice came out so quickly after being ordered. I got a piece of the Kauai pizza and while the ham had sort of melted into the cheese topping, all of the pineapple pieces were just loosely sitting on top and both toppings were tepid at best. The crust was lukewarm, barely browned, and tasted like a frozen pizza crust. While the slices are huge (about the size of two normal slices), the quality is lacking. Our server was great and kept checking in on us during a very busy night, but that wouldn't be enough for me to come back for more pizza. read more

I was really really hungry when I arrived at Talarico's which was recommended by someone who lives nearby and is a regular. We sat outside because I had my dog with me and were given the menu right away. But our server never came so we ended up ordering from the host. Our waiter came later to apologize and the saving grace was that the food came out super quick. We ordered the chop salad and I had a slice (yes, huge slice) of the butternut pizza Wow! I don't know what kind of sorcery they do to their crust that makes it so crispy and delicious. It has a special taste and I don't know what is but I loved it. Definitely recommend. Definitely will be back. read more